Free choice. Are we free to choose anything we want? So, closer to the first one, than the second.
(And, I think the choice for your second definition would give me a third choice. If I am totally indifferent to my inclinations, I tend to opt for the third choice -- do nothing. If you give me the choice between cleaning your bathroom or chopping wood, frankly? I'm staying home. lol)
(And, I think the choice for your second definition would give me a third choice. If I am totally indifferent to my inclinations, I tend to opt for the third choice -- do nothing. If you give me the choice between cleaning your bathroom or chopping wood, frankly? I'm staying home. lol)
But such free will can never happen. So we always go where our nature leads us. And we then choose what we incline to. So can this be called "free"? Yes, but not absolutely.
Do I do not know how to poll Both can be true, depends on how we define it...