God Told Me

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
T

tanach

Guest
#1
Have you ever had a situation where you have something on your mind and have discussed it with another church member?
Their answer starts with God told me...... You think about the reply and come to the conclusion that the answer given is just the persons own opinion. Worse still is those who try to use this tact to change your way of thinking to suit themselves or to make them appear more 'spiritual' In extreme cases they become cult leaders. I am not saying that God doesn't use others
in this way but discernment is really important. Anyone have examples of how this type of thing has affected their lives for good or bad.
 
Jan 25, 2015
9,213
3,189
113
#2
You have to test everything to the word of God. God will never say something that contradicts His own word and therefore we have to know His word. :)
 
Last edited:

JimmieD

Senior Member
Apr 11, 2014
895
18
18
#3
Have you ever had a situation where you have something on your mind and have discussed it with another church member?
Their answer starts with God told me...... You think about the reply and come to the conclusion that the answer given is just the persons own opinion. Worse still is those who try to use this tact to change your way of thinking to suit themselves or to make them appear more 'spiritual' In extreme cases they become cult leaders. I am not saying that God doesn't use others
in this way but discernment is really important. Anyone have examples of how this type of thing has affected their lives for good or bad.
I've seen this happen. I think the person who says, "God told me ____" is under the obligation to demonstrate that God indeed told them. If they can't prove that God told you X, then nobody is under any obligation to believe them. "God told me" is usually a ridiculous tactic to get a person to do what you want; it's an excuse, as you pointed out, to push across their own views. Unfortunately, I think the person who says, "God told me ___" will often actually believe what they're saying without realizing that he really told them nothing and everything is coming from their own minds.
 
T

tanach

Guest
#4
JimmieD Yes I fully agree. In particular the point you made about some people actually believe that what they say comes from God but is really their own thoughts.
 

Dan58

Senior Member
Nov 13, 2013
1,991
338
83
#5

If someone is implying that God audibly told them something, their nuts.. But if they are just inferring that God spoke to them through his written word, or that they gained an understanding through the guidance of the Holy Spirit, then its understandable. I'd refrain from saying "God told me". There's a special place with padded walls for people who hear voices :)
 

Pilkington

Senior Member
Jan 13, 2015
640
99
28
#6
Yes I have experienced this. Basically I was overseas and someone I knew Mother was ill my collegue said God told her to tell me I should go and pray and lay hands on the person's mother and if I asked without doubting she would be healed. The person quoted James 1 [SUP]6 [/SUP]But when you ask, you must believe and not doubt, because the one who doubts is like a wave of the sea, blown and tossed by the wind. [SUP]7 [/SUP]That person should not expect to receive anything from the Lord. [SUP]8 [/SUP]Such a person is double-minded and unstable in all they do.

I prayed about it and didn't feel it was appropriate to go and lay hands on the person concerned. I told the person I would pray for his mother. God healed his mother but it wasn't anything to do with me.

I feel not only did the person use the God told me but also twisted scripture to support what she was saying and try and get me to do something she wanted.
 
T

tanach

Guest
#7
Pilkington Thanks for sharing your experience. I am glad that the person was healed, but your experience is a typical example.
 
T

tanach

Guest
#8
Dan58 I know what you mean, but often people don't explain how they got the information. I am yet to meet someone who heard an audible voice though!
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,782
2,951
113
#9
I can't count the number of times people have done this to me! The example that always stands out in my mind, is that a group of WoFers told me I was healed, and to confess it. I did confess, and believed for healing. It didn't come, which left me feeling depressed. I felt like I was shamed, because I didn't have "enough" faith. And they told me that over and over, because God had told them, and I was not receiving it!

I think it is arrogant to set yourself up as a prophet and tell people what to do. We have their own relationship with God, and he can speak to us, not through a mediator or third party.

It took me a long time and lot of pain to see that God is in control, and suffering is part of this life. About a week ago, an old friend told me I just needed to confess that the pain was gone, and it would be gone. I just cut him short and said I didn't want to listen to heresy. I wouldn't have done that a few years ago, because I thought he had an understanding of the Bible.
But he hangs around people who say "God told me."

I personally know God has spoken to me in an audible voice, and I was not crazy! Everything that God spoke came to pass. Nor was what God said for other people - only for me. God speaks to me every day in amazing ways. He comforts and cares for me. He guides and leads through the Holy Spirit. He chastizes and rebukes me. He forgives me, and always lets me know he is real.

