Not By Works

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
P

PHart

Guest
These are done through the power of Holy Spirit. Only.

One can do good deeds by His leading, true. But, too many are spinning their wheels by not waiting on the Lord for instruction. Go by what they think is His will. I see it all the time, and it's not lasting.
And so this instantly and categorically and without exception means that person is trying to earn their salvation?????

That's absurd.

At the very worst it is as you (almost) say.....that person is simply seeking to be obedient without aid of the Holy Spirit. Seeking to be obedient is NOT the definition of the works gospel. You know this, right?
 

TruthTalk

Senior Member
Jul 17, 2017
2,904
2,262
113
Hi TruthTalk...I have to be honest but i am not that far in my knowledge that i can say i understand your post...My post was to Frans post about what Joh 28-29 meant when one read it, so i read it and gave my opinion on what it means to me, oh i have so much to learn and i am loving it :D...xox...
Hi again Rosemaryx, I understand, grow in the wonderful grace of Jesus, He said, "Learn from Me, for I am gentle and humble of heart. Matthew11:29." God bless! :)
 

Stunnedbygrace

Senior Member
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
Yes. Why do you suppose?
Consensus is not as important as walking in love in the Spirit. (I know you know that :))
James could answer Chris1975's question - in fact he did in chapter 4!
The trick is for each person to see their part in it when they read James - even if their part was more subtle. It was probably more subtle in the first place because of the Spirits gentling influence, and having received that, more is expected of them.
Blessed are the peacemakers.
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
Loved reading your post SOF :)...I don`t know much about the Sabbath from the OT but i do know what it means in the NT...I was mentally sick for many years, and once i was saved, i rested in my Lord everyday...I was to sick to go out in the world, i found it very hard to be around people, i was a total hermit, the only people i saw were my children and psychiatrist...After i remained in bed for a year, apart from getting up to the things we do, i fell into my new Bible and got drenched in the Word of God...From that year in bed i cried to Him daily, He taught me what it meant to be saved, He told me how much He loved me, He gave me His promises that He would heal me, today i still do many things from my bed but i am alive, He gave every day to me as His day of rest, and through that rest He built me up in His strength, He has not told me in anyway that i must choice a day, He has told me that He alone is my rest untill the day He calls me home \o/...xox...
Loved reading your testimony Rosemary. We need more of this on this site. Might unify us if we did.
 

Rosemaryx

Senior Member
May 3, 2017
3,727
4,083
113
62
Hi again Rosemaryx, I understand, grow in the wonderful grace of Jesus, He said, "Learn from Me, for I am gentle and humble of heart. Matthew11:29." God bless! :)
Love that Scripture :)...Thank you TruthTalk...That Scripture is so beautiful to me right now and you posted it at the right time...Jesus has taught me so much, and now that i am secure in knowing i am saved He is moving me on to other things :)...I went through a stage for a good few months wondering if i was saved or not, i now know that it was the evil one putting doubts in to my mind, but through the Holy Spirit leading me He put them doubts out of my mind for good, praise the Lord \o/...Coming into this thread got me shaky for a while LOL, but not so much now, one again thanks for the Scripture...xox...
 

AllenW

Senior Member
Apr 20, 2016
1,450
70
48
INTERMISSION


[video=youtube;SHYgjyGoV9s]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHYgjyGoV9s[/video]
 

Stunnedbygrace

Senior Member
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
Did you think I said adam and eve birthed a spirit Stunned? Not sure how you saw that.

God gives breath. Breath is pneuma. Wind. Holy Spirit is likened to wind. With Rosemarys post I wasn't saying that we are born with Holy Spirit. We have a spirit. And it's compared to an egg in scripture and seed of the children of God are born again...the seed is said in greek to be sperma.

Likened to the act of conception. We need to be awakened in our spirit and that is only by the new birth. It's seen in psalms and in Song of Solomon. Also in the prophets but I can't tell you right now which one. Someday I am going to go off the boards and write these things out. Need the go from above, but my husband is prodding me to do it now.

So if you see me gone...you will know why.
Oh...yes, I believe we all misunderstood you. We thought you were saying men are born with Gods' Spirit in them. I have never heard anyone call the act of respiration/breath to be spirit. All born things have respiration. They get it from their parents. Men, deer, rabbits, bears, etc. Although some living things breath through their skin instead of lungs come to think of it...:)

Sorry for misunderstanding what you meant to say. :) I read your response to the young woman and misunderstood and thought you were agreeing with her. (Although it looked to be more of a..."I think you may have something here" response than a "dogma" response.) And since she was saying she heard babies were born with the Holy Spirit, it snowballed from there.

I have often said dumb things and then realized those dumb things weren't based on scripture but rather on something that sounded appealing. When I recall one of them I'll post it because I've had some real doozies! I'll rack my brain to remember because I'm sure I could make you laugh real hard!! :D
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
That's what I've been saying. These sanctified people are now in outright unbelief, not the struggles of living the faith.



