DID GOD CREATE EVIL?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Dan58

Senior Member
Nov 13, 2013
1,991
339
83
#21
Evil is a by-product of sin... It didn't exist in the beginning, but was manifested in a fallen world. Did God create evil? Is a tornado evil? Yes, in a catastrophic sense, nature can be evil. Disastrous things happen and were set in motion by God. I believe that's what Isaiah 45:7 means.
 
Jul 25, 2013
1,329
19
0
#22
" DID GOD CREATE EVIL? "

In my personal view, if we believe that God created a perfect world and he's sovereign, where did evil come from?
There are those who believe that His sovereign control includes the creation of evil, and they base that conclusion on the words of " Isaiah 45:7 " were it says: " I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace and create evil, I the lord do all these things"

So does God create evil? most certainly "NOT" If he was the author of evil, then he would certainly not be a good God who is worthy of all worship and praise, much less trusted to have our well being in mind.

The idea of a good God creating His own enemy and subject to His own wrath seems inconsistent for a good God to mastermind the idea of evil, will it into existence and still be considered a good God.

Rather, God created man in his image with the freedom to choose. With his freedom came the opportunity to rebel against Him. Man did rebel (Genesis 3) and the rest is history. The records of human history chronicle how God uses everything-Even the chaos of his world - To bring about his glory and purpose. Those purposes include our growth in becoming more Christlike.

So you maybe wondering what the point of "Isaiah 45: 7"? Well God reveals His almighty and awesome character to us so we can have the confidence that comes from knowing - even in the most darkest, desperate and discouraging times - that God is continually up to something good in our lives...............
So who created the tree of knowledge of good AND EVIL?
I wonder if there is such a thing as a righteous evil. Maybe our definition of the word evil is so far fetched from God's definition of it that we won't accept the truth about it.
 
K

Kerry

Guest
#23
So who created the tree of knowledge of good AND EVIL?
I wonder if there is such a thing as a righteous evil. Maybe our definition of the word evil is so far fetched from God's definition of it that we won't accept the truth about it.
If the were no tree of the knowledge of good and evil, then we would not have a choice. We are freewill agents and not robots. We love God because we want to love God or we hate God because we want to hate God.

The same choice that God gave Satan and 1/3 of the angels. God will not force anyone to obey Him, He may use them as He used Pharoah, but will not force them to love Him.
 
R

Richie_2uk

Guest
#24
The same choice that God gave Satan and 1/3 of the angels. God will not force anyone to obey Him, He may use them as He used Pharoah, but will not force them to love Him.
thats true, Satan will not force anyone, but his infuences is enough to make the weak to fall into sin against God.
 
Dec 19, 2009
27,513
128
0
71
#25
When it comes to creating evil, I think that is what we human beings do.
 
Jul 25, 2013
1,329
19
0
#26
If the were no tree of the knowledge of good and evil, then we would not have a choice. We are freewill agents and not robots. We love God because we want to love God or we hate God because we want to hate God.

The same choice that God gave Satan and 1/3 of the angels. God will not force anyone to obey Him, He may use them as He used Pharoah, but will not force them to love Him.
Ok,...but how does your reply have anything to do with my statements? I don't follow.
 
Jul 25, 2013
1,329
19
0
#27
Evil is a by-product of sin... It didn't exist in the beginning, but was manifested in a fallen world. Did God create evil? Is a tornado evil? Yes, in a catastrophic sense, nature can be evil. Disastrous things happen and were set in motion by God. I believe that's what Isaiah 45:7 means.
Not true, the tree of knowledge of good and EVIL existed before Adam and Eve sinned (your fallen world). And God says He creates evil plain and simple. How can anyone be appalled by anything God Him self says.
 
K

Kerry

Guest
#28
thats true, Satan will not force anyone, but his infuences is enough to make the weak to fall into sin against God.

