Does God Hate The Unsaved?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
G

Gr8grace

Guest
Pre or post the Fall. But since God trandscends time, I'll go brush my teeth.
This is what we can't wrap our brains around. God knew this from eternity past. God knows all and has never learned a thing.

He knows all things and has always known all things. God Does not learn anything and never will. He knows all.

You brush, I will floss!
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
First, I apologize if I am stating what someone else has said . . . I did go back and read a couple pages but not all.

HOW can someone who IS love . . . hate?

Does not "Jacob" and "Esau" represent two nations - Israel and Edom? Can God hate a nation as an enemy? Yes, but IMHO, I do not believe he HATES individuals.

And the children struggled within her: and she said, If it be so, why am I thus? And she went to inquire of the LORD. And the LORD said unto her, Two nations are in thy womb, and two manner of people shall be separated from thy bowels; and the one people [nation] shall be stronger than the other people [nation]; and the elder [Esau (Edom)] shall serve the younger [Jacob (Israel)] . . . Genesis 25:22,23

The burden of the word of the LORD to Israel by Malachi. I have loved you, saith the LORD, Yet ye say, Wherein hast thou loved us? [even after all that God has done for them they still can't see God's love for them!! Amazing!] Was not Esau Jacob;s brother? saith the LORD: yet I loved Jacob - [Israel], And I hated Esau [Edom] and laid his mountains and his heritage waste for the dragons of the wilderness. Whereas Edom . . . . Some of this also was the result/consequences of Esau giving up his birthright.

We can't have this: 1 John 4:16 . . . . God IS LOVE . . . . then have God hating in the same breath. He has to either be love or hate - a house divided cannot stand.

Please note: My opinion only.

What's wrath then?
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,365
6,653
113
God's ways are not man's ways. He is perfectly capable of all, even allowing free will of individuals wo function within the parameters of this age and the laws that goven this age. Yes, time is like viewing a mural for our Father, but do not deceive yourselves, we have free will to choose good over evil. No man is able to change the overall scheme of things as designed by the greatGod of all that is.
Yes, there is a finite number of souls to be saved, but this hardly translates as the number being predesstined. The Father knows when it will Be acheived, and the closer we come to that number, the more demons will be incarnated. Again, this does not negate the working of the freewill of the individual, it underscores it.
 
G

Gr8grace

Guest
Yes, that's the place we see the greatest demonstartion of both God's Love and Wrath.
But Crossnote, what was Gods motive for putting His Son On the Cross? Was it Gods wrath or His Love?
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,742
3,670
113
But Crossnote, what was Gods motive for putting His Son On the Cross? Was it Gods wrath or His Love?
In His Love He punished sin upon His Son for us jerks.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
What put Gods Son on the Cross? Wrath or love?
What happened to Jesus was because of God's wrath. Why Jesus did that was because of God's love.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
God's ways are not man's ways. He is perfectly capable of all, even allowing free will of individuals wo function within the parameters of this age and the laws that goven this age. Yes, time is like viewing a mural for our Father, but do not deceive yourselves, we have free will to choose good over evil. No man is able to change the overall scheme of things as designed by the greatGod of all that is.
Yes, there is a finite number of souls to be saved, but this hardly translates as the number being predesstined. The Father knows when it will Be acheived, and the closer we come to that number, the more demons will be incarnated. Again, this does not negate the working of the freewill of the individual, it underscores it.
Thank God we aren't saved of our own free will, because we'd still be hiding in the darkness to cover up our sin, if we got our will.
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,365
6,653
113
God's ways are not man's ways. The laws of physics for mankind do not limit the Almighty. I was drawn to Jesus Christ by the Father, after I repented of the world in favor of all things God. Perhaps you believe this is not a choice. This is your right as a human thinking.

Remember, whosoever willl to the Lord may come? I believe this. I will not be availablefor the rest of the day so if anyone wishes to comment to me, private messages are welcome, and will await......God bless all who are in Jesus Christ, amen.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
God's ways are not man's ways. The laws of physics for mankind do not limit the Almighty. I was drawn to Jesus Christ by the Father, after I repented of the world in favor of all things God. Perhaps you believe this is not a choice. This is your right as a human thinking.

Remember, whosoever willl to the Lord may come? I believe this. I will not be availablefor the rest of the day so if anyone wishes to comment to me, private messages are welcome, and will await......God bless all who are in Jesus Christ, amen.
Same place I'm getting not-of-free-will from. The whosoever speech by Jesus. You got verse 16. Now read verse 17-21. It covers we hide in the darkness to cover our sins, right after declaring "whosoever will believe."
 

MarcR

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2015
5,486
183
63
sorry, But not sure where you get your hebrew interpretations from.

