To all of you non flat earthers.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
PC123

PC123

Banned
#221
Jun 22, 2020
1,231
740
113
Australia
#221
The simple question was how can me Dwyane see the crux behind me as well???

The answer at the start if he video was that we can't see it simultaneously...
That my friend, is simply incorrect...
Misleading. He threw in the word simultaneously for the south only...

Not interested in such deceptions mate...
You cannot explain it. Nor can the video. 20 minutes sleep lost...
 
BigSky2021

BigSky2021

Active member
#222
Apr 23, 2021
78
111
33
#222
PC123 said:
There is a South African on this forum...
If you like we can try to arrange a celestial confirmation...
We can try to see if we can both see the crux at the same time...
Click to expand...
There is something to be said for testing these things. There are many more experiments the average person can conduct.

Check some out for yourself: http://www.testingtheglobe.com/quest2.html
 
PC123

PC123

Banned
#224
Jun 22, 2020
1,231
740
113
Australia
#224
GaryA said:
@PC123 - did you read post #206 and post #207 ???
Click to expand...
#206. Thats fine
#207. Thas fine as well..
Doesnt address the specific detail that im studying... The crux... The south pole

Question still remains Garry... How can we be looking south at crux at the same time???
 
PC123

PC123

Banned
#225
Jun 22, 2020
1,231
740
113
Australia
#225
BigSky2021 said:
There is something to be said for testing these things. There are many more experiments the average person can conduct.

Check some out for yourself: http://www.testingtheglobe.com/quest2.html
Click to expand...
Im sure there are many tests. I can only conduct one at a time but, right...

Im not pro FE or anti FE. Before this is concluded that the scientific explanation of how our solar system moves through space cannot be correct... I think they're both wrong... None of them have the infallible truth... Only parts of it

Recently iv been observing the movements and orientation of the southern cross.
Iv concluded that there must be one south pole making that particular FE model impossible
 
PC123

PC123

Banned
#226
Jun 22, 2020
1,231
740
113
Australia
#226
Southern cross cannot be in front of me and behind me at the same time

flat earth.jpg

And the lies of the video are just that... Lies...
The crux can be seen simultaneously from any dark place in the south... Just like Polaris in the north
Millions of us can see it at any given moment. Not just Dwayne and Diego

Maybe my mate is right... Americans... LoL...:) Hello... We do exist down here... :LOL:

Anyway... Thats the given explanation. We can't see it simultaneously... Noted and documented... Study complete
 
G

GaryA

Truth, Honesty, Love, Courage
#227
Aug 10, 2019
9,106
3,973
113
mywebsite.us
#227
PC123 said:
#206. Thats fine
#207. Thas fine as well..
Doesnt address the specific detail that im studying... The crux... The south pole

Question still remains Garry... How can we be looking south at crux at the same time???
Click to expand...
Did you read post #215 ?
 
G

GaryA

Truth, Honesty, Love, Courage
#228
Aug 10, 2019
9,106
3,973
113
mywebsite.us
#228
PC123 said:
Anyway... Thats the given explanation. We can't see it simultaneously... Noted and documented... Study complete
Click to expand...
Hey mate! You have misunderstood. Slow down. Pay attention. The answer to your question is here. You are overlooking it.
 
G

GaryA

Truth, Honesty, Love, Courage
#229
Aug 10, 2019
9,106
3,973
113
mywebsite.us
#229
You seem to be "hung up" on this statement from the video:

The supposed "South Pole star, Sigma Octantis," the Southern Crux and other outer constellations conversely can NOT be seen simultaneously from every point in the Southern Hemi'sphere' the way Polaris can from every point in the North.

Please pay particular attention to the last ten words:

the way Polaris can from every point in the North

You need to "unhang" yourself from the word 'simultaneously', calm down, and pay attention.
 
PC123

PC123

Banned
#234
Jun 22, 2020
1,231
740
113
Australia
#234
GaryA said:
The key phrase here is 'at the same time'.

