Your explanation completely collapses when you look at the actual timeline and verbs used in Isaiah 53. You are arguing that Christ’s identity as a Savior depends on human cooperation, but the text declares that His death successfully secured a specific, already-defined group of people. [
1]
1. The Timeline of "My People" (Isa. 53:8)
You claim that "my people" only refers to those who
would later choose to believe and become faithful.
But look at the tense of the verse:
"For the transgression of MY PEOPLE was he stricken."
At the moment Christ was being stricken on the cross, God already called this group
"my people." They did not become His people
after they decided to walk with the Lord or respond to a preacher; they were already His people at the moment of the crucifixion. Christ was not dying for an abstract, empty category waiting for volunteers; He was dying for a distinct covenant people who already belonged to God. [
1]
2. The Direct Effect of Justification (Isa. 53:11)
You argue that the "many" are simply those who choose to respond to the gospel. This completely reverses the cause-and-effect stated in the text.
Look at
Isaiah 53:11:
The text does not say, "He shall bear the iniquities of all, and those who respond will be justified." It says He will justify the many
BECAUSE (
for) He bore their iniquities.
The bearing of iniquities is the direct, unfrustrated cause of their justification. If Christ bore the iniquities of an individual on the cross, that individual
must and
will be justified. If any person for whom Christ died ends up in hell, then Christ bore their iniquities in vain, and the word "for" in this verse becomes a lie. The "many" are justified precisely because the cross was an actual, successful substitution, not a conditional option.
3. The Condition of the Sheep (Isa. 53:6)
You claim the elect are simply "the faithful who walk with the Lord."
But Isaiah 53 does not describe the elect as faithful, obedient walkers. It describes them as completely helpless, rebellious, and lost:
We were not "walking with the Lord" when He died for us—we were walking away from Him in total rebellion. The only reason any "astray sheep" ever returns to become a faithful follower is because their specific iniquity was laid on Christ, and His sovereign grace tracks them down.
Faith and walking with the Lord are not the
conditions that make you one of His people; they are the
fruits of the fact that He already purchased you as His own on the cross.
