Replacement theology? Yes or No.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Yes, the disciples spoke three clauses, but grammatically they form one compound question with two actual horizons,
because the second and third clauses (“the sign of your coming” and “the end of the age”) are not two separate events in Jesus’ answer, but one eschatological reality,
Which is why Jesus responds with only two demonstratives, “this generation” for the near judgment and “that day” for the final coming. The disciples assumed all three things would happen together, but Jesus corrects that assumption by splitting their question into a near fulfillment (vv. 4–34) and a far fulfillment (vv. 35–51).
Meaning the disciples’ three‑part wording doesn’t create three prophetic, categories, it simply reveals their confusion, and Jesus’ answer establishes the actual interpretive structure.

Does that mean that you want to partially take back what you said here? :

"meaning “this generation” is always the generation in view, not a timeless category applied across eras."

I never said that the generation in view was applied across "eras". I said that different generations were going to see the fulfillment of the different events.
 
All you are doing is following a very small group of words spoken by Jesus instead of taking ALL of them into context. Your view is very limited. God's word doesn't just dissolve because you choose not to address or listen to the REST OF THEM.

That would be incorrect.
 
Is there a single verse in the Bible that we can all agree on? I searched for bunny rabbits thinking that might one but it came up with no results :)
 
Actually we don't talk about politics on pulpit.

But we do teach whoever rejecting Jesus today is not children of God.

Whoever saying Jesus is a lier today is not children of God.

What about your church?
I guess the silence means people know they are wrong but can't get themselves out of the wrong pit.

Here is help, pray to Jesus to help people come out of the sinful acts, repent and sin no more.

If they refuse, shake off the dirt on the shoe bottom and move on.
 
I guess the silence means people know they are wrong but can't get themselves out of the wrong pit.

Here is help, pray to Jesus to help people come out of the sinful acts, repent and sin no more.

If they refuse, shake off the dirt on the shoe bottom and move on.

The silence means that people involved in this conversation don't believe Jesus is a liar and their church isn't teaching that.

We're not currently discussing "sinful acts" either.

That's why people are shaking the dirt off of their shoes and ignoring your posts.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Churchgoer
But the Millennial Kingdom period is a time of peace, not a time of wrath, which shows that it comes after the Second Coming of Jesus in my opinion. I'm not sure I would count the Tribulation as the start of it. Once the Tribulation is over, Jesus will return to perform the Sheep & Goat judgement, then it will start.
Read it again. And again. And again.
The peaceful reign is indeed the bulk of the millennium.

But the DOTL aka the millennial reign BEGINS with the BIRTH PAINS aka the 7 year tribulation.

And can ONLY begin AFTER the rapture.
 
Read it again. And again. And again.
The peaceful reign is indeed the bulk of the millennium.

But the DOTL aka the millennial reign BEGINS with the BIRTH PAINS aka the 7 year tribulation.

And can ONLY begin AFTER the rapture.

I might have understood what you were saying better if you had shown the verses below. You believe that at the sound of the 7th trumpet that God/Jesus takes over the kingdoms of the world? The only thing is that this happens towards the end of the tribulation period. If there are other verses you're looking at, let me know.

Revelation 11:15-19

15 And the seventh angel sounded; and there were great voices in heaven, saying, The kingdoms of this world are become the kingdoms of our Lord, and of his Christ; and he shall reign for ever and ever.

16 And the four and twenty elders, which sat before God on their seats, fell upon their faces, and worshipped God,

17 We give thee thanks, O Lord God Almighty, which art, and wast, and art to come; because thou hast taken to thee thy great power, and hast reigned.

18 And the nations were angry, and thy wrath is come, and the time of the dead, that they should be judged, and that thou shouldest give reward unto thy servants the prophets, and to the saints, and them that fear thy name, small and great; and shouldest destroy them which destroy the earth.

19 And the temple of God was opened in heaven, and there was seen in his temple the ark of his testament: and there were lightnings, and voices, and thunderings, and an earthquake, and great hail.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2ndTimeIsTheCharm
I might have understood what you were saying better if you had shown the verses below. You believe that at the sound of the 7th trumpet that God/Jesus takes over the kingdoms of the world? The only thing is that this happens towards the end of the tribulation period. If there are other verses you're looking at, let me know.

