Busted: "Sinless" Perfectionists Debunked

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
J

JesusIsAll

Guest
Like parents, we obey because we trust they have always kept their promises.

Trusting because we obey is manipulation. The foundation would be trust me only when I do right. Not biblical
And what is this concept that God will toss His baby in the fire, for throwing food too many times, that He is less loving and patient, less merciful, righteous and forbearing, than we?
 
Jul 22, 2014
10,350
51
0
Yep. You have said it 1000 times it seems, and 1000 times it has been proven to you that that is not true.

All sin in the eyes of God is breaking the law of God. that brings about it a curse. Scripture says even the smallest sin makes us guilty of the whole law.

Now, there are some sins which may not lead to death (a small lie for example) and some sins which may lead to death (get behind the wheel when you had to much to drink and hit a concrete wall, your now dead)

Your context is out of line, your excusing your lesser sins, while judging what you deem more dangerous or evil sins, That is not of God. I judge all sin is evil no matter what it is, no matter who does it, no matter what excuse they make.




Yep he will not. that is why he demands you recieve it, he will not force it on you.

Yet one who receives it, and experiences its joy, will NEVER WILLINGLY give it up. You think they can because you have never experienced it, I am telling man, if you will repent and recieve it, and experience it, only then can you understand where I am coming from.



if your not elect. Your not saved, period. never have been, never will be. period (this is not calvin speaking, this is the word of God speaking)





Oh they can, They can be prodigal children, But the suffering and pain and not to mention chastening of God will not keep them their long (I know I was one)

but they will never stop being Gods child.




yep. because their foundation was on the sand, not in Christ (they were never saved) so the waves and persecution and cares of life tore their building down.

when are you going to realise this?
I believe only those who have root in God's Word are the Elect and they endure in the faith. But that does not mean others were not regenerated and did not endure for a short time and then fell away. A believer can go from a saved state to a lost state. For you cannot say that all believers are going to be saved. That is false to teach that. There are many who have admitted to once following Jesus but they walked away from him. This can be seen even in the Bible.

As for greater and lesser sins: Read 1 John 5:16-18.

Also, how do you ignore Paul's many warnings on sin in the New Testament? He says they that which do such things will not inherit the Kingdom of God. He says, be not deceived. He is talking to the brethren and not unbelievers.

Also, in Revelation 21:8, it says all liars will have their part in the Lake of Fire. All means all. This would include believers, too. They are not allowed to lie.
 
E

ember

Guest
I believe only those who have root in God's Word are the Elect and they endure in the faith. But that does not mean others were not regenerated and did not endure for a short time and then fell away. A believer can go from a saved state to a lost state. For you cannot say that all believers are going to be saved. That is false to teach that. There are many who have admitted to once following Jesus but they walked away from him. This can be seen even in the Bible.

As for greater and lesser sins: Read 1 John 5:16-18.

Also, how do you ignore Paul's many warnings on sin in the New Testament? He says they that which do such things will not inherit the Kingdom of God. He says, be not deceived. He is talking to the brethren and not unbelievers.

Also, in Revelation 21:8, it says all liars will have their part in the Lake of Fire. All means all. This would include believers, too. They are not allowed to lie.
you cannot state that all BELIEVERS are going to be saved?

hellooooo...do you not see the irony in that?

What is a believer to you then? Someone who believes but does not believe as do you?

If that is your judgement, perhaps you may well be judged according to your own words for God says that He will have mercy upon whom He will have mercy

Jesus is our High Priest

Why do we need a High Priest if we never sin?
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
Why the idea of classifying sin fails

Lying. Is lying saying something is not true, or exaguration for effect or painting a picture which is intended for a reason that may be called dis-honest.

You can end up lying in many different ways, to yourself be putting the wrong things as more important than others, as saying something is one way when it is actually another. If you analyse most of language you will find truth is not our primary means of communication but emotional intent.

Now at what point do you say this is sin, or just an incorrect description of what is?

So judging yourself ends up in the same place. Unless you are pure and see correctly you do not know. So we stand alone on grace and trust "the Lord will forgive our sins as we forgive those who sin against us."

