So Then What?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Z

zaoman32

Guest
#41
My first statement is not as much for Criss, as it is for several ignorant statements. If you have not been in, or experienced an abusive relationship, or have absolutely no idea what it's like, your statements are null and void, not to mention in complete opposition of the very bible you're backing your own arguments with. God never once calls divorce a sin (it says he hates it) He does however command us to love, abuse and manipulation are not love.

This next one is for Criss. In addition to advice I gave earlier (which may still need to exercise) I gather from reading your responses, as well as a select few from others, that you're are at the point where a decision needs to be made. Consider advice from Jullianna and Catherder who are urging you to pray so much. Pray constantly over the whole situation. Also consider the advice of Misty77 and Nod, since they've obviously dealt with the same.

Here's my thing, the breaking point for me with my ex was when she cheated on me, but another main factor was the verbal abuse (I didn't recognize the manipulation until later on). When I had left and was SERIOUSLY considering divorce, my kids were 4, 3, and 1. My daughter was 3 and even at that young age she was very sensitive to the emotional environment around her, and me and my ex living together (before separating) was making her extremely sad and upset. When I had left and talked to people who had been divorced about what was going on they all said, "Look, ultimately you don't want a divorce, but if you HAVE to, your kids are young, they're not going to remember about it as much now as they will if you wait until they're older, and it possibly explodes even bigger, and could scar them even more."

So, not telling you to get a divorce, but pray about the situation constantly, and like Misty said, even if not divorce, get some separation time. I have to fully agree with her in saying that you'll only be able to see things more clearly when you distance yourself for a time.
 
G

GreenNnice

Guest
#45
mizcris, and, others make good points here, even the ones that say to give up and divorce because you HAVE to, as one person caps put it, but , THAT is not the good point they've made. And, my comments may very well be 'null and void' and 'ignorant,' because I've never reallly dated (most dates I've been on with one girl is TWO), let alone been in a long-term relationship. No kids, no illegit kids, no rapes (no sex even. and have I had my chances? You bet! I'm not ugly, I'm not unintelligent, I'm not shy, I've been around girls a ton in my life, parties of all kinds, college for 4 years, etc.), no drunkenness in my entire life, but I was close to drunk once.

THERE, that prefaces what I'm about to say next.

Am I ignorant? Is what I say NEXT null and void? You decide :)

God NEVER wants divorce. Did you hear me correctly? There is never a "HAVE TO" when it comes to divorce. It's a DECISION--and, NO, I'm NOT sorry when I do caps, the Lord leads, this I HOPE and PRAY, they're for emphasis :) ) that someone MAKES.

Now, WHY is that decision made ?

Good question, green?

Yeah, it is, isn't it. A good question, hmmm. (And, I may sound glib here, or, something else, no, no, no. And, as I told those arguing about something in streams of consciousness thread yesterday, in so many words, I said, it's AWFULLY hard to convey or 'inflect' my tears, my smiles, my words, even, OVER THE INTERNET to y'all. And, YOU are not immune to this either :) )

So, we get to the abuse, finally, and, the answer IS......what IS the abuse? WHY is everything your marriage partner saying abusive TO YOU?

And, if we go a step further than emotional abuse, then, WHY is the person hurting you PHYSICALLY? Did they just suddenly SNAP! and go off on you physically, emotionally, manipulatively ABUSING you? Not likely. There's a reason WHY they began abusing YOU. And, NO, it's NEVER right to be abused, it's NEVER right to think it's YOUR fault, but, it's not right to think it's the abuser's fault either WITHOUT going to Christ, without taking a serious look at WHY they began abusing YOU.

Now, mizcris says she's being abused NOW. Has it been for the whole relationship, from when she first went out with the person? Maybe? Not likely, but, yeah, maybe, But, what likely happened is that something HAPPENED that led to the........abuse. What happened? Did they start smoking and it made the person upset? Drinking? Crack cocaine? Cannabis?

I mean, WHAT happened? Something happened? The person isn't suddenly a raving, abusing lunatic, are they? No.
Maybe, YOU started to do something differently, maybe, YOU started to get upset at them for things, maybe, sports watching, or, going hunting more, or ????? The list goes on and on............Guys like to do a lot of things :) And, we don't like shopping ! :D I say half in jest, half serious. But, yeah.....

And, NO, in all my past posts, two of them, to be exact, I've not said that the abused should stick around in the house if being abused PHYSICALLY, SEXUALLY. But, that's between you and God and His Spirit, who, yes, Scripture tells us, not just me, not just, green :), that He is IN our HEART :) That's a powerful, powerful, p--p-POWERFUL Truth of God. He's in us. Wow!

Wow, green.


