Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
C

cfultz3

Guest
#21
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

Eternally Grateful,

ET = blue, Me = red

lol. We were chosen BEFORE THE FOUNDATION OF THE WORLD to be adopted into Gods family, to be made holy and blameless. To be Justified before God. --- This is not a laughing matter. I spoke truth to you, so seek not a rebuttal in a correction, but seek God's understanding. So this thread is not derailed, I will not reply anymore. But, if you wish, we can start a new thread.

We = those of faith. It was God who predetermined beforehand that salvation would be by faith, and by such a plan, we received justification from the adverse sentencing of death. Indeed, faith in the works of the Christ is what has justified us. What purpose is there in following Christ, if we, after all, have been predestined for death? What purpose is there for one to leave the rebellion, if we, after all, have been predestined for life? The only thing which has been predestined is salvation through faith.


so tell me. How can we be chosen to be given eternal life and adopted as Gods eternal sons BEFORE the foundation of the world. Then 1. Be given it when God knows we will lose it for whatever reason, and 2, have it taken away after we were given it? Did God get fooled somehow into thinking we would get it, then have to take it back because we did not deserve it? --- All humans have been offered everlasting life, the opportunity to leave the rebellion, seeing that He died for all. And it is said to all, WHOSOEVER believes in the Son shall not perish. Therefore, God has chosen to offer life and sonhood through faith and not deeds since the foundation of the world. Your point one disagrees with God being able to erase one's name from the Book of Life. Have we not all given a present to only find out that the person lost it by a choice of an action? Second point is that God did not take it away, but you forfeited it when your heart becomes stubborn to His Voice. Never think that we deserved His gracious act of love He showed through the works of Christ. No, everlasting life is a free gift offered to all who believes.

As paul said, are we to be fools thinking we begin our eternal life by the spirit, then my perfect our salvation by the works of the law or being good enough? -- Again, salvation is a free gift offered through God's gracious act of having justification received through faith. We have not and we cannot earn it. But are we to be fools to think that we can have a faithless heart after salvation and still enter into His rest?

If Salvation is by grace, and is freely given to people who do not deserve it. Then it can not be taken away because someone did not deserve to keep it. We did not deserve it, we will never deserve it. and to say otherwise it to place to much faith in self and not enough faith in God. -- So then, is God a liar to have said a name can be blotted out from the Lamb's Book of Life?

As for book of life. I believe everyone is written in, untilt hey die, those blotted out are done so because they committed the unpardonable sin, which is to reject the grace of God. -- Not according to those two verses which states a willful deception, a willful hardening of the heart. Plus, how can those who never believed in the works of the Christ have been written it that Book if they do not have Life, Jesus, in them by faith?
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#22
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

question is why draw us and save us if we have a heart to spit and then He has to toss us....unregenerate us which would mean it corrupted
can be defiled, fades away, plucked out and by the way it needs to add something to the list of what can seperate us from the Love of God...right?

Are you sure all names arnt written in there to start with?
 
F

feedm3

Guest
#23
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

The whole "God taking back salvation" is a cheap way to put the blame on God if we fail in keeping his will. The truth is God gave salvation - Tit 2:10-f.
It's there for anyone who hears the gospel and is willing to accept it. Yet if we accept it, and later turn our backs on God, it does not mean God takes away his salvation, it means WE reject his gift and throw it away.

This is the meaning of doing "despite unto the spirit of grace". We reject it, showing we count the blood that washed us of our sins as a unholy thing - Heb 10:26-f.
 
F

feedm3

Guest
#24
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

question is why draw us and save us if we have a heart to spit and then He has to toss us....unregenerate us which would mean it corrupted
can be defiled, fades away, plucked out and by the way it needs to add something to the list of what can seperate us from the Love of God...right?

Are you sure all names arnt written in there to start with?