So the principle is on us exercising forgiveness, not on knowing we are walking in perfection, which we never can.
It is not that we intend to stay in conscious sin, it is just admiting we are limited frail human beings.

Look as King David, look at Samson, look at Job, all called men of God. They failed and yet were called faithful, followers after Gods heart. The direction of the heart matters more than self understanding and legalism.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
No obedience does come first and the bible clearly teaches this;
Nope. then it would be a gospel of works, and not grace, we would all be under law not grace. why do you place yourself under law?

eph 2: 8-10

we are saved by grace THROUGH FAITH and NOT WORKS. Those who are saved by grace are created to do works and thus do them. (obedience is works my friend)


Point 1) Luke 13:3 - You can not be saved until you first obey the command to repent of your sins, unless repentance is made you will still perish. So you can not perish if you are already saved, so obedience to repent comes before being saved.
Repentance is part of the gospel. it is not a work of man. Get real man, when are you going to prove your point?


Point 2) Acts 5:32 - The bible here states the Holy Spirit is given only to those who obey. So you have to obey the first steps of faith to receive the Holy Spirit who will then guide you in the rest.
Obey the gospel. when are you going to obey the gospel (repent and believe)?

it has nothing do with with doing good works.


Point 3) Salvation - Eternal security and OSAS doctrines teach salvation/eternal life is physically ours right now. The bible says we have hope, assurance, and seek for the receiving of salvation by contending and keeping the faith, and that it is reserved up in heaven for us who continue in the faith.....
I do have hope. If I do not have eternal life (security) I have no hope.

why do you think the bible keeps teaching is we HAVE THIS HOPE. so our faith will never fail us.



Point 4) Eternal security - Started by Augustine in the 4th century (301-399 A.D.) who also taught these falsehoods;

-"Impossibility of falling away or apostasy." (Eternal Security)

(Matthew 24:10-13, 1 Timothy 4:1, and James 5:19-20 refutes this stance)


"Man has no free will."

(Joshua 24:15, Matthew 6:24, Luke 16:13, and Romans 6:16 refutes this stance)


"One cannot know if they are saved."

(1 John chapters 2 through 4 refute this stance)


"God commands impossibilities."

(1 John 5:3 refutes this stance)


"The supreme authority of the Roman church."

(John 16:13, Mark 11:24, and James 1:6 refutes this stance)


"Purgatory."

(Nothing in the bible to even support a purgatory, only scriptures on hell, and the lake of fire)

Prayers for the dead.

(Luke 16:19-31 of the rich man and Lazarus refutes this stance)


The doctrine of eternal security can only be traced back to Augustine and not any further in history studies of the church. Before him this doctrine was not taught anywhere in the early church, and you can clearly see the other falsehoods he taught !!!

dude, I told ya not to bring history into the conversation. Your post proves nothing, My guide is the word of God. not what some long since dead people who did NOT WRITE THE WORD said.

stop listening to men, and listen To God.


If your saved, YOU WILL DO WHAT GOD SAYS.

if your not YOU WILL NOT (because your faith is dead, James)

period. no inbetween,
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Because it is a fragile and broken "faith," what's alarming not representing a saving faith that begins with repentance. These people don't agree with God who and what they are, out of the gate, do not really understand His holiness, even deign to compare themselves to deity. It's pretty sick, actually.
it is because their foundation is in sand, not Christ.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I believe only those who have root in God's Word are the Elect and they endure in the faith. But that does not mean others were not regenerated and did not endure for a short time and then fell away. A believer can go from a saved state to a lost state. For you cannot say that all believers are going to be saved. That is false to teach that. There are many who have admitted to once following Jesus but they walked away from him. This can be seen even in the Bible.


your right, not all who believe will be saved,

it takes true faith in Christ (their foundation)

one whos faith is in christ, can never be crushed, broken, or destroyed.

one who believes in Christ, but does not have faith in Christ, their foundation is in sand, when the things of the world come, they fall away.

they were never saved, period.


As for greater and lesser sins: Read 1 John 5:16-18.

Also, how do you ignore Paul's many warnings on sin in the New Testament? He says they that which do such things will not inherit the Kingdom of God. He says, be not deceived. He is talking to the brethren and not unbelievers.

