Salvation Not Possible Without Works

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Who are the select one's he talking to? If he was talking to select individuals, then why did all of them, 3,000 be baptized and added to the church, which is the beginning of the church having members. How could he be talking to select individuals without calling them out to be recognized, and for what reason in a mass crowd would he do something like that when it would be impossible to call a specific person in a crowd like that, it doesn't make sense.

What does not make sense is to tell everyone in plural and second person to repent. but only talk in third person singular when telling to do another event, if he is telling EVERYONE to do this

Also. It only says those who BELIEVED were baptized. it did not say everyone was baptized, Your assuming everyone who heard also believed, This would be an assumption, but not based on facts in the text.

Finally, it makes complete sense.

If I am in a crowd, And someone tells all of us to do something. And he tells only those who did this to do something else. I can look at myself. Did I do the first thing? Yes, Thus when he said to do the second, he is talking to me. However, If I did not do the first thing, I know he is NOT telling me to do the second, Because I have yet to do the first.

That is why he said it the way he did. Greek is much more complex and easier than english.

And example (about the only one I can give) in english, Is someone is speaking to a crowd of workers. He says finish you jobs, And those of you who have finished, may go to lunch. He did not tell everyone to go to lunch, ONLY htose who had finished their jobs,

This is the type of language peter used.

 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0
In Christ and his death (romans 6)

In his body. (1 Cor 12)

In Christ (gal 3: 27)

With Christ (Col 2: 12)

You're saying this is what there baptized in? Do you not see that baptism throughout the N.T. is in water? So you're saying these 3,000 souls on the day of Pentecost didn't get baptized in water?
 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0

What does not make sense is to tell everyone in plural and second person to repent. but only talk in third person singular when telling to do another event, if he is telling EVERYONE to do this

Also. It only says those who BELIEVED were baptized. it did not say everyone was baptized, Your assuming everyone who heard also believed, This would be an assumption, but not based on facts in the text.

Finally, it makes complete sense.

If I am in a crowd, And someone tells all of us to do something. And he tells only those who did this to do something else. I can look at myself. Did I do the first thing? Yes, Thus when he said to do the second, he is talking to me. However, If I did not do the first thing, I know he is NOT telling me to do the second, Because I have yet to do the first.

That is why he said it the way he did. Greek is much more complex and easier than english.

And example (about the only one I can give) in english, Is someone is speaking to a crowd of workers. He says finish you jobs, And those of you who have finished, may go to lunch. He did not tell everyone to go to lunch, ONLY htose who had finished their jobs,

This is the type of language peter used.

Common sense says those that believed are the one's that were baptized, I never said those who don't believe, so it would mean all those, referring to those that believed obviously.
 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0

What does not make sense is to tell everyone in plural and second person to repent. but only talk in third person singular when telling to do another event, if he is telling EVERYONE to do this

Also. It only says those who BELIEVED were baptized. it did not say everyone was baptized, Your assuming everyone who heard also believed, This would be an assumption, but not based on facts in the text.

Finally, it makes complete sense.

If I am in a crowd, And someone tells all of us to do something. And he tells only those who did this to do something else. I can look at myself. Did I do the first thing? Yes, Thus when he said to do the second, he is talking to me. However, If I did not do the first thing, I know he is NOT telling me to do the second, Because I have yet to do the first.

That is why he said it the way he did. Greek is much more complex and easier than english.

And example (about the only one I can give) in english, Is someone is speaking to a crowd of workers. He says finish you jobs, And those of you who have finished, may go to lunch. He did not tell everyone to go to lunch, ONLY htose who had finished their jobs,

This is the type of language peter used.

What's the second thing you're suppose to do?
 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0
The baptism that only God can perform, the baptism of the Holy Spirit unto eternal life.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
So you're saying the baptism is the Holy spirit and not water. Are you referring to the Holy Spirit that the Apostles received in which they were given gifts, such as performing miracles and other things, is that what you're imply you received? If that's what you're implying you're wrong, these were given to the Apostles as Jesus told them they would receive, not you or I.
 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0
Acts 2: 38...you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
Everyone has the holy spirit in them guiding them, but only the Apostles have the gifts to perform miracles and all those gifts have been done away with when the last Apostle died.
 
