How can I persuade our grandchlldren's dad to allow me to home-school their 2 children?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

HealthAndHappiness

Well-known member
Jul 7, 2022
8,167
3,393
113
Almost Heaven West Virginia
#21
Hi! I've read and heard claims that vaccines may adversely affect children, in at least some cases. But their older brothers, from an earlier marriage - plus their dad, was also that way to an extent, it sounds like - judging by the fact that they all had difficulty learning how to read in their school years, and having difficulty with math. So in their case, it might be partly genetic, I think. I am very health-minded, and eat very naturally and healthfully, myself. But their family eats more of the "typical American diet" - there's not much I can do about that, but to do my best to get them to eat at least some of the more healthful foods in times when I'm with them. Thanks for your comments! God bless you! By the way, I have taught the children how to read, and am glad for that. But they would have had the same difficulty, I think if it wasn't for my help on it, as compared to learning in a typical classroom setting (not interactive as when with me teaching them).
Bless your heart for helping them to read. That's so much more effective than what a teacher can do with a classroom full of children who are expected to be self motivated.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,177
113
#22
im wishing the parents of four attention deficit boys in my school would just homeschool them. They are crazy running round, not listening, disrupting the class, being rude to their classmates, shouting, picking fights etc etc. Acting like two year olds when they are six and seven.
 

I_am_Canadian

Senior Member
Dec 8, 2014
2,218
714
113
#23
Hi! I and my brothers and sisters were home-schooled in our childhood. I also help to home-school our 2 grandchildren, Dawson - 9, and Mandy - 7, though not as much as I had been, because their parents put them in a Christian public school, the last 2 years. As there's less time to do so, because of their being at the school so long each day, in the school part of the year.

I see no need for their being in the Christian public school, and they are hyperactive, and so learn better with interactive teaching methods, as compared to the typical sitting and listening to a teacher talk - method which is how public schools do it for a large part of their time of teaching children. That's how it was for me when I was young - I was better able to learn in the more interactive style of teaching, as compared to the classroom method.

I've taught them both how to read, and make them read a chapter in their Bible story book every day I'm with them. I've also taught them math for their age levels. Their father doesn't understand why I don't spend more time teaching them though, as he's used to the classroom method and finds it hard to trust the home-school method, which requires much less class room (passive sitting - aloud instructions) type of time.

But his children are hyperactive, and he has difficulty understanding their need for more rest in between study times. And fails, i think - to see that passive sittting in a class - room style of teaching, doesn't really improve their ability to learn more than otherwise.

And unfortunately, their mom - our daughter divorced her good, Christian husband, this year. That alone is hard on children. They'd be better off in being always in a stable home situation, I think and with loving, trustworthy dad and grandparents around them if available, and we are. And they both don't like to go to school.
My prayers with you, but as for the situation, whether you like it or not is the parents decision. Which you need to respect. If you suspect the kids are unhappy in a public school, than you should talk to the dad.

You should ask her why she divorced him, yes divorce is always a tragedy.
 

MyrtleTrees

Junior Member
Sep 5, 2014
800
315
63
#24
My prayers with you, but as for the situation, whether you like it or not is the parents decision. Which you need to respect. If you suspect the kids are unhappy in a public school, than you should talk to the dad.

You should ask her why she divorced him, yes divorce is always a tragedy.
Hi! Yes, we already talked about that together. But we just don't agree. She just got tired of him, that's all. She didn't say he did anything abusive to her. She just didn't like being submissive to a husband. She also complained that she felt he was too old for her. The BIble wouldn't approve of any of her reasons for leaving him. I talked with her about it along with spiritual reasons why it is wrong for her to separate from him. She doesn't want to talk about it any more. So now, there's hardly anything that I can think of to talk about with her. So I just show her my love whenever I see her (which isn't often, as I don't drive) and keep praying for her to come to repentance and for God to help in the situation that is left from it, as well as is possible.
 