8533 שָׂנֵא (śā·nē(ʾ)): v.; ≡ Str 8130; TWOT 2272—1. LN 88.198–88.205 (qal) hate, abhor, detest, loathe, be hostile, have a feeling of open hostility and intense dislike (Ge 37:4); (qal pass.) hated (Isa 60:15+); (nif) hated (Pr 14:20+); 2. LN 39.1–39.12 (qal) be an enemy, i.e., be in open hostility and strife with another (Pr 29:24), note: for qal ptcp. as n.masc., see 8533.5; (piel) note: for piel ptcp. as n.masc., see 5383.5; 3. LN 25.33–25.58 (qal) dislike, shun, not love, i.e., have a feeling of lacking of love and compassion for an object, implying a refusal or shunning of relationship (Dt 22:13, 16; 24:3; Pr 11:15; 19:7); (qal pass.) be unloved, loved less than (Ge 29:31, 33; Dt 21:15,16, 17; Pr 30:23+); (nif) unloved, be shunned (Pr 14:17+); 4. LN 13.104–13.163 unit: לֹא שָׂנֵא מִן תְּמוֹל שִׁלְשׁוֹם (lō(ʾ) śā·nē(ʾ) min temôl šil·šôm) without malice aforethought, formally, not hate from the past, i.e., pertaining to something that “just happens” without any intent, so concluded to be an accident (Dt 4:42; 19:4, 6; Jos 20:5+), see also domain LN 30.53–30.55 for its opposite, “intention”

Swanson, J. (1997). Dictionary of Biblical Languages with Semantic Domains : Hebrew (Old Testament) (electronic ed.). Oak Harbor: Logos Research Systems, Inc.

Edom was Gods enemy, they rejected God. that is why in malichi, God spoke of two nations. One he loved, and one he (english translated) hated.

the word enemy, and love less both fit with the word used. as Edom was Gods enemy,

Are you going to sit here and tell me God did not want Edom to repent and turn to him like he did ninevah, if they were willing? is that not the true defenition of love?

H8130
שָׂנֵא
śânê’
BDB Definition:
1) to hate, be hateful
1a) (Qal) to hate
1a1) of man
1a2) of God
1a3) hater, one hating, enemy (participle) (substantive)
1b) (Niphal) to be hated
1c) (Piel) hater (participle)
1c1) of persons, nations, God, wisdom
Part of Speech: verb
A Related Word by BDB/Strong’s Number: a primitive root
Same Word by TWOT Number: 2272
Total KJV Occurrences: 145
hate, 68
Gen_24:60, Gen_26:27, Exo_20:5, Lev_26:17 (2), Num_10:35, Deu_7:9-10 (2), Deu_7:15, Deu_19:11, Deu_22:13, Deu_24:3, Deu_30:7, Deu_32:41, Deu_33:11, Jdg_11:7, Jdg_14:16, 2Sa_22:41, 1Ki_22:8, 2Ch_18:7, 2Ch_19:2, Job_8:22, Psa_9:13, Psa_18:40, Psa_21:8, Psa_25:19, Psa_34:21, Psa_38:19 (2), Psa_41:7, Psa_44:10, Psa_68:1, Psa_69:4, Psa_69:14, Psa_83:2, Psa_86:17, Psa_89:23, Psa_97:10, Psa_101:3, Psa_105:25, Psa_118:7, Psa_119:104, Psa_119:113, Psa_119:128, Psa_119:163, Psa_129:5, Pro_1:21-22 (4), Pro_6:16, Pro_8:13 (2), Pro_8:36, Pro_9:8, Pro_19:7, Pro_25:17, Pro_29:10, Isa_61:8 (2), Jer_44:4, Eze_16:27, Amo_5:10, Amo_5:15, Amo_5:21, Amo_6:8, Mic_3:2, Zec_8:17
hated, 42
Gen_29:31, Gen_29:33, Gen_37:4-5 (2), Gen_37:8, Deu_4:42, Deu_19:4, Deu_19:6, Deu_21:15-17 (4), Jos_20:5, Jdg_15:2, 2Sa_5:8, 2Sa_13:15 (2), 2Sa_13:22, 2Sa_22:18, Est_9:1, Est_9:5, Job_31:29, Psa_18:17, Psa_44:5-7 (3), Psa_55:12, Psa_106:10, Psa_106:41, Pro_1:29, Pro_5:12, Pro_14:17, Pro_14:20, Ecc_2:17-18 (2), Isa_60:15, Isa_66:5, Jer_12:8, Eze_16:37, Eze_35:6, Hos_9:15, Mal_1:3
hateth, 20
Exo_23:5, Deu_7:10, Deu_12:31, Deu_16:22, Job_34:16-17 (2), Psa_120:5-6 (2), Pro_11:15, Pro_12:1, Pro_13:5, Pro_13:24, Pro_15:10, Pro_15:27, Pro_26:24, Pro_26:28, Pro_28:16, Pro_29:24, Isa_1:14, Mal_2:16
hatest, 5
2Sa_19:6, Psa_5:5, Psa_45:7, Psa_50:17, Eze_23:28
enemies, 3
Exo_1:10, 2Sa_19:6, 2Ch_1:11
enemy, 2
Pro_25:21, Pro_27:6
foes, 1
Est_9:16
hateful, 1
Psa_36:2
haters, 1
Psa_81:15
hating, 1
Exo_18:21
odious, 1
Pro_30:23

