Elin said:
The spirit raised from spiritual death (no Holy Spirit life) by eternal life in the rebirth by the Holy Spirit,
does not die again because eternal life is immortal.
What does this have to do with Jn 5:24?
John 5:24 shows obtaining the promise of
eternal life is CONDITIONAL upon a sustained hearing and believing. And since it is obtained CONDITIONALLY it
can be lost CONDITIONALLY. Therefore if one quits hearing and believing he will for certain spiritually die again.
The eternal life received through grace by faith does not exist apart from, nor outside, spirits,
any more than human life exists apart from or outside humans.
Eternal life is not some kind of object hanging out there that we move in and out of,
just as human life is not some kind of object hanging out there which a person moves in and out of.
Eternal life is Holy Spirit
life within one's personal spirit reborn (raised) from spiritual
death.
That life is immortal and does not
die,
and if it simply
departed from spirits who have received it,
where would it go since it can exist o
nly in spirits,
as human life can exist only
in humans?
Not only is your understanding of eternal life contra Biblical, it doesn't even make sense.