SUBMISSION...earn it? force it? give it?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
R

Rosesrock

Guest
#21
Hold on...let me call my husband and ask, I'll get back to you
:p
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
#22
Submit to one another out of reverence for Christ.
Eph 5:21

If I am reading this right we should do what is asked of us, unless there is a reason not to.
It appears therefore we are commanded to submit, so that we honour the Lord.

It tends to create in people a willingness to know the individual concerned is reliable to help if needed which generally is a very good thing, and helps people feel supported.

The down side is some people do literally take advantage and you have to say sometimes too much.
 

notuptome

Senior Member
May 17, 2013
15,050
2,538
113
#23
To submit you must trust. Submission to God is based on trust that God knows more and loves more than you do.

Does your spouse trust you? Does your spouse trust the Lord? Do you honor and cherish that trust? Submission becomes natural when you are able to trust the Lord.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
 
E

ember

Guest
#24
Possible to get some feedback on this? please?

ok ...we have earn, force and give

I found a site this am, that I think really addresses the submission question

Following quote is from that site

Christian submission is defined by the relationship between God the Father and Son. It cannot be properly understood apart from that mooring. Hence, I believe it is unwise for us to uphold the instruction for wives to submit themselves to their husbands as an achievable standard for those outside the faith community. People without the indwelling power of the Holy Spirit have neither the discernment nor the power to live out submission and authority in a godly manner.

So if anyone is still responding here, what do you think of this? Especially the underlined part?

Is this an aspect that gets left out?

And this as well:

Men have a responsibility to submit too—it’s not just something that’s required of women. EVERY Christian, female or male, has the responsibility to submit to the Lord, and also to the authorities the Lord has placed in his or her life. What’s more, the biblical concepts of submission and authority cannot be disassociated. The two are indivisibly connected. A biblical definition of submission cannot be understood apart from a biblical definition of authority.

I'll post more for consideration depending on how this goes...cause I think it is giving me a different perspective
 

MarcR

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2015
5,486
183
63
#25
Ephesians 5:21 (KJV) Submitting yourselves one to another in the fear of God.
The word used here ὐποτασσόμενοι means putting yourself under authority.

IMO, this does not allow any room for subjugation or abuse.
 
E

ember

Guest
#26
yes...thanks Marc! That is what I am seeing and trying to emphasize...and then also I wanted to work towards our example..Jesus...who WILLINGLY placed Himself under His Father's authority...He submitted...but I think we need to see that
almost like a revelation from the Holy Spirit because so many of us...well women especially...have no desire to submit as some teach

But I think there is a whole other world regarding submission...


Here is another excerpt:

A husband does not have the right to demand or extract submission from his wife. Submission is HER choice—her responsibility… it is NOT his right!! Not ever. She is to “submit herself”— deciding when and how to submit is her call. In a Christian marriage, the focus is never on rights, but on personal responsibility. It’s his responsibility to be affectionate. It’s her responsibility to be agreeable. The husband’s responsibility is to sacrificially love as Christ loved the Church—not to make his wife submit.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
#27
The thought of joint submission to each other is interesting with the opposite joint dominance of each other.

In joint submission, you are forced to consider the other party and work for a balance from the other parties perspective, rather if you dominate, you are forcing the other party to agree with a power play or black mail.

Maybe this is the two kingdoms, the one of light is being a servant to each other, working out what is possible, and the world of darkness is where the most powerful win through force of position and no one knows the weaker parties needs.