T

The_highwayman

Guest
Everyone has the holy spirit in them guiding them, but only the Apostles have the gifts to perform miracles and all those gifts have been done away with when the last Apostle died.
So what about all those that were not Apostles that were given the gifts? This is were the cessation doctrine falls down.

You guys forget there were more that were given power and authority than the original 12, both when Jesus was alive and after his ascension.

So lets really crack this open shall we.

Please tell me how Jesus did all the miracles and healings he did?
 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0
Who said she is ignoring them?

He said go make disciples. and baptize THEM. They were already disciples when they were baptized (saved)[quote

1. Peter did not tell them to repent AND be baptized, He told them to REPENT, and then told those who repented to be baptized (you have the context and wording wrong, He di dnot tell everyone to be baptized)
2. Mark 16 does not say to be baptized in water, Your assuming this, This would be a false assumption. Since every other place. Jesus said repent and believe ONLY .

Yes it clearly says to repent and be baptized, King James Bible
Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost.
Now are you going to tell me it doesn't say to repent and be baptized after giving you scripture for proof that you're wrong? You say above that it says go and make disciples of them and baptize them. [h=3]Matthew 28:16-20[/h]New King James Version (NKJV)

[h=3]The Great Commission[/h][SUP]16 [/SUP]Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, to the mountain which Jesus had appointed for them. [SUP]17 [/SUP]When they saw Him, they worshiped Him; but some doubted.
[SUP]18 [/SUP]And Jesus came and spoke to them, saying, “All authority has been given to Me in heaven and on earth. [SUP]19 [/SUP]Go therefore[SUP][a][/SUP] and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, [SUP]20 [/SUP]teaching them to observe all things that I have commanded you; and lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the age.” Amen.[SUP][b][/SUP]
 
Last edited:

Cassian

Senior Member
Oct 12, 2013
1,960
7
0
Hey friend, hope all is well with you this beautiful day. You say that if one believes then God "expects" one to be baptized, I say he says he " commands " one to be baptized. Please explain why you're using the word " necessarily ".
because we have a choice. He commands us to obey Him, but we don't need to obey Him, He cannot force us to obey Him.
 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0
because we have a choice. He commands us to obey Him, but we don't need to obey Him, He cannot force us to obey Him.
That's true, but in order to be pleasing we must adhere to his commands, but obviously we don't have to do anything if we choose not to.
 

jogoldie

Senior Member
Mar 20, 2014
1,616
48
48
The book of James tells us that true faith in God must be accomanied by good works....
Good works do not prove a persons belief in God or relationship with Him, but having faith leads to goods works
Faith has to come first because when good works are done in faith,God always gets the glory......
 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0
So what about all those that were not Apostles that were given the gifts? This is were the cessation doctrine falls down.

You guys forget there were more that were given power and authority than the original 12, both when Jesus was alive and after his ascension.

So lets really crack this open shall we.

Please tell me how Jesus did all the miracles and healings he did?
The Apostles recruited many people to help them with getting the message out to help the ministry of Jesus, but the Apostles no longer exist and the only way you could get the gift was through the Apostles, so as the bible says these miracles and these other gifts would cease once there job was done, and it's done.
 

Cassian

Senior Member
Oct 12, 2013
1,960
7
0
I do not teach that salvation is through what James refers to as "faith only," (faith that is barren of works, empty profession of faith). I teach that salvation is by grace through faith, not works (Ephesians 2:8,9) then we are created in Christ Jesus unto/for good works (Ephesians 2:10). This does not remove good works as the fruit of salvation, it just puts them in their proper place, subsequent to the root of salvation, faith.
Which is what the OP stated and which I and several others have been saying all along. Faith is the root, but faith without works is meaningless. It is what we do that is necessary for salvation.