Revelation 11:15-19

15 And the seventh angel sounded; and there were great voices in heaven, saying, The kingdoms of this world are become the kingdoms of our Lord, and of his Christ; and he shall reign for ever and ever.

16 And the four and twenty elders, which sat before God on their seats, fell upon their faces, and worshipped God,

17 We give thee thanks, O Lord God Almighty, which art, and wast, and art to come; because thou hast taken to thee thy great power, and hast reigned.

18 And the nations were angry, and thy wrath is come, and the time of the dead, that they should be judged, and that thou shouldest give reward unto thy servants the prophets, and to the saints, and them that fear thy name, small and great; and shouldest destroy them which destroy the earth.

19 And the temple of God was opened in heaven, and there was seen in his temple the ark of his testament: and there were lightnings, and voices, and thunderings, and an earthquake, and great hail.
No, you don't understand what I am saying.

Those verses are in the thick of the tribulation. NOT the beginning.

And most people misinterpret Rev 11.....and stupidity go mid-tribbers or post tribulation rapture. You are making the typical interpretive error, this due to ignorance.

And YES, Fruchtenbaum has it right. Among others such as myself.

Dr. Arnold Fruchtenbaum exegetes Revelation 11:15-19 through a strict classical dispensational lens. Because his framework is anchored in a pre-tribulation Rapture and the belief that the "Day of the Lord" (the Tribulation) begins with Christ taking the scroll in Revelation 5, he interprets the seventh trumpet as a major hinge point in the enforcement of God’s reclamation of the earth.
Here is how Fruchtenbaum explains this passage in light of those specific theological anchors:

1. The Scroll, the Seventh Trumpet, and the "Title Deed" (vv. 15 & 17)
For Fruchtenbaum, Revelation 5 is the legal turning point of history. When Christ takes the seven-sealed scroll, He is taking the "title deed to the earth." The breaking of the seals and the sounding of the trumpets are the progressive unrolling of that deed and the execution of the judgments required to evict Satan.
* The Telescopic Judgment: In Fruchtenbaum’s timeline, the seventh seal contains the seven trumpets, and the seventh trumpet contains the seven bowl judgments. Therefore, the sounding of the seventh trumpet in 11:15 is the release of the final, most severe series of judgments (the bowls) that will finish what began in chapter 5.
* Prophetic Certainty (Prolepsis): When the voices in heaven declare, "The kingdoms of this world are become the kingdoms of our Lord" (v. 15) and "thou hast taken to thee thy great power" (v. 17), Fruchtenbaum notes that Christ has not physically returned to earth yet. However, because the seventh trumpet unleashes the final bowl judgments, the outcome is now absolutely guaranteed. It is a proleptic (anticipatory) declaration. The legal transfer of the title deed in Revelation 5 is now moving into its final phase of physical enforcement.


2. The 24 Elders and the Pre-Tribulation Rapture (v. 16)
Fruchtenbaum identifies the "four and twenty elders" sitting on thrones as the raptured Church.
* Observers, Not Participants: Because they are already seated on thrones, wearing crowns (indicating they have already passed through the Judgment Seat of Christ), and acting in a priestly/worshipping role in heaven, this proves the Church was removed from the earth before the Day of the Lord began.
* Rejoicing at the Climax: The elders fall on their faces here because the long-awaited climax of the Tribulation has arrived. They are watching from heaven as God transitions from the trumpet judgments into the final, rapid-fire bowl judgments that will culminate in the Second Coming—an event they will eventually participate in by returning with Christ.

3. The Timeline of Wrath and Rewards (v. 18)
Verse 18 provides a summary outline of the events that the seventh trumpet will ultimately accomplish by the end of the Tribulation. Fruchtenbaum breaks this verse down chronologically:
* "The nations were angry, and thy wrath is come": This points specifically to the final Campaign of Armageddon. The nations will gather in anger against God and Israel, bringing down the final crescendo of God's wrath (the Day of the Lord).
* "The time of the dead, that they should be judged": In Fruchtenbaum's eschatology, judgments are separated by time. He views this specifically as looking forward to the end of the Tribulation when Old Testament saints and Tribulation martyrs will be resurrected and judged/rewarded (Daniel 12).
* "Give reward unto thy servants": While the Church was rewarded at the Rapture, this marks the impending resurrection and rewarding of the Tribulation saints and Old Testament prophets at the Second Coming.
* "Destroy them which destroy the earth": A direct reference to the impending destruction of the Antichrist, the False Prophet, and their followers who have ravaged the earth throughout the Day of the Lord.

