Jesus Is Our Truth, Reward, And Faithfulness So We Can Lie, Steal, and Fornicate?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

cv5

Well-known member
Nov 20, 2018
23,733
8,603
113
remember God had told Moses in another place that He would destroy the people and start a new people through him. Exodus 32:10
this is something Moses isn't going to forget. in fact Moses wrote it down, in Exodus.


the people had risen up against Moses and Aaron several times. remember the rod of Aaron budding? the Korah rebellion? Numbers 16-17. remember the remember Aaron & Miriam rebelling? Numbers 12.

why is the law of the red heifer, the water of cleansing, given right before Numbers 20?
accident? coincidence? or omniscient plan of God who wrote the most complex book in the history of the planet?
why do we have a rebellion against the authority of Moses and Aaron, threatening to kill them, being miraculously saved and approved by God in Numbers 16-17, then laws for Levites receiving their portion of tithes and offerings, then water of cleansing, then Moses and Aaron in unbelief striking the rock twice instead of speaking to it, yet the Israelites still receiving water, in Numbers 20?
totally random progression of events or an extraordinarily deep narrative organized by an all-knowing Creator & Author?


i do not believe Moses stood at that rock and forgot what he was supposed to do. i do not believe he stood at that rock without having thought about what was going to happen and walking through the possibilities in his mind. i do not believe Moses was an idiot. i do not believe i am wiser than him. i do not believe God was taken by surprise by what happened, and i don't believe it's in the Bible as a record of God & Moses both being incompetent. i don't believe preachers who say that are wiser than God, nor wiser than Moses, nor closer to Him.

Numbers 20:13 -- God was hallowed among the Israelites, even while they quarreled with Him.
this was not contrary to God's plan; He knew their hearts before He ever brought them out of Egypt - and it wasn't because of their inherent goodness or obedience that He did so. mercy -- everlasting lovingkindness. this is, IMO, what Moses didn't believe. Moses thought God would let either him & Aaron or the people die, if Moses disobeyed. so yeah, i think Moses was tired, discouraged and frustrated. the Bible absolutely portrays him this way -- his own words at the rock do. but i do not think he was an idiot. i do not think he acted without forethought. the scripture doesn't paint him as that kind of man, at all. even smashing the tablets, this wasn't a thoughtless action like kicking a rock. he knew exactly what he was doing, and why. he was raised to be a pharaoh and spoke with God face-to-face like no other man, regularly.
My dear friend why don't you just lay it on the line to tell me exactly what your theory is? I have a very simple albeit brutish theory you may have the correct theory. I would love to hear it.
 

cv5

Well-known member
Nov 20, 2018
23,733
8,603
113
and why is the very next thing that is recorded, Moses & Israel trying to pass through Edom and being refused, so they turn back the way they came? that totally random factoid just stuck in there as a filler? or is it exactly what God wants us to know next, in exactly the place it needs to be? and then Aaron dies -- another weird coincidence in a string of totally disconnected ancient notebook entries? :p
Don't get me wrong I do not think there is anything anywhere in the scripture that's random. Absolutely nothing. In fact I don't think there is such a thing as a random event but that's little more than my microencephalic Philosopher's mind speaking out loud.

But Moses being simply fed up and consequently goading God into destroying the people? Sounds like an awfully dangerous move to me.....
 

posthuman

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2013
37,925
13,607
113
Don't get me wrong I do not think there is anything anywhere in the scripture that's random. Absolutely nothing. In fact I don't think there is such a thing as a random event but that's little more than my microencephalic Philosopher's mind speaking out loud.

