Cessationism and Continuationism

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Aerials1978

Aerials1978

Well-known member
#61
Dec 10, 2019
1,707
986
113
#61
kaylagrl said:
Credible evidence, no one who believes in cessionism wants credible evidence. They believe there is such a thing. So as another poster said, each believes what they believe, why cause division?
Click to expand...
You’re making an assumption based on feelings and not actuality. If I have certain evidence based in scripture and historical records to indicate God gave certain people specific gifts at a particular point in time and that has ended that for now, some will say that I don’t enough faith and that’s just not true. Saying what’s true for me and not for thee is a logical fallacy. God does not operate on what you or I believe to be truth.
 
CS1

CS1

Well-known member
#62
May 23, 2012
12,382
4,078
113
#62
DavidTree said:
When McArthur and others who have studied the Scriptures say "speaking in tongues is of the devil" they commit egregious sin.

Saying the Gifts have ceased for today is complete ignorance and from a hardened religious self righteous heart of unbelief.
Click to expand...
well, from the context of it being of the devil was from the Hindu praying which he associated to the foolishness we see on TV and youtube

Using your jacket to knock a herd of people out is foolishness
 
Aerials1978

Aerials1978

Well-known member
#63
Dec 10, 2019
1,707
986
113
#63
DavidTree said:
Dear Aerials1978,
Peace and Love in Christ Jesus our Lord.

i can show you, beyond any shadow of doubt, if you open your heart to faith & complete trust in the Word, the Truth as it is written.

Do you desire Truth above 'respect of persons' or do yo see christian churches and their appointed leaders as Truth???
Click to expand...
This what I am taking about: not having enough faith which is not accurate. No one as of yet has asked me why I have this line of thinking. Instead accusations are used.
 
DavidTree

DavidTree

Banned
#64
Aug 2, 2021
7,317
2,048
113
#64
Aerials1978 said:
This what I am taking about: not having enough faith which is not accurate. No one as of yet has asked me why I have this line of thinking. Instead accusations are used.
Click to expand...
What is your line of thinking?
 
S

SophieT

Guest
#65
#65
CS1 said:
I agree and yes I have read strange fire. I have formulated a good argument for that which many have not been able to answer.

IN the end two things we must do just two



1. leave him alone
2. correct ourselves


That it. I don't like using names now I will and do think it is right to address the wrong understanding.


1. they say the gifts have ceased.
Please show in the word of God

2. in 1cor 13:8-10.
It does say that

3. yes it does you need to study more and no about the canonization the gifts are no longer needed.
Can't you show me in the bible?

4. well, it is clear if you look at pagan practices like kunnduni Hindu praying this is something.
Why are you looking outside the word of God to disprove what is in the word of God? can't you show me where in the bible the gifts are not for today?

5. well, k. Copeland, and this guy and that lady are demonized.

Ok, so because they are in error the gifts of the Holy Spirit are not real or for today? So you want me to look at the foolishness of those who are abusing the gifts and not HOLD YOUR FEET TO the FIRE that you can't show me in the word of God where the Gifts are not for today BE you have not seen it. Even IF the Word of God doesn't say they have stopped?

That is the same thing you are doing they you accuse others of doing, that is unbiblical.
Click to expand...

Michael Brown has written a very good response to MacArthur's claims

Authentic Fire

the rest of your post was a reply to someone else I think?
 
CS1

CS1

Well-known member
#66
May 23, 2012
12,382
4,078
113
#66
SophieT said:
Michael Brown has written a very good response to MacArthur's claims

Authentic Fire

the rest of your post was a reply to someone else I think?
Click to expand...
yes I have seen Michael Brown, there was one debate I watched that was not Brown but a guy from NY he held his own very well yet the same thing the cessionist could not prove his point biblically so he at the end told the aog preacher to perform a sign right now.
he was very upset. just like the Pharisees demanded Jesus do what they wanted.
 
Nehemiah6

Nehemiah6

Senior Member
#67
Jul 18, 2017
24,595
13,016
113
#67
DavidTree said:
You are speaking against the Word of God, you have not that authority as you are not an apostle to even make such a claim.
Click to expand...
And you are putting yourself in the position of a pope. Since Paul SPECIFICALLY stated that three spiritual gifts would cease, and they did cease, you do not have a leg to stand on. The modern tongues movement (early 20th century) revived tongues, but whether those are genuine remains questionable. Had that gift been present in all churches for 1900 years, you might have had a point.
 
S

SophieT

Guest
#68
#68
CS1 said:
yes I have seen Michael Brown, there was one debate I watched that was not Brown but a guy from NY he held his own very well yet the same thing the cessionist could not prove his point biblically so he at the end told the aog preacher to perform a sign right now.
he was very upset. just like the Pharisees demanded Jesus do what they wanted.
Click to expand...
yeah that is what they do

get upset and demand a miracle

I find Brown respectful and logical while still passionate.
 