4. The Ark of the Covenant and Israel (v. 19)
As a Messianic Jewish scholar, Fruchtenbaum places heavy emphasis on God's covenant relationship with Israel. When the temple in heaven opens and the Ark of His Testament (Covenant) is seen, it holds specific theological weight:
* God's Faithfulness to Israel: The Ark is the ultimate symbol of God's unconditional covenants with Israel (the Abrahamic, Land, Davidic, and New Covenants). Its appearance here is a signal. The second half of the Tribulation (the "Great Tribulation" or "Time of Jacob's Trouble") is about to begin.
* Protection and Judgment: God is reminding heaven and earth that He remembers His promises to Israel. The violent weather phenomena (lightnings, thunderings, earthquake, great hail) symbolize the severity of the bowl judgments to come. These judgments will simultaneously punish the Gentile nations for their antisemitism and drive the Jewish remnant to national repentance, leading directly to the Second Coming of the Messiah.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revelation1v8
No, you don't understand what I am saying.

Those verses are in the thick of the tribulation. NOT the beginning.

And most people misinterpret Rev 11.....and stupidity go mid-tribbers or post tribulation rapture. You are making the typical interpretive error, this due to ignorance.

And YES, Fruchtenbaum has it right. Among others such as myself.

Dr. Arnold Fruchtenbaum exegetes Revelation 11:15-19 through a strict classical dispensational lens. Because his framework is anchored in a pre-tribulation Rapture and the belief that the "Day of the Lord" (the Tribulation) begins with Christ taking the scroll in Revelation 5, he interprets the seventh trumpet as a major hinge point in the enforcement of God’s reclamation of the earth.
Here is how Fruchtenbaum explains this passage in light of those specific theological anchors:

1. The Scroll, the Seventh Trumpet, and the "Title Deed" (vv. 15 & 17)
For Fruchtenbaum, Revelation 5 is the legal turning point of history. When Christ takes the seven-sealed scroll, He is taking the "title deed to the earth." The breaking of the seals and the sounding of the trumpets are the progressive unrolling of that deed and the execution of the judgments required to evict Satan.
* The Telescopic Judgment: In Fruchtenbaum’s timeline, the seventh seal contains the seven trumpets, and the seventh trumpet contains the seven bowl judgments. Therefore, the sounding of the seventh trumpet in 11:15 is the release of the final, most severe series of judgments (the bowls) that will finish what began in chapter 5.
* Prophetic Certainty (Prolepsis): When the voices in heaven declare, "The kingdoms of this world are become the kingdoms of our Lord" (v. 15) and "thou hast taken to thee thy great power" (v. 17), Fruchtenbaum notes that Christ has not physically returned to earth yet. However, because the seventh trumpet unleashes the final bowl judgments, the outcome is now absolutely guaranteed. It is a proleptic (anticipatory) declaration. The legal transfer of the title deed in Revelation 5 is now moving into its final phase of physical enforcement.

2. The 24 Elders and the Pre-Tribulation Rapture (v. 16)
Fruchtenbaum identifies the "four and twenty elders" sitting on thrones as the raptured Church.
* Observers, Not Participants: Because they are already seated on thrones, wearing crowns (indicating they have already passed through the Judgment Seat of Christ), and acting in a priestly/worshipping role in heaven, this proves the Church was removed from the earth before the Day of the Lord began.
* Rejoicing at the Climax: The elders fall on their faces here because the long-awaited climax of the Tribulation has arrived. They are watching from heaven as God transitions from the trumpet judgments into the final, rapid-fire bowl judgments that will culminate in the Second Coming—an event they will eventually participate in by returning with Christ.

3. The Timeline of Wrath and Rewards (v. 18)
Verse 18 provides a summary outline of the events that the seventh trumpet will ultimately accomplish by the end of the Tribulation. Fruchtenbaum breaks this verse down chronologically:
* "The nations were angry, and thy wrath is come": This points specifically to the final Campaign of Armageddon. The nations will gather in anger against God and Israel, bringing down the final crescendo of God's wrath (the Day of the Lord).
* "The time of the dead, that they should be judged": In Fruchtenbaum's eschatology, judgments are separated by time. He views this specifically as looking forward to the end of the Tribulation when Old Testament saints and Tribulation martyrs will be resurrected and judged/rewarded (Daniel 12).
* "Give reward unto thy servants": While the Church was rewarded at the Rapture, this marks the impending resurrection and rewarding of the Tribulation saints and Old Testament prophets at the Second Coming.
* "Destroy them which destroy the earth": A direct reference to the impending destruction of the Antichrist, the False Prophet, and their followers who have ravaged the earth throughout the Day of the Lord.