I never said this. I was simply stating that Christ is the all sufficient means of our salvation. No supplements needed.
that would not be correct since our salvation depends on what we do. Christ cannot save you alone, nor can you save yourself alone, it takes both, thus what is necessary is the Holy Spirit working in us and we synergistically cooperating with Him for our salvation.



I am not simply doing nothing, I am working out my salvation, but not working for my salvation. There is a difference. Salvation is a matter of believing/faith in Christ alone. To say that faith in Christ is not enough is to say that the object of our belief/faith (Christ's finished work of redemption) is not enough to save us and we must add our works to help Him save us. That's faith in works not faith in Christ.[/quote] I think this is why you can say the correct understanding but also fall to the incorrect outlook. Christ redemption saved you already, without any help from you. He saved everyone. His saving work makes it possible for you to be in union with Him. The object of your faith is Him, but the personal salvation of each of us depends on our works through that faith. Our works have nothing to do with what Christ did not the Cross. His work on the Cross did not save you as an individual. That is a personal choice of every human being and that personal salvation involves our working with God for that salvation. That is the working out of one's salvation.



Works are separated from faith as the root of salvation, but they cannot be separated as the fruit of salvation. Faith is the root and works are the fruit of salvation. No fruit would demonstrate no root.
and no salvation. Again, one cannot speak of faith alone, it is meaningless faith, it is always faith/works. or Works through faith. Which is the meaning of the phrase we "are being saved through faith" our faith.


We have been saved from the penalty of sin through faith "justification" and we are being saved from the power of sin "ongoing sanctification". There are three tenses to salvation 1. Justification 2. Sanctification 3. Glorification. These tenses usually end up getting mixed up by those who teach salvation by works.
The first two are actually, for protestants who tend to look at the negative side, what prevents one from going to hell. The third one is the result of being faithful, the end result of our working out our salvation.




What will works determine for believers at the judgment? 1 Corinthians 3:13 each one's work will become clear; for the Day will declare it, because it will be revealed by fire; and the fire will test each one's work, of what sort it is. 14 If anyone's work which he has built on it endures, he will receive a reward. 15 If anyone's work is burned, he will suffer loss; (of reward) but he himself will be saved, yet so as through fire.



I already clearly explained that man is saved through faith and not by works, yet genuine faith is substantiated and confirmed by good works. That is the balance that you seem to have out of balance, namely, salvation by works.



Works are the fruit of faith, not the essence of faith. This is critical to understand.



Faith that trusts in Christ "alone" for salvation and faith that remains "alone" in producing good works are two separate alone's in connection with two different things.[/QUOTE]
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Common sense says those that believed are the one's that were baptized, I never said those who don't believe, so it would mean all those, referring to those that believed obviously.
Yes, And common sense and LANGUAGE would show that those who believed were saved, And because they were saved, they were baptized in water.

 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
You're saying this is what there baptized in? Do you not see that baptism throughout the N.T. is in water? So you're saying these 3,000 souls on the day of Pentecost didn't get baptized in water?
No, I am not saying that at all.

I am saying they were first baptised into Christ, Into his death, Into his body, And with Christ. which saved them. And after this happened (was performed by God himself as it says in those passages) they were baptized in water.

 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
What's the second thing you're suppose to do?

what do you mean. thjere were many commands given by Christ to his church.

the first (as you showed) is to be baptized.

 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
So you're saying the baptism is the Holy spirit and not water. Are you referring to the Holy Spirit that the Apostles received in which they were given gifts, such as performing miracles and other things, is that what you're imply you received? If that's what you're implying you're wrong, these were given to the Apostles as Jesus told them they would receive, not you or I.