DavidTree

DavidTree

Banned
#69
Aug 2, 2021
7,317
2,048
113
#69
Nehemiah6 said:
And you are putting yourself in the position of a pope. Since Paul SPECIFICALLY stated that three spiritual gifts would cease, and they did cease, you do not have a leg to stand on. The modern tongues movement (early 20th century) revived tongues, but whether those are genuine remains questionable. Had that gift been present in all churches for 1900 years, you might have had a point.
Click to expand...
i stand on Truth = It is written

The Apostle Paul never said that the Gifts ceased.

The Apostle Paul said that they will cease when we are no longer here on earth but "face to face" with the Lord.

Up until now you did not know that "face to face" is a marriage term.

i do not seek to be an apostle nor do i need to be one, but only to be submitted to the teachings of Christ and the Apostles.

When we are submitted unto God we have no desire to change or alter His Word to conform to our unbelief.

PEACE
 
Aerials1978

Aerials1978

Well-known member
#70
Dec 10, 2019
1,707
986
113
#70
DavidTree said:
What is your line of thinking?
Click to expand...
Well for one, there has been no validated evidence to support the notion that certain miracles still do occur. I’m not say God cannot do these thigs, I’m saying He choose not to. The Apostolic age was unique as it was the founding of what would be become the Church. Not only did the Apostles have to deal with the traditions of Judaism and the religious elite of their day, but with very hostile gentile nations and cultures. Nothing had been codified as far that the NT was concerned, so God used these men and gave them special gifts to carry out the ministry that would eventually lead to their deaths. Since no written word had yet been given, God used them to convince people that they were indeed commissioned by Christ. That’s another reason I have a difficult time accepting people’s testimonies about having spiritual gifts. Jesus Himself, face to face told these men what they would do and receive. Jesus speaking to you directly in a physical and audible way is unprecedented. It just doesn’t not happen randomly.
 
DavidTree

DavidTree

Banned
#71
Aug 2, 2021
7,317
2,048
113
#71
Aerials1978 said:
Well for one, there has been no validated evidence to support the notion that certain miracles still do occur. I’m not say God cannot do these thigs, I’m saying He choose not to. The Apostolic age was unique as it was the founding of what would be become the Church. Not only did the Apostles have to deal with the traditions of Judaism and the religious elite of their day, but with very hostile gentile nations and cultures. Nothing had been codified as far that the NT was concerned, so God used these men and gave them special gifts to carry out the ministry that would eventually lead to their deaths. Since no written word had yet been given, God used them to convince people that they were indeed commissioned by Christ. That’s another reason I have a difficult time accepting people’s testimonies about having spiritual gifts. Jesus Himself, face to face told these men what they would do and receive. Jesus speaking to you directly in a physical and audible way is unprecedented. It just doesn’t not happen randomly.
Click to expand...
OK, good stuff and valid.

The question now is between you and the LORD.

Do you want to know and embrace the Truth???

Do not seek Truth if you will only turn away from it or worse (as in the case of McArthur) and fight against it.

As with all revelation from God, it is always a heart issue = either you allow your heart to be circumcised or you say 'no thanks'.

The LORD your God will circumcise your hearts and the hearts of your descendants, and you will love Him with all your heart and with all your soul, so that you may live............Deuteronomy 30:6
 
Aerials1978

Aerials1978

Well-known member
#72
Dec 10, 2019
1,707
986
113
#72
DavidTree said:
OK, good stuff and valid.

The question now is between you and the LORD.

Do you want to know and embrace the Truth???

Do not seek Truth if you will only turn away from it or worse (as in the case of McArthur) and fight against it.

As with all revelation from God, it is always a heart issue = either you allow your heart to be circumcised or you say 'no thanks'.

The LORD your God will circumcise your hearts and the hearts of your descendants, and you will love Him with all your heart and with all your soul, so that you may live............Deuteronomy 30:6
Click to expand...
I don’t fight against God. That would be futile. If God decides to show me something, He will and in accordance to His purpose. I think MacArthur and I have the same opinion to an extent, but he is much more knowledgeable of theology than I am. That’s not to say I agree with everything he says, but for the most part I do.
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#73
#73
Aerials1978 said:
You’re making an assumption based on feelings and not actuality.
Click to expand...
Which is where the argument begins. Because right here you are making an assumption and a judgment.


Aerials1978 said:
If I have certain evidence based in scripture and historical records to indicate God gave certain people specific gifts at a particular point in time and that has ended that for now, some will say that I don’t enough faith and that’s just not true. Saying what’s true for me and not for thee is a logical fallacy. God does not operate on what you or I believe to be truth.
Click to expand...
When the perfect has come, it has debated, discussed, and done again and again. There is no day that is mentioned in Scripture, no date that says tongues will cease. You think it's one period in time, I think it's another. If you claim you are right, then anyone speaking in tongues today is doing it under the power of satan, period. If it's not of God it's of satan, there is no middle ground.
 
