Why I now believe in Predistination/Election

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
W

wsblind

Guest
If people would just understand relationships. They would understand,, Although what you are saying (I was saved by choice) sounds good.. It is lacking.

God could have made us robots.. Forced these people to say yes, forced those people to say no (just by not allowing them to say yes0

Or he could be a relational God. And say I will take the penalty in your place. but I will not force it on you, I will require you to say, yes, Lord, I want it. or no Lord I do not.

If you force things on people they do nto really appreciate it,, But if you offer, and they freely receive, then a much greater affect occurs and a far deeper relationship grows.

No, I did not chose to save myself. I could not save myself no matter what I did.

God chose to die for me, and chose to not force his salvation on me, but ALLOWED me to chose to say yes Lord, or no lord.
If we take this debate to the end, it comes down to ONE question. Do you REALLY believe Christ paid for ALL sin?

Yes He DID. He removed the barrier from men. So ALL men can come to Christ. He paid for ALL sin and the veil was torn. ALL men can come to Him, because He tore the veil for men. He did something about our depravity.......He threw us a life preserver that ALL can see and grab a hold of.


What he did NOT pay for was our evil or human good.......self righteousness. And at the GWTJ, unbelievers are judged according to their WORKS of self righteousness. Mankind goes to hell based upon their deeds, if they never believed that Christ died for their SINS.
 
P

popeye

Guest
My translation says it much differently. It doesn't say all are chosen. It doesn't even say all are called. It says many are called but few are chosen. It could just be my translation. There very well could be one that says all are chosen. Wouldn't make sense to me personally to say all are chosen but few are chosen...but I can't state for a fact that no translation has it that way.
He died for all. I am saying he died for all,not that all go to heaven.

He was both the sacrificial Lamb and Priest of his own Crucifixion,or offering. He did not die for a few. He died for all. That is why I say all are chosen.

I only say it to offset the limited view I am seeing here. Not making a doctrinal line in the sand over a word.
 
P

popeye

Guest
If we take this debate to the end, it comes down to ONE question. Do you REALLY believe Christ paid for ALL sin?

Yes He DID. He removed the barrier from men. So ALL men can come to Christ. He paid for ALL sin and the veil was torn. ALL men can come to Him, because He tore the veil for men. He did something about our depravity.......He threw us a life preserver that ALL can see and grab a hold of.


What he did NOT pay for was our evil or human good.......self righteousness. And at the GWTJ, unbelievers are judged according to their WORKS of self righteousness. Mankind goes to hell based upon their deeds, if they never believed that Christ died for their SINS.
I would say so.

What this thread/op is saying is that you could not grab the life preserver
 
P

popeye

Guest
acts 2;21 And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved.

Rev 3;
20 Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me.

So we see our part. We do infact CHOOSE to call on his name and open the door to let him in.


Now consider this;
Mat 22;
3 And sent forth his servants to call them that were bidden to the wedding: and they would not come.
8 Then saith he to his servants, The wedding is ready, but they which were bidden were not worthy.9 Go ye therefore into the highways, and as many as ye shall find, bid to the marriage.
10 So those servants went out into the highways, and gathered together all as many as they found, both bad and good: and the wedding was furnished with guests.

See that? the master DID NOT CHOOSE them that came.,But the ones he did choose, CHOSE not to come.
^^^^^^^^^^^^This^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
No, he showed you his son.And yes he chose to show you and he did in fact choose you. None the less ,he showed you his son,as he would anyone READY. They just aren't ready,not that they are not chosen and you are.

I can say all of that. I can include your assertions into the picture,and they are a part,NOT the whole picture
If you had read the whole thread, I think you would have noted that I specifically said: How do I know they just aren't ready for love yet? I refuse to condemn them when I don't know if He will grant them the repentance and faith He granted me. And you would have noted that I specifically said:I refuse to say I was chosen and they weren't. I can only say He chose me but will NOT say He won't choose them too because I don't know that.
 
W

wsblind

Guest
I would say so.

What this thread/op is saying is that you could not grab the life preserver
And yes, we are totally depraved in our sin. We would not choose God IF he didn't do something for us....................that is why He sent His PUBLICLY displayed Son(our life preserver) that paid for the sin of the whole world. Sin bound us all in death and blindness. He removed that sin barrier so that ALL men can see His Son.

Reject Him, and it is on us.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
The thing about it is that predestination is saying some folks will be condemned to hell just because that's what God wanted for them and no other real reason.

Having a choice and choosing wrongly is not on God. God is no respecter of persons. To say that everyone has a choice is not condemning or judging anyone, but to say some folks were made only to be rejected no matter what they do is pretty harsh.
Several people have told what it is. The dictionary tells what it is. You are bound and determined to invent your own definition. Nah. You've closed your ears and are now blaming us for understanding it.