So, WHY won't they go to counseling? WHAT is there reason?

OK, so they won't go to counseling? Fine, it's a serious problem, but what can you do but pray, at that point. Have faith, too, because, prayer changes things IF its to Him. That's definitely time, if being physically abused to go to your church and ask them--careful, I'm not a professional counselor, so, pray this all over well, to Him, want your heart afte His, contrite even Isaiah 66:2 :) -- for help. A lot of churches, big churches,at least, like mine, as I've gone to mine for several sessions that helped my relationship with my dad, which WAS abusive in the workplace, become better, become understood. And, guess what? My dad began to TRY To change how he spoke to me at work. That WILLINGNESS to change was all it took for me as I could tell after confronting him, going to counseling both, he was different around me, even, positive, a little. It's so hard to change for an abuser, the ABUSED has to understand that. 'Course, getting slapped every once in awhile is NOT good; you shouldn't EVER be slapped by your spouse. But, back to my dad story, TRULY, the actual confronting him and telling him that he was losing so much productivity, not to mention, relationship future happenings wtih his son if he kept up the never-positive criticism of my skidding, logging, I would not be around to be his son anymore. That hit home, that changed things , for my dad and I :)

Mizcris!!!! You are not worthless, don't EVER let you think that of yourself, you're soooo funny on c.c. Out of respect for your being married, or, I would be teasing and kidding you a lot more on your posts. I don't do it , for that main reason, just like there ARE girls on c.c. that I like but I DON'T flirt with them because the Lord has NEVER led me to think that I would fly 3,000 miles east to meet them. So...... YOU are very, very, VERY hilarious, flat-out a '10' rating for your humor on cc, to me, anyway. I've never said it before, until now, I just want the Lord to work on people's hearts, but, I SEE the Lord more and more interwoven into your posts and I KNOW that's Christ convicting you to entertain going deeper with Him in your relationship, and, no, 'convict' does not mean 'shame' or 'blame,' God is just seeing your openness to move forward toward new things of Him and He's moving you as YOU MOVE :)

Now, this is the last thing I will say here, and, I thank EVERYONE for putting up with green's way of speaking, I don't mean no none harm, y'all, I HATE abuse and am EXTREMELY upset at mizcris' situation and, yes, the kids of hers, that's a toughie to figure out best. I hear what zaoofmen is saying about leaving now with kids is better than older, not as 'scarred.' But, that is not even a LAST RESORT in my mind. God doesn't say He 'hates' divorce, and, yes, divorce is a sin, just like ANYTHING that seperates us from God is. And, God doesn't want us to divorce, that's a fact, that's in the bible. But, the bigger point, is, again, to make things work and I'm done with caps now. The two having problems in their marriage need to make things work. If the person being abused needs to seperate and let God work, then, so be it, that is the Lord's leading. But, don't give up on the marriage, keep wholeheartedly in prayer, and, again, really, really, really, take a look at your own self, mizcris, and, ask your husband why you are feeling worthless. Ask your husband why everything he does is right and why everything you do is wrong. Tell your husband that you raised the kids while he worked, that you cook, clean, as best you can, and, if 'I need help cooking and cleaning and raising kids and speaking to you better so you speak to me better then what do you suggest we do? Don't we want to live our lives as the Lord leads us? Don't we want to show our kids a Christian relationship between ourselves? "

And, if they are continuing abuse after confronting them, laying your heart on the line, and, after you have had faith in God to clean even more, cook even more, do things for that person even more, to compliment that person more in the face of being abused, to tell their kids that their dad is a great father who loves them and is taking the family to church.....


When you have done everything that God's put on your heart, mizcris, and, you're still being abused, then, that's the time to leave the home and pray, pray, pray, pray that God will do a miracle while you are still married but are away from him, then, go forever if He leads you that way and you will know, the Lord leads.

But, don't ever give up on God in this time. While you are then still writing him letters, or, calling him, letting him know that you love him but not his actions, and, will not be coming back to the abuse and, still, letting him know that his actions on Earth are to be love, more important than 'faith' and 'hope,' so says 1 Cor. 13.
 
R

Relena7

Guest
#46
I would rather marry a compassionate agnostic man who was not abusive than marry an abusive "christian" man who was "never wrong".
 
G

GreenNnice

Guest
#47
I would rather marry a compassionate agnostic man who was not abusive than marry an abusive "christian" man who was "never wrong".
If that's the case, rel, then, God is saying to never marry anyone. " Be not unequally yoked."

God will speak to you, too, as you go out with a guy who is an abusive believer, because one can abuse and still be WANTING to be a Christian and going to heaven wanting. I won't judge, condemn them but God does say no idolaters, adulterous, etc. will be in heaven. But, yes, that is not love, as zaoofmen said aptly, and, love is not abuse. He does not want you to marry an abusive Christian man.