I would ask the same question you are:

Why write our names in the book of life if we have a heart to spit and then he has to erase us...?
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#25
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

I would ask the same question you are:

Why write our names in the book of life if we have a heart to spit and then he has to erase us...?
Im not saying that that is the answer. I asked if that wasnt a possibility.

God is Spirit...He doesnt use books. Either He intended or at least willed
that all men be saved...as it says, and also Christ died for all.

I understand it must be received. Books(like the reference to the book of life) are a way to convey a message to us.
If and i was only asking if it was just as possible to have all names recorded
in this book of all He would create and erase or blot out those who are to be damned who
refused the love of the truth.
 
F

feedm3

Guest
#26
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

Im not saying that that is the answer. I asked if that wasnt a possibility.

God is Spirit...He doesnt use books. Either He intended or at least willed
that all men be saved...as it says, and also Christ died for all.

I understand it must be received. Books(like the reference to the book of life) are a way to convey a message to us.
If and i was only asking if it was just as possible to have all names recorded
in this book of all He would create and erase or blot out those who are to be damned who
refused the love of the truth.
Oh, well yes I would say it was/is possible.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#27
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

Again ill say why i pondered that.....

1 the many clear scripture that tells of salvation being a permanent thing(He keeps us, and of coarse we obey in that keeping...with a new heart He puts in us
that wants to be righteous and holy...not by our good nature but He makes us a new creation with holy affections)

2 few scriptures seem to contradict that.......what easier move the mountain over to the small pile or see if the pile can be swept and put on the mountain.


Thats why im not into all this quit sinning or your going to go to hell stuff arounf believers...why?
1 the unregenerate will not hear
2 the regenerate dont need to hear

What is needed is to teach how to mortify the flesh for the believer
And the gospel preached to the unbeliever
The rest is annoying noise
 
1

1still_waters

Guest
#28
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

How did this morph into the eternal security debate?

Should I bring in Matthew 24 while we're at it?

That's how you hijack a thread. :p
 
C

cfultz3

Guest
#29
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

How did this morph into the eternal security debate?

Should I bring in Matthew 24 while we're at it?

That's how you hijack a thread. :p
Again, my apologies for having hijacked your thread.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#30
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

 
F

feedm3

Guest
#31
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?


Thats why im not into all this quit sinning or your going to go to hell stuff arounf believers...why?
1 the unregenerate will not hear 2 the regenerate dont need to hear


Well, the many passages that are written to churches (Christians) show us that they were hearing even after they were Christians. Which proves we all still need to hear it. In fact, there is nothing in the Bible that we will never need to hear.

Also, the message of "quit sinning or your going to hell" is the main message we see the Lord giving:

Luke 13:3 - Repent ("quit sinning") or ye shall all likewise perish ("go to hell stuff").


What is needed is to teach how to mortify the flesh for the believer

And the gospel preached to the unbeliever
The rest is annoying noise

I would caution saying anything that stated in scripture is annoying, seeing this message is repeated so much.



How can one be taught HOW to put to death the deeds of the flesh, without being warned of the punishment that follows if he chooses not to? That would not be teaching the whole counsel of God:

Acts 20:27 For I shrank not from declaring unto you the whole counsel of God



 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#32
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

How did this morph into the eternal security debate?

Should I bring in Matthew 24 while we're at it?

That's how you hijack a thread. :p
lol, maybe because those to whom many of us believe the passages you spoke of speaks of them, do not like the fact we think it speaks of them.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#33
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

AAAh well i do have some friendly rebuttal for that but
not sure its right in this thread.
 
Jul 12, 2012
933
2
0
#34
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

Original Post:

A most excellent presentation of self-cross-referencing scripture.

"but he who does the will of My Father in heaven"

Kodesh Kodesh Kodesh!
 
