I enjoyed reading both testimonies, although not the ending of Cycel's. (No offense- I prefer a Christian ending to an atheist one!)
I also can relate to the Santa Claus story. My husband is a very strong Christian, and he said we were never going to tell our children Santa was real. One winter, my youngest son was 3 years old. My husband sat him down, and very seriously told him Santa Claus wasn't real, but Jesus was. So celebrating Christmas was about Jesus, not about a fictional man who brings toys. He even told him we give the toys, and no one comes down the chimney on Christmas night.
It was hard on me to see a small child so brutally confronted with the truth. I like fantasy and imagination, and Christmas had always been a wonderful time for me. Later that same day, I took my young son to the mall to get some pictures taken. As we arrived, a helicopter was overhead. My son liked helicopters, so we stopped to watch it land in the parking lot (Quite a surprise for both of us!). What a shock to see that the person who got out was Santa Claus! He walked into the mall to begin doing his thing of hearing Christmas wish lists.
My son was stunned for a while, then he turned to me and said, "Well, Dad sure was wrong, wasn't he?"
I relate this to show you that even if your parents had tried to tell you Santa wasn't real, you might have experienced something that showed the opposite. My naive son had proof of Santa. Yet, strangely, it never affected his faith in Jesus. We never pretended Santa was real. But Jesus was always real in our home. Maybe that was the difference between my family and yours?
My other comment would be on the United Church. I attended Baptist Sunday School from grades 1 to 3. I learned countless Bible verses, which I remember to this day. I learned who Jesus was. I committed my life to Christ. Then we moved to a new community. The only church was a United Church. I went there for 2 years. We never took a Bible, we never learned a Bible verse, and never learned about who Jesus was. I would not discount being raised in the United Church as being part of your issue. True, the JW influence was strong, but in my experience as a chaplain, and growing up Protestant in Canada, is that the United Church in Canada has been one of the biggest hindrances to the gospel in the country. I am not exaggerating.
When you do not preach the truth of God's Word and present Christ, but turn to the social gospel and church becomes a time for being with friends rather than worshipping God, you lose the presence and the power of God. I know so many people in the United church, including many high school friends. When the church got really liberal, most of the Bible believing Christians left. In fact, my high school friends and I meet for reunions. I mentioned about the United Church having a lot of infighting about doctrine. They replied "No, not since all the bible thumpers left." And they still attend there.
A church without God, formed on totally conflicting doctrines about salvation (Presbyterians - Calvinist; Methodists - Arminian), is a church that is all about compromise, and the only compromise possible became not believing anything.
I am sorry if it offends any Canadians from the United Church who might be here, but I think the United Church, which used to be the largest Protestant denomination in Canada, is the single source of Canada's (at least in the west) apostasy. Hard words, I know. I recently read an article that attributed Canada's Christian decline to Expo 67 and Pierre Trudeau's policies of tolerance and multi-culturalism. That brief period in Canadian history might have had some influence, but I think more than that was the adoption of his attitude that God was not real by the United Church. And as to what happened in Quebec, I have no idea!
So, my personal theory, which you might examine, is the influence the United Church had in leading your to atheism. As for me, I got into the Pentecostal movement after I was first saved, where I saw a lot of things that didn't sit right with me. I eventually moved back to my Baptist roots, and found a church that works for me. I think there are many good denominations, and many believers in all churches, and those who do not attend church who are sincere believers in Jesus Christ.
I also want to comment on your epiphany regarding the medieval church. I studied geography for my undergrad degree, and I had a social geography prof who was really into the meaning of the medieval architecture, especially the churches. I did several research papers on Gothic architecture and neo- Gothic revival, including a presentation on the downtown Vancouver Catholic Cathedral, which was near where I lived. I had many discussions with my prof about the purpose of those buildings. I vehemently expressed my heart felt belief that faith in Christ had nothing to do with architecture. He argued that with a mostly illiterate population, the high, sweeping lines of the buildings, the stories expressed in stained glass, the a cappella music of the monks chanting Gregorian chants were all those people knew. For them, the church did express the grandeur of God, and it dominated the landscape in a way that nothing else did in those years in the 9th to 12th centuries in Europe.