Galatians 5 :
"The acts of the flesh are obvious: sexual immorality, impurity and debauchery; 20idolatry and witchcraft; hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions 21and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. I warn you, as I did before, that those who live like this will not inherit the kingdom of God. 22But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, 23gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law. 24Those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires. 25Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit. 26Let us not become conceited, provoking and envying each other."


abuse can be classified in the bold-faced named , of course.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
R

Relena7

Guest
#48
Well to me, marrying an abusive person (christian or not) would do more damage to my christian faith than marrying someone who didn't make me feel worthless.
 
L

lav

Guest
#49
Green are you suggesting there are no such things as personality disorders like extreme narcissism, sociopathy and psychopathy...

surely these kinds of people do not need a reason to start abuse. they are already hard-wired for it.

i know. i was with one for seven years.
he abused me until there was almost nothing left of me.

to suggest that someone being blatantly, repeatedly abusive can be justified in their abuse because their partner does or does not do something, or did or did not do something- doesn't speak very well of your character.

abuse is never justified. plain and simple.

you never treat anyone that way, no matter what they do or do not do.
abuse is never the answer, in any circumstance.

by the way, would you like to take her or a number of other women's places ?
would you stand in for her, and live her life enduring perpetual torment or abuse, and leave your own ?
would you trade with her... and live the life she is subjected to, if she stays with this person who seems entirely unresponsive and noncompliant when it comes to solutions, counseling, therapy... times of separation and the like ?

would you walk the rest of your life in her shoes, and take her place ?

ask yourself this, and ask honestly.
would you take her place and absorb all the terrible abuse yourself ?
 
Last edited:
Feb 10, 2008
3,371
16
38
#50
Green are you suggesting there are no such things as personality disorders like extreme narcissism, sociopathy and psychopathy...

surely these kinds of people do not need a reason to start abuse. they are already hard-wired for it.

i know. i was with one for seven years.
he abused me until there was almost nothing left of me.

to suggest that someone being blatantly, repeatedly abusive can be justified in their abuse because their partner does or does not do something, or did or did not do something- doesn't speak very well of your character.

abuse is never justified. plain and simple.

you never treat anyone that way, no matter what they do or do not do.
abuse is never the answer, in any circumstance.
Lav,

I'm confused by your posts, especially this last one. It seems like you are making statements unrelated to the subject of discussion in this thread. I haven't seen anything posted here that discusses whether or not someone should be abusive or is justified in doing so. This thread is focused on the actions of the person being abused. :/ And how they can deal with the abuse in a God honoring way.

I'm pretty confident that I can answer for GreenNNice when I say that He is not claiming that abuse is ever the loving answer to anything.
 

Misty77

Senior Member
Aug 30, 2013
1,746
45
0
#51
NO hijacking this thread. If you have disagreements among yourselves, take it elsewhere (as I already have).
 
L

lav

Guest
#52
Lav,

I'm confused by your posts, especially this last one. It seems like you are making statements unrelated to the subject of discussion in this thread. I haven't seen anything posted here that discusses whether or not someone should be abusive or is justified in doing so. This thread is focused on the actions of the person being abused. :/ And how they can deal with the abuse in a God honoring way.

I'm pretty confident that I can answer for GreenNNice when I say that He is not claiming that abuse is ever the loving answer to anything.
man as husband and head of the household is subject to the laws and rules of his government and foremost God.
this man is not following Christ, he does not treat his wife the way Christ treats His church, and shows no consideration for change in regard to treating the people in his life he should love, care for and respect the most... a heck of a lot better.

what more evidence do you need ?

your posts make absolutely no sense to me.
they show you do not know about abusive situations, no matter what you may say.
God only expects a woman to submit and follow his direction, if the husband submits and follows God's direction, first.
this man is not acting in a godly manner, nor is he following in the example of Christ. you clearly don't know enough about abusive situations to suppose, suspect or postulate that an abuser will change.
they simply don't.
it doesn't happen.
this man is obviously not seeking Christ to show him how to lead his family... it seems he has been behaving this way for sometime, which is very common in cases of abuse.
idolize, devalue, discard.
is a repeat process that narcissists, sociopaths and psychopaths use to maintain a cycle, so that they can get what they want out of a situation... until the final sting.
these kinds of people lack empathy and compassion.
there are brain scans which show this... they are missing a few or several key pieces to the fundamentals of being a a true Christian ...such as a blatant disregard for other's feelings, a total lack of compassion and zero empathy.

you can pray all your days away for them and waste your life waiting for them to change.

they are masters at glib and superficial charm and manipulation- they are con men. they isolate their victims, and continue on with no mercy or thought of repentance. there are really people like this in this world.

do you really think God would want any of his children to continue enabling this kind of abusive predator, and be forced to waste their life away waiting for someone who is most likely never going to change ? why would He want someone who is seeking Christ to allow themselves to be beaten down to nothing, maybe even die in the process... just to preserve a marriage?
 