Sanctification in Christ perfects you in Christ one time for all time. You don't have to keep going back to fix your relationship with God with recurring sacrifices like you had to in the first covenant. You are made perfect by a single sacrifice, so keep believing in that one sacrifice that does that for you. Don't lose what it does for you by not believing in it anymore.



Yes, only people who keep believing are saved. The author is saying, you Hebrews have that salvation, don't go back to unbelief and lose that salvation. Only believing people have and keep salvation.

By the way, notice how this shows beyond a shadow of a doubt that this group is saved. And yet the author still warns them about what will happen if they shrink back in unbelief.



No, you did not consider the context. You blatantly ignored the plain simple text which plainly says what the usage of 'sanctified' is in this passage and instead are clinging to weak and vague interpretations of other context that directly contradicts the straightforward and plain text.

I see this repeatedly in OSAS arguments. I call them the 'not really' doctrines of OSAS--the plain words 'don't really' mean what they say, and instead there are these esoteric real meanings that you have to be taught in order to get the real meaning of a passage. OSAS is easily the most dishonest doctrine I have ever encountered in the church. Hands down. It's a spirit at work in the church. It's source is a lying spirit of deceit tickling the ears of a church who are too afraid to accept the truth that they can lose their salvation if they stop believing, made all the more fearful by the completely stupid teaching that if you think you have to continue to believe to stay saved you are working to keep yourself saved. What a joke.



Correct, born again Christians will never be cast into hell. FORMER born again Christians will be turned into hell if they stop believing and God turns them over to that unbelief. It's important to understand the argument correctly.

Jesus spoke of these who believe in Him but who stumble so as to go to the eternal fire in Matthew 18:6-9. It's been amazing to me to see people repeatedly not be able to see the text when I post it on line. The OSAS doctrine--a doctrine of demons--is so powerful they literally can not see Jesus' warning to people who believe in Him to get rid of those who cause them to stumble so they won't go to the eternal fire.



It's amazing that you STILL do not even understand the argument. You only 'save' yourself in the same way you got saved to begin with--by BELIEVING. That's not the damnable works gospel. If it is, then you and I were saved by our damnable works the moment our believing started.


Besides caring about people going to hell, I'm looking for my reward in the life to come of every person who hears what I'm saying and turns from their OSAS comfort zone in repentance and believes to the very end and is saved. We are so far removed from what the Bible actually teaches you probably have no idea what I'm talking about in this regard. I don't make this stuff up. I simply read my Bible for myself and do not read it through the lens of the popular doctrines of the church. It's amazing how far off from what the Bible actually says that the church is at this present time in history. Simply amazing.

The ironic thing is, it took a fallen believer (who had the genuine gift of tongues, by the way, showing they were really saved) to tell me in a Biblical discussion we were having, "so the Bible doesn't really mean what it says" to make me see how completely stupid and unreasonable I and the church have been regarding our ridiculous esoteric interpretations of scripture.



Stay in the faith and you are forever perfected and preserved. What's so hard for people to accept about that????

You probably can't even grasp that alternate understanding of being perfected forever in Christ, let alone accept it. That's how bad this present indoctrination is gripping the church today. Christians can not even see any other way to think about doctrines outside of their own pre-programmed dogmas.

I bet you can not understand how it's possible that you can be perfect forever as long as you continue to possess what it is that makes you forever perfect. It's analogous to being forever rich because you're holding the winning lotto ticket while you wait to redeem it. Even if you and others do see the truth in that you'll still choose to turn away from it. That's the truly scary part.

This problem all stems from the church's profound ignorance of Paul's law vs. grace argument. Somehow it's been gleaned from Romans that salvation is by 'nothing at all', therefore, if you think it incumbent on you to have to continue to believe to the very end then you are trying to earn your own salvation. How ridiculous. But that demonstrates the profound ignorance gripping the church and which the enemy is using against us to destroy us.
If one is just mentally assenting to the gospel, and has not actually had the Spirit of Christ pierce the darkness within, and bring light of understanding...and thinks that OSAS means this, I would agree that their interpretation of this is erroneous.

But, one who has believe into the gospel...has had light penetrating spirit...been taken out of the kingdom of darkness into His Kingdom...and is trusting in the promises of Jesus who says they are yes and amen...are safe. Will continue in safety and will always be safe. In en...the fixed position. So OSAS is truth here.

And it's the work...again...of Holy Spirit given to us. So all our crowns are given as reward but we will be throw them at His feet because we know...it's of Him that we are saved.

That is my definition of this. What Calvin says doesn't matter...I don't study the men...Just the scripture.
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
And so this instantly and categorically and without exception means that person is trying to earn their salvation?????

That's absurd.

At the very worst it is as you (almost) say.....that person is simply seeking to be obedient without aid of the Holy Spirit. Seeking to be obedient is NOT the definition of the works gospel. You know this, right?
Just speaking of what works Jesus spoke of Phart.

Point being to wait on the Lord before self appointing. And it can be self works that one thinks they are doing unto the Lord.