So although those buildings do not mean the same thing as they do now, the fact is, a vital Christianity has survived over 2000 years. There is no myth, like Zeus or Baal or any god the people invented. Jesus Christ is alive and real. He did not die in those cathedrals, and he was not a myth to the people of that day.
Instead, we find a faith that is growing in leaps and bounds in countries like atheistic China and North Korea, in spite of intense persecution by the authorities. I have a friend who I went to Seminary with, who was a member of the Communist party in China for many years. When he came to Canada to work on his master and Ph.D in engineering, he met Jesus Christ. He left university, and came to Seminary to prepare for working with Chinese Mandarin speaking youth. We won't even touch on the persecution of the church in Muslim countries that is vicious right now, nor in Hindu India, which continues its crusade against Christian believers.
So you consigned Jesus to the archeological ruins of time, when in fact, he has been alive and the church has been thriving all the time. As for the "physical" sensation your epiphany included, I find it most interesting your testimony comes on a thread to do with being freed from demon possession. I am not a great believer in blaming the devil for many things, but when it comes to
I sincerely have to wonder if some kind of demonic manifestation at a crucial time took place which pushed you into a state of NOT believing in the living God. You must remember, there is a power of evil, although he is puny compared to Jesus Christ.
I know I was confronted with a demon a long time ago - I was about 13 at the time. I was not going to church or involved in any way with God at that time. I did rebuke it, in my own way, but my life and beliefs took a huge wrong turn after that.
As Ricky carries on as his signature:
"For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in heavenly places.
Eph. 6:12 KJV"
So another long post!! I hope you will not think I am attacking you after your sincere testimony about your conclusions about God. But I just see some gaping holes, and I think you are in our forum for a reason.
As for my testimony of going from Baptist Sunday school and reading the Bible on my own, to atheism, agnosticism, New Age movement and then born again Christian, well that will have to wait for another day.
I also can relate to the Santa Claus story. My husband is a very strong Christian, and he said we were never going to tell our children Santa was real. One winter, my youngest son was 3 years old. My husband sat him down, and very seriously told him Santa Claus wasn't real, but Jesus was. So celebrating Christmas was about Jesus, not about a fictional man who brings toys. He even told him we give the toys, and no one comes down the chimney on Christmas night.
It was hard on me to see a small child so brutally confronted with the truth. I like fantasy and imagination, and Christmas had always been a wonderful time for me. Later that same day, I took my young son to the mall to get some pictures taken. As we arrived, a helicopter was overhead. My son liked helicopters, so we stopped to watch it land in the parking lot (Quite a surprise for both of us!). What a shock to see that the person who got out was Santa Claus! He walked into the mall to begin doing his thing of hearing Christmas wish lists.
My son was stunned for a while, then he turned to me and said, "Well, Dad sure was wrong, wasn't he?"
I relate this to show you that even if your parents had tried to tell you Santa wasn't real, you might have experienced something that showed the opposite. My naive son had proof of Santa. Yet, strangely, it never affected his faith in Jesus. We never pretended Santa was real. But Jesus was always real in our home. Maybe that was the difference between my family and yours?
My other comment would be on the United Church. I attended Baptist Sunday School from grades 1 to 3. I learned countless Bible verses, which I remember to this day. I learned who Jesus was. I committed my life to Christ. Then we moved to a new community. The only church was a United Church. I went there for 2 years. We never took a Bible, we never learned a Bible verse, and never learned about who Jesus was. I would not discount being raised in the United Church as being part of your issue. True, the JW influence was strong, but in my experience as a chaplain, and growing up Protestant in Canada, is that the United Church in Canada has been one of the biggest hindrances to the gospel in the country. I am not exaggerating.