Repeating a lie doesn't suddenly make it the truth.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
Umm...?? HAHA! You screamed at me for many days. HAHA! :D
LOL I was an annoyance to my bosses because I can't scream. A call comes in for my boss. He's in the (loud) factory. He doesn't hear the PA, so I'm signaling him with his back turned on me. I'm yelling, but only one guy can tell that's what I'm doing, so he has to yell for me. I really can't yell. Get mad? You betcha. Yell? No can do. lol
 
D

Depleted

Guest
I really cannot wrap my head around this predestination thing...You are saying you don't know who God will grant forgiveness too, but you are sure you are one of those elect, right. So why even worry about being shown mercy...If you are elected you should have no worries, right. It's all those other folks in the world who may or may not be elected who should worry, right:rolleyes:
That too has been answered.

Are you just going to keep asking the same questions or actually read the thread?
 
D

Depleted

Guest
The point those of us who don't believe in predestination are trying to make is that as long as the only two options are saved and not saved, choosing to save some automatically means the ones not chosen are unsaved - and thus go to hell.
A bit like if everyone is poisoned, and you choose to give antidote only to some, even if you have enough to give it to all.
More like (exactly like) Death Row. (and rightfully so), and some are pardoned. You got a problem with that?
 
D

Depleted

Guest
It is the gift of God and with any gift it can be accepted or rejected...


And saved by Grace through faith... says it all
Especially when you ignore everything everyone had written so far.
 
W

wsblind

Guest
The thing about it is that predestination is saying some folks will be condemned to hell just because that's what God wanted for them and no other real reason.

Having a choice and choosing wrongly is not on God. God is no respecter of persons. To say that everyone has a choice is not condemning or judging anyone, but to say some folks were made only to be rejected no matter what they do is pretty harsh.
We are ALL elected to condemnation. We are born sinners(Gods sovereignty) and condemned at birth. ALL of us.

The epitome of arrogance is to say that God's sovereignty also elected me to be saved and only elects an unknown few to be saved after He elected ALL mankind to condemnation at birth.

We were all condemned at birth in order that the righteousness of God could OFFER salvation to ALL.


He condemned all in equity, so He could offer salvation to all in equity.......WHOSOEVER can believe.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
This is what must happen - this "god" goes around and picks and chooses people and says - Heaven for you. It's hell for you. Heaven for you. It's hell for you. It's heaven for you. It's hell for you...etc.

IMO this whole thing violates the very reason of the "why" of the gospel in the first place and it is a direct violation of the nature and character of God.

But as I say - this whole predestination thing has as much use as knowing the ant population in the Amazon. But in hindsight - it does serve a purpose - only it is not of God

Whosoever calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved ( Except for you - you have to go to hell despite the fact that Jesus took away your sin and offers you the free gift of grace and the gift of righteousness )

The devil just loves this doctrine. He uses it to ruin the faith of believers and ship-wrecked their faith and mentally torments them and their families.
You too are repeating as if repeating suddenly makes it so.

And the devil loves a Godly doctrine? Up there with a cow's favorite meal is cow tongue.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
I agree G7, this predestination thing is way morbid, I believe when the Lord said all who call upon him, He meant all people not some here and some there.

Roman 10:13
for, "Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved."

Psalm 145:18
The LORD is near to all who call on him, to all who call on him in truth.
Yeah, the other choice is far more warm and fuzzy. Let everyone in Death Row be executed to seal their sentence.
 

Johnny_B

Senior Member
Mar 18, 2017
1,954
64
48
who said anything about Ameritech people. I said the amorites. the people of canaan.. WHo God waited 400 years until they reach the point of no return before God chose to send Israel in and said to kill them all.


You did go back and look at the post.
 

gotime

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2011
3,537
88
48
I have not been on this chat in 3 years but I felt heavily compelled in my heart to write this today.


I have always struggled to make sense of the predestination verses. (Romans 8: 29-30, Matthew 11:27, Psalm 65:4, Romans 9, etc.) To make sense of it I tried to think that God chose people to be saved based of knowing the future and seeing people choosing Him, hence the “foreknowing” but now I know how flawed that way of thinking is. In regards to free will I used to think how God made the way of salvation clear and just waited for us to accept like a gift. I now know how flawed that way of thinking is as well.


Yes, these predestination verses helped me to better understand but I still fought against it because I didn’t want to believe that God would choose some and not others. Ultimately I wanted to believe that I had a choice. How selfish and prideful I was to think that way.


It was not a verse about predestination that opened the door to the truth but actually verses about our utter depravity of sin:
Psalm 53:2-3
God looks down from heaven
on all mankind
to see if there are any who understand,
any who seek God.
Everyone has turned away, all have become corrupt;
there is no one who does good,
not even one.