Just read a book by John Bevere about this very thing.
 
P

PHart

Guest
But, one who has believe into the gospel...has had light penetrating spirit...been taken out of the kingdom of darkness into His Kingdom...and is trusting in the promises of Jesus who says they are yes and amen...are safe. Will continue in safety and will always be safe. In en...the fixed position. So OSAS is truth here.
Then why does the Bible warn believers to keep believing in order to be saved?

You must be of the thinking that genuinely believing/saved people can never stop believing and, therefore, can never stop being saved.
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
Oh...yes, I believe we all misunderstood you. We thought you were saying men are born with Gods' Spirit in them. I have never heard anyone call the act of respiration/breath to be spirit. All born things have respiration. They get it from their parents. Men, deer, rabbits, bears, etc. Although some living things breath through their skin instead of lungs come to think of it...:)

Sorry for misunderstanding what you meant to say. :) I read your response to the young woman and misunderstood and thought you were agreeing with her. (Although it looked to be more of a..."I think you may have something here" response than a "dogma" response.) And since she was saying she heard babies were born with the Holy Spirit, it snowballed from there.

I have often said dumb things and then realized those dumb things weren't based on scripture but rather on something that sounded appealing. When I recall one of them I'll post it because I've had some real doozies! I'll rack my brain to remember because I'm sure I could make you laugh real hard!! :D
I have done the same thing. Still do as a matter of fact. Sometimes I don't read the posts carefully enough.

I'd rather post than live chat. That way I can delete stupidity when I catch it. lol

You have a beautiful inside stunned. Always have had and has never changed.
 
P

PHart

Guest
Just speaking of what works Jesus spoke of Phart.

Point being to wait on the Lord before self appointing. And it can be self works that one thinks they are doing unto the Lord.

Just read a book by John Bevere about this very thing.
You didn't really answer my question.
Are you saying that what you said has nothing to do with trying to earn one's own salvation?
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
Then why does the Bible warn believers to keep believing in order to be saved?

You must be of the thinking that genuinely believing/saved people can never stop believing and, therefore, can never stop being saved.
I can't see how one who has known the Lord would ever turn...truly known. He's too good to turn away from

One can backslide for a time even though backsliding is OT term. Slide back into sinful habits. But, can never be happy for chastening by the Word will be always in mind.

The reason why we stay in faith and examine our faith is that we remain in a place where we can receive from God. I've said this before several times. Faith is substance in the spiritual realm. It has power. And it moves God.

A double minded person...going back and forth...receives not the promises. So stay in faith...check self that we aren't being lied to by the enemy in some way.
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
You didn't really answer my question.
Are you saying that what you said has nothing to do with trying to earn one's own salvation?
I am saying that our salvation is completely dependent on the works of God through Holy Spirit in our life.

We cooperate by placing our faith in Him. That is how the gifts work. And the giftings are the works.

The church has stepped away from the setup of Paul.
 

Jackson123

Senior Member
Feb 6, 2014
11,769
1,370
113
If one is just mentally assenting to the gospel, and has not actually had the Spirit of Christ pierce the darkness within, and bring light of understanding...and thinks that OSAS means this, I would agree that their interpretation of this is erroneous.

But, one who has believe into the gospel...has had light penetrating spirit...been taken out of the kingdom of darkness into His Kingdom...and is trusting in the promises of Jesus who says they are yes and amen...are safe. Will continue in safety and will always be safe. In en...the fixed position. So OSAS is truth here.

And it's the work...again...of Holy Spirit given to us. So all our crowns are given as reward but we will be throw them at His feet because we know...it's of Him that we are saved.

That is my definition of this. What Calvin says doesn't matter...I don't study the men...Just the scripture.
as long AS people alive, there is posibillity of change, from believe to unbelieve or Vice versa.

Peter, Said he Will not Deny Jesus, he Deny, and back to the Lord.

[h=1]Matthew 24:13King James Version (KJV)[/h]13 But he that shall endure unto the end, the same shall be saved.
 
P

PHart

Guest
The reason why we stay in faith and examine our faith is that we remain in a place where we can receive from God.
"....remain in a place where we can receive from God."

Including salvation, right?
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
as long AS people alive, there is posibillity of change, from believe to unbelieve or Vice versa.

Peter, Said he Will not Deny Jesus, he Deny, and back to the Lord.

Matthew 24:13King James Version (KJV)

13 But he that shall endure unto the end, the same shall be saved.
Peter denied Jesus before conversion and then receiving Holy Spirit. Afterwards? He and the others turned the world upside down with the gospel. Remember reading this?
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
"....remain in a place where we can receive from God."

Including salvation, right?[/QUOTE)

Salvation is daily. Always today. Today is the day. We have died with Jesus and been resurrected with Him. Now we sit in the heavenlies with Him in His victory. Have said this so many times.

Where are you Phart? Have you sat down with Him? Walking in Spirit then? And standing for the victories in your own life by the overcoming blood and the testimony of Jesus?