Also, in Revelation 21:8, it says all liars will have their part in the Lake of Fire. All means all. This would include believers, too. They are not allowed to lie.
Oh you mean like paul. who said the people who do these sins will not inherit the kingdom of God. then follows it by the words "and such were some of you, but you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of Christ.

ok. Nice try.


Adam ate a peace of fruit, and the fall of mankind, and ongoing fall of the world occured, which has been going on for over 6000 years now. ALL of creation on the earth was affected by that one act, eating a peace of fruit.

and you want to tell me not all sin is equal in the eyes of God as far as separating us from him.

no thanks. I bought it growing up when I was tought it, but I started to study for myself. and found it not to be true, not going to fall for that trap again so I can excuse my sin and appear more righteous than I really am.

You continue to do this, thats up to you. but I will not return to the filth of your gospel
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
John 14:23
Jesus answered and said unto him, If a man love me, [obedience]: he will keep my words: and my Father will love him, and [salvation]:we will come unto him, and make our abode with him.
one problem

we love because God loves first, if we are not saved (experienced Gods love) we have no capacity to love God, nor do we have any power to obey his commands.

Again, nice try, but utter failure.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
you cannot state that all BELIEVERS are going to be saved?

hellooooo...do you not see the irony in that?

What is a believer to you then? Someone who believes but does not believe as do you?

If that is your judgement, perhaps you may well be judged according to your own words for God says that He will have mercy upon whom He will have mercy

Jesus is our High Priest

Why do we need a High Priest if we never sin?
you will notice the further they are confronted on their false truths, the further their excuses have to get from reality, and their doctrine starts to fall apart.
 
K

KennethC

Guest
Nope. then it would be a gospel of works, and not grace, we would all be under law not grace. why do you place yourself under law?

eph 2: 8-10

we are saved by grace THROUGH FAITH and NOT WORKS. Those who are saved by grace are created to do works and thus do them. (obedience is works my friend)




Repentance is part of the gospel. it is not a work of man. Get real man, when are you going to prove your point?




Obey the gospel. when are you going to obey the gospel (repent and believe)?

it has nothing do with with doing good works.




I do have hope. If I do not have eternal life (security) I have no hope.

why do you think the bible keeps teaching is we HAVE THIS HOPE. so our faith will never fail us.





dude, I told ya not to bring history into the conversation. Your post proves nothing, My guide is the word of God. not what some long since dead people who did NOT WRITE THE WORD said.

stop listening to men, and listen To God.


If your saved, YOU WILL DO WHAT GOD SAYS.

if your not YOU WILL NOT (because your faith is dead, James)

period. no inbetween,

I just showed you 2 scriptures that shows obedience comes first before and you still rejected them..

So you are saved before you repent of your sins ?

If you answer yes to that then you make Jesus a liar, for He is the one that said if you do not repent you will perish. So a person can not be saved before obeying to repent of their sins. Then Acts clearly says the Holy Spirit is given only to those who obey. What are they obeying ?

To put their trust in the Lord, repent of their sins, and get baptized............Acts 2:38

The bible says we have hope of receiving eternal life by keeping the faith, it does not say we have hope because we already have it.................Please stop flipping around the scriptures to fit your doctrine, as Paul shows many times keeping the faith and building on that foundation comes before one receives salvation. Apostle Peter also states salvation is the ending result of our faith, not the beginning.........1 Peter 1:9

Peter says you receive at the end of your faith the salvation of your souls.

You just like the real history of the early church that shows eternal security was started by a man named Augustine who also taught other fallacies. That is the only reason you did not want history brought in because if proves the doctrine man made and false.

Once again I do not listen to men, as I listen to the Holy Spirit who has guided me to these things to show others who are stuck in this man made doctrine. Men were the ones who guided me eternal security and oSAS, but the Holy Spirit opened my eyes to the Truth and brought me out of the false teaching.....