Marriages that work seem to be where people work for each other, and those that fail focus often on only one dominant party, whether male or female.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#28
When someone forces another to submit they are in essence, saying that the persons wants needs desires personality are inconsequential to them. It is stealing for one thing and murder for another.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
#29
When someone forces another to submit they are in essence, saying that the persons wants needs desires personality are inconsequential to them. It is stealing for one thing and murder for another.
If you are forcing submission is this not just dominating? Earning submission is about someone having respect for another so they accept that persons direction etc.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#30
If you are forcing submission is this not just dominating? Earning submission is about someone having respect for another so they accept that persons direction etc.
I'm not sure that "earning" submission is a biblical concept....it's just something that God made that is good and should be done mutually in kindness, connectedness and love for one another and God. I'm of the mindset that at least in the marital realm, forced submission allowing oneself to be dominated.....are two people conspiring in ignorance. I'm sure I'm gonna get flak for that comment. :)
 
E

ember

Guest
#31
yeah, earning submission is not biblical by any means

well, I thought this thread might generate more interest since it is always a hot topic and sure featured in that other infamous thread on women

alas...well, thanks guys!
 

Grandpa

Senior Member
Jun 24, 2011
11,551
3,190
113
#32
I can see how submission to an imperfect person would be much more difficult than submission to God.

But I wonder if you can see how hard it is to love an imperfect person as Christ loves His Church?

Its a difficult situation all the way around.

I wonder how we can overcome this?

To us, it always seems like we are trying harder than the other person. But are we? Just as we give excuses for ourselves do we give those excuses for the other?

Its hard for narcissistic, selfish people to lay down their issues.

I'm trying to be like Christ and all you people are ruining it for me...
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#33
I can see how submission to an imperfect person would be much more difficult than submission to God.

But I wonder if you can see how hard it is to love an imperfect person as Christ loves His Church?

Its a difficult situation all the way around.

I wonder how we can overcome this?

To us, it always seems like we are trying harder than the other person. But are we? Just as we give excuses for ourselves do we give those excuses for the other?

Its hard for narcissistic, selfish people to lay down their issues.

I'm trying to be like Christ and all you people are ruining it for me...
We expect people to grow faster than they are able.
 
E

ember

Guest
#34
yeah, earning submission is not biblical by any means

well, I thought this thread might generate more interest since it is always a hot topic and sure featured in that other infamous thread on women

alas...well, thanks guys!
it lives!
 
E

ember

Guest
#35
I can see how submission to an imperfect person would be much more difficult than submission to God.

But I wonder if you can see how hard it is to love an imperfect person as Christ loves His Church?

Its a difficult situation all the way around.

I wonder how we can overcome this?

To us, it always seems like we are trying harder than the other person. But are we? Just as we give excuses for ourselves do we give those excuses for the other?

Its hard for narcissistic, selfish people to lay down their issues.

I'm trying to be like Christ and all you people are ruining it for me...
yes exactly...we approach from our own understanding...understandably...and offer reasons and deters for what is staring us in the face

but I am having a fresh look at this and now it makes much better sense to me

golly...I would like to post the whole article, but will anyone read the thing? well here goes...