I_am_Canadian

Senior Member
Dec 8, 2014
2,218
714
113
#26
Hi! Yes, we already talked about that together. But we just don't agree. She just got tired of him, that's all. She didn't say he did anything abusive to her. She just didn't like being submissive to a husband. She also complained that she felt he was too old for her. The BIble wouldn't approve of any of her reasons for leaving him. I talked with her about it along with spiritual reasons why it is wrong for her to separate from him. She doesn't want to talk about it any more. So now, there's hardly anything that I can think of to talk about with her. So I just show her my love whenever I see her (which isn't often, as I don't drive) and keep praying for her to come to repentance and for God to help in the situation that is left from it, as well as is possible.
Yeah sounds like she is immature and doesn't want to commit to Godly relationship. It also sounds like he might be neglecting his wife. But ultimately if she didn't think he was the right man to marry she shouldn't have married him. I would suspect they got married for the wrong reasons.

I guess showing her God's love is all you can do at this point. Because you can't help someone that doesn't want help.
 

MyrtleTrees

Junior Member
Sep 5, 2014
800
315
63
#27
Yeah sounds like she is immature and doesn't want to commit to Godly relationship. It also sounds like he might be neglecting his wife. But ultimately if she didn't think he was the right man to marry she shouldn't have married him. I would suspect they got married for the wrong reasons.

I guess showing her God's love is all you can do at this point. Because you can't help someone that doesn't want help.
Thanks for your reply! Yes, she had to have either married him for the wrong reasons, or changed her mind later - that happens too, you know. Marriage is a new experience to newly weds - weaknesses get exposed with time.
 

JohnDB

Well-known member
Jan 16, 2021
5,626
2,210
113
#28
Well,
It's difficult (and almost impossible at times) to watch children or grandchildren make what we think of as mistakes.

I totally get it.

I know that at times we know to have the right answers but can't get them to do the correct things...only for them to come back later and say, "you were right".

But....

Nobody is a perfect parent. In each of us there is a desire to be better parents than our parents. To provide more, to be less harsh, to be more restrictive or less restrictive....whatever. And in our trying to do so we end up making more mistakes in the long run. And then after the kids have grown and have kids of their own we have a LOT of hindsight in what to do better and we have more patience because we aren't tasked with the daily annoyances or frustrations from doing it all fresh. Because when younger....it's all new.

And that is something that God designed.
We don't have a patriarchal home life culture anymore. Kinda sad in a lot of ways. But that's by God's design too.

I know that your desires are the best of intentions. I have them too. But ultimately you get what you get...this is his turn. He will succeed or fail based on what you have already done to teach and guide him. And currently he is doing what he sees as best...Even if it isn't in your understanding. And the children will reap the consequences. So will he.

He may change his mind...he may not.

He may feel that the social interaction with other kids is more important than the learning...especially when he is Divorced and he was homeschooled....he feels like a failure for the divorce. He might feel like If he had been in public schools he would have known better than to marry her or been a better husband in some way.
It's a possibility. I and you don't know for certain.
Public School is a mixed bag of good and bad things to learn for all of us. But our relationships with our children are the most important thing because they are the guidance for their moral character.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,177
113
#29
apparently making mistakes is how a lot of us learn
Not all of us have luxury of teachers or tutors that can focus solely on us.

If your grandchildren know how to read, and practice regularly then thats good. School will be much easier for them.

If they are dyslexic it will be harder, but make sure they know, otherwise just be sure they pick up that skill. If they are actually diagnosed as dyslexic then the school can get special funding put in place to help them out more, eg audio books, phonics readers, sound tubes, reading aids.

A lot of children that cant focus, sit still, get their letters backwards or cant spell, then FAKE reading actually have problems with reading because their eyes are unable to track writing properly. They can draw pictures, but writing and spelling are difficult. This is where you need to systemically teach them to spell and say, and then they can read.

Children that CAN read, usually then dont have much trouble sitting down and focusing on a book, because they can, and they also find books that interest them and WANT to read them. Children that cant, wander around lost, or ask others to read FOR them.

I think a certain amount of spoon feeding is beneficial, but by the time they reach school age or year 3 all children in school need to know how to read so they can learn from themselves.

Its like church, you dont actually need to go to church to listen to a sermon for half an hour when you have a copy of the Bible and can read the entire book yourself everyday. Its just there to reinforce what you are ALREADY learning, and to meet others in worship right.

School is not going to spoonfeed your children forever.
 