No no no, Satan will force you and it's called bondage, I.E. addiction and Satan will tempt you. The only way to defeat him is to trust and have faith in the one that did defeat him and that is Christ and Him Crucified. Jesus is the seed that was promised to Eve that He would bruise his head.

The definition of evil is disobedience to God and or thinking of yourself as god, this is called pride and pride goes before a fall. Satan was filled with pride when he wanted to be God. In Job God describes Satan as a dragon that laughs and mocks the weapons of men and calls him the father of the children of pride. Jesus told the pharisee's that they were of their father Satan. Why because of their pride in their own works.

The humble and the meek shall inherit the Earth.
 
K

Kerry

Guest
#29
Not true, the tree of knowledge of good and EVIL existed before Adam and Eve sinned (your fallen world). And God says He creates evil plain and simple. How can anyone be appalled by anything God Him self says.
To give him a choice or a free will. God told him not to eat of that tree. He warned him and willed that he did not. Yet Adam chose to eat of it and all of us would have done the same thing.
 
Jul 25, 2013
1,329
19
0
#30
To give him a choice or a free will. God told him not to eat of that tree. He warned him and willed that he did not. Yet Adam chose to eat of it and all of us would have done the same thing.
Yes I agree with you, however the OP question that I answered was, did God create evil. God created the tree of knowledge of good and evil. Isaiah 45:7: " I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace and create evil, I the lord do all these things"
I think we just misunderstand the word evil.
 

Anna1985

Junior Member
Apr 12, 2014
1
0
1
#31
I agree with you completely, - God didn't create the evil, but God created each of His perfect creations with a free will to choose, not as robots. I even read a blog on this once on one of the web-sites and I liked it. Here it is : What Matters Most: Why Didn't God Make Us Robots?

Would anyone want to be a robot instead of a human? :) Robot is programmed to do what he is designed to do, without feelings. Humans have feelings and aren't programmed, they can choose whether to obey God, their Creator, or disobey Him. So, evil, in this sense is a result of one's choice when one decides to do his own free will, while disobeying God and His principles. We are free to choose : to obey God and His laws, or disobey them.

So, if we live by His laws, - we are in light, if we choose to rebel against God and do the opposite, - we are in darkness. It's a choice, not a destiny. We can always turn away and come back to Him to be in His light, if we wish to. It's up to a person to decide.

[h=3]1 John 1:5 (New International Version (NIV))[/h]
[SUP]5 [/SUP]This is the message we have heard from him and declare to you: God is light; in him there is no darkness at all.
 
Jul 27, 2011
1,622
89
0
#33
God created lucifer, but lucifer rebelled against God, i believe thats how evil came about. All this is still a mystery, but in my eyes Gos is all Good, and i will not say God Himself created evil, this is not a game. i don't think God created good and evil and put us here to see who wins. God knows who wins already, He tells us evil will be abolished, and only good will remain. In my opinion people saying God created evil, is disrespecting the Father, and trying to find loop holes to jump through. There is only one way, one truth, one life, and we learn that way, truth, and life, getting closer to Christ Jesus.
 
Jan 21, 2013
2,004
23
0
#34
don

God created lucifer, but lucifer rebelled against God
Did God know that before He created him ? Yes or No ?

Could Lucifer had rebelled if God did not create him in the first place ? Yes or No ?
 
Sep 10, 2013
1,428
19
0
#35
Yes I agree with you, however the OP question that I answered was, did God create evil. God created the tree of knowledge of good and evil. Isaiah 45:7: " I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace and create evil, I the lord do all these things"
I think we just misunderstand the word evil.
No, God does not create evil. You misunderstand the verse from Isaiah. The verb "ktizo" which have been tranlsated into english with "create" ("I create evil") means to work with already existing materials. The "I create evil" does not refer to the objective evil, to Evil with capital E, but it refers to evils that happen in our lives and that God allows so that we correct ourselves.
 