Nope.

that would be the annointing of the holy spirit.

the baptizm of the HS and the annointing of the HS are two separate events, although they occure prety much simultatiously.

look at the OT example. the priest was washed, the sacrifice given, then the annointing occured.

the same thing happens to us, and is what makes us kings and priests unto our god and father

 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
because we have a choice. He commands us to obey Him, but we don't need to obey Him, He cannot force us to obey Him.

nope. your right, he will not

thats why those who just believe and did not really repent will not obey him.

thats why those who have true faith will obey him.

and why those who are religious will appear to obey him, but their faith is in their owrks, not the promise of God. so they to have never yet repented and have just a mwere belief in the promises of God.

 
Mar 3, 2014
300
3
0
No, I am not saying that at all.

I am saying they were first baptised into Christ, Into his death, Into his body, And with Christ. which saved them. And after this happened (was performed by God himself as it says in those passages) they were baptized in water.

Somehow I misunderstood what you were saying, sorry about that. I thought you said they were not baptized in water.
 

Cassian

Senior Member
Oct 12, 2013
1,960
7
0
Mailmandan,

Continuation......

We have been saved from the penalty of sin through faith "justification" and we are being saved from the power of sin "ongoing sanctification". There are three tenses to salvation 1. Justification 2. Sanctification 3. Glorification. These tenses usually end up getting mixed up by those who teach salvation by works.
The first two are actually, for protestants who tend to look at the negative side, what prevents one from going to hell. The third one is the result of being faithful, the end result of our working out our salvation.
For me, Christ saved all of us/the world from death and sin. He overcame the fall, the condemnation of death through Adam. Thus we are saved (past tense).
We were saved so that man could fulfill the purpose of our existence, namely to be in union with God in this world and for an eternity. Thus union is through faith. Man freely joining with Christ and working with Christ in this world for which we were created. That is being saved, the present tense. If we remain faithful, we shall be saved, or inherit the promise at the end, glorification.

What will works determine for believers at the judgment? 1 Corinthians 3:13 each one's work will become clear; for the Day will declare it, because it will be revealed by fire; and the fire will test each one's work, of what sort it is. 14 If anyone's work which he has built on it endures, he will receive a reward. 15 If anyone's work is burned, he will suffer loss; (of reward) but he himself will be saved, yet so as through fire.
Yes, we will be purified. We cannot enter heaven with some of the impurities in our lives. We have done some things,(works) that were not in faith. Whatever we have left of those they will be burned.

I already clearly explained that man is saved through faith and not by works, yet genuine faith is substantiated and confirmed by good works. That is the balance that you seem to have out of balance, namely, salvation by works.
Incorrect. It is your misunderstanding or fear of using the word "works". Part of your misunderstanding is that you have already been saved (past tense) by Christ overcoming your condemnation to death through Adam. Works cannot save you from death and sin. That is what the "law of works" is always addressing. It is NEVER addressing the works of faith, or what Paul terms, the Law of faith. It is not faith alone which is meaningless. You are not saved by faith, but are being saved through faith and that involves works. Without the works whatever faith you think you have, is meaningless. So it is the works that we do that ensures our salvation through faith. It is the works for which we will give an account, not our faith.

Works are the fruit of faith, not the essence of faith. This is critical to understand.
It is the content of faith. Without the works you have no faith. You cannot separate them. The NT never separates them.

Faith that trusts in Christ "alone" for salvation and faith that remains "alone" in producing good works are two separate alone's in connection with two different things.
You don't need any faith to be saved by Christ alone. He saved all men from death and sin. You or any individual cannot add or effect anything to do with Christ's work.
If you are saying that one needs to trust Christ and not something else for salvation that would be correct, but that does not address the work issue. Christ needs YOU, your commitment to be in union with Him. That part of our salvation is NEVER alone, it is always a synergistic, cooperative covenantal relationship entered in this life, and if faithful, will inherit eternal life with Christ.
I'm not sure why you seem to try to work an end-around regaring faith/works. You have stated it correctly a couple of times, but then for whatever reason, you seem to deny it and try to say it another way.