No my faith is alive and active because the Holy Spirit guides my actions, speech, and walk which is why I stay humble and do not come back with insults, false allegations, and condemning remarks toward others as some have done on here from the doctrine you follow. Instead of debating with me over this subject maybe you should spend time calling out those of the OSAS doctrine on here that act like wolves in sheep clothing. They abuse the faith and make it a license of iniquity, and misuse how to rebuke and reprove others by being condemning in nature.
 
J

JesusIsAll

Guest
you will notice the further they are confronted on their false truths, the further their excuses have to get from reality, and their doctrine starts to fall apart.
It turns into a contradictory wasteland, most telling already mentioned, their claims of having perfection, but not having perfection, this silly "stumble" sins concept they permit only themselves, and oblivious that falling short of the glory of God in just one sin, which our Lord pointed out can be sin in our hearts we've not physically committed: one little sin and you've broken the entire law (James 2:10). Their so-called "doctrines" are quicksand of works salvation, dead works. Their claims of the perfect righteousness of Christ proves them utter frauds, people of the flesh, of self righteousness, not the imputed righteousness of Christ, alone, that saves.
 
K

KennethC

Guest
It turns into a contradictory wasteland, most telling already mentioned, their claims of having perfection, but not having perfection, this silly "stumble" sins concept they permit only themselves, and oblivious that falling short of the glory of God in just one sin, which our Lord pointed out can be sin in our hearts we've not physically committed: one little sin and you've broken the entire law (James 2:10). Their so-called "doctrines" are quicksand of works salvation, dead works. Their claims of the perfect righteousness of Christ proves them utter frauds, people of the flesh, of self righteousness, not the imputed righteousness of Christ, alone, that saves.

Answer this question then;

How does a born again believer overcome and have victory over sin, if every fleeting thought is a sin or everybody continues to sin everyday ???
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
Apostle Peter also states salvation is the ending result of our faith, not the beginning.........1 Peter 1:9
Though you have not seen him, you love him; and even though you do not see him now, you believe in him and are filled with an inexpressible and glorious joy, for you are receiving the end result of your faith, the salvation of your souls.
1 Peter 1:8-9

Kenneth. Peter is telling the believers, they believe and are saved, the fruit of which is love of Jesus, and being filled with an inexpressible and glorious joy in the present.

The order is always, you believe, repent and are filled with the Holy Spirit. That is salvation, being born into the Kingdom here. Your inheritence is stored in heaven, but you are a child now.

Jesus included in the Lords prayer, "Forgive us our sins just as we forgive those who sin against us"
Not because we are perfect, but because we are being sanctified.
And if we reach maturity and walking aright, does that make us proud and boastful? No, because that would be pride and self righteousness. We are forever weak, and in need of the Lord, to have communion, to dwell with Him.

We cannot focus on sin or perfection but on loving from the heart. Anything else and we will sin and fall. So in your attempt to nit-pick and accuse the bretheren of sin, you fail, rather than encouraging people to find ways to execute good works.

I imagine a believer who continually needs cleaning, so that one day, the dirt no longer sticks and the walk is true. But that is hard because we are in the flesh and easily distracted. If this was not so, then we would be law keeps, still under Moses and needing to follow all the commands and be careful to not upset things but always keep our slate clean, but this is self righteousness and claiming I am ok because I have achieved x rather than glorying in the Lord.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I just showed you 2 scriptures that shows obedience comes first before and you still rejected them..


No. Youo did not show me any such passage. Only your twisted view.
So you are saved before you repent of your sins ?

Repent is not a work of obedience, It is Gods work in us, God has to show us his work, so we have the ability to repent.


If you answer yes to that then you make Jesus a liar, for He is the one that said if you do not repent you will perish. So a person can not be saved before obeying to repent of their sins. Then Acts clearly says the Holy Spirit is given only to those who obey. What are they obeying ?

The gospel of Christ, Believe in the name of Jesus and you will be saved, you and your household type of thing. If one has not repented, That can have no faith.