F

feedm3

Guest
#35
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

I Thess 3:4 For verily, when we were with you, we told you before that we should suffer tribulation; even as it came to pass, and ye know. 5 For this cause, when I could no longer forbear, I sent to know your faith, lest by some means the tempter have tempted you, and our labour be in vain

Paul wrote this to Christians as well. he wanted to know of their faith, so he sent Tim. Why was he worried? Because if the "tempter tempted them" and they acted on these temptations, Paul says his labour "would have been "in vain".

Why would his labor be in vain? How could teaching people the gospel, and them being added to the church ever be "in vain"?

It is ONLY if they cease being the church, and become cut off, by rejecting the grace of God that was given to them. Then his labor would have been in vain.

It is the same warning the Corinthians had been given as well:
II Cor 6:1 We then, as workers together with him, beseech you also that ye receive not the grace of God in vain

How could God's grace ever be received in vain? Vain means of no effect. How could grace they already received become of no effect?

The washing of our sins, is not a ONE TIME thing that happens. The blood of Christ, CONTINUES to cleanse the Christian, as he repents and confesses his sins to God.
I Jn 1:7 But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all sin

The "eth" endings on the words in the KJV mean something continuous. The word can be literally written, 1Jn 1:7 ESV But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin.

His blood continues to cleans us AS we walk in the light. If we choose not to walk in the light, our sins remain, and will until judgment.

So it's not a matter of one was saved, or was never saved. It's a matter of are we walking in the light? Continuing to walk in the light? Does this mean we have no sin?

NOPE it ROm 3:23 tells us we all have sinned. However, it does not mean we all cant help sinning. When we continue in sin, we continue in darkness, and we have no fellowship with him, so the blood of Christ is not cleansing us from all sin. That is the implication of Jn 1:7.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#36
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

AAAh well i do have some friendly rebuttal for that but
not sure its right in this thread.
I like what Paul said to the corinthians.

When I came to you. O sought nothing but the knowledge of Christ and him crucified.

Not stop sin, Not change your life. Not turn from you sin, nothing but Christ crucified.

The rest happens, as he explained to them in both his letters, AFTER you get saved and are born again into the family of God.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#37
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

Eternally Grateful,

ET = blue, Me = red

lol. We were chosen BEFORE THE FOUNDATION OF THE WORLD to be adopted into Gods family, to be made holy and blameless. To be Justified before God. --- This is not a laughing matter. I spoke truth to you, so seek not a rebuttal in a correction, but seek God's understanding. So this thread is not derailed, I will not reply anymore. But, if you wish, we can start a new thread.

We = those of faith. It was God who predetermined beforehand that salvation would be by faith, and by such a plan, we received justification from the adverse sentencing of death. Indeed, faith in the works of the Christ is what has justified us. What purpose is there in following Christ, if we, after all, have been predestined for death? What purpose is there for one to leave the rebellion, if we, after all, have been predestined for life? The only thing which has been predestined is salvation through faith.


so tell me. How can we be chosen to be given eternal life and adopted as Gods eternal sons BEFORE the foundation of the world. Then 1. Be given it when God knows we will lose it for whatever reason, and 2, have it taken away after we were given it? Did God get fooled somehow into thinking we would get it, then have to take it back because we did not deserve it? --- All humans have been offered everlasting life, the opportunity to leave the rebellion, seeing that He died for all. And it is said to all, WHOSOEVER believes in the Son shall not perish. Therefore, God has chosen to offer life and sonhood through faith and not deeds since the foundation of the world. Your point one disagrees with God being able to erase one's name from the Book of Life. Have we not all given a present to only find out that the person lost it by a choice of an action? Second point is that God did not take it away, but you forfeited it when your heart becomes stubborn to His Voice. Never think that we deserved His gracious act of love He showed through the works of Christ. No, everlasting life is a free gift offered to all who believes.

As paul said, are we to be fools thinking we begin our eternal life by the spirit, then my perfect our salvation by the works of the law or being good enough? -- Again, salvation is a free gift offered through God's gracious act of having justification received through faith. We have not and we cannot earn it. But are we to be fools to think that we can have a faithless heart after salvation and still enter into His rest?