It is not [directly] in front of you continually at all times.
Click to expand...
#215

Yes it is Garry... The crux is always directing us south within 30 degrees

GaryA said:
It is never [directly] in front of more than one of you at the same time.
Click to expand...
Thats false Gazza... I can see at the same time as the s African or at the same time as the s American

GaryA said:
Only two of you may possibly ever see it at the same time.
Click to expand...
Correct... Just like only two of you can only see it at a time in the north if i pick 3 points...
Can u see Polaris in the day? No
I can't see the crux in the day.
Neither north or south can see those stars all at once

So then, you acknowledge that two of us are looking south at the crux simultaneously. But no explanation how

GaryA said:
These things are true because it is moving in a circular path whereby it passes by each of you to the south once a day (at night) - but, at different times relative to each of you.
Click to expand...
False again... we know what we are seeing... You are inventing things...

When its 10pm in Santiago its 4am in South Africa
They're both looking south at the crux

When its 4am in Santiago its 6pm here
We're both looking at the crux

When its 10pm here in Johannesburg its 4am
We are both looking at crux

Sorry mate but what your imagining is false... Im looking at it...
Whether you believe me or not is another story, your in America, you can't see it, so
 
PC123

PC123

Banned
#235
Jun 22, 2020
1,231
740
113
Australia
#235
So lets recap then @GaryA
According the the FE model the south pole is everywhere
The southern cross is either a myth or can only be see from one position at a time

flat earth sp.jpg
Is that about right?
 
G

GaryA

Truth, Honesty, Love, Courage
#236
Aug 10, 2019
9,106
3,973
113
mywebsite.us
#236
PC123 said:
#215

Yes it is Garry... The crux is always directing us south within 30 degrees



Thats false Gazza... I can see at the same time as the s African or at the same time as the s American



Correct... Just like only two of you can only see it at a time in the north if i pick 3 points...
Can u see Polaris in the day? No
I can't see the crux in the day.
Neither north or south can see those stars all at once

So then, you acknowledge that two of us are looking south at the crux simultaneously. But no explanation how



False again... we know what we are seeing... You are inventing things...

When its 10pm in Santiago its 4am in South Africa
They're both looking south at the crux

When its 4am in Santiago its 6pm here
We're both looking at the crux

When its 10pm here in Johannesburg its 4am
We are both looking at crux

Sorry mate but what your imagining is false... Im looking at it...
Whether you believe me or not is another story, your in America, you can't see it, so
Click to expand...
You are not "getting" what I mean when I say '[directly] in front of you'. I don't mean "anywhere in the sky in the general southern direction" - I mean when the crux is "straight up" from the 'South Celestial Pole' point in the sky that the crux rotates around.

PC123 said:
I see the crux spinning clockwise
Click to expand...
- around the 'SCP' mentioned above - correct?

When more than one of you, Diego, and Dwayne can see the crux at the same time - the position and orientation of the crux relative to the 'SCP' is different. For example, one will see it somewhere to the left while the other will see it to the right - correct?

It is only [directly] in front of you (as you look due south) when it is "straight up"; otherwise, it is "off to one side or the other"..

Make sense?
 
PC123

PC123

Banned
#237
Jun 22, 2020
1,231
740
113
Australia
#237
GaryA said:
You are not "getting" what I mean when I say '[directly] in front of you'. I don't mean "anywhere in the sky in the general southern direction" - I mean when the crux is "straight up" from the 'South Celestial Pole' point in the sky that the crux rotates around.
Click to expand...
Again... The crux points south with in 30 degrees. Where ever you are on earth
 
PC123

PC123

Banned
#238
Jun 22, 2020
1,231
740
113
Australia
#238
GaryA said:
It is only [directly] in front of you (as you look due south) when it is "straight up"; otherwise, it is "off to one side or the other"..
Click to expand...
Again... No its not... It is always pointing south within 30 degrees
 
G

GaryA

Truth, Honesty, Love, Courage
#240
Aug 10, 2019
9,106
3,973
113
mywebsite.us
#240
PC123 said:
So lets recap then @GaryA
According the the FE model the south pole is everywhere
The southern cross is either a myth or can only be see from one position at a time

View attachment 227763
Is that about right?
Click to expand...
Something like that - yes. Remember, we are discussing the FE model. The earth is stationary while the stars are continually moving clockwise (east-to-west).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.