Is Yoga Ok for Christians?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Is Yoga OK for Christians to engage in?

  • Yes

    Votes: 18 28.6%
  • No

    Votes: 39 61.9%
  • Not sure

    Votes: 6 9.5%

  • Total voters
    63

Dan_473

Senior Member
Mar 11, 2014
9,054
1,051
113
I have four yoga centres near me.

1) Yoga Bindu
An image search shows this place has an altar in it dedicated to hindu gods. Their website shows they have Hatha classes and kundalini classes, an intense workout to help the nervous system.

2) Inner Harmony Yoga studio
They have several classes including tantra yoga designed to stimulate the desires of the body.

3) Yoga at the Y
No description available.

4) People's Yoga (Health and dance)
They offer yoga for kids, basic yoga, kundalini yoga, belly dancing, zumba and more.

Which one would go to? I say none.
say, one more thing i thought of... while i wouldn't go to a yoga center to practice yoga, if i was walking down the street... needed a used computer... saw a sign in the window of one of those centers that said 'good used computer, cheap for cash'...i'd probably go in to take a look at it... :)
 
D

danschance

Guest
say, one more thing i thought of... while i wouldn't go to a yoga center to practice yoga, if i was walking down the street... needed a used computer... saw a sign in the window of one of those centers that said 'good used computer, cheap for cash'...i'd probably go in to take a look at it... :)
When did I ever suggest we buy only from Christians?
 
D

danschance

Guest
definitely... of course, though, now were talking about going to a yoga center... maybe different from just practicing yoga stretches...
Yoga centers and yoga studios are very typically where yoga is performed.
 

Dan_473

Senior Member
Mar 11, 2014
9,054
1,051
113
When did I ever suggest we buy only from Christians?
oh, i don't think you did... i was just talking about the idea of going into a yoga center... i wouldn't go into one to practice yoga... i was just saying there were times when I might go into one for some other reason... :)
 
D

danschance

Guest
oh, i don't think you did... i was just talking about the idea of going into a yoga center... i wouldn't go into one to practice yoga... i was just saying there were times when I might go into one for some other reason... :)
Going into a garage doesn't mean I am a car and walking into a Yoga center doesn't mean anything. I understand what you meant, but I feel it is a bit over top.
 

iamsoandso

Senior Member
Oct 6, 2011
7,935
1,584
113
Im just curious is yoga a religion or an exercise?,,
 
D

didymos

Guest
Is it Ok to engage in Yoga for it's health benefits? Are there any spiritual negatives that come with Yoga? Many claim Yoga is a good why to stretch. Some churches alow a Yoga program to operate to benefit members. (...)

Yoga comes from Hinduism and yes it is a spiritual discipline. Each posture is designed to worship a particular Hindi diety. There are different types of Yoga practiced in the US. One of them is Kundalini yoga which is literally designed to open up your chakras and get in touch with the Kundalini spirit (...)


The way yoga is practised in the west usually has nothing to do with the hindu and buddhist traditions it originally came from, especially ashtanga and power yoga. I do however mistrust kundalini, because its main purpose is to try achieve a spiritual experience. To me yoga is just a good work out, it helps me relax too. As long as the Holy Spirit is in us, there's nothing to worry about. Then yoga is just another way of treating our body as a temple, a place where God's Spirit may dwell. (1 Cor. 6:19-20)

 

ob77

Banned
Mar 8, 2014
273
3
0
Is it Ok to engage in Yoga for it's health benefits? Are there any spiritual negatives that come with Yoga? Many claim Yoga is a good why to stretch. Some churches alow a Yoga program to operate to benefit members.

First lets google the definition of Yoga:

Yoga comes from Hinduism and yes it is a spiritual discipline. Each posture is designed to worship a particular Hindi diety. There are different types of Yoga practiced in the US. One of them is Kundalini yoga which is literally designed to open up your chakras and get in touch with the Kundalini spirit.

Here is a good YouTube video from a former Yoga master who details why he believes Yoga should not be practiced by Christians.
[video=youtube;wKwEkXcmEUQ]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wKwEkXcmEUQ[/video]
I do not know. What do the yoga instructors say about it? If it is simply physical without spiritual implications, I would not think it against God. If it contains some sort of spiritual connotations, then, I might be concerned.
 

Dan_473

Senior Member
Mar 11, 2014
9,054
1,051
113
Im just curious is yoga a religion or an exercise?,,
i think yoga can be a religion... or it can be an excersise... just like motorcycle riding can be a religion... or it can be just a fun thing to do...

grace and peace to you!
 
