Question about the Eucharist

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

MarcR

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2015
5,486
183
63
#21
So about a year ago, after a near coma binge, I decided to stop drinking, once and for all. It's not easy, especially because all of my friends still drink and sometimes tease me saying I'm some kinda goody two shoes lol. They do respect my decision not to drink anymore though.

My teetotalism is a problem when [on rare occassions] I do go to church and the Eucharist is celebrated. Apart from the fact that the priest's whole "charade" makes me feel uncomfortable [it always has] I just don't want to drink from the wine. Ofcourse there's option to drink grape juice, but isn't that against scripture? Doesn't it clearly say Jesus ordered his disciples to drink from the wine? If so, doesn't Jesus or God order me to do something that goes against my conscience? And can you be a christian if you don't want to celebrate the Eucharist, even if Jesus ordered his disciples to do so?
The Hebrew ooayne; which is translated wine, means 'the pressing of the grape'. 'New wine' is un-fermented grape juice; while 'old wine' is fermented. Modern 'forced' wines are 28 proof (14%) alcohol, because of added sugar. Biblical (natural) wines were 6-18 proof (3-9%) alcohol. NOTHING is unscriptural about having grape juice.
 
K

kennethcadwell

Guest
#22
So about a year ago, after a near coma binge, I decided to stop drinking, once and for all. It's not easy, especially because all of my friends still drink and sometimes tease me saying I'm some kinda goody two shoes lol. They do respect my decision not to drink anymore though.

My teetotalism is a problem when [on rare occassions] I do go to church and the Eucharist is celebrated. Apart from the fact that the priest's whole "charade" makes me feel uncomfortable [it always has] I just don't want to drink from the wine. Ofcourse there's option to drink grape juice, but isn't that against scripture? Doesn't it clearly say Jesus ordered his disciples to drink from the wine? If so, doesn't Jesus or God order me to do something that goes against my conscience? And can you be a christian if you don't want to celebrate the Eucharist, even if Jesus ordered his disciples to do so?

The bible shows it is about your heart and not about the drink itself, and grapes rather it comes in the form of wine or grape juice come from the same vine. If your heart is not in it then do not partake of it as you would not be partaking of it in the proper manner. However you can drink either grape juice or wine as there is no direct command for it to only be wine. God knows your heart and He will know why you are partaking of it by the juice and not the wine, but it all comes down to your heart. Doing it out of love for Him as your Lord and Savior.....



P.S. ---- I just wanted to add that this is not just a Catholic thing, as the bible clearly mentions it from Lord Jesus in the Gospel books to Acts, to Apostle Paul in 1 Corinthians 11......
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#23
So about a year ago, after a near coma binge, I decided to stop drinking, once and for all. It's not easy, especially because all of my friends still drink and sometimes tease me saying I'm some kinda goody two shoes lol. They do respect my decision not to drink anymore though.

My teetotalism is a problem when [on rare occassions] I do go to church and the Eucharist is celebrated. Apart from the fact that the priest's whole "charade" makes me feel uncomfortable [it always has] I just don't want to drink from the wine. Ofcourse there's option to drink grape juice, but isn't that against scripture? Doesn't it clearly say Jesus ordered his disciples to drink from the wine? If so, doesn't Jesus or God order me to do something that goes against my conscience? And can you be a christian if you don't want to celebrate the Eucharist, even if Jesus ordered his disciples to do so?
are you talking about the eucharist. or christian supper.

a huge difference. context needs to be set first.
 

Joidevivre

Senior Member
Jul 15, 2014
3,838
271
83
#24
When Jesus gave communion, it was at the Passover Supper and he picked up the cup of wine that was there representing the blood that gave them protection when the angel of death passed over the Israelites. He gave the disciples new meaning for that cup - soon to become His blood.

I like looking at the red of wine and visualizing Christ's blood. I also like the warmth of wine on my tongue like it is more real somehow. I was raised on using grape juice (Baptist church), but the first time I used wine, it was like an "ah" moment.

In reading the other postings, I think it really is a matter of doing whatever causes the body and blood of Jesus to be more real to each person. And I love the fact that people would use other elements when they had to. Like water and bread. If Jesus could turn water into wine, it seems to me that He would bless with His presence any substance we need to use.

As long as we spend that time with Jesus, and receive what He is offering us through these elements.

My husband would feel comfortable taking communion using beer and crackers. And I think Jesus would actually smile if he did that.
 
Jan 25, 2015
9,213
3,189
113
#25
Do a study on wine and grape juice and you will find that Yeshua did not touch alcohol. The translators of the Bible used wine on more than one occasion when the Bible was actually referring to unfermented grape juice.
 
Feb 5, 2015
1,852
13
0
#26
Do a study on wine and grape juice and you will find that Yeshua did not touch alcohol. The translators of the Bible used wine on more than one occasion when the Bible was actually referring to unfermented grape juice.
Can I ask a sincere question? How could the Pharisees accuse Jesus of being a drunkard, if he never drank alcohol?

