You might want some Bactine, because I think I may be about to rub you the wrong way again. lol
I disagree. I think there can be love without forgiveness. Like you said on the other thread, there is something to talking it out before even asking about the forgiveness part, but that's also a two-way street. What if the other person wronged you, you go to her, try to get it straightened out but she wants nothing to do with asking for forgiveness, because she did nothing wrong? (And this is after talking it out, before getting to the point of asking.) Sure, there is a solution to that, if the person is a Christian. (Get two others to join you and try again. And, if that doesn't work, bring the sis to the church and talk it out there. And, if that doesn't work, the sis is no longer a sis, but is to be treated as someone who needs God.) BUT, what if the person isn't a Christian?
Do you think that person should be forgiven anyway, just because? I don't. I haven't seen any scripture that bears that out. AND, that's not to say we don't need to love the person, but there's a distinct difference between love and forgive. Even God expects a confession from us before he forgives us, and he doesn't forgive just anybody, or every single person would be saved.
I could be wrong. Maybe I missed something in the Bible, but I have loved without forgiving, and in that love anger, sourpuss, and the making of Gollum, (LoTR Gollum, since I think he gets his name from a word in the Bible), is adverted, but not through forgiveness.
I've never forgiven the guys who raped me. Never had the chance to talk to them about it, and wouldn't have taken the chance if I had, (unless a couple of sharp shooters were my bodyguards lol), but I have prayed to see them again in heaven, through the same mercy God gave me. That is love, or the best I can do for love considering the obvious.
In like kind I've loved bros who did me wrong, but wouldn't recognize it was wrong to get to the point of freely giving forgiveness. I still consider them bros, still love them, just haven't forgiven them.