R

Richie_2uk

Guest
#36
No no no, Satan will force you and it's called bondage, I.E. addiction and Satan will tempt you. The only way to defeat him is to trust and have faith in the one that did defeat him and that is Christ and Him Crucified. Jesus is the seed that was promised to Eve that He would bruise his head.

The definition of evil is disobedience to God and or thinking of yourself as god, this is called pride and pride goes before a fall. Satan was filled with pride when he wanted to be God. In Job God describes Satan as a dragon that laughs and mocks the weapons of men and calls him the father of the children of pride. Jesus told the pharisee's that they were of their father Satan. Why because of their pride in their own works.

The humble and the meek shall inherit the Earth.
No No No!, Satan Does not force you or anyone, He dont have to, He only has you in bondage if you are weak to resist him. His influences is enough to tempt the weak, and thats when Satan has you on bondage. He doesnt have to do much to be honest, As we are a sinful world, all he has to do is just put a little hint in you, no force! It only becomes a force when we the stronger ones resists him. but in general Satan don't force nothing. Just influence, tempt, and twists the truth, with little force..

Thats why we have to wear the armour of God, to learn to ressit the enemy. Because it dont say in the bible that satan forces his way into our life does it? It mentions, temptations, and temptations is not a force.
 
R

Richie_2uk

Guest
#37
don



Did God know that before He created him ? Yes or No ?

Could Lucifer had rebelled if God did not create him in the first place ? Yes or No ?
Well Im sure when God created the angels, he gave them free will too. He did not make them robots. So the fall of Lucifer was his doing. Hence why Lucifer then named, fall from heaven, because Sin is forbidden there. So yeh God did create lucifer, But he did not create evil. It was lucifer created it for himself, and God quite rightly kicked him out of heaven. As sin dont belong in heaven. So to be honest, This free will has a lot to answer for. Its us that create evil, because the enemy now called Satan, is the prince of the air, and was cast down to earth. and roams the earth devouring.with his influences of evil. There was a suggestion or statement that Satan forces evil upon us, well he don't he dont need to, we are a sinful being anyways, all Satan has to do, is influence us, and thats enough to cause us to sin, and be evil.

Otherwise God would not of told us to put on the armour of God, to resist agains the arrows from the enemy. Those arrows aren't force, he just has to fling them at you, and if we are weak, then thats were he has us in a bondage of some sort.
 
Jan 21, 2013
2,004
23
0
#38
Richie

Well Im sure when God created the angels, he gave them free will too.
Let me ask you the questions, and please answer them with honesty #1.Did God know , that Lucifer would rebel, before He created him ? Yes or No ?

#2. Could Lucifer had rebelled if God did not create him in the first place ? Yes or No ?
 

Apostol2013

Senior Member
Jan 27, 2013
2,105
39
48
#39
God exist beyond time and measure , we as humans forget that therefore God knows all things because He has been there to us its foreknowledge to God its what He seen already .
 
Last edited:
R

Richie_2uk

Guest
#40
Richie



Let me ask you the questions, and please answer them with honesty #1.Did God know , that Lucifer would rebel, before He created him ? Yes or No ?

#2. Could Lucifer had rebelled if God did not create him in the first place ? Yes or No ?
To answer your question honestly. Well those questions are not for me to answer. Why did God create Lucifer if he was to rebel? well I'm not sure, But God may felt that he would like to give him a second chance perhaps, He created the angels as his children with free will, if you had children and one of them rebelled, would you disown him straight way? I think you would give him another chance to see if he would not do it again right?.

As far as God knowing that Lucifer would rebel? well that I cant say with honesty. however, God does know everything, and perhaps he did knew that lucifer would turn against him. But again as a loving father God is, he may have thought well there is good in Lucifer, and hoped that he could shine that goodness. but he didnt and thrown him out of heaven, You noticed he did not destroy lucifer? Did you noticed he did not kill him?
Why? because God the father must of loved him still. But Sin, and that rebelion wasnt to be in heaven so that why he threw lucifer out of heaven.