I don’t know. I think she should love the man she wants to love. The second man did a lot for her, but in the scenario, you did not say that they were intimate (I mean intimate in a soul sense). The intimacy with the first man is worth more than all the things the second man can do for her. Why didn’t she run away with him?
I have this feeling you did not read the theoretical scenario but to humor you since you are so determined to shut me down.
I will kick you the epilogue of her running away with the first man..
Theoretical epilogue continues:
So, since she does not know the 2nd man very well she turns his love down. She says to her parents, friends and family "Forget ya'll!" (people she loves with everything she has, they are pretty much everything to her)..
and saves all her money, and runs away to be with the first man, the artist...
Well here are a few things that might happen:
1. She walks up to him, and says: "I gave everything up to be with you. I love you." he looks at her and laughs, and grabs a beautiful slender young woman with huge boobs and walks away. She has spent all her money, pretty much abandoned her family and friends, denied a man who would have loved her. She has no one and no where to go. Humiliated she has to find a new job, earns her way back home to her family (who's heart's she just broke) turns into an old woman and dies alone of a broken heart. This is probably the more realistic.
2. This would be a 1 in a million, rare thing that would probably never happen statistically, I mean if you weren't looking at it realistically...
She walks up to the artist, and says "I have given up everything to be here with you. I love you." he says, "Me too!" and they run off and get married, he suddenly decides to change and become brave and they end up with a hard life together but at least they are together.
---
People don't change...especially for another person. I wish that were true. If the person isn't trying anymore, isn't talking, cuts you off, then maybe they don't want to be together anymore..
What would running away accomplish then..? Who is she running to anymore?