is Smoking a sin?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
D

dane_g87

Guest
You err in your doctrine of justification because you know nothing about the doctrine of regeneration.
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
Truly Coming to Christ involves faith in His sacrifice alone for the grounds of your justification and repentance from all that contradicts the law, nature, and will of God. You have not repented of your sins in full - only in part. You've only picked and chosen what you want to repent from. You do not live a life marked by repentance and faith. Jesus preached the necessity and prescribed the outlines of His living functioning church. You claim you believe, but you have no more belief than a demon. Because if you truly believed in Jesus, you would believe in His words and you would love Him and obey Him. Jesus ordained His church, and you refuse to enter it.
You should have taken my advice yesterday, it was good advice, believe me.
 
D

dane_g87

Guest
(1 Timothy 5:17) Let the elders who rule well be counted worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in the word and doctrine. For the Scripture says, “You shall not muzzle an ox while it treads out the grain,” and, “The laborer is worthy of his wages.”

How are you to count the elders worthy of double honor, and how are you to support them with their wages, if you refuse to join a church? You are in opposition to Spurgeon and Paul the apostle.
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
I am very grateful for you posting this from Spurgeon, very grateful indeed vDane, thank you. Faith brings obediance, that is what Spurgeon says. I am now going to list wo4rd for word some of your comments in this debate. I cannot be accused of making anything up.

It isw one of striving and struggling. If a person is not struggling against sin they must be corrected.

We are commanded to put to death the deeds of the body.

I do not believe anyone can keep the law of God in any degree pleasing to God. I believe firmly that each and everyone of us including myself fails God miserably and breaks each and every one of of his commandments each day

Those whom God saves he causes them to walk in his statutes and they are from that point onward careful to keep his ordinances. This is what you are seeing in me and my striving.

Now by this we know that we know Him if we keep his commandments He who says I know Him and does not5 keep His commandments is a liar

Am I wrong or lying when I say I break the commandments of God daily

I do not have the capacity to keep any of His commandments perfectly.

We are unable to detect the hidden sin deep within our being
But the Holy Spirit reveals it to us!

My issue has been regarding what happens aftyer Gode saves a person and the new creation God makes him into. My issue concerns what a person becomes as a result of the grace of God. The changes God has wrought in his heart.

I am too wicked. I have a sinful nature and my heart is deceitfully wicked

These are all word for word your statements Dane. Conflicting statements. You say that Spurgeon says faith brings obediance. Are your statements proof of your obediance?

On the one hand you quote John to say ifd we do not keep the commandments and say we know Him(Jesus) we are a liar. You then say you break all the commandments. I believe by your own statements you have shown muddled theology at best, and a very confused Christian theology.
 
D

dane_g87

Guest
According to Scripture, the true believer:
- Delights in the law of God
- Meditates on the law of God
- does the will of God
- obeys the commandments of God
- practices righteousness
- confesses their sins
- believes in the atonement of Christ for justification alone
- pursues peace and holiness

I have stated all of these; you have rejected that. Clearly I am the one here who is scriptural. The Bible commands us not to forsake the fellowship of the saints, to support and honor the elders, and to bear one another's burdens. You said yourself that you refuse to join a church. In the Bible Paul said he "would not be enslaved by anything" and yet you willfully continue in your enslaved bondage to smoking.
 
D

dane_g87

Guest
If Paul said that he would not be enslaved to anything, why haven't you struggled to be freed from being enslaved to smoking?
If the Bible commands us not to forsake the fellowship of saints, why do you refuse to join the fellowship of saints?
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
No. I'm afraid there is a law that has far exceeded the law of Moses. And that is the law of Christ. The law of God, in general, is the mind of God by which He judges certain things to be righteous and just, and others to be unrighteous and corrupt. What God deems good or bad is the delight of any child of God. In the Old Covenant, since God ordained the law of Moses, the saints loved the law and it was their delight. In the New Covenant, Christ has ordained His law that fulfills and surpasses the law of Moses, and it is the delight of the children of God.

The law of Moses forbade murder but not hatred.
The law of Moses forbade adultery but not lust.
The law of Moses allowed divorce and polygamy.
The law of Moses required 10%.
The law of Moses required a Levitical priesthood.
The law of Moses required animal sacrifices.
The law of Moses required sabbath observance.
The law of Moses required circumcision.