The Son of Man came eating and drinking, and they say, ‘Here is a glutton and a drunkard, a friend of tax collectors and sinners.’ But wisdom is proved right by her deeds.” Matt11:19
 
Jan 25, 2015
9,213
3,189
113
#27
Can I ask a sincere question? How could the Pharisees accuse Jesus of being a drunkard, if he never drank alcohol?

The Son of Man came eating and drinking, and they say, ‘Here is a glutton and a drunkard, a friend of tax collectors and sinners.’ But wisdom is proved right by her deeds.” Matt11:19
Because he sat between them and spend time with them.

Have you ever spend time with drug addicts? Does that make you a drug addict if you spend time with them without using it? :)

The Pharisees were looking for excuses to discredit Yeshua and that is why they spread lies like this. Do a study on this. Very interesting :)
 
Feb 5, 2015
1,852
13
0
#28
Because he sat between them and spend time with them.

Have you ever spend time with drug addicts? Does that make you a drug addict if you spend time with them without using it? :)

The Pharisees were looking for excuses to discredit Yeshua and that is why they spread lies like this. Do a study on this. Very interesting :)
You can only be accused of being a drunkard if you actually drink alcohol.
If I eat with people who smoke, that does not make me a smoker unless I myself smoke
You are right about drug addicts too. I cannot be accused of being a drug addict unless I actually take drugs myself
I could be accused of mixing with people who do smoke, but not of being a smoker
 
Last edited:
Jan 25, 2015
9,213
3,189
113
#29
You can only be accused of being a drunkard if you actually drink alcohol.
If I eat with people who smoke, that does not make me a smoker unless I myself smoke
You are right about drug addicts too. I cannot be accused of being a drug addict unless I actually take drugs myself
Do the study Michael. I am not going to argue over this my friend :)
 

breno785au

Senior Member
Jul 23, 2013
6,002
765
113
39
Australia
#32
Lumberjack, from your comments in this thread..and this is to help you and encourage but it sounds like you need to experience a living relationship with the Holy Spirit and not a set of rituals. Your zeal to do what is right biblically is good but there's more to it than that, I pray that you find that out sooner rather than later :)
 
L

lumberjack

Guest
#33
Thank you all, it's impossible for me to respond tot all posts, but I will take them all into consideration. Some left me with even more questions [for instance what breno said about the HS] but that's OK, I'm here tot learn, so...
 
M

mikeuk

Guest
#34
I've taken The Lord's Supper with Triscuits and water, Ritz Crackers and Pepsi, and several other combinations, at least 70 times. If someone is telling you that you have some rules about this that God has set down... you may well be in the wrong church.
There are biblical precedents!
Jesus is referred as a priest of the order of Melchisedech, who most certainly used bread and wine!, so uniting the levitical priesthood ( bloody, offering himself as lamb) and melchisedech priesthood ( un bloody, offering bread and wine) sacrifices.
Do not think ritz crackers are an adequate biblical substitute!
 
Feb 5, 2015
1,852
13
0
#35
There are biblical precedents!
Jesus is referred as a priest of the order of Melchisedech, who most certainly used bread and wine!, so uniting the levitical priesthood ( bloody, offering himself as lamb) and melchisedech priesthood ( un bloody, offering bread and wine) sacrifices.
Do not think ritz crackers are an adequate biblical substitute!
I thought what was important to God was the heart when you take communion. If you use ritz crackers and pepsi, or any other drink, as long as you in your heart do so with gratitude for what Christ did for you at Calvary, God will be well pleased I am sure
 
Jan 19, 2013
11,909
141
0
#36
I thought what was important to God was the heart when you take communion. If you use ritz crackers and pepsi, or any other drink, as long as you in your heart do so with gratitude for what Christ did for you at Calvary, God will be well pleased I am sure
To a point. . .when it is based in ignorance.

But God is not pleased when we change his ordinances, and at some point we become liable for our ignorance of his NT ordinances (1Co 4:6).
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
#37
I thought what was important to God was the heart when you take communion. If you use ritz crackers and pepsi, or any other drink, as long as you in your heart do so with gratitude for what Christ did for you at Calvary, God will be well pleased I am sure
Yes I wonder how many churches use unleavened barley bread which is what Jesus would have used.
 

GuessWho

Senior Member
Nov 8, 2014
1,227
34
48
#38
Yes I wonder how many churches use unleavened barley bread which is what Jesus would have used.
Really? After you hear about people who use cheeseburger and ketchup at their "communion", you wonder if the bread is unleavened? Is that your dilemma?

Christianchat didn't change since I got banned.
 

Elin

Banned
Jan 19, 2013
11,909
141
0
#39
Really? After you hear about people who use cheeseburger and ketchup at their "communion", you wonder if the bread is unleavened? Is that your dilemma?

Christianchat didn't change since I got banned.
Troll?. . . .
 
Jan 6, 2014
991
27
0
#40
You must realize his body is sufficient to receive both his flesh and blood, you do not have to receive the wine to have received the Eucharist.

Christ be with you always.