Not only are we not under the law, we should not try to abide by it.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
J

jaybird88

Guest
U must understand what is the flesh, something that is in all of Adam's descendants. The law stirs flesh into sin, this is true before and after you are a Christian.

Jesus was born of a virgin, from God himself, he did not have the flesh. Thus he is the only one that can keep the entire law.
so if Jesus was like us could He have kept them?
 
J

jaybird88

Guest
So Jesus was not tempted like you and me, He had a huge advantage and if this is true i have no respect for Jesus as my brother.
His brother James said He was tempted exactly like you and me.
 
Jan 12, 2019
7,497
1,399
113
I believe Jesus was born like you and me, but did not ever choose to sin. A nature like me and you but overcame in every way so He was without fault.
Well, the NT Greek, whenever they talk about sin, its almost always a noun and not a verb. There are only very few occasions when the word sin is a verb, when Paul said "Shall we sin more so that grace may increase" Romans 6:1

Sin is a noun as in "sinful nature", so when the Greek in the NT stated that Jesus did not sin, the sin is not referring to actions but his nature. He had no flesh in him that sin could get a grip on.

My view is that it is "impossible" for him to sin. When he was tempted by Satan at the wilderness, its for Satan to know for sure that Jesus is pure gold, Satan's temptation will not work on him.

It may be a difficult view for people to accept at first, personally, whether you believe either way, it does not matter, its not key for salvation. :)
 

TMS

Senior Member
Mar 21, 2015
3,921
1,254
113
Australia
Well, the NT Greek, whenever they talk about sin, its almost always a noun and not a verb. There are only very few occasions when the word sin is a verb, when Paul said "Shall we sin more so that grace may increase" Romans 6:1

Sin is a noun as in "sinful nature", so when the Greek in the NT stated that Jesus did not sin, the sin is not referring to actions but his nature. He had no flesh in him that sin could get a grip on.

My view is that it is "impossible" for him to sin. When he was tempted by Satan at the wilderness, its for Satan to know for sure that Jesus is pure gold, Satan's temptation will not work on him.

It may be a difficult view for people to accept at first, personally, whether you believe either way, it does not matter, its not key for salvation. :)
The nature of Christ a can of worms.
I believe sin is a choice because God is not just if we are guilty of sin condemned to death without us choosing.
Adam sinned and we have all inherited the tendency to sin but we are not guilty when we have not chosen to sin.
The Guilt of Adam is not passed on to His Children.
I believe in a just God.
 

TMS

Senior Member
Mar 21, 2015
3,921
1,254
113
Australia
Can you have a sinful nature and not be guilty of SIN?
 

TMS

Senior Member
Mar 21, 2015
3,921
1,254
113
Australia
When we are forgiven of our sins, when we are justified and freed from the Guilt of all sin because of faith in Jesus, do we still have a sinful nature, at that point.
 
Jan 12, 2019
7,497
1,399
113
The nature of Christ a can of worms.
I believe sin is a choice because God is not just if we are guilty of sin condemned to death without us choosing.
Adam sinned and we have all inherited the tendency to sin but we are not guilty when we have not chosen to sin.
The Guilt of Adam is not passed on to His Children.
I believe in a just God.
Romans 5:12-19 will answer your point. Adam was our federal head, when he sinned thru disobedience, all of us sin "in him".

Only when you understand that, then you can understand how we are also righteous, apart from works. We are righteous because of Jesus's obedience.
 
Jan 12, 2019
7,497
1,399
113
When we are forgiven of our sins, when we are justified and freed from the Guilt of all sin because of faith in Jesus, do we still have a sinful nature, at that point.
Our spirit is free from the sinful nature, but its still in our body. We will only be rid of it at the rapture.
 

Lafftur

Senior Member
Apr 18, 2017
6,889
3,633
113
When we are forgiven of our sins, when we are justified and freed from the Guilt of all sin because of faith in Jesus, do we still have a sinful nature, at that point.
Faith works by LOVE. Those that love God put their faith in Him and God knows those that love Him.

Christ has given us authority over sin. Never are we “captive” to it. However, if we choose to walk according to our flesh, we will sin, but never be “captive.” We always have the power to say, “No.”

There are consequences. The sword never departed from King David’s house and God did not remove His Spirit from King David.
 

TMS

Senior Member
Mar 21, 2015
3,921
1,254
113
Australia
The doctrine of original sin.
Beginning with the valid biblical position of man's inherent carnal nature, which predisposes him to sin, the idea gradually evolved that Adam's guilt was also imputed to his descendants. Augustine was responsible more than any other for propagating this view of transmitted guilt. Through Luther and the reformers it found its way into many of the Protestant churches.
 