I preached in our church on Sunday morning and I agonized over the sermon. It was a very difficult subject, and I didn't want to be controversial my first time preaching in this church. I prayed for months, and always got the same answer. That this was the topic and direction I was to go. I even tried to cut out a section, but I knew God's will was for me to say it, even though it was a long quote, and not from the Bible.

After the service, an elder got up and spoke. She had an announcement, and she was crying. Because the message which God gave me, was exactly the answer to prayer in her announcement, and I had opened the doors to healing, love and support.

If you are really following Christ, you will know his voice.

"My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me." John 10:27
 
Jan 25, 2015
9,213
3,189
113
#10

If someone is implying that God audibly told them something, their nuts.. But if they are just inferring that God spoke to them through his written word, or that they gained an understanding through the guidance of the Holy Spirit, then its understandable. I'd refrain from saying "God told me". There's a special place with padded walls for people who hear voices :)
What will you say to Moses when you meet him one day? :)
 

jb

Senior Member
Feb 27, 2010
4,940
591
113
#11
Have you ever had a situation where you have something on your mind and have discussed it with another church member?
Their answer starts with God told me...... You think about the reply and come to the conclusion that the answer given is just the persons own opinion. Worse still is those who try to use this tact to change your way of thinking to suit themselves or to make them appear more 'spiritual' In extreme cases they become cult leaders. I am not saying that God doesn't use others
in this way but discernment is really important. Anyone have examples of how this type of thing has affected their lives for good or bad.
Discernment is SO important in ALL matters (as you so rightly say)!

1Thess 5v21: "But test and prove all things [until you can recognize] what is good; [to that] hold fast." [AMP]

Yahweh Shalom
 
J

JesusistheChrist

Guest
#12

If someone is implying that God audibly told them something, their nuts.. But if they are just inferring that God spoke to them through his written word, or that they gained an understanding through the guidance of the Holy Spirit, then its understandable. I'd refrain from saying "God told me". There's a special place with padded walls for people who hear voices :)
Jesus said that His sheep hear His voice and that they will not follow the voice of a stranger. I can recall at least two times when I've heard the audible voice of God and they were both basically reproofs from the Lord. The first time, I was actually taking part in play practices at the church that I was then attending and God apparently wasn't too fond of the play. As I was driving home from practice one night, I heard the audible voice of God ask me, "How will this play glorify My Son, Jesus Christ?" My hands literally momentarily came off of the steering wheel and trembling I said, "What?" God then repeated the question audibly and when I arrived home, He proceeded to tell me what type of play He wanted and told me to speak to the Associate Pastor who was heading up the play the next day and to tell him what He had told me. I obeyed and it didn't go over well. Needless to say, I dropped out of the play and I didn't go to it either and it truly was an ungodly mess.

Anyhow, several people in the Bible heard the audible voice of God including Paul.
 
J

JesusistheChrist

Guest
#13
JimmieD Yes I fully agree. In particular the point you made about some people actually believe that what they say comes from God but is really their own thoughts.
...or something that they truly heard from another "god" (a demon).
 
J

JesusistheChrist

Guest
#14
Have you ever had a situation where you have something on your mind and have discussed it with another church member?
Their answer starts with God told me...... You think about the reply and come to the conclusion that the answer given is just the persons own opinion. Worse still is those who try to use this tact to change your way of thinking to suit themselves or to make them appear more 'spiritual' In extreme cases they become cult leaders. I am not saying that God doesn't use others
in this way but discernment is really important. Anyone have examples of how this type of thing has affected their lives for good or bad.
There are two people in my life, my wife and one of my sisters, who are infamously known to repeatedly say "God told me" or "God showed me" when what God allegedly told or showed them is contrary to scripture. Unfortunately, allegedly led by their God, the two of them conspired together a few years ago and they pressed totally false charges against me with the police and I actually had to defend myself in court. I won by a landslide and I literally could have had my wife arrested for what she did, but I chose not to.
 
O

oldthennew

Guest
#15
I can't count the number of times people have done this to me! The example that always stands out in my mind, is that a group of WoFers told me I was healed, and to confess it. I did confess, and believed for healing. It didn't come, which left me feeling depressed. I felt like I was shamed, because I didn't have "enough" faith. And they told me that over and over, because God had told them, and I was not receiving it!

I think it is arrogant to set yourself up as a prophet and tell people what to do. We have their own relationship with God, and he can speak to us, not through a mediator or third party.

