Have you believed the false grace message?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
59,909
29,289
113
Yes, I have seen that we can often get to where we are not really believing what we are saying. Or that we are holding two opposing ideas in our mind as both being true and not seeing that we are doing this.

I agree that it is all through the power of the Spirit in us, through trusting, abiding. I even agree that it isn't complete perfection I'm aiming at. I am aiming at abiding more and more. But I do not agree with the idea that I can stop abiding and still claim a saved status. The very idea is preposterous to me and it feels like a mocking of God to me. I take to heart to take care that my heart does not become evil and unbelieving as with them in the desert, even though He saved them, because after He saved them, He became displeased with them because of their subsequent unbelief and refused to allow them to enter the rest He had prepared for them.
True, we can do nothing aside from Him. Does someone say we can? It seems to me that we are all relying on Him in our own ways, and yet there is this great divide where one faction is always claiming the others are not saved because they don't believe exactly as they do. In fact, the claim seems to be that they are doing of their own power, as if they maintain their salvation of themselves. I believe resting in Him, relying on Him, turning to Him, believing on Him, all is abiding in Him, being renewed by His Word, and allowing myself to acknowledge my absolute powerlessness without Him also. There are people who are religious but lost. I always wonder if those people who think they are saved but are not, realize that a personal relationship means they have encountered the living Lord.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
59,909
29,289
113
Sometimes I wonder if hitting my head against a brick wall is easier.
It does get frustrating to be pursued by people with their insights, not
recognising saying the same stuff 100 times means it is no longer an insight,
either it is true, and the person is not going to respond or it is simply wrong.

But it is worth it, because the claims made against normal simple believers
are so bad, quite a few believers I know would be devastated, literally by
such unwise language and extremes. I put this down to emotional immaturity,
and trying to find simple solutions to deep emotional trauma, and faith has
just got wrapped up in it.

What inspires me is the flip side, walking in power and authority, knowing
the Lords will and seeing how one can reach and help encourage His Kingdom.

Now I know of failure and struggle, people dying and often deep emotional trauma,
but not the opposite, revival, great moves of God, people burning in passion for Christ
and His word. And boy, would I love to see this and be a part of it. But this is Christs
promise, abide in the vine and you will be fruitful, Amen
Is this supposed to have anything to do with what I said?
 
W

wsblind

Guest
Thankyou for this uplifting affirmation of my love of Christ.
It warms my heart that you regard me is such a positive light as a brother
in Christ, walking as part of the family into the heavenlies.

God bless you, Ed.
Ed Is right Peter. We don't doubt your love. It's the fact that you doubt HIS love. If we are believers and our love wanes for Him................HIS NEVER does for His Children.

37But in all these things we overwhelmingly conquer through Him who loved us. 38For I am convinced that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor things present, nor things to come, nor powers, 39nor height, nor depth, nor any other created thing, will be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.


 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0

Yet it occurred to me recently, since they say if you are saved that you never sin
again

This particular belief is emotional suicide. You can just count the ticks on the bomb,
before it blows up or one becomes a hypocrite.

It is also a problem when you look at the apostles. They had their issues, but in a
loving relationship they can always be resolved. But both sides of the argument can
suffer from a hard heart.

I realised once, that no matter how well one has walked in the past, we can freeze up
and cease to be spiritually alive, and have a hard heart. There have been numerous preachers
who lead revivals, only years later to be convinced they were totally wrong etc.

For me it is why listening to the Spirit and being open to others no matter who they are is
very important. Without communion we are lost, that is an eternal reality.
 
Mar 2, 2016
8,896
113
0
It's a problem and a temptation and a thing common to all men. Can any one of us say we have never got a smug little dig in at someone in here who we became annoyed at or a bit offended in our pride at how they spoke to us? So it's okay to point it out, out of love, with as much respect as we can. But it's not okay to act like we haven't done it. It's by God showing us we have that we learn to have some bit of humility to not demand some perfection from them that even we don't have!
The thing is...I don't claim perfection.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
59,909
29,289
113
Thankyou for this uplifting affirmation of my love of Christ.
It warms my heart that you regard me is such a positive light as a brother
in Christ, walking as part of the family into the heavenlies.

God bless you, Ed.
It would be better if you were honest.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
I do realise this medium is very deceptive.

It is partly us just writing our own thoughts down, but then publishing them
without the filter of this is totally public.

