This is the Dividing Line on BDF

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
ALL obedience requires works. Faith in & of itself is NOT obedience, but requires obedience to be manifested in our lives. (Faith without works is dead)
Taaaay.
What do you make of the verse that says Jesus learned the obedience of faith from the things He suffered?
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
Yes, and that's where self examination comes in. Once He has shone the light on our hypocrisies, we see that we are pretty helpless and quite sneaky and that we always seem to tip the scales in our own favor and against the favor of others. What can you do at that point but say: it is useless - I'm not good and I'm sneaky about hiding that fact from everyone AND even from myself...! "Because I CAN"T be good and there is something in me that needs to die so I can live. It's at that point that we have given up and realized what a farce we are and tell Him if we're going to be pure of heart it's going to have to be done by Him. THAT is the point at which we are walking in the light/truth! And He comes pretty quickly with His own strength then. And we truly experience the verse that says when I am weak I am strong!
What do you mean stunnedby grace?
You're not perfect?

Do you think you ever will be?

So while you're growing, you can't do any of these here work things?
You mean, you do NOTHING all day long?
You don't go to school, you don't go to work, you don't have a family, you never go shipping and let the little old man pass ahead of you, you never smile at someone, you never try to encourage a friend?

I mean, really, you do NOTHING?
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
What do you mean stunnedby grace?
You're not perfect?

Do you think you ever will be?

So while you're growing, you can't do any of these here work things?
You mean, you do NOTHING all day long?
You don't go to school, you don't go to work, you don't have a family, you never go shipping and let the little old man pass ahead of you, you never smile at someone, you never try to encourage a friend?

I mean, really, you do NOTHING?
Of course not silly! :D
The kind things I try to do for or to others is not where push comes to shove though, is it?
I can easily be kind or forgive people who I'm never going to see again.
But then I come home and the same dirty, unwashed dishes are lying about and there's mud on the floor and everyone wants me to do something for them the second I walk in the door and now I not only had to get the groceries but apparently, no one has the decency to say thanks, help me carry them up the stairs, or help me put them away. So now I'm exhausted and one of them just said: what's for dinner??!

Going out and about and doing and saying kind things to strangers isn't where push comes to shove.
 

PennEd

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2013
13,031
8,715
113
Yes, I agree that continuing belief and growing belief is necessary. That is what abiding means. Israel believed enough to step out under a huge towering wall of water, but then He became displeased over their subsequent unbelief.

The man seems to think it is important for us to understand WHO God later became displeased with and did not let enter His rest. He goes to great pains to say: WHO did God nevertheless become displeased with and refuse entrance in to His rest? Wasn't it...THOSE HE HAD SAVED? So pay attention and take care that you also, having been saved, do not allow your heart to become hard and unbelieving as their hearts did.
Well, if you equate the Jews unbelief in the wilderness, expressed through their sin, as disqualifying them for eternal rest, then you must also disqualify Moses eternal rest.
He also was not permitted into the Promised land because of his sinful disobedience in following God's instructions.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
In fact, push comes to shove in here too. When dcCon is curt or abrupt with me. When EG gets on my last nerve and I want to snap at him to be kinder to someone in his manner of speech and the words he uses. When Depleted talks to me in her matter of fact way when I'm hurting and want some tenderness. When stephen can't admit and say, you know what, you're right, just because someone has been harsh with me doesn't mean I should be harsh back. When grace7 repeats for the five-thousandth time: to keep slander and malice to a minimum..."

And I love them all. I don't give up on any of them, even when I could almost reach through the screen and smack them in my exasperation. I ask for MORE love and MORE patience.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
Well, if you equate the Jews unbelief in the wilderness, expressed through their sin, as disqualifying them for eternal rest, then you must also disqualify Moses eternal rest.
He also was not permitted into the Promised land because of his sinful disobedience in following God's instructions.
It's a race of trust. The ONLY thing that can disqualify one in this race is to become hardened and untrusting/unbelieving.
That entails more than first meets the eye though, doesn't it?
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,395
113
In fact, push comes to shove in here too. When dcCon is curt or abrupt with me. When EG gets on my last nerve and I want to snap at him to be kinder to someone in his manner of speech and the words he uses. When Depleted talks to me in her matter of fact way when I'm hurting and want some tenderness. When stephen can't admit and say, you know what, you're right, just because someone has been harsh with me doesn't mean I should be harsh back. When grace7 repeats for the five-thousandth time: to keep slander and malice to a minimum..."