Last edited:
G

GreenNnice

Guest
#53
Green are you suggesting there are no such things as personality disorders like extreme narcissism, sociopathy and psychopathy...

surely these kinds of people do not need a reason to start abuse. they are already hard-wired for it.

i know. i was with one for seven years.
he abused me until there was almost nothing left of me.

to suggest that someone being blatantly, repeatedly abusive can be justified in their abuse because their partner does or does not do something, or did or did not do something- doesn't speak very well of your character.

abuse is never justified. plain and simple.

you never treat anyone that way, no matter what they do or do not do.
abuse is never the answer, in any circumstance.

by the way, would you like to take her or a number of other women's places ?
would you stand in for her, and live her life enduring perpetual torment or abuse, and leave your own ?
would you trade with her... and live the life she is subjected to, if she stays with this person who seems entirely unresponsive and noncompliant when it comes to solutions, counseling, therapy... times of separation and the like ?

would you walk the rest of your life in her shoes, and take her place ?

ask yourself this, and ask honestly.
would you take her place and absorb all the terrible abuse yourself ?
Words are often not said perfect in a social arena such as this but I would never, just as lightnin' says, justify ANY form of abuse in ANY way, ANY shape, ANY form. I know my posts are long, confusing, I'm sorry for that, I'm long-winded on certain subjects and my heart breaks for mizcris and her kids, even her husband, who may not even realize he's abusing her, but, of course, he is still hurting her. He needs help, no way I'm saying not, I'm just saying, like lightnin' says too, to pray for the abuser and to REALIZE that working things out is the ONLY choice unless God says different, and, I didn't like these words lightnin' said, 'unless God makes it physically impossible,' but, no doubt, God will, at some point, just work things out for good for those that love Him, like Romans 8:28 says :) , even IF the two are married, with kids, and, they decide that they are not going to work it out, so,they divorce.

But, NO! I will NEVER justify abuse, and, someone who is living their life for the Lord, will understand abuse in a marriage is absolutely, positively unacceptable and not according to the will of God, ever.

But, we all sin and make mistakes and are still a Christian, we've still accepted Christ,, and, I probably reach into doctrine some with the OSAS (once saved, always saved) and others believing different than me folk, but, I BELIEVE that we are CONFESSION AWAY from being cleansed of our unrighteousness and ABUSE is merely 'sin.' In God's eyes, abuse is right the same as any other adultery, sexual immoraility, fits of rage, etc. of Galatians 5 explained, they are all simply 'sin.'

How so, green, what verse?

"If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness." 1 John 1:9

But, no, no, no, lavHislady, no, no, no, and, I apologize in advance if my words say different, or, you think they said different, I NEVER support abuse. I simply want us to allow Christ to work on the abuser, I believe in HOPE, 100%, not the hopelessness of "5%" being able to be changed. Whosoever has faith in Him, in Him changing them WILL be changed :)

I speak in love and so does lightnin' , milady. The Lord leads :)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
L

lav

Guest
#54
"they are missing a few or several key pieces to the fundamentals of being a a true Christian ... *considering the fact that they hold such attitudes/attributes such as a blatant disregard for other's feelings, a total lack of compassion and zero empathy."


- i needed to correct that, it wasn't worded very well... and i'm not sure if it is even now. i know MissCriss knows what to do, i am not here to argue or debate... this is my final entry- i never posted to upset you MissCriss, i'm just astounded at any response that expects you to go on and possibly waste the rest of your life waiting, hoping and praying for someone who seems to lack empathy, to change.
of course no one wants divorce! but there are special circumstances in which sometimes it turns out to be the best option for all parties involved. in the case of extreme and repeated abuse of any kind... or continual abuse of any kind, i do not think God would judge you at all for wanting to extricate yourself and your babies from these kinds of unstable and unhealthy situations.
 
Last edited:
G

GreenNnice

Guest
#55
they are missing a few or several key pieces to the fundamentals of being a a true Christian ... *considering the fact that they hold such attitudes/attributes such as a blatant disregard for other's feelings, a total lack of compassion and zero empathy.


