Hello, I just wanted to chime in and say, it really does not matter how we word salvation by faith/works.
Basically it the same thing.
1. If the saved WILL do works because they are saved, then it is by works (obedience) salvation is qualified.
So if by works faith can be determined dead or alive, then works play an essential part in our salvation.
If your saying a believer with TRUE faith, will do works, because he is saved, then you are saying, if a believer does NOT have works, his faith is dead, and is not saved. therefore you're saying we MUST have works. Saying "will have works" doesn't change the fact we MUST have them in order to have true faith which is salvation.
Great passages. They were DEAD but repented (an obedient work that MUST be done) and now they are alive.
God's grace allowed this because He died for us when we did not deserve it, making it possible for us to obey this commands and be washed of sin.
Yes, and as you said, he WILL have good works, if not he does not have Eternal life, so his faith is qualified by obedience, therfore it is absoulutly essential to this believer's salvation.
Of course, it is Grace, not of works, no one was so great and pure God sent his son, no one can boast. It is purely undeserved grace, a gift, this does not imply that obedience has nothing to do with grace.
Disobedience cause our grace to be "in vain".:
2 Cor 6:1 We then, as workers together with him, beseech you also that ye receive not the grace of God in vain
Paul is telling this to the Corintian church, believers, Christians. Warning them not receive the grace of God in vain.
This would once again be disobedience. Heb 10:25-27, willful sin leads to the sacrifice Christ made of no effect upon the believer.
Gal 5 "..Christ has become of no effect ye have fallen from Grace"
What does it matter if we say, "I must obey to obtain salvation" or "I will obey because im saved"?
The outcome and necessity for obedience is the same in each statement. Either we obey and are saved, or we do not obey and were not saved, bottom line we must obey.
Saying it either way produces the same outcome.
Anyone who thinks obeience is not essential is fooling themselves. It's not putting trust in yourself to obey what God has told us. It's putting trust in God to know we must do what he told us.
Luke 17:10 10 So likewise ye, when ye shall have done all those things which are commanded you, say, We are unprofitable servants: we have done that which was our duty to do
After we have obeyed what is commanded, we say we are still unprofitable servants which only have done our duty.
That is the humility in obeience. It is prideful to think it is not a MUST to keep our "duty".
It is silly to say Jesus said "you will keep" and that does not mean we "must keep". It's the same meaning either way you say it. if he is telling me in order to love Him I will keep his commands, then I must keep his commands in order to love him.
If you cant see that, then try using implication.
If one will keep his commands if they love Him? the one who does NOT keep his commands does not love him.
Thereforeone MUST keep his commands. Seriously? This is simple logic that does not even need to be explained.
Yes "must keep" because a saved person "will keep". Otherwise not saved. So either way you put it, even you believe it's a must obviously if it shows saved or unsaved.
Because in the way you're saying it, you're not staying true to the word used here in this passage.
The word "keep"
from teros (a watch; perh. akin to G-2334); to guard (from loss or injury, prop. by keeping the eye upon; and thus differing from G-5442, which is prop. to prevent escaping; and from G-2892, which implies a fortress or full military lines of apparatus), i.e. to note (a prophecy; fig. to fulfil a command); by impl. to detai
Also this word is in IMPERATIVE form. Which mean "you MUST keep" is the correct way of putting this.
Take a look for yourself:
ηρέω tēreō Tense: Aorist
Voice: Active
Mood: Imperative <--------------a "Must"
* The Aorist Active Imperative verb form occurs 375 times in the New Testament.
There is no arguing with Greek, we Must (imperative) keep his commands.
Take care,