The whole concept of settling for being choices is strange and a bit foreign to me. I know literally hundreds of women. If I'm in a relationship with one, I'm going to be loyal. I'm not just going to drop her because something more interesting came along or an old friend has started connecting with me.
Good Relationships have a natural, mutual progression. If I'm hanging out with a girl who is also hanging out with a bunch of other guys, my time is clearly worth the same to her as theirs, and therefore not relationship material. But If I go out of my way to hang out with someone and she goes out of her way to hang out with me, that will typically lead to something more. I'm naturally a one friend at a time kind of person, and a one relationship at a time kind of person.
I don't have a list numbered 1-10 of women I would like to date. If I am dating someone I don't think about other women I could be dating. I'm just not wired that way. I date who I connect with and see potential to end in marriage. If it no longer has that potential, I usually fast pray and break up.
I think if two guys both like a girl, it is up to her to choose or ignore them both. I also don't think aggressive women are a turn off. I was friends with a guy who was seeing this Latin girl in San Diego. She was aggressive about making it known that she wanted him (and he was aggressive about pursuing her too) and there was no one else going to stand between her and her man. She publicly praised him in front of guys and girls. There was never any doubt about her intentions but she wasn't controlling or possessive.
Also if I think that a bunch of guys are in love with a a girl and pursuing her, I will not get involved, especially if all parties involved are my friends. If she has a swarm of guys trying to win her over and she likes me, she needs to say something because.... I will not ever jockey for position with a bunch of guys over a girl who doesn't know what she wants, especially if I'm not exactly in love with her. I'm not going to stand between a man and the woman that he wants to be with just because I can.
Also I will be considerate of a woman that I like, especially if she is in a terminal relationship. If its in its death spiral, I will wait for her. Sometimes there are no words needed to express that something is dead, only a look that says, "Hey, wait up. I'll catch up with you soon."