I can't vote because of the use of the word "Secret".
I do believe it is probably referring to the rapture but nothing secret about it. They will rise visibly into the air and just like vultures that circle in one spot in the sky they will all be gathered to that spot which is the meeting of Christ in the air.
People will see them rise until they are no longer visible like Jesus ascension.
I also believe that they will be transfigured and partake of the same visible light glorification as seen upon Jesus on the mount of transfiguration. I believe this because Dan 12 says they will shine as bright as the firmament and like the stars, and also because Peter and Paul both hint at such a glorification in the saints when that even occurs.
There are several scriptures that suggest that we will shine with visible glory when we are changed and rise and absolutely none that say we will disappear from view the moment we are changed. To rise into the clouds is something one would describe from the perspective of viewing the event from below and therefore cannot be a SECRET vanishing where the rising to the clouds is no longer a description.
So my vote would be "Visible Rapture" not Secret.
The question that the disciples asked Jesus "Where Lord" and his answer was not to hell, or to the Lake of Fire, but to the clouds like when vultures gather in one point in the sky because they have found a body.
They understood that those left were those who would suffer the judgments to be poured out on the earth but they wanted to know where the ones who were taken to be saved from it were going. Jesus only gives them a partial answer. They will meet the Lord in the air.
Some think that taken as in the flood of Noah is the interpretation. If so why did the disciples ask "where Lord" if they knew that they would be taken in sudden destruction they would not really care about where, since they were destroyed like the flood. They understood that those taken had an continuation and a destiny and they wanted to know where? They did not ask about the ones left behind and if they had included themselves with the ones being left behind as the saved they would have asked about them, but they were not concerned with those left behind they saw themselves in the ones taken and wanted to know WHERE.
The other reason I believe this is that the Flood of Noah was sudden and final. The judgments at the end are a series of judgments that all contribute to dispossesing the earth of its unlawful inhabitants by the goel near kinsman redeemer Jesus, the Lamb worthy to open the seals of the title deed of planet earth and all those judgments that ensue as each seal, bowl, trumpet etc is released are in a series and not a one day event. There is no One day judgment that wipes out everyone like the flood. It is a series of judgments. How could one be taken in one judgment and the other left as a one day event when that is not how the end time judgments occur. To make the one taken as the one judged would have to be reconciled with the many outpourings of judgments.
What, would one be taken with poisoned waters (1/3 of man) on one day and others left. On another day would one be killed by famine and another left, on another day would one be killed by a 50-100 lb hail stone and another left? There is no One day judgment that would take all away and leave only the saved.
There is no one day flood, or one day judgement that compares with the flood. The creation of the new earth is after the final judgment so that will not work either.
Therefore the comparison with the flood must be the same as when he talked about people marrying and eating and drinking, that day will catch them unaware and the rapture will be the first of the events which will be followed by the series of judgments that will come upon those left behind.
I do believe it is probably referring to the rapture but nothing secret about it. They will rise visibly into the air and just like vultures that circle in one spot in the sky they will all be gathered to that spot which is the meeting of Christ in the air.
People will see them rise until they are no longer visible like Jesus ascension.
I also believe that they will be transfigured and partake of the same visible light glorification as seen upon Jesus on the mount of transfiguration. I believe this because Dan 12 says they will shine as bright as the firmament and like the stars, and also because Peter and Paul both hint at such a glorification in the saints when that even occurs.
There are several scriptures that suggest that we will shine with visible glory when we are changed and rise and absolutely none that say we will disappear from view the moment we are changed. To rise into the clouds is something one would describe from the perspective of viewing the event from below and therefore cannot be a SECRET vanishing where the rising to the clouds is no longer a description.
So my vote would be "Visible Rapture" not Secret.
The question that the disciples asked Jesus "Where Lord" and his answer was not to hell, or to the Lake of Fire, but to the clouds like when vultures gather in one point in the sky because they have found a body.
They understood that those left were those who would suffer the judgments to be poured out on the earth but they wanted to know where the ones who were taken to be saved from it were going. Jesus only gives them a partial answer. They will meet the Lord in the air.
Some think that taken as in the flood of Noah is the interpretation. If so why did the disciples ask "where Lord" if they knew that they would be taken in sudden destruction they would not really care about where, since they were destroyed like the flood. They understood that those taken had an continuation and a destiny and they wanted to know where? They did not ask about the ones left behind and if they had included themselves with the ones being left behind as the saved they would have asked about them, but they were not concerned with those left behind they saw themselves in the ones taken and wanted to know WHERE.
The other reason I believe this is that the Flood of Noah was sudden and final. The judgments at the end are a series of judgments that all contribute to dispossesing the earth of its unlawful inhabitants by the goel near kinsman redeemer Jesus, the Lamb worthy to open the seals of the title deed of planet earth and all those judgments that ensue as each seal, bowl, trumpet etc is released are in a series and not a one day event. There is no One day judgment that wipes out everyone like the flood. It is a series of judgments. How could one be taken in one judgment and the other left as a one day event when that is not how the end time judgments occur. To make the one taken as the one judged would have to be reconciled with the many outpourings of judgments.
What, would one be taken with poisoned waters (1/3 of man) on one day and others left. On another day would one be killed by famine and another left, on another day would one be killed by a 50-100 lb hail stone and another left? There is no One day judgment that would take all away and leave only the saved.
There is no one day flood, or one day judgement that compares with the flood. The creation of the new earth is after the final judgment so that will not work either.
Therefore the comparison with the flood must be the same as when he talked about people marrying and eating and drinking, that day will catch them unaware and the rapture will be the first of the events which will be followed by the series of judgments that will come upon those left behind.