- i needed to correct that, it wasn't worded very well... and i'm not sure if it even is now. i know MissCriss knows what to do, i am not here to argue or debate... this is my final entry- i never posted to upset you MissCriss, i'm just astounded at any response that expects you to go on and possibly waste the rest of your life waiting, hoping, praying for someone who seems to lack empathy, to change.
of course no one wants divorce! but there are special circumstances in which sometimes it turns out to be the best options for all parties involved. in the case of extreme and repeated abuse of any kind... or continual abuse of any kind, i do not think God would judge you at all for wanting to extricate yourself and your babies from this kind of unstable and unhealthy situation.
I agree, and, mizcris, she has done nothing wrong but live her life to follow Christ and the Lord will continue to be in her life as she follows Him and that is all I'm saying, to follow Him, for the Lord leads, our job is simple as humans..... Follow Him :)

'...you follow Me.' John 21:22 explains it well, with Peter talking to Jesus, upset that John will be the only of The Twelve to not die a horrible martyr's death. Jesus tells Peter. "If I will that he (John) remains, what is that to you, you follow Me."
 
M

MissCris

Guest
#56
So, we get to the abuse, finally, and, the answer IS......what IS the abuse? WHY is everything your marriage partner saying abusive TO YOU?


And, if we go a step further than emotional abuse, then, WHY is the person hurting you PHYSICALLY? Did they just suddenly SNAP! and go off on you physically, emotionally, manipulatively ABUSING you? Not likely. There's a reason WHY they began abusing YOU. And, NO, it's NEVER right to be abused, it's NEVER right to think it's YOUR fault, but, it's not right to think it's the abuser's fault either WITHOUT going to Christ, without taking a serious look at WHY they began abusing YOU.

Now, mizcris says she's being abused NOW. Has it been for the whole relationship, from when she first went out with the person? Maybe? Not likely, but, yeah, maybe, But, what likely happened is that something HAPPENED that led to the........abuse. What happened? Did they start smoking and it made the person upset? Drinking? Crack cocaine? Cannabis?

I mean, WHAT happened? Something happened? The person isn't suddenly a raving, abusing lunatic, are they? No.
Maybe, YOU started to do something differently, maybe, YOU started to get upset at them for things, maybe, sports watching, or, going hunting more, or ????? The list goes on and on............Guys like to do a lot of things :) And, we don't like shopping ! :D I say half in jest, half serious. But, yeah.....
Green...
I'm sorry, I think you're a pretty good guy and usually very uplifting to others...
But what you've said to me is pretty hurtful. You've made it sound like it's my fault he started this. Like something I did caused him to start the cycle of abuse with me.

And that's just simply not how it works. It is NEVER the victim's fault- so anyone else reading this who is in an abusive relationship, listen up- IT. IS. NOT. YOUR. FAULT.

My husband grew up with an abusive father. My husband began the abuse, verbal and emotional, while we were still dating. I was just too freshly wounded and too young and too stupid to see what was happening.

10 years later, I see it, and I'm trying to figure out how to do something about it.
I didn't cause this. I didn't nag him into it, I didn't say hurtful things to him, I didn't try to control him, I didn't try to push him away...I did nothing, NOTHING, that caused him to be this way to me.

...except for marry him and allow it to continue. That is on me. I did that.

If anyone else would like to blame me for where I'm at right now...keep it to yourself, please. I've had quite enough of taking the blame for things that aren't my fault.
 
Mar 22, 2013
4,718
124
63
Indiana
#57
to make it short, Abusers only change if THEY WANT to change, and biggest majority do not want to change.

If in an abusive relationship its time to leave it. honestly. Yeah God dislikes divorce, but God also dislikes Abuse. God gave you a brain use it.
 
U

Ugly

Guest
#58
mizcris, and, others make good points here, even the ones that say to give up and divorce because you HAVE to, as one person caps put it, but , THAT is not the good point they've made. And, my comments may very well be 'null and void' and 'ignorant,' because I've never reallly dated (most dates I've been on with one girl is TWO), let alone been in a long-term relationship. No kids, no illegit kids, no rapes (no sex even. and have I had my chances? You bet! I'm not ugly, I'm not unintelligent, I'm not shy, I've been around girls a ton in my life, parties of all kinds, college for 4 years, etc.), no drunkenness in my entire life, but I was close to drunk once.

THERE, that prefaces what I'm about to say next.

Am I ignorant? Is what I say NEXT null and void? You decide :)

God NEVER wants divorce. Did you hear me correctly? There is never a "HAVE TO" when it comes to divorce. It's a DECISION--and, NO, I'm NOT sorry when I do caps, the Lord leads, this I HOPE and PRAY, they're for emphasis :) ) that someone MAKES.

Now, WHY is that decision made ?

Good question, green?