So in a public setting, I would go, you cannot say that, but here it seems
like just writing a note or two.

And ones emotions always get the better of us, and suggest stuff we should
leave out. But by Gods grace I will get better, and He teaches and transforms
me through the sharing of others in His body, Amen.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
It would be better if you were honest.
lol. Not sure how people play honest here. Kick the idiot around, prod
poke, make fun, play the troll. And among this who is real? Who is the
player and who really cares? Such serious subjects, yet children with toys,
and punishment if you do not play their way.

So what is honesty and what is the lie?
 
Mar 2, 2016
8,896
113
0
lol. Not sure how people play honest here. Kick the idiot around, prod
poke, make fun, play the troll. And among this who is real? Who is the
player and who really cares? Such serious subjects, yet children with toys,
and punishment if you do not play their way.

So what is honesty and what is the lie?
a good start to honesty would be admitting your own frailty....but you'll just say glory be to God amen... I am perfection personified....in a round the barn kinda way of course.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
a good start to honesty would be admitting your own frailty....but you'll just say glory be to God amen... I am perfection personified....in a round the barn kinda way of course.
Sirk - I am nothing special, I am weak, in need, needing love and affection, openness
and encouragement like all people, and like a Child of God. I stay up late and sleep in
longer. I need a crisis to get me going, and like puzzles to solve, and risk to be taken.

I am nothing like perfection, I am just a redeemed man trying to follow my Lord and love
and serve people along the way.

And what is the biggest issue I have today. The future of one daughter to see her real
talents and the way it lights her soul, and have the courage to recognise how she needs
to explore where to go.

If I could see I would run away, if I knew the future I would make it not happen,
if I understood the trauma He will help me through, I would buckle now and give up,
but I know all I need to do is trust Him, because He is my strength and my song,
my hope in the night and my psalm in the morning. Amen.
 
Mar 2, 2016
8,896
113
0
Sirk - I am nothing special, I am weak, in need, needing love and affection, openness
and encouragement like all people, and like a Child of God. I stay up late and sleep in
longer. I need a crisis to get me going, and like puzzles to solve, and risk to be taken.

I am nothing like perfection, I am just a redeemed man trying to follow my Lord and love
and serve people along the way.

And what is the biggest issue I have today. The future of one daughter to see her real
talents and the way it lights her soul, and have the courage to recognise how she needs
to explore where to go.

If I could see I would run away, if I knew the future I would make it not happen,
if I understood the trauma He will help me through, I would buckle now and give up,
but I know all I need to do is trust Him, because He is my strength and my song,
my hope in the night and my psalm in the morning. Amen.
It's good to see an honest post like this. Humility is the willingness to be known as you are.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
Good night you lovely people.
May the Lord bless you tonight as He has blessed me today,
and may we rise in His love and blessing to face a new day tomorrow.
 

Bladerunner

Senior Member
Aug 22, 2016
3,076
59
48
Honestly EG. I don't believe we are required to do it. We should do it.

I am 15 years into being saved......And Am just starting to grasp it. And I KNOW I am saved and haven't lived up to that standard. And am pretty sure I will fail more than succeed for the rest of my life. Those are pretty high standards.

So this is where I am coming from. If we WILL do good works............I haven't been saved for the past 15 years Because I am just starting to figure out how to live the Christian way of life.
wsblind:;;...... Good works comes in many packages and are dictated by the Holy Spirit within you not by some authority who will tell you if you do not do this, you will go to hell.

Read my Signature,,and listen to the Holy Spirit within you very carefully my friend. You will do fine. Don't worry so much.
 
W

wsblind

Guest
wsblind:;;...... Good works comes in many packages and are dictated by the Holy Spirit within you not by some authority who will tell you if you do not do this, you will go to hell.

Read my Signature,,and listen to the Holy Spirit within you very carefully my friend. You will do fine. Don't worry so much.
Thanks Brother........And worry is a sin. Don't worry much these days. Thank God.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
59,909
29,289
113
lol. Not sure how people play honest here. Kick the idiot around, prod
poke, make fun, play the troll. And among this who is real? Who is the
player and who really cares? Such serious subjects, yet children with toys,
and punishment if you do not play their way.