[h=2]Seven Misconceptions about Submission:[/h][h=4]Misconception #1: Submission is universal—the directive can be applied correctly by all, even those outside of the faith community.[/h]
Christian submission is defined by the relationship between God the Father and Son. It cannot be properly understood apart from that mooring. Hence, I believe it is unwise for us to uphold the instruction for wives to submit themselves to their husbands as an achievable standard for those outside the faith community. People without the indwelling power of the Holy Spirit have neither the discernment nor the power to live out submission and authority in a godly manner.
[h=4]Misconception #2: Submission is gender-exclusive—it’s just for women.[/h]
Men have a responsibility to submit too—it’s not just something that’s required of women. EVERY Christian, female or male, has the responsibility to submit to the Lord, and also to the authorities the Lord has placed in his or her life. What’s more, the biblical concepts of submission and authority cannot be disassociated. The two are indivisibly connected. A biblical definition of submission cannot be understood apart from a biblical definition of authority.
[h=4]Misconception #3: Submission is generic—every woman submits to every man.[/h]
The Bible instructs a wife to submit herself to her own husband; not to men in general.
[h=4]Misconception #4: Submission is a right—a husband has the right to demand his wife’s submission.[/h]
A husband does not have the right to demand or extract submission from his wife. Submission is HER choice—her responsibility… it is NOT his right!! Not ever. She is to “submit herself”— deciding when and how to submit is her call. In a Christian marriage, the focus is never on rights, but on personal responsibility. It’s his responsibility to be affectionate. It’s her responsibility to be agreeable. The husband’s responsibility is to sacrificially love as Christ loved the Church—not to make his wife submit.
[h=4]Misconception #5: Submission is indiscriminate—it means mindless acquiescence.[/h]
A Christian’s first responsibility is to submit to the Lord and His standard of righteousness. A wife is not called to submit to sin, mistreatment, or abuse. The Lord does not want “weak-willed” women—women who lack the discernment and strength to respond to the right things and in the right way. Godly women do not submit to sin. They carefully and intentionally weigh and discern how to submit to sinful human authority in light of their primary responsibility to submit to the ways of the Lord. No brain-dead doormats or spineless bowls of Jello here! Submission is neither mindless nor formulaic nor simplistic. Submitting to the Lord sometimes involves drawing clear boundaries and enacting consequences when a husband sins. Submission is an attitude of the heart. A woman can have a submissive spirit even when saying “no” and refusing to go along with sin.
[h=4]Misconception #6: Submission precludes mutuality—it creates lopsided, one-way relationships.[/h]
Submission and authority function hand-in-hand with all the other biblical directives about how Christians ought to interact with one another. Along with submitting to her husband, a Christian wife also has the responsibility to be transparent, speak truth, confront sin, and challenge her husband to ever increasing levels of holiness. As heirs together of the grace of life, both husband and wife have the responsibility to love, encourage, and build one another up; and to interact with forbearance, kindness and humility. Biblical authority and submission contribute to mutuality, and do not diminish or detract from it. (It’s “both-and” not “either-or.”)
[h=4]Misconception #7: Submission promotes abuse—it encourages husbands to be domineering, self-centered boors.[/h]
When properly understood and enacted, the framework of hierarchical relationships within the Christian community serves a protective function, because every authority is accountable to a higher authority. This community structure encourages husbands to fulfill their responsibility to love as Christ loves, and holds them to account when they don’t. It fosters Christlikeness and prevents abuse. A wife whose husband is abusive can appeal to higher authorities for intervention and protection. It is the responsibility of the authorities to protect and seek the good of all those under their care.
 

Grandpa

Senior Member
Jun 24, 2011
11,551
3,190
113
#36
"Well you aren't Jesus, honey".

That is true. But in this marriage it goes 1.Jesus 2.Me 3.You. Go into your prayer closet and ask the Lord how he wants this marriage to go. Come back and let me know.

Its way easier if we are both submitting to Christ. Its much more difficult when we come out from under Him and attempt to argue our "rights".

Good one, ember...
 
E

ember

Guest
#37
ummm...i am not sure I quite I understand yr post?

I get all things are perfect in a perfect world...shame about people ruining it (haha)

I found the article helpful and I totally get how 50% does not a marriage make

however, I am of the mind that marriage vows are broken by abuse...not just adultery

seen some really good cases discussed on other forums

I am not advocating disertion or divorce because someone got up in a frumpy mood...but chillesing away at the personality of another, or faking Christianity to marry someone, or continued mental and emotional abuse sounds like breaking the marriage vows to many people I am finding out
 

mar09

Senior Member
Sep 17, 2014
4,927
1,259
113
#38
Ive bn searching on submission and found ths thread informative as well as with lots of biblical encouragement. I also realize much of my own hurts came abt bec. I was nt submitting rightfully to hußband. Its really a prayer sitation for me, needing change in many ways. Words dont come easy at all, but i know there is- there ws room for confession long before. May God still hear and grant mercy to restore, do the good work He started.
 
O

oldthennew

Guest
#39
we all must 'submit' as our Father leads, and not as the world leads.....
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
689
113
#40
Deference sounds so much nicer than submission, and for me it doesn't have the same hooks.