The law of Christ forbids hatred and murder.
The law of Christ forbids lust and adultery.
The law of Christ does not allow for divorce (except in the case of infidelity) or polygamy
The law of Christ requires 100%.
The law of Christ establishes the church as the priesthood.
The law of Christ establishes Christ as the ultimate sacrifice.
The law of Christ establishes complete rest and peace in Christ with God.
The law of Christ requires spiritual circumcision of the heart.
This post contradicts Spurgeon as it is pretty clear you are saying we are under law for condemnatioon. I agree with Spurgeon, we are not. And according to Paul that is not the law of Christ he was under
 
Last edited:
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
If Paul said that he would not be enslaved to anything, why haven't you struggled to be freed from being enslaved to smoking?
Lol, desperate or what. I would be more cxoncerned about yourself breaking all of god's commandments if I was you, rather than worrying about my smoking
 
D

dane_g87

Guest
I have said, as Paul, that we are under the law of Christ. I then said being under the law of Christ is not the same as being under the law of Moses. Being under the law of Moses means you have to satisfy the demands of the law, and being under the law of Christ means the opposite - the demands have been satisfied in Christ alone. Being under the law is believing in Christ and obeying Him from the heart on the basis of love - "If you love Me, keep my commandments."
 
D

dane_g87

Guest
I told you that I am not able to keep the commandments of God perfectly. God does not require perfect obedience otherwise no one would be going to Heaven. The difference between you and I is that I repent from my sins. God requires repentance. "Unless you repent, you will all likewise perish" Luke 13:3. You refuse to repent - you are still in your sins.
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
I have said, as Paul, that we are under the law of Christ. I then said being under the law of Christ is not the same as being under the law of Moses. Being under the law of Moses means you have to satisfy the demands of the law, and being under the law of Christ means the opposite - the demands have been satisfied in Christ alone. Being under the law is believing in Christ and obeying Him from the heart on the basis of love - "If you love Me, keep my commandments."
Do you really believe people will accept this answer? If they read the whole post including what you wrote at the top I am pretty sure it will become evident that for you this is a law we can be condemned for
 
D

dane_g87

Guest
So in all reality you are not living by grace because you fail to realize that the grace of God does not allow us to live lives disregarding His law...the grace of God frees us from the bondage of sin so that we may serve Him according to His law!
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
And this is Hios command to believe in the name of His son Jesus Christ and to love one another as he commanded us 1John3:23

Carry each others burdens and in this way you will fulfill the law of Christ Gal6:2

I would say there is an agreement there.

You know Dane it is a very dangerous thing to add to scripture be careful!
 
D

dane_g87

Guest
Read the sermon on the mount - there are boatloads of commandments there too. Jesus declared that if you continue lusting you will go to Hell; if you continue to hate, you will go to Hell. Jesus said only those who do the will of God will enter Heaven, and those who practice lawlessness will be thrust into Hell. He said those who are wise are those who hear His word and do it. James declared that faith without works is dead. John said the one who does not practice righteousness is a child of the devil. The writer of Hebrews commanded us not to forsake the fellowship of saints, and that if we continue sinning after knowing the truth, the only thing awaiting us is the fiery judgment of God. Paul said no adulterer, fornicator, homosexual, idolater will go to Heaven. He also said that those who practice uncleanness, lewdness, jealousies, outbursts of wrath, envy, drunkenness, will not inherit the kingdom of God (Galatians 5:19-21). As you can see, far more commandments to be acknowledged than what you've laid out on the table there living!
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
No. I'm afraid there is a law that has far exceeded the law of Moses. And that is the law of Christ. The law of God, in general, is the mind of God by which He judges certain things to be righteous and just, and others to be unrighteous and corrupt. What God deems good or bad is the delight of any child of God. In the Old Covenant, since God ordained the law of Moses, the saints loved the law and it was their delight. In the New Covenant, Christ has ordained His law that fulfills and surpasses the law of Moses, and it is the delight of the children of God.

The law of Moses forbade murder but not hatred.
The law of Moses forbade adultery but not lust.
The law of Moses allowed divorce and polygamy.
The law of Moses required 10%.
The law of Moses required a Levitical priesthood.
The law of Moses required animal sacrifices.
The law of Moses required sabbath observance.
The law of Moses required circumcision.