So what is honesty and what is the lie?
It is telling that you do not know. Why pretend your post was honest? Ed did not compliment you, and yet your response was such that nobody would know this if they did not go back to see what Ed had actually said, which I did. Are you calling yourself an idiot? Or are you again insinuating someone said something they did not. Honesty, Peter. It will server you much better than whatever you are doing here.
 
W

wsblind

Guest
Sirk - I am nothing special, I am weak, in need, needing love and affection, openness
and encouragement like all people, and like a Child of God. I stay up late and sleep in
longer. I need a crisis to get me going, and like puzzles to solve, and risk to be taken.

I am nothing like perfection, I am just a redeemed man trying to follow my Lord and love
and serve people along the way.

And what is the biggest issue I have today. The future of one daughter to see her real
talents and the way it lights her soul, and have the courage to recognise how she needs
to explore where to go.

If I could see I would run away, if I knew the future I would make it not happen,
if I understood the trauma He will help me through, I would buckle now and give up,
but I know all I need to do is trust Him, because He is my strength and my song,
my hope in the night and my psalm in the morning. Amen.
We know quite a bit of the future. And we know Christ is going to make it Happen.....We ARE going to heaven and we WILL get glorified bodies. We CAN'T make that not happen if we Trusted Christ.

It's like your daughter, Even if she messes up and doesn't succeed, Dad is there no matter what.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
823
113
True, we can do nothing aside from Him. Does someone say we can? It seems to me that we are all relying on Him in our own ways, and yet there is this great divide where one faction is always claiming the others are not saved because they don't believe exactly as they do. In fact, the claim seems to be that they are doing of their own power, as if they maintain their salvation of themselves. I believe resting in Him, relying on Him, turning to Him, believing on Him, all is abiding in Him, being renewed by His Word, and allowing myself to acknowledge my absolute powerlessness without Him also. There are people who are religious but lost. I always wonder if those people who think they are saved but are not, realize that a personal relationship means they have encountered the living Lord.
Does someone say we can...? One of your previous posts was talking about the garbledness where some think they aren't relying on their own strength but they are, so...yeah, some say we can while simultaneously thinking they aren't doing it. But I don't count them unsaved. I think it's a phase a lot of us go through where we truly believe we're not relying on our own strength or working, toward holiness, but we really are, at least in some areas. It happened to me personally. I did it. And I KNOW how much the Spirit communed with me and how many consolations He gave me even during that. I was trying to help bring about my growth in holiness and I struggled long and hard in it. I suppose some may have said I had fallen from grace and was trying to earn my salvation, but I don't believe that's right. I think I just didn't understand that sanctification is ALSO by faith alone. It's like Abraham, trying to bring about the child of promise, but he wasn't thinking that would save him...so even Abraham got stuck in whatever it was I was stuck in for a time, in my opinion.

It would take a lot for me to really suspect in my mind that all religious people are lost. I don't want to be the one who decides they're unsaved. I'm afraid to pronounce that about someone. They could very well have received His Spirit but are trying to bring about their own sanctification by hard work and trying rather than by abiding. And combined with very little growth as yet in humility, I just can't make that pronouncement. They might look pretty awful and messed up to me but just be new or be stuck a little but having trusted and believed and received the Spirit. And I'm even MORE adamant that I'm not going to make that pronouncement because they have what I believe is some error of thinking or doctrine. I'm going to talk with them, but I'm not going to dare toss around pronouncements of unsaved when I can't see their heart. I'm going to keep looking for improvement and rejoice when I see it!
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
823
113
The thing is...I don't claim perfection.
At the very least, we think we are humbler than we really are. It's one of our struggles.
Just because a man has some lack of humility in some area or from time to time, or even a lot of the time, it doesn't mean he lacks even a speck of humility. Gods' usually working on Him. :)
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
823
113
I spent nearly all day here. I'm not one bit sorry. I enjoy talking with you guys and you're a great blessing to me!
I have to go nighty-night. :)
 
W

wsblind

Guest
At the very least, we think we are humbler than we really are. It's one of our struggles.
Just because a man has some lack of humility in some area or from time to time, or even a lot of the time, it doesn't mean he lacks even a speck of humility. Gods' usually working on Him. :)
I agree. And always remember that there are tares in the wheat. People acting humble and they are not. People acting saved and they are not. And God is NOT working on them.

And I am absolutely NOT saying anyone here is a tare. Just don't forget that this will happen. They will look like wheat, but inwardly........