Not By Works

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,402
113
Its the new age tolerance trend Peter, they are tolerant of most anything except the truth..
You know....for pushing a sinless perfectionist dogma where one can lose salvation for the "big sins"......Lying is on that so called list.....how is that working out for you pal.....? AND anyone with eyes can see who it is that leads you to make such false accusations.......
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
No we are not speaking past one another. He is not listening. I mentioned the concept of being blameless versus the concept of sinless perfection in hopes of him dropping the false accusations he made against me(which I clearly showed when he attempted to answer Peter a question directed toward me) but instead he goes into a rant against hypergrace.

If he wants to rant at people, it's his choice, just as it's mine to ignore him until he apologize.

Why don't you correct him?

The reason I didn't "correct" him is because I didn't see anything wrong with what he said. Instead YOU used a term that is not biblical and which I've been hearing from my first day here and do not know where this idea came from.
It's the concept of sinless perfection. I don't know who here expouses this concept. I don't see anyone saying that they are perfectly sinless. If you could show me where this is affirmed, I'd be thankful. I don't believe anyone here thinks they never sin. This goes agains everything we know about human nature.

On the other hand, everyone understands the concept of being blameless because Jesus covers for our sins. However, it does come through, at times, that some here believe they are not REQUIRED to obey the Law which was never abolished. I'm speaking about the Moral law.

You must admit that I myself do not have a problem proclaiming this, but most here do. Why is that? I've never received a reply
.


Before anyone accuses me of being anger or holding a grudge.

I am not.

I hold no I'll will towards Willybob and was hoping to help him communicate his message in a way that his fellow sisters,and brothers would understand and accept.

Yes folks who don't have the Holy spirit may still reject it but often it's not the message that is rejected here in CC but the manner it's preaented.

See.... Who here does not have the Holy Spirit. I know of no one. Some may not agree with me, but I cannot say they do not have the Holy Spirit. I CAN say that their behavior should be more Christianly. But I cannot know if they have the Holy Spirit or not. It's not up to me to determine this.

For example your dislike of Calvinism can cause you to miss read certain posts, because they use words like election,predestination or eternal security.

People might not mean it in the Calvinist sense at all but the Biblical sense just as you do with the word free will.

I'm the same way if Willy Bob stop accusing people of teaching hypergrace, he might actually hear what they believe.

I have read both sides of hypergrace debate and know we have some components of it here on CC. Juar as we do have hardcore Calvinist on the site.

I would challenge you to have an actual dialog with both without the hostility.

I have hostility? I said I have Calvinism NOT CALVINISTS. I hate the doctrine, not the people who believe it. And yes, hearing the words ELECTION, PREDESTINATION AND ETERNAL SECURITY, DO make me think of Calvinism, since those are Calvinist words ! And there's something funny about a Calvinist that believes in Free Will. They don't.

BTW, if Willybob believes some are teaching hypergrace and does not believe in it, what's wrong with him saying that it's an incorrect doctrine?


Most are immature and can't handle the heat, but the older Calvinist will admit to believing in a type of free will.

G777 has said the Holy Spirit does chastens people of sin.


Personally what I don't like about Calvinist is that they have hundreds of words to define concepts not actually used in the Bible itself (concepts might be there but not the words themselves). You have to learn a new language to figure out what they are saying.

Hypergrace seems to focus always on God and what God does but often doesn't talk about what that means practically.


It is good to say follow the Holy spirit. It true and right, but I ask where does the Holy spirit lead you?

You see Fran just because I don't spend hours debating people, doesn't mean I haven't taken the time to research.

I believe in meeting people where they are, listening to what they say and affirming what I agree with, gently stating what I don't agree with. Them praying and fellowshipping together.
.I trust God to teach them and if I spoke anything worthwhile bring to their mind later when they study and pray.

When people tell me I am stupid and don't know anything that shows me a pridefilled heart...therefore an unreachable heart, at least by me. So I just pray and allow God to work. He normally sends another to reach out.

Anyway, going to read the rest of the post of folks I don't currently have on ignore and maybe a couple of those who I do to see if anything has changed.

Who has called you stupid?? And because I know about different belief systems DOES NOT mean that I cannot understand each person individually. It actually helps me to understand them.