Yeah, it is, isn't it. A good question, hmmm. (And, I may sound glib here, or, something else, no, no, no. And, as I told those arguing about something in streams of consciousness thread yesterday, in so many words, I said, it's AWFULLY hard to convey or 'inflect' my tears, my smiles, my words, even, OVER THE INTERNET to y'all. And, YOU are not immune to this either :) )

So, we get to the abuse, finally, and, the answer IS......what IS the abuse? WHY is everything your marriage partner saying abusive TO YOU?

And, if we go a step further than emotional abuse, then, WHY is the person hurting you PHYSICALLY? Did they just suddenly SNAP! and go off on you physically, emotionally, manipulatively ABUSING you? Not likely. There's a reason WHY they began abusing YOU. And, NO, it's NEVER right to be abused, it's NEVER right to think it's YOUR fault, but, it's not right to think it's the abuser's fault either WITHOUT going to Christ, without taking a serious look at WHY they began abusing YOU.

Now, mizcris says she's being abused NOW. Has it been for the whole relationship, from when she first went out with the person? Maybe? Not likely, but, yeah, maybe, But, what likely happened is that something HAPPENED that led to the........abuse. What happened? Did they start smoking and it made the person upset? Drinking? Crack cocaine? Cannabis?

I mean, WHAT happened? Something happened? The person isn't suddenly a raving, abusing lunatic, are they? No.
Maybe, YOU started to do something differently, maybe, YOU started to get upset at them for things, maybe, sports watching, or, going hunting more, or ????? The list goes on and on............Guys like to do a lot of things :) And, we don't like shopping ! :D I say half in jest, half serious. But, yeah.....

And, NO, in all my past posts, two of them, to be exact, I've not said that the abused should stick around in the house if being abused PHYSICALLY, SEXUALLY. But, that's between you and God and His Spirit, who, yes, Scripture tells us, not just me, not just, green :), that He is IN our HEART :) That's a powerful, powerful, p--p-POWERFUL Truth of God. He's in us. Wow!

Wow, green.


So, WHY won't they go to counseling? WHAT is there reason?

OK, so they won't go to counseling? Fine, it's a serious problem, but what can you do but pray, at that point. Have faith, too, because, prayer changes things IF its to Him. That's definitely time, if being physically abused to go to your church and ask them--careful, I'm not a professional counselor, so, pray this all over well, to Him, want your heart afte His, contrite even Isaiah 66:2 :) -- for help. A lot of churches, big churches,at least, like mine, as I've gone to mine for several sessions that helped my relationship with my dad, which WAS abusive in the workplace, become better, become understood. And, guess what? My dad began to TRY To change how he spoke to me at work. That WILLINGNESS to change was all it took for me as I could tell after confronting him, going to counseling both, he was different around me, even, positive, a little. It's so hard to change for an abuser, the ABUSED has to understand that. 'Course, getting slapped every once in awhile is NOT good; you shouldn't EVER be slapped by your spouse. But, back to my dad story, TRULY, the actual confronting him and telling him that he was losing so much productivity, not to mention, relationship future happenings wtih his son if he kept up the never-positive criticism of my skidding, logging, I would not be around to be his son anymore. That hit home, that changed things , for my dad and I :)

Mizcris!!!! You are not worthless, don't EVER let you think that of yourself, you're soooo funny on c.c. Out of respect for your being married, or, I would be teasing and kidding you a lot more on your posts. I don't do it , for that main reason, just like there ARE girls on c.c. that I like but I DON'T flirt with them because the Lord has NEVER led me to think that I would fly 3,000 miles east to meet them. So...... YOU are very, very, VERY hilarious, flat-out a '10' rating for your humor on cc, to me, anyway. I've never said it before, until now, I just want the Lord to work on people's hearts, but, I SEE the Lord more and more interwoven into your posts and I KNOW that's Christ convicting you to entertain going deeper with Him in your relationship, and, no, 'convict' does not mean 'shame' or 'blame,' God is just seeing your openness to move forward toward new things of Him and He's moving you as YOU MOVE :)

Now, this is the last thing I will say here, and, I thank EVERYONE for putting up with green's way of speaking, I don't mean no none harm, y'all, I HATE abuse and am EXTREMELY upset at mizcris' situation and, yes, the kids of hers, that's a toughie to figure out best. I hear what zaoofmen is saying about leaving now with kids is better than older, not as 'scarred.' But, that is not even a LAST RESORT in my mind. God doesn't say He 'hates' divorce, and, yes, divorce is a sin, just like ANYTHING that seperates us from God is. And, God doesn't want us to divorce, that's a fact, that's in the bible. But, the bigger point, is, again, to make things work and I'm done with caps now. The two having problems in their marriage need to make things work. If the person being abused needs to seperate and let God work, then, so be it, that is the Lord's leading. But, don't give up on the marriage, keep wholeheartedly in prayer, and, again, really, really, really, take a look at your own self, mizcris, and, ask your husband why you are feeling worthless. Ask your husband why everything he does is right and why everything you do is wrong. Tell your husband that you raised the kids while he worked, that you cook, clean, as best you can, and, if 'I need help cooking and cleaning and raising kids and speaking to you better so you speak to me better then what do you suggest we do? Don't we want to live our lives as the Lord leads us? Don't we want to show our kids a Christian relationship between ourselves? "