I

isoneedahug

Guest
Yoga is not innocent nor is it harmless, it has very dangerous spiritual implications, whether one wants to accept it or not. It derives from esoteric beliefs and cannot be "washed out" by sprinkling christianity on it. I would really advise any born again christian to stay away from it unless you're interested in opening doors in your life that will take deliverance and repentance to close back again later on.
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,713
3,651
113


The way yoga is practised in the west usually has nothing to do with the hindu and buddhist traditions it originally came from, especially ashtanga and power yoga. I do however mistrust kundalini, because its main purpose is to try achieve a spiritual experience. To me yoga is just a good work out, it helps me relax too. As long as the Holy Spirit is in us, there's nothing to worry about. Then yoga is just another way of treating our body as a temple, a place where God's Spirit may dwell. (1 Cor. 6:19-20)

I guess His Word and Holy Spirit are insufficient at giving us peace of mind (relaxation)?
 
L

Larry_Stotle

Guest


The way yoga is practised in the west usually has nothing to do with the hindu and buddhist traditions it originally came from, especially ashtanga and power yoga. I do however mistrust kundalini, because its main purpose is to try achieve a spiritual experience. To me yoga is just a good work out, it helps me relax too. As long as the Holy Spirit is in us, there's nothing to worry about. Then yoga is just another way of treating our body as a temple, a place where God's Spirit may dwell. (1 Cor. 6:19-20)


I agree it's an excellent work out and a good way to maintain muscle tone and flexibility - I used the various Yoga "moves"' for years but have gotten slack with work out nowadays.

I can still do the Scorpion pretty easily:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
D

didymos

Guest
I agree it's an excellent work out and a good way to maintain muscle tone and flexibility - I used the various Yoga "moves"' for years but have gotten slack with work out nowadays.

I can still do the Scorpion pretty easily:

I'm impressed. My lower back is relatively stiff, so I would never be able to perporm that asana. In my opinion yoga practise is less about 'what posture you can do' and more about series of asanas, and trying to integrate the whole concept of yoga into your life. One of the the basic rules of yoga practise is that we guard our boundaries, but at time same time (how fitting) try to stretch them. We shouldn't be looking at what others can (or can't) do, but what we ourselves may achieve. :)
 
L

Larry_Stotle

Guest
I'm impressed. My lower back is relatively stiff, so I would never be able to perporm that asana. In my opinion yoga practise is less about 'what posture you can do' and more about series of asanas, and trying to integrate the whole concept of yoga into your life. One of the the basic rules of yoga practise is that we guard our boundaries, but at time same time (how fitting) try to stretch them. We shouldn't be looking at what others can (or can't) do, but what we ourselves may achieve. :)
I agree there are many more gentle and less demanding postures and moves for healthy benefits - actually that pose is not that hard to achieve from the head stand position, it does demand some physical tone in the arms especially to hold it for a length of time, to get to it is more balance and positioning really.

Of course I didn't get "there" overnight.

The problem I see in the negative responses in this thread is trying to attach certain postures to worship of Hindu deities - that may be true for those that practice it with that intent.

I lived in India and Nepal for quite a while so I'm quite familiar with the idolatry and religious aspects of it especially in regards to the adepts.

A poor analogy could be made between "offerings" the Israelites made to God and those offered to idols - the intent is what matters. The food in itself is neutral.
 
D

didymos

Guest
I agree there are many more gentle and less demanding postures and moves for healthy benefits - actually that pose is not that hard to achieve from the head stand position, it does demand some physical tone in the arms especially to hold it for a length of time, to get to it is more balance and positioning really.

Of course I didn't get "there" overnight. (...)
As if the 'head stand position' is so easy to do, lol.
I've only been practising yoga for 3.5 years, so apparently I still got a long way to go.
 
L

Larry_Stotle

Guest
As if the 'head stand position' is so easy to do, lol.
I've only been practising yoga for 3.5 years, so apparently I still got a long way to go.
LOL - I started around the age of 17 - can't remember why I did - but I certainly wasn't into the "religious" side of it.
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,713
3,651
113
I agree it's an excellent work out and a good way to maintain muscle tone and flexibility - I used the various Yoga "moves"' for years but have gotten slack with work out nowadays.

I can still do the Scorpion pretty easily:


I'm impressed. My lower back is relatively stiff, so I would never be able to perporm that asana. In my opinion yoga practise is less about 'what posture you can do' and more about series of asanas, and trying to integrate the whole concept of yoga into your life. One of the the basic rules of yoga practise is that we guard our boundaries, but at time same time (how fitting) try to stretch them. We shouldn't be looking at what others can (or can't) do, but what we ourselves may achieve. :)

But that is not a 61 year old obviously.
 

Deva_1972

Senior Member
Nov 3, 2011
201
23
18
I don't like yoga, its not my thing....I personally think its hokey and stupid so guess what? I don't care whether its christian like or not