If Salvation is by grace, and is freely given to people who do not deserve it. Then it can not be taken away because someone did not deserve to keep it. We did not deserve it, we will never deserve it. and to say otherwise it to place to much faith in self and not enough faith in God. -- So then, is God a liar to have said a name can be blotted out from the Lamb's Book of Life?

As for book of life. I believe everyone is written in, untilt hey die, those blotted out are done so because they committed the unpardonable sin, which is to reject the grace of God. -- Not according to those two verses which states a willful deception, a willful hardening of the heart. Plus, how can those who never believed in the works of the Christ have been written it that Book if they do not have Life, Jesus, in them by faith?
I find it odd NO ONE has answered the most important question. How can God say depart from me FOR I NEVER KNEW YOU, if he at one time knew them but they left him. Can God lie?

As for those two verses. Romans 1 takes care of that. They knew, thus they have NO EXCUSE. But God gave them over to a debased mind. Even so, Although they know they deserve judgment, they openly do the things which cause them to be judged,
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#38
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

I like what Paul said to the corinthians.

When I came to you. O sought nothing but the knowledge of Christ and him crucified.

Not stop sin, Not change your life. Not turn from you sin, nothing but Christ crucified.

The rest happens, as he explained to them in both his letters, AFTER you get saved and are born again into the family of God.
Yes understanding the real gospel leads to salvation. Been doing alot of thinking lately about
the carnal mind and the fleshy mind in relation to understanding spiritual things.Ive known
this for years but i think im gona get a deeper understanding soon.

An aquaintance said to me the other day that some cant understand the difference
between salvation and sanctification. Which make me wonder if they really understand the
gospel. Im not wondering whether God will show mercy...He will He knows we are but dust.
But when we are saved it takes awhile to not think fleshy and carnal thoughts and
takes some time till we see it in a spiritual way. Take trusting the Lord for instance.

All will say they do untill the first test.
 
Last edited:
F

feedm3

Guest
#39
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

I like what Paul said to the corinthians.

When I came to you. O sought nothing but the knowledge of Christ and him crucified.

Not stop sin, Not change your life. Not turn from you sin, nothing but Christ crucified.

The rest happens, as he explained to them in both his letters, AFTER you get saved and are born again into the family of God.
I love those passages as well. They say so much about some in Corinth.

I would like to point out, if we take out sin, repentance (stop sin, change your life") from the crucifixion message, there would be no message. All that would be left was the manner he died, and was hung on a cross which would not save anyone.

Why was he crucified? Because of our Sin

What was the point? So his blood would be shed so the WE CAN repent of sin.

If we teach Christ crucified, and yet do not include repentance and changing of life, from following sin, to serving Christ, then we have not preached Christ crucified.

Seeing the messages in the letters to Corinth, it is easy to understand with Paul's many warnings of continuing in sin, that preaching Christ crucified was the bases for the rest. Because that is the ONLY reason why we can repent and be forgiven.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#40
Re: Who did Jesus say would be told to "depart" from Him because he didn't know them?

I love those passages as well. They say so much about some in Corinth.

I would like to point out, if we take out sin, repentance (stop sin, change your life") from the crucifixion message, there would be no message. All that would be left was the manner he died, and was hung on a cross which would not save anyone.

Why was he crucified? Because of our Sin

What was the point? So his blood would be shed so the WE CAN repent of sin.

If we teach Christ crucified, and yet do not include repentance and changing of life, from following sin, to serving Christ, then we have not preached Christ crucified.

Seeing the messages in the letters to Corinth, it is easy to understand with Paul's many warnings of continuing in sin, that preaching Christ crucified was the bases for the rest. Because that is the ONLY reason why we can repent and be forgiven.

im not understanding the point....you cant preach the gospel with out repentance,
Thats part of the gospel...So fill me in on the point.