And, if they are continuing abuse after confronting them, laying your heart on the line, and, after you have had faith in God to clean even more, cook even more, do things for that person even more, to compliment that person more in the face of being abused, to tell their kids that their dad is a great father who loves them and is taking the family to church.....


When you have done everything that God's put on your heart, mizcris, and, you're still being abused, then, that's the time to leave the home and pray, pray, pray, pray that God will do a miracle while you are still married but are away from him, then, go forever if He leads you that way and you will know, the Lord leads.

But, don't ever give up on God in this time. While you are then still writing him letters, or, calling him, letting him know that you love him but not his actions, and, will not be coming back to the abuse and, still, letting him know that his actions on Earth are to be love, more important than 'faith' and 'hope,' so says 1 Cor. 13.
I didn't even need to finish reading to find out how utterly and completely ignorant you are on this subject. In one breath you say 'its not your fault' and then turn around and say 'what did you do to start it?'. This mentality that a person has done something to cause abuse against themselves is flat out moronic. In one fraction of a response on a subject you obviously have no clue whatsoever on, you have caused me to lose a LOT of respect for you. Anyone who think an abuse victim is at fault or has 'done something to cause it' needs to pull their head out of their... you know... and go learn something before opening their mouth on a topic they have no right to be commenting on.
And guess what, prefacing your comment with an explanation that you have ZERO experience or knowledge of any kind, on the subject doesn't excuse your flagrant, insensitive, legalistic ignorance in the least bit.

And as i said in the other thread on this, once again someone who has no clue thinks they have any right to comment on things to fly their ignorance proudly in the air by putting the abuser as the victim and the real victim as the cause for blame. And then continue on in more ignorance by accusing a person that they haven't done enough, sought God enough. Your post is a slap in the face to Cristen, and pretty much any other person who reads this that has been abused. I am honestly disgusted by this post any others like it. This attitude is inexcusable. Maybe next time you should get a clue before thinking you should open your mouth to give advice. Congratulations on insulting many of the women on this site.. and disgusting some others. You must be proud.
 
G

GreenNnice

Guest
#59
Green...
I'm sorry, I think you're a pretty good guy and usually very uplifting to others...
But what you've said to me is pretty hurtful. You've made it sound like it's my fault he started this. Like something I did caused him to start the cycle of abuse with me.

And that's just simply not how it works. It is NEVER the victim's fault- so anyone else reading this who is in an abusive relationship, listen up- IT. IS. NOT. YOUR. FAULT.

My husband grew up with an abusive father. My husband began the abuse, verbal and emotional, while we were still dating. I was just too freshly wounded and too young and too stupid to see what was happening.

10 years later, I see it, and I'm trying to figure out how to do something about it.
I didn't cause this. I didn't nag him into it, I didn't say hurtful things to him, I didn't try to control him, I didn't try to push him away...I did nothing, NOTHING, that caused him to be this way to me.

...except for marry him and allow it to continue. That is on me. I did that.

If anyone else would like to blame me for where I'm at right now...keep it to yourself, please. I've had quite enough of taking the blame for things that aren't my fault.
Mizcris, I am not blaming you, and, my last post before this post should explain that, so, forgive me for sounding that way, because that is not how I want to sound. I'm sorry to sound like that, I simply am saying that your husband NEEDS to go to Christian marriage counseling for why he is doing the things to you, why he is making you feel worthless, why he is always right and you are always wrong.

And, I already said, abuse is bad and physical abuse is the last straw, it's time to go, I didn't say anything blaming you on purpose, not my intent, just saying that your husband needs to understand why he is abusing you. You can tell him THIS and go from the house. I would mention his father too, that he is doing the kinds of things to you that he explained to you, at some point in your relationship I'm sure he shared, didn't he, that he was abused by his own dad.

I also explained to you that my dad hurt me and I finally, after TWO years of working with him in the woods logging, confronted him and said, 'IF you don't just once say something positive to me, I will not be seeing you a whole lot the rest of my life. I work hard skidding, falling trees, and, you never say anything nice to me, dad. I'm done with that. Find a way to postiively criticize me. Not only is it just bad on me, but, you are losing a lot of productivity because of it.'