4. The Ark of the Covenant and Israel (v. 19)
As a Messianic Jewish scholar, Fruchtenbaum places heavy emphasis on God's covenant relationship with Israel. When the temple in heaven opens and the Ark of His Testament (Covenant) is seen, it holds specific theological weight:
* God's Faithfulness to Israel: The Ark is the ultimate symbol of God's unconditional covenants with Israel (the Abrahamic, Land, Davidic, and New Covenants). Its appearance here is a signal. The second half of the Tribulation (the "Great Tribulation" or "Time of Jacob's Trouble") is about to begin.
* Protection and Judgment: God is reminding heaven and earth that He remembers His promises to Israel. The violent weather phenomena (lightnings, thunderings, earthquake, great hail) symbolize the severity of the bowl judgments to come. These judgments will simultaneously punish the Gentile nations for their antisemitism and drive the Jewish remnant to national repentance, leading directly to the Second Coming of the Messiah.

I see what you're saying now!!

Revelation 5

6 And I beheld, and, lo, in the midst of the throne and of the four beasts, and in the midst of the elders, stood a Lamb as it had been slain, having seven horns and seven eyes, which are the seven Spirits of God sent forth into all the earth.

7 And he came and took the book out of the right hand of him that sat upon the throne.

8 And when he had taken the book, the four beasts and four and twenty elders fell down before the Lamb, having every one of them harps, and golden vials full of odours, which are the prayers of saints.

9 And they sung a new song, saying, Thou art worthy to take the book, and to open the seals thereof: for thou wast slain, and hast redeemed us to God by thy blood out of every kindred, and tongue, and people, and nation;

10 And hast made us unto our God kings and priests: and we shall reign on the earth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LTTexan and cv5
I see what you're saying now!!

Revelation 5

6 And I beheld, and, lo, in the midst of the throne and of the four beasts, and in the midst of the elders, stood a Lamb as it had been slain, having seven horns and seven eyes, which are the seven Spirits of God sent forth into all the earth.

7 And he came and took the book out of the right hand of him that sat upon the throne.

8 And when he had taken the book, the four beasts and four and twenty elders fell down before the Lamb, having every one of them harps, and golden vials full of odours, which are the prayers of saints.

9 And they sung a new song, saying, Thou art worthy to take the book, and to open the seals thereof: for thou wast slain, and hast redeemed us to God by thy blood out of every kindred, and tongue, and people, and nation;

10 And hast made us unto our God kings and priests: and we shall reign on the earth.
Good job buddy.
And how many others on this thread choose to receive this word of eschatological truth?

Not many. If any.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revelation1v8
Does that mean that you want to partially take back what you said here? :

"meaning “this generation” is always the generation in view, not a timeless category applied across eras."

I never said that the generation in view was applied across "eras". I said that different generations were going to see the fulfillment of the different events.
No, I’m not taking anything back; I’m tightening the distinction.
When I said “this generation is always the generation in view, not a timeless category applied across eras,” I was rejecting the move where “this generation” becomes a floating theological symbol that can be reassigned to any era you want — a system‑preserving trick. You weren’t doing that; you were saying different generations see different fulfillments, which is a separate claim.
The correction I’m making now is about the structure of Matthew 24: the disciples bundle three clauses into one horizon, Jesus splits that horizon into near judgment (vv. 4–34) and far coming (vv. 36–51), and He marks the split with two demonstratives — “this generation” for the near, “that day” for the far.
That doesn’t contradict your point that different generations see different events; it simply means the text itself assigns the near fulfillment to His generation and the final appearing to a future one, not because “this generation” floats across eras, but because Jesus Himself divides the horizons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revelation1v8
I see what you're saying now!!

Revelation 5

6 And I beheld, and, lo, in the midst of the throne and of the four beasts, and in the midst of the elders, stood a Lamb as it had been slain, having seven horns and seven eyes, which are the seven Spirits of God sent forth into all the earth.

