But that other thread is creating all the problem because it singles out one specific group of Christians. And it does not do so in a healty way. The title alone already implies one side is correct and the other in error. It leaves no room for real debate. It turns people like me away from CC as a whole and gives a false representation of all of CC when a small few are causing such offense to an even smaller minority.
Well said, this is why I really shuttered when I read the title of that thread, because yeah, it's just such a bad witness when we do this mud-slinging. Like, I can understand where Roaringkitten was coming from in that she saw how Jesus passionately opposed hypocrites and whatnot and thought "Well, this is what Catholics teach, this is how it differs from the Bible and I'm going to let everyone know and not appologize for it." But, it's just not that simple. Before we take on Jesus' passionate anger against false doctrines we need to remember that Jesus was always right and we're not always right.
And I've said it before, Protestants are wrong about things too. On Oprah yesterday they were talking about families who've been caught up in the current ecomonic crisis. There was one couple who had both been layed off and not long after their child become very sick and required a hospital stay that ate up a big part of their savings. This is why I'm so glad I don't live in the USA. I could not imagine hesitating taking my child* to the doctor because it would wipe out my savings. So that begs the question, why aren't American Christians
leading the fight for universal health care for children?? Instead I see American Evangelicals supporting candidates that
oppose such a position. Why is that???? Didn't Jesus say that whatever we do for the least of these we do for him??? There's a lot along those lines that I wonder about, but instead of pointing fingers, it's more important tha I seek to understand.
Like for example, I learned in university that studies investigating why the USA has a higher teen pregnancy rate than their industrialized counterparts, the conclusion is that the "anstainace only" sex ed. Anstaince sex ed in a "just do it" culture is really a bad idea. Especailly considering how many teens do not have a stay at home parent and therefore they have unsupervised time after school. So, what I did was, I looked on the internet for the position of those who supported this position. Why? Because I don't critizes something until I really understand.
So, my point is this: instead of giving Catholics a hard time about doctrines they hold that contrary (as Roaringkitten see it anyway) to the Bible, maybe it would be a better idea if she just
asked "Hey Catholics, how do you Biblically justify..." It's not like that questions don't have answers.
*I don't have any kids, but over Christmas I changed my nephew's diaper and there was a streak of fresh blood in his stool. I freaked out and called the public health nurse. She asked me some important questions and then told me which after hours clinic to take him to. The whole thing didn't cost my sister's family a dime.