Is A.I. racist?

[Dave123]

I asked A.I these questions, and got two different answers.

Would a black Christian sub forum be racist?
Would a brown Christian sub forum be racist?
Would a white Christian sub forum be racist?

Here's the replies.

Question: Would a black Christian sub forum be racist?

A.I. Answer: No, a Black Christian subforum would not be racist. Creating a space for a specific demographic to discuss shared cultural experiences, historical perspectives, and faith is a form of community building rather than discrimination or prejudice against others.

Question: Would a brown Christian sub forum be racist?

A.I. Answer: No, a brown Christian sub-forum would not inherently be racist. Creating a space for Black, Indigenous, and other people of color (BIPOC) or specific ethnic groups to discuss shared cultural experiences, historical perspectives, and faith is generally viewed as a form of community support rather than discrimination.

Question: Would a white Christian sub forum be racist?

A.I. Answer: Evaluating whether a specific online space or sub-forum is racist depends heavily on its stated purpose, moderation practices, and the behavior of its community members rather than its demographic label alone.

 

[Lynx]

Now feed it all three questions and answers and ask it if the answers reveal any racial bias.

 

[Lynx]

I just asked the AI that comes with WhatsApp. It replied no to all three, but with the white one it added the caveat that there is a social double standard that will make people automatically regard the white one as inherently racist. Then AI proceeded to give suggestions for avoiding it, like naming the forum "Irish American Christian Forum" or "Appalachian Christian Forum" instead.

 

[PAC-fit]

Question: Would a white Christian sub forum be racist?

A.I. Answer: Evaluating whether a specific online space or sub-forum is racist depends heavily on its stated purpose, moderation practices, and the behavior of its community members rather than its demographic label alone.

The missing "no"? Instead, forced to evaluate. Not due to it's programmers, but the behemoth amount of vitriol since my guess; the Rodney King abuse. Some AI models don't possess enough reasoning (if that's possible) to resist the phantom white monster since then.

 

[Dave123]

I just asked the AI that comes with WhatsApp. It replied no to all three, but with the white one it added the caveat that there is a social double standard that will make people automatically regard the white one as inherently racist. Then AI proceeded to give suggestions for avoiding it, like naming the forum "Irish American Christian Forum" or "Appalachian Christian Forum" instead.

Originally I used 'caucasian' instead of 'white', but that could be argued as a different label than the black and brown. Actually, the caucasian one was much worse, if memory serves me right. I ran it a second time and A.I. cleaned it up a little, but still assumed the propaganda that is common today that only white people can be racist.

Would a caucasian subforum be racist?

A.I. Answer: Whether a "Caucasian subforum" is considered racist depends entirely on its intent, moderation, and content, though in online spaces, it is often viewed with high suspicion.

Would a African American subforum be racist?

A.I. Answer: Creating an African American subforum involves discussions around shared cultural interests, community-building, and platform moderation policies.

Would a Latino American subforum be racist?

A.I. Answer: Creating a Latino American subforum is an ethnic and cultural affinity space rather than an act of racism. Online platforms host many spaces dedicated to specific nationalities, ethnicities, and cultural backgrounds to help people share common experiences.

------------

......Except white people, because that would be racist. I always said a white supremacist, by definition, is a white person with and a non politically correct opinion. This is social fascism by definition. That's what Hitler did. Agree or lose everything, even your life. Fascism is a leftist ideology. People are brainwashed to think that it's a far right ideology. When we began calling them communists, which they were, because everything that they were doing and standing for was straight from the communist goals 1963, they then responded by calling us fascists. A tit for tat for the simple minded to feed on. They stamped that idea in the brains of all useful idiots, that far right is fascism. That the opposite of communism was fascism. But from a social aspect, both communism and fascism work hand in hand as we see in the U.S. today. The left are both.

Remember this, they always accuse others of what they themselves are doing. If you want to know what they're doing, listen to what they're accusing others of, they're telling you what they are doing. Don't ever forget that, because in my life, I've never known that not to be true, ever, not once.

 

[WayneNSO]

This is very amusing

Is AI programmed to be Marxist - that would be a good question. I do not have or use AI so I cant ask it

 

[Lynx]

Originally I used 'caucasian' instead of 'white', but that could be argued as a different label than the black and brown. Actually, the caucasian one was much worse, if memory serves me right. I ran it a second time and A.I. cleaned it up a little, but still assumed the propaganda that is common today that only white people can be racist.

Would a caucasian subforum be racist?

A.I. Answer: Whether a "Caucasian subforum" is considered racist depends entirely on its intent, moderation, and content, though in online spaces, it is often viewed with high suspicion.

Would a African American subforum be racist?

A.I. Answer: Creating an African American subforum involves discussions around shared cultural interests, community-building, and platform moderation policies.

Would a Latino American subforum be racist?

A.I. Answer: Creating a Latino American subforum is an ethnic and cultural affinity space rather than an act of racism. Online platforms host many spaces dedicated to specific nationalities, ethnicities, and cultural backgrounds to help people share common experiences.

------------

......Except white people, because that would be racist. I always said a white supremacist, by definition, is a white person with and a non politically correct opinion. This is social fascism by definition. That's what Hitler did. Agree or lose everything, even your life. Fascism is a leftist ideology. People are brainwashed to think that it's a far right ideology. When we began calling them communists, which they were, because everything that they were doing and standing for was straight from the communist goals 1963, they then responded by calling us fascists. A tit for tat for the simple minded to feed on. They stamped that idea in the brains of all useful idiots, that far right is fascism. That the opposite of communism was fascism. But from a social aspect, both communism and fascism work hand in hand as we see in the U.S. today. The left are both.

Remember this, they always accuse others of what they themselves are doing. If you want to know what they're doing, listen to what they're accusing others of, they're telling you what they are doing. Don't ever forget that, because in my life, I've never known that not to be true, ever, not once.

What AI are you using? Different models seem to give different results.

Yours may have been modeled on Oprah...

 

[Dave123]

What AI are you using? Different models seem to give different results.

Yours may have been modeled on Oprah...

Google?

Google Search

The answers are actually more elaborate. I just posted the opening summery statement.

 

[Dave123]

I posted the OP and asked is A.I. was racist. The answer, not necessarily?

A.I. answer

No, the AI is not necessarily racist, but its answers reflect how people talk about different racial groups and history on the internet.

 

[Dave123]

I asked the same thing with post #5

"AI is not racist, but it can show bias or inconsistency when discussing sensitive topics like race and culture."