And I love them all. I don't give up on any of them, even when I could almost reach through the screen and smack them in my exasperation. I ask for MORE love and MORE patience.
Exactly why I started the thread about being without sin and casting the first stone....I am trying to do better and have called no one a cake taker today ;)
 

PennEd

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2013
13,031
8,715
113
It's a race of trust. The ONLY thing that can disqualify one in this race is to become hardened and untrusting/unbelieving.
That entails more than first meets the eye though, doesn't it?
so you are suggesting the NEW heart that God gives us when we are born again, indwelt by the Holy Spirit, can become hardened to the point of unbelief?
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,395
113
You have never read that He learned the obedience of faith from the things He suffered?
I can try to find it - be right back. :)
Hebrews 5:8

Though he were a Son, yet learned he obedience by the things which he suffered;
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
Exactly why I started the thread about being without sin and casting the first stone....I am trying to do better and have called no one a cake taker today ;)
It's a good thread. It shows starkly to us who is continuing to walk in the Spirit or learning to walk consistently in the Spirit and who is not. Every single one of us can read back through and learn a lot about where we fumbled the ball and made a mistake or let ourselves be dragged into hatred or bitterness. It's a good thread. I think God is giving you practice for what He placed on your heart that you needed improvement in. :)
 

BillG

Senior Member
Feb 15, 2017
8,897
4,342
113
Exactly why I started the thread about being without sin and casting the first stone....I am trying to do better and have called no one a cake taker today ;)
Ah but what was your heart saying:cool:

Only joking please don't shoot me.
 

miknik5

Senior Member
Jun 2, 2016
7,833
588
113


don;t worry, Gods children will persevere.. Because they are children of the living God, not children of a dead God.

Would you say in the day of darkness (when truth is cast down and even with it natural love grows cold ) that the falling away is those who were following at first

or those who never did follow to begin with?
 

Desertsrose

Senior Member
Oct 24, 2016
2,824
207
63
Well, if you equate the Jews unbelief in the wilderness, expressed through their sin, as disqualifying them for eternal rest, then you must also disqualify Moses eternal rest.
He also was not permitted into the Promised land because of his sinful disobedience in following God's instructions.

Hi Ed,

The unbelieving Jews lived a life of sin. Moses was punished for one sin, striking the rock twice. Moses was not an unbelieving Jew. He loved God and obeyed Him. He did not live a life of sin, he lived a life of righteousness.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
Hebrews 5:8

Though he were a Son, yet learned he obedience by the things which he suffered;
Ah, there it is! My version says the obedience of faith.
As I said, there is more to it than first meets the eye.
You can actually see the steps in the story of Israel in the desert.
Believe Him that the water wouldn't come crashing down on them when they passed through.
Believe Him that He would care for them and not let them die of thirst even though they became very, very thirsty and uncomfortable in that thirst.
Believe Him and so obey and only gather enough for the day and believe that He would give them just enough the next day too.

The obedience of faith involves some struggle when the notice comes that my water will be shut off in 3 days and I have 95 cents to my name and can't find a job no matter what I try. I learn the obedience of faith through what I suffer. And then when I get to that place of obedience of faith and trust what He's said no matter what it looks like, I get even other believers saying: what? You just think He's going to drop money from the sky for you? Why aren't you worried??! And when I answer that He DID drop provision from the sky for others, they scoff at me even more and call me stupid. And so I get the miracles and they have their bank accounts to take security in. Keep me poor and getting the miracles! I'm going to run this race of trust, by George!
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I can only discuss South African churches because that is what I know, but from what I witnessed in South Africa the churches declaring only grace is 99,9% (I am talking about Christian churches). This is the "free for all churches".

From what I see of American churches on TV they are all grace churches (might only be my perception).

From what I see, alot of churches claim grace only, But then when they preach, or you listen to their core beliefs, grace only is the furthest from the truth about what they base their eternal life on.

I do know alot of true grace churches in china and africa and many other places are growing, But in most countries outside the united states, it is still mostly catholic. Even the united states is most likely mostly catholic or protestant but based on mostly catholic beliefs. .