CS1

CS1

Well-known member
#74
May 23, 2012
12,382
4,078
113
#74
Aerials1978 said:
Well for one, there has been no validated evidence to support the notion that certain miracles still do occur. I’m not say God cannot do these thigs, I’m saying He choose not to. The Apostolic age was unique as it was the founding of what would be become the Church. Not only did the Apostles have to deal with the traditions of Judaism and the religious elite of their day, but with very hostile gentile nations and cultures. Nothing had been codified as far that the NT was concerned, so God used these men and gave them special gifts to carry out the ministry that would eventually lead to their deaths. Since no written word had yet been given, God used them to convince people that they were indeed commissioned by Christ. That’s another reason I have a difficult time accepting people’s testimonies about having spiritual gifts. Jesus Himself, face to face told these men what they would do and receive. Jesus speaking to you directly in a physical and audible way is unprecedented. It just doesn’t not happen randomly.
Click to expand...
says you? Or secular humanism? In the same breath, YOU SAY, YOU ARE NOT SAYING " God cannot do these things",
but stand by that God doesn't do them today. Really?

That is a half-baked cake LOL. You can't have it both ways. God does whether you see it or NOT. Faith is the substance of things hoped for and the evidence of things NOT SEEN. Jesus said you believe because you have seen, Blessed IS he who believes and doesn't have to see.

The Apostolic age and the word of God say nothing of the Gifts of the Holy Spirit have stopped or would stop.
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#75
#75
Oblio said:
I'm not a fan of Word Of Faith, in fact I'm not a fan of denominations.
Click to expand...

Well, not being nasty here, Word of Faith churches are independent, meaning no denomination. They have no government in the church, no overseer they preach and do as they like. A pastor can't be voted out. That is why we have denominations, so a pastor can be voted out if needs be, so the church is held accountable for what money is spent where, and people have a vote on what is and is not done in the church. Independents aren't like that. That's why so much foolishness and abuse happens in these churches, they are accountable to no one.
 
DavidTree

DavidTree

Banned
#76
Aug 2, 2021
7,317
2,048
113
#76
Aerials1978 said:
I don’t fight against God. That would be futile. If God decides to show me something, He will and in accordance to His purpose. I think MacArthur and I have the same opinion to an extent, but he is much more knowledgeable of theology than I am. That’s not to say I agree with everything he says, but for the most part I do.
Click to expand...
How does God show to us Truth???

Is McArthur fighting against Truth???

How can you know if someone is fighting against Truth???
 
Aerials1978

Aerials1978

Well-known member
#77
Dec 10, 2019
1,707
986
113
#77
kaylagrl said:
Which is where the argument begins. Because right here you are making an assumption and a judgment.




When the perfect has come, it has debated, discussed, and done again and again. There is no day that is mentioned in Scripture, no date that says tongues will cease. You think it's one period in time, I think it's another. If you claim you are right, then anyone speaking in tongues today is doing it under the power of satan, period. If it's not of God it's of satan, there is no middle ground.
Click to expand...
Can you pinpoint a time within the last 1,800 where the Apostolic ministry was and has been continuous beyond the original 13? Any of the early church fathers writtings on the matter?
 
CS1

CS1

Well-known member
#78
May 23, 2012
12,382
4,078
113
#78
kaylagrl said:
Well, not being nasty here, Word of Faith churches are independent, meaning no denomination. They have no government in the church, no overseer they preach and do as they like. A pastor can't be voted out. That is why we have denominations, so a pastor can be voted out if needs be, so the church is held accountable for what money is spent where, and people have a vote on what is and is not done in the church. Independents aren't like that. That's why so much foolishness and abuse happens in these churches, they are accountable to no one.
Click to expand...
that is a good point in fact there are many independent churches from both sides of the coin why? many of them can't live under the bylaws of that fellowship. They leave and start a new thing.


gay marriage
drinking
divorce and remarrying
unsubmissive to leadership
no accountability

Yet those who are non-denomination are really from a denomination. How do I know that? because Read the statement of faith they all mirror a denomination LOL.
 
I

Isaskar

Active member
#79
Nov 13, 2021
139
55
28
#79
SophieT said:
huh

didn't know about that one

do you have a reference?
Click to expand...
Here is one, from a Q&A he did.

He is also a staunch calvinist and very anti-spiritual gifts. Not good. Best to remain neutral than anti, at the very least.
 
S

SophieT

Guest
#80
#80
Aerials1978 said:
Can you pinpoint a time within the last 1,800 where the Apostolic ministry was and has been continuous beyond the original 13? Any of the early church fathers writtings on the matter?
Click to expand...
are you able to time travel and affirm this statement or deny it?

don't tell others to do what you could not do yourself

you are repeating what you are taught. these objections have been evidenced throughout this forum over and over

do you have an objection you achieved through your own study, or will you simply continue to parrot what your teachers tell you?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.