7 And he came and took the book out of the right hand of him that sat upon the throne.

8 And when he had taken the book, the four beasts and four and twenty elders fell down before the Lamb, having every one of them harps, and golden vials full of odours, which are the prayers of saints.

9 And they sung a new song, saying, Thou art worthy to take the book, and to open the seals thereof: for thou wast slain, and hast redeemed us to God by thy blood out of every kindred, and tongue, and people, and nation;

10 And hast made us unto our God kings and priests: and we shall reign on the earth.
"Revelation 5 is the legal turning point of history. When Christ takes the seven-sealed scroll, He is taking the "title deed to the earth." The breaking of the seals and the sounding of the trumpets are the progressive unrolling of that deed and the execution of the judgments required to evict Satan."

And yes, the identity of the 24 Elders can only be the now raptured gentile Bride Church, seen first in Revelation chapter 5.
Which PRECEDES chapter 6 opening of the seals of judgement upon the earth.
Nothing could be more obvious, yet the detractors deny despite the indisputable identity so noted.

[Rev 4:1 KJV]
1 After this I looked, and, behold, a door [was] opened in heaven: and the first voice which I heard [was] as it were of a trumpet talking with me; which said, Come up hither, and I will shew thee things which must be hereafter.

[Rev 11:12 KJV]
12 And they heard a great voice from heaven saying unto them, Come up hither. And they ascended up to heaven in a cloud; and their enemies beheld them.
 
  • Love
Reactions: LTTexan
Current secular Israel, jews are enemy of Jesus, so let's see how we can truly love them.

- refuse to commit murdering, stealing, lying together with the enemy, not as in ot, many Israelites instead of worshipping YHVH, they joined the enemy side and worship Baal, sacrificing babies....they supposed to lead other people to YHVH, but instead they joined the other people became followers of baal, ...pagan idols.

- be like Daniel, 3 young men, refuse to bow down to fake gods.

- telling them the gospel, tell them if they don't repent, God's wrath will be upon them.

- tell them to stop all the murdering, stealing. Expose the murdering, stealing, immoralities.

More ideas welcome.
How about stop monkeying around with the scriptures.
 
We have all had this conversation before.

While God/Jesus doesn't prefer war, sometimes it is necessary for God/Jesus to protect His people from Satan and anyone who wants to do them harm, regardless of their current state. Especially, when we already know that God has a specific plan and purpose for these people based on what has been written. Don't forget that while Jesus will ultimately bring peace into the world, He has to do it by returning with the Wrath of God. Does that mean He won't use people on the earth to carry out part of those plans before He returns to finish it off? The answer is "No".

Let's look at some history in the Bible:

God personally waged war against the Egyptians by destroying their army in the Red Sea and later commanded Israel to execute judgment on the Canaanites, who were deemed exceedingly wicked. In these conquests, God provided specific battle strategies, such as the collapse of Jericho’s walls after the Israelites marched and shouted, demonstrating that victory relied on divine intervention rather than conventional military might.

God directed ancient Israel’s armies to defend their land and enforce His laws, often intervening supernaturally to secure victory. Key examples include Gideon’s 300 men defeating the Midianites to prove God saves through His power, and King David receiving divine battle tactics to defeat the Philistines. God also fought for Israel without their direct combat, such as when He caused a coalition of enemies to rout themselves during King Jehoshaphat’s reign.

Heavenly hosts and angelic armies are depicted as executing God’s will alongside or instead of human forces. The commander of the Lord’s army appeared to Joshua to lead the conquest of Canaan, and Elisha’s servant saw mountains filled with "horses and chariots of fire" to protect Israel. Ultimately, biblical texts portray God as the Supreme Leader who determines when to wage war, ensuring that His people trust in His power rather than their own strength.

You expose the psychopathic nature of the dispensationalist religion there.
Israelis are not the ancient Israelites and the people of the region are not ancient Amalek.
The new covenant has happened since that time.
God has not given authority to modern Israel to commit genocides and start preemptive wars.
Jesus does not need any of us to facilitate His second coming.
We are called to follow Him, He does not follow us.
 
How about stop monkeying around with the scriptures.
Important thing is to break the connection between dispensationism and support secular system.

Even if they are on dispensationism side, they still can't explain this support of secular state.

Many of them just get the saying from churches, pastors, but they themselves never dig deeper. Whatever the majority says, they just follow.

It is very dangerous to follow majority.