It took me a long time and lot of pain to see that God is in control, and suffering is part of this life. About a week ago, an old friend told me I just needed to confess that the pain was gone, and it would be gone. I just cut him short and said I didn't want to listen to heresy. I wouldn't have done that a few years ago, because I thought he had an understanding of the Bible.
But he hangs around people who say "God told me."

I personally know God has spoken to me in an audible voice, and I was not crazy! Everything that God spoke came to pass. Nor was what God said for other people - only for me. God speaks to me every day in amazing ways. He comforts and cares for me. He guides and leads through the Holy Spirit. He chastizes and rebukes me. He forgives me, and always lets me know he is real.

I preached in our church on Sunday morning and I agonized over the sermon. It was a very difficult subject, and I didn't want to be controversial my first time preaching in this church. I prayed for months, and always got the same answer. That this was the topic and direction I was to go. I even tried to cut out a section, but I knew God's will was for me to say it, even though it was a long quote, and not from the Bible.

After the service, an elder got up and spoke. She had an announcement, and she was crying. Because the message which God gave me, was exactly the answer to prayer in her announcement, and I had opened the doors to healing, love and support.

If you are really following Christ, you will know his voice.

"My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me." John 10:27
================================================

Angela,

your witness was very moving, thank you for sharing...we love your total honesty about how you
balked before God for so long,,,this is like Moses, 'Oh Lord, I am slow of tongue and cannot speak',
You've picked the wrong guy....we have to laugh, because we can totally identify, we just can't
count the times that we have fallen short and doubted what our Father was telling/showing us..

one-on-one communication from our Lord is His precious way, but oh how mulish we can be
before we learn how to submit and trust....oh the times we have fretted and worried NEEDLESSLY,
only to be shown how His grace is manifested in the wonderful works of our lives...
this part of our learning and growing surely does take a-while, but He is always Faithful, and
will not ever forsake us, because He truly is our Best Friend.....

of course, at some point we come to realize that false teachers, preachers, and prophets abound,
for it is written, 'many shall come in My name saying I am Christ, (Jesus is Lord), and shall
deceive many.'

may we all keep on hearing and doing what our Saviour requires of us,
as it is written, Hear Oh Israel, the Lord our God is One.' and again, I and My Father are One.'
 
Last edited by a moderator:
S

shotgunner

Guest
#16

If someone is implying that God audibly told them something, their nuts.. But if they are just inferring that God spoke to them through his written word, or that they gained an understanding through the guidance of the Holy Spirit, then its understandable. I'd refrain from saying "God told me". There's a special place with padded walls for people who hear voices :)
Then I suppose I'm nuts, but I like it. I have had many conversations with God. Yes, he does speak through his written word but he also speaks straight into our hearts. From scripture, he also speaks so many hear, though I have never experienced that.

God has explained some things to me in prayer, He has also corrected me on some things in prayer. God has also given me specific direction and warned me about things concerning ministry. God absolutely will talk to you if you allow and desire him to.

As to the OP's situation, I have never had God tell me to say anything to another believer except scripture. I have had God nudge me concerning someone else to go and encourage them with certain scripture, even sometimes letting me know that they are going through a problem and need the encouragement.
 

Budman

Senior Member
Mar 9, 2014
4,153
1,998
113
#17
God told us everything we need to know in the Bible.


'nuff said.
 
S

shotgunner

Guest
#18
God told us everything we need to know in the Bible.


'nuff said.
On the surface I would agree, but God wants a much closer relationship with us. God wants to lead and guide us in everything we do through the ministry of the Holy Spirit. The Bible can't warn me not to get involved with a certain person, nor lead me to find the perfect wife. While the Bible is the first step to knowing God, it is not the end of God. Why even pray if the Bible tells us everything we need to know?
 

Budman

Senior Member
Mar 9, 2014
4,153
1,998
113
#19
On the surface I would agree, but God wants a much closer relationship with us. God wants to lead and guide us in everything we do through the ministry of the Holy Spirit. The Bible can't warn me not to get involved with a certain person, nor lead me to find the perfect wife. While the Bible is the first step to knowing God, it is not the end of God. Why even pray if the Bible tells us everything we need to know?
The Bible tells us not to hang with people of bad reputation, it also gives the attributes to look for in a wife. Prayer is part of our relationship with God, but as far as "information" goes, the Bible is sufficient.
 
T

tanach

Guest
#20
JesustheChrist That is aweful. It just goes to show where the Devil can take something of God and use it against believers. Thankfully we can rely on God to protect us.