Encrypting it would make it so that believers from those countries may not be able to find it either, and we would like to reach out to them. Also, I think the encryption would mess with our page ranking on Google as well. I may be wrong about that though.
You don't have to force HTTPS, just enable port 443 with any SSL provider. It doesn't affect Google Rank. Paypal, Google itself, eBay, and all reputable online stores already have HTTPS on by default when you login. This is to protect you from session stealing mostly.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secure_Socket_Layer
https://www.instantssl.com
Encrypting would slow the site down a lot.
If people need to visit from a country that doesn't like Christianity, they need to use proxies.
Most web-proxies are setup by people recording everything you do; more or less defeating the purpose. Stealing your cookies so they can do session hijacking or downright grab your passwords in plain-text. If in an evil country, they can also log everything and use it against you later, e.g. China. HTTPS would prevent them from eavesdropping
as much. Also, I've used HTTPS over dial-up, doesn't slow it down too much at all.
Proxy doesn't mask the ISP's identification of the end user. At best, it will prevent CC from properly tracing the user's IP address.
True. Also, most people that are actually in those areas aren't using open-proxies anyway. They resort to TOR or VPN providers, although China recently shutoff all unauthorized VPN use making it even more difficult for the poor people there to get out into the free internet.
It would be a big help, to prevent password-stealing but not a lifesaver. Most of the times they just block DNS access altogether; meaning ChristianChat.com would not resolve in their country, or intercept the SSL cert and replace it with their own -
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/08/iranian-man-middle-attack-against-google
Anyways enough geek talk, none of the staff has responded to their thoughts on the post yet...