I do think we need to pay better attention to what everyoneis saying
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
I totally agree and even Peterjens would agree.
.that isn't the point.
The point is that Bill taking medicine doesn't make him less able to relate to reality and build relationships based on God's truth as Peterjens states.
Ariel - I do not think Bill takes any medication, and I was not thinking of him.

I was speaking generally, and how anti-anxiety medication does tend to remove one
from the situation.

benzodiazepines - emotional anaesthesia

These drugs remove the patient from the situation and dull their sense of engagement.

The truth is if we ignore the effects of these powerful drugs on people and their convictions
and ability to engage or take on board nuanced points about belief and feelings, it becomes
almost pointless to expect a balanced response.

If you want better understanding, google them.
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,402
113
Christ righteous is NEVER imputed anywhere in the text, there is not one example of the transfer of virtue anywhere in the bible...

LET NO ONE DECEIVE YOU,
You are a deceiver of the basest sort pal.....

Even as David also describeth the blessedness of the man, unto whom God imputeth righteousness without works,
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
I totally agree and even Peterjens would agree.

.that isn't the point.


The point is that Bill taking medicine doesn't make him less able to relate to reality and build relationships based on God's truth as Peterjens states.
I agree, although I really wasn't following along....


Here's what I agree with:

If a person needs medicine, he does better WITH the medicine than without it.

This is common knowledge.

Some believe it's harmful or desensitizes us in some way, it's their prerogative to believe whatever they want to.

We each have our own beliefs.
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
The key comes from what is driving the communication.
Is it fear and weakness, or love and victory?
I would think the key would be the kind of fear giving us strength because of Christ’s labor of love or work of His faith. We fear Him because with him there is forgiveness. Without him there is none. As we are informed in Psalms, if Christ would take into account even the least of all sins they would be guilty of violating the whole law ….therfore who could stand before his throne of mercy and receive His grace in respect to His finished work. Just one sin of eating the forbidden fruit of self righteousness brings eternal damnation never to rise to new spirit life again .

He informs us with Him there in plenty of forgiveness… he forgives all sins, past, present and future therefore giving us the confidence if he has begun the good work of salvation he will finish it to the end of the matter.

Out of the depths have I cried unto thee, O LORD.Lord, hear my voice: let thine ears be attentive to the voice of my supplications.If thou, LORD, shouldest mark iniquities, O Lord, who shall stand?But there is forgiveness with thee, that thou mayest be feared.I wait for the LORD, my soul doth wait, and in his word do I hope.My soul waiteth for the Lord more than they that watch for the morning: I say, more than they that watch for the morning. Let Israel hope in the LORD: for with the LORD there is mercy, and with him is plenteous redemption.And he shall redeem Israel from all his iniquities. Psa 130:1-8


A proper fear is necessary to know Him. Some might offer their good or wonderful works turning things up side down making self righteousness their fear according to the dead works they offer towards God (dead faith). Christ’s informs us he does not know that kind who crucify Him over and over subjecting him to public shame. He did not say they did not prophecy in His name or cast out demons according to the authority of God.But simply I never knew you depart from me you who work inquity according to the idea of self rightousness .

Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works?And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity. Mat 7:22
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,402
113
Went back and found the full post you quote.
Quite astonishing to see such ignorance and lack of compassion combined in one post!

I stand with Bill!
You are not he only one..........the workers for, sinless perfectionists and losers of salvation personify the word υποκριτής........!
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
your are correct the everyday word was a figure of speech, I should have used a different word.

now, the rest of the post , I stand by it. when you claim others say things they do not say, when you distort what others say,( you did it with ariel just a few moments ago), put words into people's mouths, this is bearing false witness.

deny it all you want, you do it on a regular basis....
gb9 - I want to make a simple point to you, I hope you can understand it.

It is easy to say, I believe something unless it appears in a bad light.
Or I believe this idea, but there are no contradictions in this position.

By showing contradictions or putting a different case is not bearing false witness.
God is talking about lying about ones neighbour.

You cannot be lying by stating something that is true. It is this aspect you cannot actually
accept. I am not here to defend myself, I am here to try and understand your point,
as a sin against anyone I take seriously.

But you again have failed to say how I am sinning. Mentioning something without
actually saying what it is, is just missleading.

I have the feeling you feel or see some great evil going on, where none is intended. :)
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
This is a lie and an underhanded attack
The above comment is typical of this environment.
A lie is something that is not true. What I have stated is not a lie, the effect of medication
varies from patient to patient, but if it did not have an effect it would not be used.