When you do not preach the truth of God's Word and present Christ, but turn to the social gospel and church becomes a time for being with friends rather than worshipping God, you lose the presence and the power of God. I know so many people in the United church, including many high school friends. When the church got really liberal, most of the Bible believing Christians left. In fact, my high school friends and I meet for reunions. I mentioned about the United Church having a lot of infighting about doctrine. They replied "No, not since all the bible thumpers left." And they still attend there.
A church without God, formed on totally conflicting doctrines about salvation (Presbyterians - Calvinist; Methodists - Arminian), is a church that is all about compromise, and the only compromise possible became not believing anything.
I am sorry if it offends any Canadians from the United Church who might be here, but I think the United Church, which used to be the largest Protestant denomination in Canada, is the single source of Canada's (at least in the west) apostasy. Hard words, I know. I recently read an article that attributed Canada's Christian decline to Expo 67 and Pierre Trudeau's policies of tolerance and multi-culturalism. That brief period in Canadian history might have had some influence, but I think more than that was the adoption of his attitude that God was not real by the United Church. And as to what happened in Quebec, I have no idea!
So, my personal theory, which you might examine, is the influence the United Church had in leading your to atheism. As for me, I got into the Pentecostal movement after I was first saved, where I saw a lot of things that didn't sit right with me. I eventually moved back to my Baptist roots, and found a church that works for me. I think there are many good denominations, and many believers in all churches, and those who do not attend church who are sincere believers in Jesus Christ.
I also want to comment on your epiphany regarding the medieval church. I studied geography for my undergrad degree, and I had a social geography prof who was really into the meaning of the medieval architecture, especially the churches. I did several research papers on Gothic architecture and neo- Gothic revival, including a presentation on the downtown Vancouver Catholic Cathedral, which was near where I lived. I had many discussions with my prof about the purpose of those buildings. I vehemently expressed my heart felt belief that faith in Christ had nothing to do with architecture. He argued that with a mostly illiterate population, the high, sweeping lines of the buildings, the stories expressed in stained glass, the a cappella music of the monks chanting Gregorian chants were all those people knew. For them, the church did express the grandeur of God, and it dominated the landscape in a way that nothing else did in those years in the 9th to 12th centuries in Europe.
So although those buildings do not mean the same thing as they do now, the fact is, a vital Christianity has survived over 2000 years. There is no myth, like Zeus or Baal or any god the people invented. Jesus Christ is alive and real. He did not die in those cathedrals, and he was not a myth to the people of that day.
Instead, we find a faith that is growing in leaps and bounds in countries like atheistic China and North Korea, in spite of intense persecution by the authorities. I have a friend who I went to Seminary with, who was a member of the Communist party in China for many years. When he came to Canada to work on his master and Ph.D in engineering, he met Jesus Christ. He left university, and came to Seminary to prepare for working with Chinese Mandarin speaking youth. We won't even touch on the persecution of the church in Muslim countries that is vicious right now, nor in Hindu India, which continues its crusade against Christian believers.
So you consigned Jesus to the archeological ruins of time, when in fact, he has been alive and the church has been thriving all the time. As for the "physical" sensation your epiphany included, I find it most interesting your testimony comes on a thread to do with being freed from demon possession. I am not a great believer in blaming the devil for many things, but when it comes to
slamming like a physical object into my consciousness that must have created the physical sensation in my body."
I know I was confronted with a demon a long time ago - I was about 13 at the time. I was not going to church or involved in any way with God at that time. I did rebuke it, in my own way, but my life and beliefs took a huge wrong turn after that.
As Ricky carries on as his signature:
"For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in heavenly places.
Eph. 6:12 KJV"
So another long post!! I hope you will not think I am attacking you after your sincere testimony about your conclusions about God. But I just see some gaping holes, and I think you are in our forum for a reason.
As for my testimony of going from Baptist Sunday school and reading the Bible on my own, to atheism, agnosticism, New Age movement and then born again Christian, well that will have to wait for another day.