Are we still protesting pagan holidays or did we surrender?

You can please all of the people some of the time and some of the people all of the time. But you will never please all of the people all of the time.

Matthew 2:9-11

9 When they had heard the king, they departed; and, lo, the star, which they saw in the east, went before them, till it came and stood over where the young child was.
10 When they saw the star, they rejoiced with exceeding great joy.
11 And when they were come into the house, they saw the young child with Mary his mother, and fell down, and worshipped him: and when they had opened their treasures, they presented unto him gifts; gold, and frankincense and myrrh.

As per the point made already, if we celebrate any birthday, surely Jesus' birthday is the most important one to celebrate, and has the most biblical support? If we won't celebrate Jesus' birthday, surely we shouldn't celebrate any?

I think the charge of legalism comes in where one decrees that anyone who celebrates Christmas or supports it is supporting evil.

This exactly was the point I was intending to bring up next, but you did so with much more knowledge than me. To me, the heart of the attack on Christmas isn't that December 25th is the wrong date. If this was the case, and those against it celebrated on the 25th of April, or whenever date they believe Jesus really was born (or conceived - the important theological issue is the Incarnation - when God became Man), I wouldn't have a problem. My issue is that the purpose of this seems to be to eliminate the mention of Christmas in association with Christ. And then where to next? The Resurrection, of course, because of yet another long-dead, long-forgotten pagan. The core of the issue isn't about the dates being wrong, or the dates also coinciding with some long-dead pagans (and which dates don't, by the way?) The core of the issue is elimination of the Christian Holy Days, but this effort thus far has been unsuccessful from without the Church, so it is being attempted by sinister means - holy-sounding arguments and justifications to do so from within.

@Papermonkey , why does “negativity” bother you?

When you have God with you and all the internal peace and joy, all the “negativity” is basically like a beautiful breeze in the face in a hot summer day.
Im usually like “oh that was nice”.

When you have God with you, you are like a still lake with no ripples.

View attachment 247030

I'm not a Buddhist.

If I were I'd recollect the Dali Lama leading a band of armed monks in a revolution against the Chinese army.

I'm a Christian.

I recall Jesus responding against the blasphemy of the money changers before his father's house.
His calling the Pharisee's and Sadducees vipers, and of their father the devil, when they brought him before the Sanhedrin in an illegally convened trial.

I respond to negativity because it needs be rebuked.

Still lakes are not a constant. Many things cause ripples.

Constantly still water becomes stagnant. And toxic. If this perpetuates, all living in that water die. And rot. And that makes things far worse. The pond is no longer serving the natural environment but is now toxifying the surrounds.
And if wild things know no better and drink of that toxic fluid, they sicken and die. And rot. Therein compounding the problem.

Jesus was a revolutionary. It's why the temple elders wanted him dead.

Nice picture though. 😊

I see that you are well-versed on a lot of areas.
‘Next question.
How do you know it’s “negativity”?
Also, what do you know about the stranger on the internet or the random person on the supermarket who bumped into your cart and swore at you?
Also, What do you know about Dude in specific to think that he’s “negative”? I for example know one thing about him which I don’t want to share here because it’s painful.

Yeah I think she put me on ignore. That's too bad because I actually liked her. But I was not intending to be negative at all. All I was saying is don't judge people because their reasons for celebrating or not celebrating holidays his entirely subjective

I see that you are well-versed on a lot of areas.
‘Next question.
How do you know it’s “negativity”?
Also, what do you know about the stranger on the internet or the random person on the supermarket who bumped into your cart and swore at you?
Also, What do you know about Dude in specific to think that he’s “negative”? I for example know one thing about him which I don’t want to share here because it’s painful.

Interesting.
Remember it was you who first judged communications here as negativity.

Interesting.
Remember it was you who first judged communications here as negativity.

Yeah I think she put me on ignore. That's too bad because I actually liked her. But I was not intending to be negative at all. All I was saying is don't judge people because their reasons for celebrating or not celebrating holidays his entirely subjective

Again, its a matter of what is being celebrated. Halloween celebrates witches and demons which is 100% different than celebrating the birth of Christ.

So if a kid is wearing a SpongeBob costume and I give him a Snickers is that satanic?

So, if God-fearing Christians .....irrefutable conclusion that Christmas' origins are pagan and/or demonic

Some of us just like to honor God.

God did not inspire the origin of the celebration we now call Christmas or Christ Mass. Satan and demons did.

nobody is questioning the motives of the individual here who dug up all of these old threads.

How is it pagan to celebrate God Himself entering into the world so that He may save us from the wrath and judgement that we have brought upon us. To sing hymns that honour Him for doing so, to engage in charitable giving in his name, to gather around family and friends in our churches and worship him for coming and saving us?

How is it pagan to celebrate God Himself entering into the world so that He may save us from the wrath and judgement that we have brought upon us. To sing hymns that honour Him for doing so, to engage in charitable giving in his name, to gather around family and friends in our churches and worship him for coming and saving us?

To Christmas or not to Christmas, that is the question.