Secondly it is not underhand, it is actually being honest and identifying why some cannot
engage properly. One contributor was an alcoholic and had a struggle with addiction.

This type of addiction lends one to a dualistic view of life, where the addiction is an external
enemy and one is a victim of it. This obviously leads to viewing the christian life through
similar glasses where one is a perfect spirit being with an evil flesh master.

One of the difficulties of these forums is we just see peoples contributions and positions, not
their tendencies or dispositions. I do not devalue people and who they are, but there are limits
to this medium and how far it is just an expression of where people are, rather than a means
of progressing in faith and fellowship.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
your are correct the everyday word was a figure of speech, I should have used a different word.

now, the rest of the post , I stand by it. when you claim others say things they do not say, when you distort what others say,( you did it with ariel just a few moments ago), put words into people's mouths, this is bearing false witness.

deny it all you want, you do it on a regular basis....
I was thinking about the problem being expressed here.
If we are talking ideas and how people express them or other handle them, it is difficult
to talk about "false witness".

This is because other than quoting the exact words used some could claim they are not
being handled correctly. So I tend to talk about the idea and not the person who expressed
it or even how they expressed it. It is the idea that matters not the person who expressed it.

Some call this lying, yet this is the basis of discussion and debate. Ideas and concepts is what
bdf is about. At the end one hopes agreement can be reached and opinions formed.

God was talking about false witness in terms of I saw x doing y when x did not do y.
It is about concrete events in time and which are not a matter of argument but fact.

Now if one wants to create condemnation and judgementalism and guilt in others one
can mix the two. I do not recommend this as it is very confusing in the world of ideas,
and is actually pointless.:cool:
 

gb9

Senior Member
Jan 18, 2011
12,323
6,691
113
I was thinking about the problem being expressed here.
If we are talking ideas and how people express them or other handle them, it is difficult
to talk about "false witness".

This is because other than quoting the exact words used some could claim they are not
being handled correctly. So I tend to talk about the idea and not the person who expressed
it or even how they expressed it. It is the idea that matters not the person who expressed it.

Some call this lying, yet this is the basis of discussion and debate. Ideas and concepts is what
bdf is about. At the end one hopes agreement can be reached and opinions formed.

God was talking about false witness in terms of I saw x doing y when x did not do y.
It is about concrete events in time and which are not a matter of argument but fact.

Now if one wants to create condemnation and judgementalism and guilt in others one
can mix the two. I do not recommend this as it is very confusing in the world of ideas,
and is actually pointless.:cool:
let me give an example of what I am saying-

if I say " it should be every believer's goal to not sin but we all stumble and fall short of that goal" and then you respond and say " gb9 just said it is o.k. for believers to sin" this is MIS-REPRESENTING what I said. that is inserting words , that is dishonest.

that is not a different approach, a different expression , a different view. that is bearing false witness.
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,402
113
let me give an example of what I am saying-

if I say " it should be every believer's goal to not sin but we all stumble and fall short of that goal" and then you respond and say " gb9 just said it is o.k. for believers to sin" this is MIS-REPRESENTING what I said. that is inserting words , that is dishonest.

that is not a different approach, a different expression , a different view. that is bearing false witness.
AMEN....and there are about 4 to 6 that do that regularly......the also say we teach that we can live like the devil and do as we please because we believe in eternal security........
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
I was going to respond but I am going to trust God with it instead.

A song for you Bill and others before I go.


https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xPpEOUVpxrM
Christ saved me, no holding back

CROWDER FEAT. TEDASHII - LIFT YOUR HEAD WEARY SINNER (CHAINS) (LIVE) LYRICS

The rap section for those who need to see the words..