But Moses being simply fed up and consequently goading God into destroying the people? Sounds like an awfully dangerous move to me.....
i think God giving water out of the rock shocked them.
i think that was the last thing they expected
i think they thought either we will die in the sight of the people at the hand of God, or the people will rebel and either kill us or be slain by God trying.

i don't think it's an accident that provisions for Levites and ashes of the red heifer for cleansing after coming into contact with a corpse are given right between a rebellion seeking to overthrow Moses & Aaron and Moses and Aaron disobeying God at the rock. there were a lot of corpses in Numbers 16, and i think the most likely case is that Moses expected God to take his life for disobedience, in full view of all the people.
i think it's very similar to Elijah in 1 Kings 19, and that both Moses and Elijah acted in very intelligent, calculated ways, expecting to die, but in unbelief in their thoughts, and their love having grown cold because of increase in iniquity. in both cases God proved them wrong, and preserved them.

they endured. and they endured despite their unbelief and their sin. the mercy of God was on them
from there Elijah was led to the cave where he learned that God was the sill, small voice in the quiet. from there Moses and the people were led to a place with fiery snakes, and made one of the most astonishing figures of Christ, the brazen serpent lifted up, just like the Son of Man. :)
 
Aug 3, 2019
3,744
507
113
why did Moses and Aaron strike the rock twice?
Please stop dancing around the issue...you know full well the Ten Commandments yet "stand fast forever and ever" and Jesus has given no one grace or permission to break them.

Does the fact that Jesus is our reward mean we can break 8th and the rob banks?
Does the fact that Jesus is our faithfulness mean we can break the 7th and bed or neighbor's wife?
Does the fact that Jesus is our truth mean we can break the 9th and lie?

So, why do "Christians" argue that since Jesus is our rest, we can break the 4th?
 
Aug 3, 2019
3,744
507
113
Num 20:11
Hhmmmm........Well actually they were supposed to speak to the rock. But Moses alone is one who struck the rock, twice. In doing so, evidently he ruined Gods intention to frame a prophetical type of the Lord Jesus Christ. Consequently (and tragically) God punished him.

I'm not sure why that cropped up but I thought I would comment about it.
I've said for years that Moses absolutely ruined what could have been one of the most compelling "Type/Antitype" examples in all of Scripture, 2nd only to the Passover lamb. It's why he was denied entrance to the Promised Land - to show that even those closest to Him are to take no liberties when it comes to the plainly spoken commandment of God.

Think of the devastation it would have caused to that disgusting Papal heresy known as the "Catholic Mass" where Jesus is kept on the Cross perpetually through their supposed "morning and evening bloodless sacrifice" performed daily, which is followed by the equally disgusting "Eucharist" ceremony where they are taught the wafer and wine are the actual transubstantiated body and blood of Jesus.
 
Aug 3, 2019
3,744
507
113
That is a very informative post in fact. Quite frankly the question of weekly Sabbath keeping is still open to debate. But what I can offer is that Christians have entered into their perpetual Sabbath rest.
Yes, Luke 17:10 KJV says perfect obedience can't earn us one foot off the ground when Jesus comes in the clouds (how much less unprofitable then is our imperfect obedience?). Obedience is simply the outward evidence that demonstrates we've previously been saved by grace through faith (1 John 2:3-4 KJV; 1 John 5:2-3 KJV) because it is our foreordained, duty to God which He says is to follow salvation (Ephesians 2:8-10 KJV).

Likewise, Hebrews 4:9-10 KJV says if we're resting in the finished work of the Cross, we'll evidence that by resting ("rest" = Greek: "Sabbatismos" which is the weekly Sabbath) each week on the Sabbath, proving to the world that we worship the Creator who made all in six days and rested the seventh day, as well as the fact that He is the only true Re-Creator of the hearts of men which enables us to love God and our neighbor -- abilities of which Allah, Buddha, Zoroaster, Brahma, Baal, Zeus, Molech, Bel, Dali Lama, Shiva, Maitreya, Baphumet, and the rest of the satanic counterfeits are completely impotent.
 
Aug 3, 2019
3,744
507
113
That's quite a bit of rumination you've got going on there. The easy answer is that Moses cracked under pressure. To postulate that he sought To betray his people is a stretch.
Why would Moses offer to God his life in exchange for Israel which he loved so much, but then later seek to do them harm in the Wilderness of Zin? Sure, he executed judgment against those who rebelled, but certainly did nothing of the sort to those who stumbled in their walk due to having spent 400 years steeped in paganism.