The law of Christ forbids hatred and murder.
The law of Christ forbids lust and adultery.
The law of Christ does not allow for divorce (except in the case of infidelity) or polygamy
The law of Christ requires 100%.
The law of Christ establishes the church as the priesthood.
The law of Christ establishes Christ as the ultimate sacrifice.
The law of Christ establishes complete rest and peace in Christ with God.
The law of Christ requires spiritual circumcision of the heart.
Carry erach others burdens and in this way you will fulfill the law of Christ Gal6:2

And this is His command to believe in the name of His son Jesus Christ and to love one another. 1John3:23

That sounds an accord to me Dane

Be careful, adding to scripture is viewed as a grave error

And this post contradicts Spurgeon, who I am in agreement with on this issue
 
Last edited:
D

dane_g87

Guest
Why do you run from legitimate Scriptures?

Read the sermon on the mount - there are boatloads of commandments there too. Jesus declared that if you continue lusting you will go to Hell; if you continue to hate, you will go to Hell. Jesus said only those who do the will of God will enter Heaven, and those who practice lawlessness will be thrust into Hell. He said those who are wise are those who hear His word and do it. James declared that faith without works is dead. John said the one who does not practice righteousness is a child of the devil. The writer of Hebrews commanded us not to forsake the fellowship of saints, and that if we continue sinning after knowing the truth, the only thing awaiting us is the fiery judgment of God. Paul said no adulterer, fornicator, homosexual, idolater will go to Heaven. He also said that those who practice uncleanness, lewdness, jealousies, outbursts of wrath, envy, drunkenness, will not inherit the kingdom of God (Galatians 5:19-21). As you can see, far more commandments to be acknowledged than what you've laid out on the table there living!
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
Why do you run from legitimate Scriptures?

Read the sermon on the mount - there are boatloads of commandments there too. Jesus declared that if you continue lusting you will go to Hell; if you continue to hate, you will go to Hell. Jesus said only those who do the will of God will enter Heaven, and those who practice lawlessness will be thrust into Hell. He said those who are wise are those who hear His word and do it. James declared that faith without works is dead. John said the one who does not practice righteousness is a child of the devil. The writer of Hebrews commanded us not to forsake the fellowship of saints, and that if we continue sinning after knowing the truth, the only thing awaiting us is the fiery judgment of God. Paul said no adulterer, fornicator, homosexual, idolater will go to Heaven. He also said that those who practice uncleanness, lewdness, jealousies, outbursts of wrath, envy, drunkenness, will not inherit the kingdom of God (Galatians 5:19-21). As you can see, far more commandments to be acknowledged than what you've laid out on the table there living!
Lol run from scripture, you ignored loads of mine because they didn't fit in with what you choose to believe which directly goes against Spurgeon by the way, as shown in your post on the lasw of Christ
 
D

dane_g87

Guest
If it is true that I have neglected your posts, why do you feel it is right for you to do the same? If I have truly been neglecting you, why would you return the same back? Are you not 50 or so years old? Do you not have more maturity to lead by example?
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
Why do you run from legitimate Scriptures?

Read the sermon on the mount - there are boatloads of commandments there too. Jesus declared that if you continue lusting you will go to Hell; if you continue to hate, you will go to Hell. Jesus said only those who do the will of God will enter Heaven, and those who practice lawlessness will be thrust into Hell. He said those who are wise are those who hear His word and do it. James declared that faith without works is dead. John said the one who does not practice righteousness is a child of the devil. The writer of Hebrews commanded us not to forsake the fellowship of saints, and that if we continue sinning after knowing the truth, the only thing awaiting us is the fiery judgment of God. Paul said no adulterer, fornicator, homosexual, idolater will go to Heaven. He also said that those who practice uncleanness, lewdness, jealousies, outbursts of wrath, envy, drunkenness, will not inherit the kingdom of God (Galatians 5:19-21). As you can see, far more commandments to be acknowledged than what you've laid out on the table there living!
Maybe one day you will understand

Rom6:14

Rom3:31

Rom7:5-11 and a host more
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
If it is true that I have neglected your posts, why do you feel it is right for you to do the same? If I have truly been neglecting you, why would you return the same back? Are you not 50 or so years old? Do you not have more maturity to lead by example?
I do not understand most of this post. I am 51 by the way. I have stayed in this debate due to my concern at your errancy in scripture. The truth of the Bible must be put alongside your wrtong theology