Calvinists: The Just Shall Live BEFORE Having Faith

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Natural revelation saves no one, and that is what Romans 1 avers. Look at Acts 17. Paul goes through Athens, a city totally given to idolatry. Those in remote areas who have never seen a bible, never heard about the Christ, know there is God, but they worship idols carved from wood, stone, some sun god, stars, moon, trees, &c.

This is what Romans 1 speaks about. They know God exists, but they worship idols. No one is there to tell them about the Christ. So they worship an idol.
No one will be saved without knowing the part of romans 1. No one, it is part of the gospel.


It says what may be known of God is clearly seen, That would include the gospel. Paul said Timothy had enough knowledge pre christ to be saved.
 
Dec 28, 2016
5,455
236
63
How? Is God supposed to make Shawn believe against his will?
No, He changes His will. No one wills themself to heaven. Romans 9:16 & John 1:11-13.

Not the same, It would. Be like you leaving your will to a group of people. But only those who wanted it would recieve it, You would not force anyone to take it against their will (some may not think your things are worth it)
God does not force anyone to serve Him. Man, in his fallen state, hates Him. That's what Romans 8:5-9 avers. Those who love God have been born of Him.[1 John 4:7]


the only difference is, since your not God, you do not know who will say yes and who will God. So you could not predestine anyone to take your stuff.
But God did not base His election on anyone other than Himself. He did not elect based upon ppl's actions, either. There are none who seek Him. There are none who understand.[Romans 3 & Psalm 14]



People are lost because they reject God. “He who believe4s is not condemned, He who does not believe (reject God) is condemned already, why are they condemned? Because they did not believe.
They were condemned already. Ppl are condemned because they reject Him, but reject Him because they're already condemned.

And if God did not allow a person or give them a choice to be saved, He chose them for hell. And he shows favoritism. At least in my view.

Ps. Thank you for an honest/ humble conversation. It is pleasant.
Again, God did not choose ppl based upon themselves, but Himself. God does give them a choice, and they freely choose no thanks. The lost don't go around looking for some way in. They are freely running from Him. It is He who seeks and saves.
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
No one will be saved without knowing the part of romans 1. No one, it is part of the gospel. It says what may be known of God is clearly seen, That would include the gospel.


Now you're adding to the Gospel. Nowhere does it say that a person needs to know any certain passage to be saved. MANY have heard the Gospel, and were saved, and never even got a Bible and had never seen the epistle to the Romans.

Why? It was written in 57-58 A.D. Many were saved prior to this! You're just making up new unbiblical mandates not supported by Scripture, more "extra-biblical" material.

People, these things are not true. Goodness sake man stop teaching this bunk...

Paul said Timothy had enough knowledge pre christ to be saved.
Um, no, he never made such a statement, you did. You're just making things up as you go along.
 
Dec 28, 2016
5,455
236
63
No one will be saved without knowing the part of romans 1. No one, it is part of the gospel.


It says what may be known of God is clearly seen, That would include the gospel. Paul said Timothy had enough knowledge pre christ to be saved.
I think our disconnect is the target audience we're thinking about. I am thinking about those who have never heard the gospel, never seen a bible.

They know God exists, but they don't know that the Christ came and died for them. Natural revelation doesn't express the gospel.

They know God exists, but worship wooden or stone statues, stars, sun, moon, or some other idol.
 
Dec 28, 2016
5,455
236
63
Faith comes from hearing, and hearing the message concerning the Christ.

It doesn't come from clouds, stars, sun, moon, iow, natural revelation.
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
I have the Bible to back me.

Jesus did not say the HS would convict with the word. Your adding to the word of God.

Now your attacking, what is it with you two? Can you not have a conversation without attacking people you disagree with?
You and your attacking accusations. If you think that is an attack, time for you to grow up. I'm withstanding your heresies here, and that is what it has become, not just heterodoxy, heresy.

I'm going against your false teachings. The Holy Spirit did convict and does convict the world, through the Gospel, not through your mysticism, your experiences, and your stories which you are right now arguing for validity to the point of being as valid as Scripture.

Anyone here can see who's adding to the Word, and it is you.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
No, He changes His will. No one wills themself to heaven. Romans 9:16 & John 1:11-13.9
You said he was headed to hell. God did not change his will. I never said anyone willed themselves to heaven.



God does not force anyone to serve Him. Man, in his fallen state, hates Him. That's what Romans 8:5-9 avers. Those who love God have been born of Him.[1 John 4:7]
You can not love God until you first experience his love, You are not saved because you love God, Your saved because God loved you and offered you his gift.



But God did not base His election on anyone other than Himself. He did not elect based upon ppl's actions, either. There are none who seek Him. There are none who understand.[Romans 3 & Psalm 14]
again to me, this says God shows favoritism, It does not matter what the reason. God choosing one and not another is showing favoritism to the one, and not the other.

God draws. God calls. Many are called. But few are chosen, Not everyone he calls wil be saved,




They were condemned already. Ppl are condemned because they reject Him, but reject Him because they're already condemned.
The Bible says they are condemned already BECAUSE they have not believed.

John 3: 18 [FONT=&quot]He who believes in Him is not condemned; but he who does not believe is condemned already, because he has not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God.[/FONT]

Cause and affect cannot be ignored.

Again, God did not choose ppl based upon themselves, but Himself. God does give them a choice, and they freely choose no thanks. The lost don't go around looking for some way in. They are freely running from Him. It is He who seeks and saves.
God gives them a choice but does not allow them to chose yes? Where is choice? They have one choice in this senerio. You can not condemn someone for saying no when they had no possibility of saying yes
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
Faith comes from hearing, and hearing the message concerning the Christ.