I ain't from here I'm H-town
But at this stage my place now
It's going down, no parachute
This so sick I need Theraflu
And there might be some they don't have a clue
These folks don't getting no rarer dude
Cliqued up, 40 deep right there with you
Unashamed of the name, ain't we can't do
We turnt up, that's right
Mind blown no glass pipe
In my zone we pass tight
This right here could be my last night
I count that, I don't doubt that
Going in I shout that
You don't see it I'm bout that
This world man, I'm out that
He paid it all, no green backs
With the bruised heel and stained back
The King is back
You've seen that
I've mean that, redeem that
So we in here
Better get used to it??
Trying to be fly
Gassed up, trying to touch the sky??
You can't be wasting my time like waiting
We faking most
We here to stay so let me hear you say
Here to stay so let me hear you say
Chains off me????
Christ saved me no holding back
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
let me give an example of what I am saying-

if I say " it should be every believer's goal to not sin but we all stumble and fall short of that goal" and then you respond and say " gb9 just said it is o.k. for believers to sin" this is MIS-REPRESENTING what I said. that is inserting words , that is dishonest.

that is not a different approach, a different expression , a different view. that is bearing false witness.
Perhaps we should call it a false observation?
 
Aug 15, 2009
9,745
179
0
You know....for pushing a sinless perfectionist dogma where one can lose salvation for the "big sins"......Lying is on that so called list.....how is that working out for you pal.....? AND anyone with eyes can see who it is that leads you to make such false accusations.......
He's not a sinless perfectionist, I've been following his posts.

You just don't like what he posts.
 
Aug 15, 2009
9,745
179
0
i have the same problem, I always wake up in deep sweat my oldest has died, I can hardly handle stress, like my mother I smoked to tak are of it, I hid it from th church, n help there, when my wife kicked me out I broke. Turned to sin, nothing helped, I quit smoking 4 years ago, but started again, two yeas ago my grandson was born, considering m mm passed from emphasima, I quit for God two years ago,

i am on anxiety meds, sometimes they help sometimes they do not, I had a severe attack a few weeks ago in a mountain had to stop in middle of a highway next to a cliff and let my wife drive, that was dangerous, I scuba dive, but times I can not get in water.

Your not not alone bro, my brothers in Christ help me out,

i am with ya bro, you have my prayers, your not alone

i am sure I gave a few more fuel to attack me but I do not care, I am done with some people
It's not healthy nor wise for anyone with anxiety or depression to be on the BDF. There's too much stress here.
 
D

Dade

Guest
Paul was addressing the Jews. Who were clinging to the Old testament law and believed in righteousness by works , rejecting the Gospel of Christ. James was referring to Faith without works is dead. For By Grace(greek word charis: benevolent influence of God , favor ) are ye saved( Greek word sozo : rescued from danger , destruction , made safe )thru Faith ( Greek word : pistis : referring to Christ , a strong and welcome conviction or belief that Jesus is the Messiah through whom we obtain eternal salvation in the kingdom of God ) and that not of yourselves (Greek word hymon , You ! ) it is the gift ( Greek word : for on , sacrifice to God ) of God . Ephesians 2:8 . God and only the Almighty God can give salvation . None calleth upon the name of God , no not one . You cannot upon he whom you don't know . None are righteousness no not one . God calls US . God imputed the righteousness of Christ upon those who believes . Praised be the Name of the Lord! He hath declared the end from the beginning .
 
Aug 15, 2009
9,745
179
0
It is one thing to judge doctrine or dogma, but to judge an individual and point the finger always equals 3 more pointing back at yourself.....who cares what they think...and anyone having anything to say about this will show how sorry they really are..
So no one's allowed to say anything about someone because they have a physical problem, or an emotional one?

I will recommend them getting outta Dodge before this stuff sends them spiraling into a panic attack!

I didn't know either one of them had a problem, because they're always in the heat of these arguments!

They need to ask their doctor before getting on here..... If they don't, it's not anyone's fault if this hurts them, because they have been warned.
 
Aug 15, 2009
9,745
179
0
Anyway before I got distracted I was going to post these scriptures.

I challenge anyone to post scriptures talking about folks who are "sinless".
.God calls many "blameless"

You know why? Because God forgave their sins and washes them clean and taught them His ways.

****

The one whose walk is blameless,
who does what is righteous,
who speaks the truth from their heart;
whose tongue utters no slander,
who does no wrong to a neighbor,
and casts no slur on others.
Psalm 15:2-3 | NIV

Do everything without grumbling or arguing, so that you may become blameless and pure, children of God without fault in a warped and crooked generation. Then you will shine among them like stars in the sky as you hold firmly to the word of life.
Philippians 2:14-16a | NIV
Sorry, the only ones who make claims about others being "sinless" is you guys..... just check the history.

Also slander, slurs, & malice come from your group..... yes, YOUR GROUP.

Quit acting just alike & I'll quit saying "group", fair enuff?