S
I have been going through marital issues for some time now. I feel fairly sure I am doing as God would have me to do. However, some recent conversations I have had on this site made me want to get a man's perspective on things. I would appreciate some input from the men out there on the following abbreviated situation.
In April 2013 your wife finds evidence that you have been having an affair for the last year. You tell her you are sorry and that it happened because of the excitement of having someone else want you. You agree to be honest and more open with your wife, to never speak to the other woman again, to never cheat again, and to not make your wife feel bad for questioning you in the future because you broke her trust. After several months you gain her trust back and things are close to normal again.
Then in April 2014, your wife discovers an empty condom wrapper and a bar receipt among the items you recently emptied from your pants pocket. You tell her that you only had dinner at the bar/diner and the condom was something you jokingly threw at a friend. Your wife asks you to call your friend and let her speak to him. She wanted to tell your friend that the two of you had a bet about the other night and she needed him to tell her what you threw at him. You refuse to make the call. You tell her that she should trust you because nothing happened. (FYI: You don't use condoms with your wife, you haven't in over 15 years). Having no concrete proof: your wife lets this slide but is untrusting again.
Then in September 2014, your wife discovers another affair with a different woman. She says she stills loves you but you have to leave. You tell her you love her and want to stay. You will do anything she asks. She doesn't file any legal papers, she allows you to stay at the house when visiting with the kids, the two of you agree on financial arrangements and you move over an hour away.
A couple months later, you tell your wife that you want to come home. She says that before she will consider allowing it, that YOU have to make an appointment for marriage counseling and the two of you must work some things out together in counseling.
What is your perspective, as the husband? How would you feel and react if you were this man, honestly?
I think it is a perfectly reasonable request to make. I think that if the husband truly wants to save his marriage and come home, he should be willing to put his marriage first for once and make the appointment. I think the wife should stand strong. I think that her husband will not change if he doesn't have to face his indiscretions and admit his behavior. His family doesn't even know that he isn't living with his wife and kids. I think he is waiting for the wife to allow him back home, hoping that everything will be the same. He said that he talked to his wife about it and there is no need to talk with anyone else.
So, what do you think? Is the wife being reasonable or unreasonable? Should she stand strong or should she make the appointment herself?
In April 2013 your wife finds evidence that you have been having an affair for the last year. You tell her you are sorry and that it happened because of the excitement of having someone else want you. You agree to be honest and more open with your wife, to never speak to the other woman again, to never cheat again, and to not make your wife feel bad for questioning you in the future because you broke her trust. After several months you gain her trust back and things are close to normal again.
Then in April 2014, your wife discovers an empty condom wrapper and a bar receipt among the items you recently emptied from your pants pocket. You tell her that you only had dinner at the bar/diner and the condom was something you jokingly threw at a friend. Your wife asks you to call your friend and let her speak to him. She wanted to tell your friend that the two of you had a bet about the other night and she needed him to tell her what you threw at him. You refuse to make the call. You tell her that she should trust you because nothing happened. (FYI: You don't use condoms with your wife, you haven't in over 15 years). Having no concrete proof: your wife lets this slide but is untrusting again.
Then in September 2014, your wife discovers another affair with a different woman. She says she stills loves you but you have to leave. You tell her you love her and want to stay. You will do anything she asks. She doesn't file any legal papers, she allows you to stay at the house when visiting with the kids, the two of you agree on financial arrangements and you move over an hour away.
A couple months later, you tell your wife that you want to come home. She says that before she will consider allowing it, that YOU have to make an appointment for marriage counseling and the two of you must work some things out together in counseling.
What is your perspective, as the husband? How would you feel and react if you were this man, honestly?
I think it is a perfectly reasonable request to make. I think that if the husband truly wants to save his marriage and come home, he should be willing to put his marriage first for once and make the appointment. I think the wife should stand strong. I think that her husband will not change if he doesn't have to face his indiscretions and admit his behavior. His family doesn't even know that he isn't living with his wife and kids. I think he is waiting for the wife to allow him back home, hoping that everything will be the same. He said that he talked to his wife about it and there is no need to talk with anyone else.
So, what do you think? Is the wife being reasonable or unreasonable? Should she stand strong or should she make the appointment herself?