It doesn't come from clouds, stars, sun, moon, iow, natural revelation.
BAM!!!!!!!!!! Exactly! He's out on a limb. I'm going to continue to withstand his false teachings for the same of others. I appreciate your stance on truth brother.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
You and your attacking accusations. If you think that is an attack, time for you to grow up. I'm withstanding your heresies here, and that is what it has become, not just heterodoxy, heresy.

I'm going against your false teachings. The Holy Spirit did convict and does convict the world, through the Gospel, not through your mysticism, your experiences, and your stories which you are right now arguing for validity to the point of being as valid as Scripture.

Anyone here can see who's adding to the Word, and it is you.
See, here we go again, His personal opinion is I am a heretic, Thus he will not discuss anything, just as he admitted, attack me.

I pray you are not a pastor. If you treat your congregation this way, I feel sorry for them./


 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I think our disconnect is the target audience we're thinking about. I am thinking about those who have never heard the gospel, never seen a bible.
So am I

They know God exists, but they don't know that the Christ came and died for them. Natural revelation doesn't express the gospel.

They know God exists, but worship wooden or stone statues, stars, sun, moon, or some other idol.
No one knew christ came in the OT, are they all lost?

God gave the gospel right after the fall. I believe they had more than adequate information.

 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Faith comes from hearing, and hearing the message concerning the Christ.

It doesn't come from clouds, stars, sun, moon, iow, natural revelation.
So now your mocking the HS.

Way to go.

And yes, faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word. I never said a person can have faith apart from thre word. So please stop trying to insist I have.
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
See, here we go again, His personal opinion is I am a heretic, Thus he will not discuss anything, just as he admitted, attack me.

I pray you are not a pastor. If you treat your congregation this way, I feel sorry for them.
Oh, poo-hoo, this bad treatment calling you out on your false teachings. How turrible!!!! :rolleyes:

They'd feel sorry for you and call you to repent because with your teaching you'd be defrocked and cast out of fellowship otherwise.

Yes, what you are teaching is extra-biblical heresy. Telling you this isn't an attack on your person, it's an address against your error. Man up and quit your belly aching with this attack nonsense, it is over-used and lame.
 
Dec 28, 2016
5,455
236
63
You said he was headed to hell. God did not change his will. I never said anyone willed themselves to heaven.





You can not love God until you first experience his love, You are not saved because you love God, Your saved because God loved you and offered you his gift.




again to me, this says God shows favoritism, It does not matter what the reason. God choosing one and not another is showing favoritism to the one, and not the other.

God draws. God calls. Many are called. But few are chosen, Not everyone he calls wil be saved,






The Bible says they are condemned already BECAUSE they have not believed.

John 3: 18 He who believes in Him is not condemned; but he who does not believe is condemned already, because he has not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God.

Cause and affect cannot be ignored.


God gives them a choice but does not allow them to chose yes? Where is choice? They have one choice in this senerio. You can not condemn someone for saying no when they had no possibility of saying yes
Those who love God have been born of Him[1 John 4:7] That's why regeneration, faith, repentance, salvation all occur simultaenously. The lost hate God. That's why God must change the lost's will. In the fallen state, their will is bondage to sin and Satan. God frees their will from this bondage and they freely choose Him.

Those who reject Him are condemed already. Their rejecting Him never changed their state.
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
Those who love God have been born of Him[1 John 4:7] That's why regeneration, faith, repentance, salvation all occur simultaenously. The lost hate God. That's why God must change the lost's will. In the fallen state, their will is bondage to sin and Satan. God frees their will from this bondage and they freely choose Him.

Those who reject Him are condemed already. Their rejecting Him never changed their state.
Yes, the were condemned before ever rejecting Christ.
 
Dec 28, 2016
5,455
236
63
So now your mocking the HS.

Way to go.

And yes, faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word. I never said a person can have faith apart from thre word. So please stop trying to insist I have.
I am not mocking the Holy Spirit. But the Spirit draws ppl via the word.

Ppl, you can see where the insults are coming from, the false allegations. I have been civil and he accuses me of mocking the Spirit.
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
I am not mocking the Holy Spirit. But the Spirit draws ppl via the word.

Ppl, you can see where the insults are coming from, the false allegations. I have been civil and he accuses me of mocking the Spirit.

Yep. What he said about you and the Holy Spirit is uncalled for. THAT is what an attack is.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Those who love God have been born of Him[1 John 4:7] That's why regeneration, faith, repentance, salvation all occur simultaenously. The lost hate God. That's why God must change the lost's will. In the fallen state, their will is bondage to sin and Satan. God frees their will from this bondage and they freely choose Him.

Those who reject Him are condemed already. Their rejecting Him never changed their state.
Think about what you just said, You just said God saves people because they loved him, ie, they saved themselves.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I am not mocking the Holy Spirit. But the Spirit draws ppl via the word.

Ppl, you can see where the insults are coming from, the false allegations. I have been civil and he accuses me of mocking the Spirit.
lol.. lets turn the tables.

I said the HS can draw people any way he wishes, and you called it the air, clouds, sun etc. so in reality, you did.

I never said the sun, the clouds the air etc spoke to us, so who is the one mocking?
 
Dec 28, 2016
5,455
236
63
lol.. lets turn the tables.

I said the HS can draw people any way he wishes, and you called it the air, clouds, sun etc. so in reality, you did.
The Holy Spirit draws ppl through the word. That's what sola scriptura is. He does not draw via clouds, sky, moon,stars,sun, iow, natural revelation.