We are not talking about repentance or faith. those are not outward works. We are talking about Obeying Gods commands (law)

To put their trust in the Lord, repent of their sins, and get baptized............Acts 2:38

Oh, now you sadly went off the deep end, You also think one must do the WORK of water baptism to be saved. oh woe is me, your trying to earn your salvation by your deeds. You poor thing, Repent my friend of your self righteous deeds, and come to Christ. Place your foundation in the one who can not be broken (christ) no matter what this world throws against it, and not in yourself (sand)
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Answer this question then;

How does a born again believer overcome and have victory over sin,


By laying their foundation on Christ, By having faith in Christ. By being born of the spirit etc etc etc



if every fleeting thought is a sin or everybody continues to sin everyday ???

well there is your problem, they have not been saved yet, They do not KNOW GOD, nor does God KNOW THEM.

so the first thing they need to do is GET SAVED (repent and trust Jesus)
 
J

JesusIsAll

Guest
Answer this question then;

How does a born again believer overcome and have victory over sin, if every fleeting thought is a sin or everybody continues to sin everyday ???
It's an insulting question, because it has been answered a thousand times around here. Salvation is the righteousness of Christ. This you don't understand, this you reject. You stumble at the Cornerstone, which, in the end, is going to crush you, if you don't repent.

But this vain repetition you indulge in has come down to trolling, as you've been already provided all the answers you reject, too many times. Maybe find another thread to spread your painfully repetitive garbage "gospel" around in and get the attention you crave?
 
E

ember

Guest
you will notice the further they are confronted on their false truths, the further their excuses have to get from reality, and their doctrine starts to fall apart.
yes of course

it's kind of like a kid making up a story and in order for the story to be believable, the child has to add and add to the story until he/she has met himself/herself at the beginning and is not sure how he/she got there

please excuse the equal opportunity gender notations...lest I be accused of having anyone in particular in mind and therefore maligning them and therefore giving yet more fodder to the fake fire of persecution through questioning their sacred word which is sacroscant and on par with the Holy Spirit manifesting through the teaching herein identified by its support of the ability to earn one's salvation and having done so, to keep it even though an entire nation who met God almost face to face, was unable to do so
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
It turns into a contradictory wasteland, most telling already mentioned, their claims of having perfection, but not having perfection, this silly "stumble" sins concept they permit only themselves, and oblivious that falling short of the glory of God in just one sin, which our Lord pointed out can be sin in our hearts we've not physically committed: one little sin and you've broken the entire law (James 2:10). Their so-called "doctrines" are quicksand of works salvation, dead works. Their claims of the perfect righteousness of Christ proves them utter frauds, people of the flesh, of self righteousness, not the imputed righteousness of Christ, alone, that saves.
they are hypocrites, they tell us we excuse our sin, when it is THEY who excuse their own sin, or deny they have any sin at all.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
yes of course

it's kind of like a kid making up a story and in order for the story to be believable, the child has to add and add to the story until he/she has met himself/herself at the beginning and is not sure how he/she got there

please excuse the equal opportunity gender notations...lest I be accused of having anyone in particular in mind and therefore maligning them and therefore giving yet more fodder to the fake fire of persecution through questioning their sacred word which is sacroscant and on par with the Holy Spirit manifesting through the teaching herein identified by its support of the ability to earn one's salvation and having done so, to keep it even though an entire nation who met God almost face to face, was unable to do so

amen, and I need to start gender neutrality myself.
 
Feb 21, 2012
3,794
199
63
Because you are looking at the Scriptures with a certain biased that ignores the verse that I just put forth. If you do what Christ says it will be as if you built your house upon the rock. If you do not do so, then you are building your house upon shaky ground. So how can your house stand if you do not do what Jesus says? For when you build, the foundation must be Jesus Christ. Jesus is the Rock. And doing what Jesus says is a part of building on a solid foundation. If you do not do what Jesus says, then you are making a Jesus of your own imagining.
Well, I could say the same about you - looking at Scriptures with a certain bias.

In my post I addressed 1 Cor. 3 . . . You brought up building our house upon a firm foundation . . . which is basically what I had said anyway by saying - Our foundation is Jesus Christ. So now you go further explaining it when 1 Cor. 3 did just as good a job . . . My Jesus is my advocate, My Jesus died for me and rose so that I could have eternal life . . . simple gospel truth.

At least we can agree - Jesus Christ is our firm foundation, our Rock and our Savior.