you are saying that previous to Acts 15 Peter is preaching a false gospel?
how do you get that from the text?
and wants 'from then on' to preach something different?
he doesn't seem to me to be making the argument that anything has changed - James doesn't take him that way:
where do you get "from a literal reading" that Peter is has two gospels and is deciding "from then on" to preach a different gospel?
they send men to Antioch, a church Peter founded. the church in Antioch is questioning what they should do because certain Jews are telling them they should be circumcised keep the law of Moses -- something that is apparently radically different than the gospel they first heard and believed from Peter.
if anything here, James is the one who becomes enlightened, because it's men from James that make Peter act hypocritically in the account given in Galatians 2.
where do you get from the text that Peter has some kind of epiphany and goes from preaching one gospel to an entirely different gospel "from then on" ?
how do you get that from the text?
why do you test God by putting a yoke on the neck of the disciples which neither our fathers nor we were able to bear?
(Acts 10:10)
are these the words of a man who has been believing and preaching this yoke is salvation? and wants 'from then on' to preach something different?
he doesn't seem to me to be making the argument that anything has changed - James doesn't take him that way:
Simon has declared how God at the first visited the Gentiles to take out of them a people for His name.
(Acts 10:14)
"at the first" -- Abraham. Gentile. nothing about law here, only about a people being chosen by God.where do you get "from a literal reading" that Peter is has two gospels and is deciding "from then on" to preach a different gospel?
they send men to Antioch, a church Peter founded. the church in Antioch is questioning what they should do because certain Jews are telling them they should be circumcised keep the law of Moses -- something that is apparently radically different than the gospel they first heard and believed from Peter.
if anything here, James is the one who becomes enlightened, because it's men from James that make Peter act hypocritically in the account given in Galatians 2.
where do you get from the text that Peter has some kind of epiphany and goes from preaching one gospel to an entirely different gospel "from then on" ?
We see the gospel opened to the gentiles.
The paulines see only paul as preaching the true gospel.
They see 2 gospels.
The false gospel that came from Jesus that the non paulines preached.
Then the true gospel of grace that came solely from paul.
Even peters revelation that the lord commanded the gentiles be brought in is poo pooed by them.
It is even critical for them that peters revelation come AFTER pauls same revelation. (For some bizarre reason).
Which peter was probably shown it first.
- 1
- Show all