I_am_Canadian

Senior Member
Dec 8, 2014
2,218
714
113
#30
Thanks for your reply! Yes, she had to have either married him for the wrong reasons, or changed her mind later - that happens too, you know. Marriage is a new experience to newly weds - weaknesses get exposed with time.
your welcome, I know, and its a tragedy.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,177
113
#31
This is when marriage being a big decison that affects everyone needs careful thought and prayer changing your mind later actually has consequences.

I guess many couples dont think about that when they make what is supposed to be solemn vows. You wonder how they got married in the first place. Pushed into it by their parents? Decided on a whim?
 

I_am_Canadian

Senior Member
Dec 8, 2014
2,218
714
113
#32
This is when marriage being a big decison that affects everyone needs careful thought and prayer changing your mind later actually has consequences.

I guess many couples dont think about that when they make what is supposed to be solemn vows. You wonder how they got married in the first place. Pushed into it by their parents? Decided on a whim?
I know some people dont even regard a wedding or marriage as a sacred vow but treat it more as a show for friends and family
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,177
113
#33
I know some people dont even regard a wedding or marriage as a sacred vow but treat it more as a show for friends and family
its a problem for both men and women, men lying saying they will keep a promise just to seal a deal
women being fickle and not sticking to what they agreed to

Its not like a job contract where you could always decide to quit and leave for a better one, its a lifelong commitment

anyway, I dont know why that is. Maybe its just young people dont know any better. I recall Rachel Hunters reason why she left Rod Stewart..she married him when she was young and drunk (he was older than her father) and then she had two children but spent her life buying groceries and cleaning and didnt really want to do that anymore, while he was off living the high life and being waited on hand and foot. Men are stupid about marriage thinking once they are married their wife is their servant and will always want to be at their beck and call. They often dont think about doing the grocery shopping themselves or maybe helping out with childcare and giving their wife a break and time for herself.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,177
113
#34
Can I say if you are homeschooling good on you it relieves the presure on teachers esp when they have classes of up to 30 and one kid is acting up and disrupts the whole class.

I wish I had the magic thing where everyone is well behaved but it takes time to establish relarionships or bonds with your students/pupils. If they are coming from a tough start/beginning then the road is harder. Some kids have to deal with abandonment so early in their life and that doesnt bode well for them.

In the Bible its the orphan spirit or spirit of rejection...all children need to know they are loved, its so important, If you offend a child its better for a millstone to be placed around your neck and be cast to the bottom of the sea.

Suffer the little children and forbid them not for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
 

I_am_Canadian

Senior Member
Dec 8, 2014
2,218
714
113
#35
Can I say if you are homeschooling good on you it relieves the presure on teachers esp when they have classes of up to 30 and one kid is acting up and disrupts the whole class.

I wish I had the magic thing where everyone is well behaved but it takes time to establish relarionships or bonds with your students/pupils. If they are coming from a tough start/beginning then the road is harder. Some kids have to deal with abandonment so early in their life and that doesnt bode well for them.

In the Bible its the orphan spirit or spirit of rejection...all children need to know they are loved, its so important, If you offend a child its better for a millstone to be placed around your neck and be cast to the bottom of the sea.

Suffer the little children and forbid them not for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
its a parents first duty to train their children to become productive well behaved memebers of society. Education is the churches responcibility.
 

MyrtleTrees

Junior Member
Sep 5, 2014
800
315
63
#36
Can I say if you are homeschooling good on you it relieves the presure on teachers esp when they have classes of up to 30 and one kid is acting up and disrupts the whole class.

I wish I had the magic thing where everyone is well behaved but it takes time to establish relarionships or bonds with your students/pupils. If they are coming from a tough start/beginning then the road is harder. Some kids have to deal with abandonment so early in their life and that doesnt bode well for them.

In the Bible its the orphan spirit or spirit of rejection...all children need to know they are loved, its so important, If you offend a child its better for a millstone to be placed around your neck and be cast to the bottom of the sea.

Suffer the little children and forbid them not for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
Hi, Lanolin! Thanks for your kind reply! Yes, I think you know from experience, and have also thought it through from the biblcial perspective, as I have - that home-schooling one's children is the best way, whenever possible!