I left that afternoon. THREE days later, my dad called me and said , 'Son, I just am not able to be real positive...'

That was all I needed to hear, I came back then and I was skidding 3 to 5 log truck loads to the landing per day, while for the first two years I was lucky if I skidded a half load a day. Dad couldn't even keep up with me ! And, he wasn't using a chainsaw to cut down the trees, he was using a fellerbuncher that clips the trees as it goes along on tracks !

The difference that made for me to confront my dad changed our relationship in a big way, mizcris, I hope and pray this helps you in some way. The Lord leads. Again, sorry, that my words sounded like they were blaming you. No, no, no, I simply am asking you to go to Christ for the answers of your husbands behavior and your own reasons for leaving. I am not questioning your reasons, milady,

blessings and love, green :)
 
L

lav

Guest
#60
Words are often not said perfect in a social arena such as this but I would never, just as lightnin' says, justify ANY form of abuse in ANY way, ANY shape, ANY form. I know my posts are long, confusing, I'm sorry for that, I'm long-winded on certain subjects and my heart breaks for mizcris and her kids, even her husband, who may not even realize he's abusing her, but, of course, he is still hurting her. He needs help, no way I'm saying not, I'm just saying, like lightnin' says too, to pray for the abuser and to REALIZE that working things out is the ONLY choice unless God says different, and, I didn't like these words lightnin' said, 'unless God makes it physically impossible,' but, no doubt, God will, at some point, just work things out for good for those that love Him, like Romans 8:28 says :) , even IF the two are married, with kids, and, they decide that they are not going to work it out, so,they divorce.

But, NO! I will NEVER justify abuse, and, someone who is living their life for the Lord, will understand abuse in a marriage is absolutely, positively unacceptable and not according to the will of God, ever.

But, we all sin and make mistakes and are still a Christian, we've still accepted Christ,, and, I probably reach into doctrine some with the OSAS (once saved, always saved) and others believing different than me folk, but, I BELIEVE that we are CONFESSION AWAY from being cleansed of our unrighteousness and ABUSE is merely 'sin.' In God's eyes, abuse is right the same as any other adultery, sexual immoraility, fits of rage, etc. of Galatians 5 explained, they are all simply 'sin.'

How so, green, what verse?

"If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness." 1 John 1:9

But, no, no, no, lavHislady, no, no, no, and, I apologize in advance if my words say different, or, you think they said different, I NEVER support abuse. I simply want us to allow Christ to work on the abuser, I believe in HOPE, 100%, not the hopelessness of "5%" being able to be changed. Whosoever has faith in Him, in Him changing them WILL be changed :)

I speak in love and so does lightnin' , milady. The Lord leads :)
i very much respect your response, i would like to thank you for such a kind and generous way of resolving things.
you're right, in so much of what you say.. and i'd like to word this better... but i just want to go rest after all of this - though i love and respect you all, i didn't mean to come off as disrespectful... and my situation and research of these types of personality disorders and the statistics i have found there-in, do not offer very favorable outcomes in the sense of repentance and redemption of these types of characters.

however !

i am with you about praying and leaning on Christ and following the course that God wants us to follow in our lives... and i don't pretend to have all the answers, i just fear for the safety and well being, mental-emotional-spiritual, etc. health of those who are subjected to incredibly damaging and harmful abuse.

that is not to say we should not pray for the abuser, but i also don't think that they should be a part of the family if that is all they will do ...and prove this time and again.

i think getting away and separating physically are very important now, no matter how much prayer or thought is put into it... no one needs to endure abuse. it would be the best thing if somehow a miracle occurred, and the abuser turned around and really changed his ways... sought counseling and guidance through a good church and other good male models to help hold himself accountable. a complete turn-around is what we all want, it's just that the odds and the likelihood are not that great when you do the research. that does not mean, that i don't sincerely wish he would turn around and that all those things would happen so that this couple could start fresh and begin a new life together... in safety and honesty for all members concerned.

i'm tired - so it may not be great, and this entry could make it in too late, to show that i do not want to argue or fight- and i am sorry if i have been adamant to the point of going overboard. i just really know how bad it is to be on the other side of abuse... to be the abused, and i wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy.

thank you, i respect your response, Green.. and i didn't mean to come down too hard... i apologize if anything i said was out of line. i didn't assume those things of you, and perhaps should have used more careful wording-
just trying to get to the bottom of this, since it has affected me deeply in my personal life. i don't want to be accusatory, and i'm sorry that i may have come off this way.

agape love to you brother,
in Christ-
Lav.

it's just that MissCriss is battling for her sanity and her life and those of her children, and i've been there.
 
Last edited: