What's Our Christian Responsibility to Christian Ex-Girlfriends/Boyfriends?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,138
362
83
#21
Your Christian ex is now a sister/brother in Christ and you should treat them accordingly.
Thanks, IndianGirl. Did you read the first post? How would you apply what you said to the situation presented in the first post?
 

MatthewWestfieldUK

Well-known member
May 13, 2021
871
498
63
#22
Oh yeah, there's underlying issues. She told me what they were.

Still, I don't know why you're saying "her behavior shows an imbalance". What behavior(s) are you referring to? And what do you mean by "an imbalance"?
When you said.....
She professes to be a christian, but never wanted to talk about her personal conversion; most often she only references wacky fringe videos on end-times issues, giants, Biden sign-of-the-beast, lowbrow conspiracy junk; she's a narcissist: continues to do horribly insensitive things that you'd think she knows hurts me deeply.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,138
362
83
#24
Can two walk together without agreeing where to go? From Amos 3:3:)
LOL interesting! You're a tricky one, Magenta! I think they call this eisegesis use of scripture.

When you said.....
She professes to be a christian, but never wanted to talk about her personal conversion; most often she only references wacky fringe videos on end-times issues, giants, Biden sign-of-the-beast, lowbrow conspiracy junk; she's a narcissist: continues to do horribly insensitive things that you'd think she knows hurts me deeply.
I like you Matthew. You like to come at things from an angle. You often don't answer questions directly. Curious if you mean imbalance is she treats me different than I treat her. Or if you mean she has a "mental imbalance"; which doesn't mean the same thing.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
59,816
29,195
113
#25
LOL interesting! You're a tricky one, Magenta! I think they call this eisegesis use of scripture.
How so? :unsure:

What about it do you disagree with?

It certainly seems applicable to me.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,138
362
83
#26
How so? :unsure:

What about it do you disagree with?

It certainly seems applicable to me.
The verse, as a stand alone, is applicable, which would be eisegesis, or otherwise out of context. Which is cool, and I dig it the wider use of it's wisdom, or use as a proverb.

However, what that verse means in context (exegesis) probably takes a scholar, but the two commentaries on this verse from biblehub says the 'two' in the verse is likely God and Israel; and in context means man needs to be in harmony with God's way if man is to walk with God, and since Israel isn't in harmony with God's way Israel is facing God's judgment. And so, in context, it's not suggesting all readers of this verse should not hang with people if they're not agreeing on the same course (where to go).

The full text where this is taken from is:
"1Hear this word that the LORD has spoken against you, O children of Israel, against the whole family that I brought up out of the land of Egypt:
2“Only you have I knowna
from all the families of the earth;
therefore I will punish you
for all your iniquities.”
3Can two walk together
without agreeing where to go?
b
4Does a lion roar in the forest
when he has no prey?
Does a young lion growl in his den
if he has caught nothing?
5Does a bird land in a snare
where no bait has been set?
Does a trap spring from the ground
when it has nothing to catch?
6If a ram’s horn sounds in a city,
do the people not tremble?
If calamity comes to a city,
has not the LORD caused it?
7Surely the Lord GOD does nothing
without revealing His plan
to His servants the prophets."


Commentaries on this verse:

Ellicott's Commentary for English Readers
(3) Two.--Who are the two here represented? Some commentators say, two prophets; Rosenmller, "God and the prophet." But Grotius, Lowth, Henderson, and Pusey refer it, with more reason, to God and Israel, the expression denoting, not merely God's knowledge of a man, but man's response to God. His practical obedience, his communion of heart and will, are described as "walking with" or "before God." (Genesis 5:22; Genesis 6:9; Genesis 17:1; Psalm 56:13; Psalm 116:9.) Will, then, God walk with man, guiding, shielding, strengthening him, if man is not in harmony with Him? This is the first of a series of parabolic apothegms, all of which require a negative answer. (Leviticus 26:23-24.) Each states an event, closely and indissolubly related to another in the bond of cause and effect. All these symbolic utterances point on to the climax in Amos 3:7-8. . . .

Pulpit Commentary
Verses 3-8. - Before announcing more particularly the coming judgment, Amos, by a series of little parables or comparisons, establishes his right to prophesy, and intimates the necessity laid upon him to deliver his message. He illustrates the truths that all effects have causes, and that from the cause you can infer the effect. Verse 3. - Can two walk together except they be agreed? or, except they have agreed? The "two" are God's judgment and the prophet's word. These do, not coincide by mere chance, no more than two persons pursue in company the same end without previous agreement. The prophet announces God's judgment because God has commissioned him; the prophet is of one mind with God, therefore the Lord is with him, and confirms his words. The application of the parables is seen in vers. 7, 8. The Septuagint, reading differently, has, "except they know one another."
 

MatthewWestfieldUK

Well-known member
May 13, 2021
871
498
63
#27
LOL interesting! You're a tricky one, Magenta! I think they call this eisegesis use of scripture.


I like you Matthew. You like to come at things from an angle. You often don't answer questions directly. Curious if you mean imbalance is she treats me different than I treat her. Or if you mean she has a "mental imbalance"; which doesn't mean the same thing.
Hope that you are not offended by any comments i msde. Im questioning the mental health
 

SomeDisciple

Well-known member
Jul 4, 2021
2,240
1,038
113
#28
I think there's no such thing as a "girlfriend"... certainly not in scripture. You're either married, or not married. Dating someone doesn't give you any restrictions or privileges. Committed, or not committed. There's no in between.
 

MatthewWestfieldUK

Well-known member
May 13, 2021
871
498
63
#29
I think there's no such thing as a "girlfriend"... certainly not in scripture. You're either married, or not married. Dating someone doesn't give you any restrictions or privileges. Committed, or not committed. There's no in between.
Ive heard other faiths say that. If u feel like a friendship is not enough, marry. Don't fo the inbetween.
But that is often the first step to disaster
 

SomeDisciple

Well-known member
Jul 4, 2021
2,240
1,038
113
#30
Ive heard other faiths say that. If u feel like a friendship is not enough, marry. Don't fo the inbetween.
But that is often the first step to disaster
Well, I deny the existence of any in-between; and in this particular case there's no marriage, which means no responsibility to maintain a relationship with this woman outside of a church setting, and even in a church setting if the situation has already been mediated by the church.
 
R

Ruby123

Guest
#31
I would say pray for them. Deal with any unforgiveness that you may have (if that is the case) and leave it at that.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
#32
um ok sounds like you just excommunicated someone

so why the guilt. I dont know, maybe just dont use your love of Christ as a means to an end I would say.

I remember once I had this weekly bible/prayer group an a lunch hour. The purpose of it was to get close to God, share testimony etc.
Got all sorts of people coming and we read scriptures and shared etc. Wel, there was one guy who came along and he asked not just me but everyone out ....and when I went on this coffee date he then started this spiel on how he was an evangelist and he needed all this money to fund his mission...

I said. I cant PAY you. But I can PRAY for you.

I think he was expecting everyone to get out their (non existent) credit cards and pay him to do what we ALREADY did.
 

Icedaisey

Well-known member
Jul 19, 2021
1,398
475
83
#33
What is our Christian responsibility to ex-girlfriend/boyfriends who are, or say they are, Christians?

-- as far as being their Christian friend and advisor -- or allowing them to have any contact with you -- when they are not good friends, are narcissists and very often just hurt you carelessly, subconsciously, or purposely? That is to say, are we allowed to tell them we don't ever want to talk to them ever again... outside of heaven?

I would think there's general scriptural commands and guidelines that cover this issue. And then there's what to do in specific cases. I'm curious in what you all think about both.

This is how I would assess my specific situation: I dated a woman who appears to be a new christian. Is she really a christian? Really difficult to say because her "fruits" are a mixed bag. She professes to be a christian, but never wanted to talk about her personal conversion; most often she only references wacky fringe videos on end-times issues, giants, Biden sign-of-the-beast, lowbrow conspiracy junk; she's a narcissist: continues to do horribly insensitive things that you'd think she knows hurts me deeply.

Many months ago we went out, got along great, she talked about being soulmates, wanting to use the Love word and speed up to marriage, though she acknowledged (as I made clear) we needed months to get to know each other. After about a couple months she said she didn't want a relationship, but wanted to keep dating/seeing me 5+ days a week, what she calls "just for company". I wanted to think she wasn't really decided about no-relationship, so I continued. With my eyes opening to who she was, and incompatibility, eventually I stopped 'dating' her. But because we worked together, and had become 'friends/confidants', and because she was a new christian, I felt I had to try to be a good christian friend to her, giving her advise when asked and listening to her. I suffered through this because, without going into it, she's not a good friend and hurtful. I thought I was doing what's required of me as a follower of Christ.