I have read these verses before but about 1-2 years ago these verses really hit home to how sinful I really am. We always want to find some kind of good in us, some kind of tiny little ray of light (even if it’s the act of choosing God) and to show God saying, “Look, I did this! I chose You!”


Ultimately that is pride. It is us trying to believe that we are capable of goodness outside of Christ. In reality that is not possible. Even as Christians we are filled with sin: our actions, out thoughts, even our prayers are tainted with sin. There is no escape, no explaining away, and no changing it. We are filled with sin at all times.


In addition, because we are always filled with sin, our base nature is to reject anything that is of Christ. We were born into rebellion and live on in ultimate rebellion before becoming a Christian. It is impossible for anything in us to choose the salvation of Christ. No matter how free, wonderful, loving etc…..it is impossible. Our sin nature would never allow it. Evil would never choose its destruction which is Christ.


That is how I finally realized that predestination makes sense. Because it is literally the ONLY way that I would ever “choose” salvation. It is the Spirit of God that has given me the desire for Jesus, and it is His Spirit that has given me the power to “choose” Him.


Yes, at the age of eight, I remember making a conscience decision to accept His salvation through faith. I remember my fear of my sin and hell, desiring His love, of wanting a Father. I remember choosing Him. But I have come to realize that these desires for Him were not of myself but of His Spirit through me. I had no say in the matter.
Then how do I marriage the two facts that I consciously chose Him but also knowing that it is only God that would give me the desire to chose Him to begin with?


I don’t know. Any you know what? I am ok with that. I trust God that He knows how it works and that gives me peace. Confusion is not always a bad thing. Sometimes you just have to lay it at the feet of Jesus and say, “Lord, You know.”
There is song that I have found by a Christian rapper named Shai Linne called “Election”. I highly recommend you give it a listen as it explains Election/Predestination quite well. I know you might have heard how free will is like someone who is floating out at sea and salvation is God throwing a rope at us and all we have to do is grab it. There is a part of this song that explains how flawed that line of thinking is:


“Some people say that we were drowning in the ocean
Barely floating until God threw us the rope then
Our free will helped us as we groped
Our faith is the hand that grabbed the rope and God put us back in the boat
Nope! Without apology I deny that analogy
Reality- we were dead at the bottom of the sea
I was a swollen corpse with hope no more
Until Jehovah the LORD dove from the shore to the ocean floor
Yeah, I was a corpse and I smelled like it
I’ll keep it simple, why did God choose me? Because He felt like it!
He brought me out, not an act of my volition
Breathed life into my lungs and didn’t ask for my permission”


I was a corpse at the bottom of the ocean. I could not grab that rope nor would I ever want to even if I could.


Honestly, I so glad that I had no say in my salvation. How awful would it be that God had to depend on our choice? That is like stripping power out of God’s hands and placing it in ours. Knowing how utterly sinful and disgusting I am, I am so thankful that it could only be by the grace of God that I could ever be saved. Depending on myself to accomplish any type of good is horrifying because I know that I am not capable of producing any good at all outside of Christ.


Lord Jesus, thank You!


I apologize for this being so long haha. It was just on my heart all morning as I was cleaning the house.
I suppose the question I come to is this, Does God only inspire some by his spirit? I personally think He inspires all by His Spirit. I believe we have choice because He has given us choice. The choice is simple, resist that Spirit or surrender to it.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0

I got faith because God worked hard in me to cause me to repent..
After months of discussion and redefinition of the word repent to just changing ones
mind, what do you actually mean by this?

What I mean by this is accepting sin is evil, disgusting, destructive, leads to death,
destroys the soul and all who touch it.
Confession, the outward declaration of the sins one has commited and the commitment
to not repeat them, whether as a long term struggle or as leaving them behind.
Faith - putting my trust in Christ and the cross for the forgiveness of my sins.
A commitment to walk in obedience, love and righteousness as empowered by God.

This is something spoken from the heart, with a desire to cleanse and purify ones heart
and emotions, to be transformed into the likeness of Christ.

As Paul declares to take captive our thoughts

We take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ.
2 Cor 10:5

Now if this is your meaning of repentance, then Amen, but based on how and what
you share, I believe you mean something different. I would sincerely hope not but
it appears so.
 
Apr 15, 2017
2,867
653
113
I suppose the question I come to is this, Does God only inspire some by his spirit? I personally think He inspires all by His Spirit. I believe we have choice because He has given us choice. The choice is simple, resist that Spirit or surrender to it.
1Pe 2:11 Dearly beloved, I beseech you as strangers and pilgrims, abstain from fleshly lusts, which war against the soul;
1Pe 2:12 Having your conversation honest among the Gentiles: that, whereas they speak against you as evildoers, they may by your good works, which they shall behold, glorify God in the day of visitation.