From BDB via E-Sword all Hebrew entries have been stripped
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
Sorry to take things back a bit but it struck me you cannot love and hate someone. Love appears to be about unrestrained desiring the best of a situations, or a person or of the future. It is the optimistic up side. If there is an upside to something, love will find it and stick with it.

Hate appears to be that thing that turns you away, that you will run from, that nothing freely would make you do such a thing, or be near something, or be positive at all about that thing.

You therefore cannot hate and love someone, but you could love the person but hate how they behave. If unfortunately the behaviour and the person are linked and cannot be separated, then you have to remove the person, because there is no love left, because there is no more upside.

On this basis while there is still time, when people could choose the Lord and love, there is love of people and hope. Once the sin is sealed in there is no more upside, so people are fully rejected and removed.

So while there is hope, the sinner is loved, but once the door is closed, the sinner is rejected or hated.
 

MarcR

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2015
5,486
183
63
Sorry to take things back a bit but it struck me you cannot love and hate someone. Love appears to be about unrestrained desiring the best of a situations, or a person or of the future. It is the optimistic up side. If there is an upside to something, love will find it and stick with it.

Hate appears to be that thing that turns you away, that you will run from, that nothing freely would make you do such a thing, or be near something, or be positive at all about that thing.

You therefore cannot hate and love someone, but you could love the person but hate how they behave. If unfortunately the behaviour and the person are linked and cannot be separated, then you have to remove the person, because there is no love left, because there is no more upside.

On this basis while there is still time, when people could choose the Lord and love, there is love of people and hope. Once the sin is sealed in there is no more upside, so people are fully rejected and removed.

So while there is hope, the sinner is loved, but once the door is closed, the sinner is rejected or hated.
Peter,

That is precisely what I want to believe; but Mal 1:3 simply can't be made to say that without indulging in intellectual dishonesty.

As I said earlier, an inconvenient fact of linguistics is that words do NOT change their meanings to fit our theology.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
Peter,

That is precisely what I want to believe; but Mal 1:3 simply can't be made to say that without indulging in intellectual dishonesty.

As I said earlier, an inconvenient fact of linguistics is that words do NOT change their meanings to fit our theology.

I agree that on the surface it appears God hates an individual.

Yet I have loved Jacob; 3 but I have hated Esau, and I have made his mountains a desolation and appointed his inheritance for the jackals of the wilderness.
Mal 1:3

The phrase is looking back over history and saying, love and hate as extreme versions of blessed and judged or condemned or brought bad things about or in parts of scripture, evil.

Now if God hated the sinner, he would say I hate Esau, but this is I have hated Esau, or I have brought bad things upon the people, and they still will not be blessed but will be judged as wicked.

I therefore do not think this effects the concept of God only loving the sinner while there is still hope.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest

When I use a lexicon, I use Brown, Driver, and Briggs Hebrew and English Lexicon of the of the Old Testament, published by Oxford University Press; However, in this case, I knew the definition and did not use a lexicon.
Since you posted this, I did check BDB; and they agree with me; as I knew they would.

My copy of BDB is in a format that does not copy and paste well.
I use logos bible study, I have access to many lexicons and dictionaries and etc etc..

I posted the possible interpretations of the word. Not sure why we are even arguing.

It does not really matter, Paul quoted an OT passage written by Micah speaking of two nations (not two babies) and he was speaking of his love/hate relationship with those nations. not the two babies of whom their namesake comes. So either way the fatalistic view of romans 9 in that area is incorrect.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Sure chastizing our children whom I love is one thing but murdering them and considering that love gives a whole new definition to love. Do you believe God is loving those He sentenced to the Lake of Fire?
Do you have Scripture for it?
Did he die for them? Does that not prove love? Thats why the power of the cross is so powerfull and why Gods love can never be questioned again!
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I would not say God predestined Adam to fall (infra or sublapsarian..can never get the two straight). Adam was without sin but obviously wasn't perfect otherwise we wouldn't be having this conversation. Scripture doesn't say why he sinned. I could speculate that he would take the fall with Eve, identifying with her sinful state...sorta preview of Christ and His Church.
What do you mean by saying adam was not perfect? Pre-fall or post fall?

I can only think of two things in our conversation which would have given adam the ability to sin.. I can think of no other reason.