Finally now, we rarely work together anymore, so I feel I can let her know I'm not going to have any contact with her though she's still contacting me. Is this OK? Thoughts?
My advice, stay away from an ex that treats you as you described. They're an ex for a reason.

Your responsibility is to keep yourself in a place of love and respect when with others. Those who do not demonstrate that aren't worth your time. Because someone who respects you doesn't work to hurt you.

Pray for them. But don't let them rob you of your joy and peace of mind.

Your life is better with good loving people in it.
Sometimes people who behave as you describe don't know any different. That's not your fault or responsibility.

People will treat you how you allow them to treat you. If you continually suffer abuse, they'll continue to dish it. It isn't you. It's them. They're like that everywhere they go.

Love and respect yourself first. Then you'll know when others feel the same for you. And you'll never again settle for less.

Stay Blessed.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,138
362
83
#34
I'm sorry Lanolin, can we back track a little? This part:

LOL, you're funny, Lanolin. I didn't date her to make her a christian. She was a christian that I asked out. It didn't work out, we stopped dating. We are not dating. But she wanted to keep being my friend and hanging out, and I knew she was a new christian and didn't have any christian friends. I felt guilty about blocking her. Does that make more sense?
Again, You have me very curious. What part (of what I wrote) doesn't make sense to you?
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
#35
I'm sorry Lanolin, can we back track a little? This part:




Again, You have me very curious. What part (of what I wrote) doesn't make sense to you?
oh ok

I wrote that you could introduce her to your other christian friends, since you wrote she was new and didnt know anybody. But then you were like you didnt even want to TALK to her.

so it sounds like you just excommunicated her....something is a bit off. I dont know why you would be feeling guilty, but if she doesnt have any other friends then maybe you could suggest that she join a small group or something, if shes a new christian
 

Desdichado

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2014
8,768
838
113
#36
You have a responsibility to protect your heart and theirs. That often involves forgiveness and distance.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,138
362
83
#37
oh ok

I wrote that you could introduce her to your other christian friends, since you wrote she was new and didnt know anybody. But then you were like you didnt even want to TALK to her.

so it sounds like you just excommunicated her....something is a bit off. I dont know why you would be feeling guilty, but if she doesnt have any other friends then maybe you could suggest that she join a small group or something, if shes a new christian
OK, I think I know what you're questioning. Think of a huge wounded grizzly bear caught in a trap and desperate to protect it's nearby cubs. You want to let it out of the trap... it's the right thing to do... but it's gonna maw you. I don't want to go into the details, but she's a walking bad ending. Every interaction ends in pain for me. She's a narcissist, insensitive and probably gets-off subconsciously or secretly by hurting me. Many times I told her to go to church, join a bible study, establish interactions with any of her christian friends, or make new ones, pray, read the bible, and then definitely get professional christian counseling for specific things. As far as I know, she doesn't do any that. Do my actions and attitude make more sense now?
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,138
362
83
#38
I would say pray for them. Deal with any unforgiveness that you may have (if that is the case) and leave it at that.
When you say, 'leave it at that', how would one handle unwanted texts?
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
#40
OK, I think I know what you're questioning. Think of a huge wounded grizzly bear caught in a trap and desperate to protect it's nearby cubs. You want to let it out of the trap... it's the right thing to do... but it's gonna maw you. I don't want to go into the details, but she's a walking bad ending. Every interaction ends in pain for me. She's a narcissist, insensitive and probably gets-off subconsciously or secretly by hurting me. Many times I told her to go to church, join a bible study, establish interactions with any of her christian friends, or make new ones, pray, read the bible, and then definitely get professional christian counseling for specific things. As far as I know, she doesn't do any that. Do my actions and attitude make more sense now?
ok thats harsh
well dont feel guilty then just shake the dust off your feet
and stop thinking of her as YOUR christian ex girlfrield. She was not. Just someone who is lost and you dated once. Give her to God He can handle it. Its not up to you.