TMS

Senior Member
Mar 21, 2015
3,921
1,254
113
Australia
I think you are making it more complicated than it needs to be.
Sin = Guilt. choosing to Sin means we are guilty.
A sinful nature = inclination to sin, a selfish desire, selfishness, flesh, carnal nature.

We are all born with a sinful nature because of what Adam did and we all sin as a result.
 

Adam4Eve

Active member
Nov 26, 2018
179
42
28
I think you are making it more complicated than it needs to be.
Sin = Guilt. choosing to Sin means we are guilty.
A sinful nature = inclination to sin, a selfish desire, selfishness, flesh, carnal nature.

We are all born with a sinful nature because of what Adam did and we all sin as a result.
Don't mean for this to come across in the wrong way, but it's tiresome when somebody makes several posts and you have to wade through each of them individually.

It's much more helpful if the person decides what they want to say and puts it all in one post.

🙂
 

TMS

Senior Member
Mar 21, 2015
3,921
1,254
113
Australia
Our spirit is free from the sinful nature, but its still in our body. We will only be rid of it at the rapture.
When we crucify the flesh (evil nature) and walk in the Spirit, (which is a continual battle) we will not choose to sin. The spirit in us is the only force and way to overcome the flesh, which comes by faith.
 

Lafftur

Senior Member
Apr 18, 2017
6,889
3,633
113
When we crucify the flesh (evil nature) and walk in the Spirit, (which is a continual battle) we will not choose to sin. The spirit in us is the only force and way to overcome the flesh, which comes by faith.
In God’s domain, NOTHING is a battle. It’s all about AUTHORITY. Who is The Most High? He is the One with the most authority.

In Christ, we are born again of incorruptible seed and given authority over our sinful nature and this world.

Therefore, we are NEVER taken as captives to sin, but we have a choice to walk according to our flesh or the spirit.

If we choose the flesh, we will sin.

If we choose the spirit, we will not sin.

It’s not about “natures” anymore. We’re back in the garden - it’s about “choices”..........again!!!
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
Macabeus and Adam4Eve are correct. The question is, if Jesus fulfilled all of of the Law, then what is our role? It can't be that it's enough to just accept Jesus into your heart and confess him as Lord. Surely repenting and turning your thoughts and actions toward loving thoughts and actions are required to go to heaven.

I can't really accept that salvation is a one and done kind of thing, where you just accept Jesus and you're safe forever. Why else would Jesus tell the churches to return to their first love in Revelation?
We are to be led by and walk In the Spirit. The Spirit of Christ will never lead you to sin. Also, don’t miss the part where I said God writes His Law I’m our hearts. God cleanses the inside, so that both the inside and outside are clean.

What is our part abide in Jesus and walk in the Spirit. But only God can regenerate us, preserve us, and only He can begin and perfect the work in us
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
When we crucify the flesh (evil nature) and walk in the Spirit, (which is a continual battle) we will not choose to sin. The spirit in us is the only force and way to overcome the flesh, which comes by faith.
Yes, and crucifying the flesh is accomplished by denying its fleshly lusts and following the promptings of the Spirit instead
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
the law is a curse, did Jesus get cursed for obeying it?
You demonstrate that you don’t even try to hear what others are saying. The Law is a curse to people who are under it and don’t fulfill it to perfection. Jesus was born under the Law but fulfilled it to perfection,therefore why would you ask if it is a curse to Him?

You put yourself under the Law so you are obligated to do everything in it perfectly and completely, or you place yourself under a curse

WE HAVE been crucified with Jesus who is our substitute, taking the curse of the broken law on Himself. Our curse. This is precisely why Jesus came to fulfill the Law, to redeem us from its curse. He was and is the only one who could accomplish this
 
J

jaybird88

Guest
You demonstrate that you don’t even try to hear what others are saying. The Law is a curse to people who are under it and don’t fulfill it to perfection. Jesus was born under the Law but fulfilled it to perfection,therefore why would you ask if it is a curse to Him?

You put yourself under the Law so you are obligated to do everything in it perfectly and completely, or you place yourself under a curse

WE HAVE been crucified with Jesus who is our substitute, taking the curse of the broken law on Himself. Our curse. This is precisely why Jesus came to fulfill the Law, to redeem us from its curse. He was and is the only one who could accomplish this
so now its only a curse is its not done perfect. not what you said before.
Jesus commanded we love the Father and man, if we dont love them perfect, then what? see the problems this "you must do it perfect" causes.
the Father forgives sins, and has always forgiven. the curse comes from turning from the law and never turning back.