Paul was referring to those who were going back to 'works of the law'. He is not talking about 'good works' that only one bearing fruit can 'do'.
But here is what you actually said:
If you mean that Faith + works righteousness does not save any one then yes I agree. I have already stated my belief on that.. By grace alone, through Faith alone, in Christ alone.
As I said, I agree with most of what you say, I believe your problem is that you fail to differentiate between any sort of work or deed. You think that when I say we need to be doing good work's/deed's that I am referring to my own power for salvation. that is wrong.. Again I don't see how you think I am taking James out of context.
Faith without deed's is a dead faith. I also know there are others who think faith and works go hand in hand for regeneration, this is wrong and unscriptural. Only Jesus can save, and once we are saved, even our good deed's don't save...However the changed man will do good deed's.. If he doesn't that faith may be a dead faith for there is no obedience..that is exactly Jame's point.
I have just 2 questions to illustrate a further point
1. Who does your good deed's ?
2. when you sin, who is doing that?
Oh BTW DiscipleDave if your reading this, the above 2 questions answers your erroneous bad tree/good tree analogy. Those who are saved are ''good trees' that bear good fruit by the power of the Holy Spirit, and yet by the very nature of man we still have the remnant of the Old sin nature, that's what we fight (Flesh). A bad tree can 'only' bear bad fruit, meaning it is evil. A good tree can only bear good fruit because it is 'Good', it may have mishapen branches and some fruit goes bad, but it is at it essence Good.. The bad tree is always evil.
If we read some of these posts, people seem to be saying..it's the Holy Spirit doing all the work, when its Good, and then say when its sin it's the flesh... no one seems to realise that you are one man. not and idle sofa sitter spectating a good and evil battle going on as you watch the latest film. Stand firm and do!
The Holy Spirit enables you and prompts you to do good deeds; you intellectually and physically still have to do them. and it is all by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ only!
The scriptural warning is that faith without works is a dead faith! It seems that people don't like to be obedient to anyone, because that sounds like works!! and others seem to think their obedience saves them, work righteousness.
But here is what you actually said:
If you mean that Faith + works righteousness does not save any one then yes I agree. I have already stated my belief on that.. By grace alone, through Faith alone, in Christ alone.
As I said, I agree with most of what you say, I believe your problem is that you fail to differentiate between any sort of work or deed. You think that when I say we need to be doing good work's/deed's that I am referring to my own power for salvation. that is wrong.. Again I don't see how you think I am taking James out of context.
Faith without deed's is a dead faith. I also know there are others who think faith and works go hand in hand for regeneration, this is wrong and unscriptural. Only Jesus can save, and once we are saved, even our good deed's don't save...However the changed man will do good deed's.. If he doesn't that faith may be a dead faith for there is no obedience..that is exactly Jame's point.
I have just 2 questions to illustrate a further point
1. Who does your good deed's ?
2. when you sin, who is doing that?
Oh BTW DiscipleDave if your reading this, the above 2 questions answers your erroneous bad tree/good tree analogy. Those who are saved are ''good trees' that bear good fruit by the power of the Holy Spirit, and yet by the very nature of man we still have the remnant of the Old sin nature, that's what we fight (Flesh). A bad tree can 'only' bear bad fruit, meaning it is evil. A good tree can only bear good fruit because it is 'Good', it may have mishapen branches and some fruit goes bad, but it is at it essence Good.. The bad tree is always evil.
If we read some of these posts, people seem to be saying..it's the Holy Spirit doing all the work, when its Good, and then say when its sin it's the flesh... no one seems to realise that you are one man. not and idle sofa sitter spectating a good and evil battle going on as you watch the latest film. Stand firm and do!
The Holy Spirit enables you and prompts you to do good deeds; you intellectually and physically still have to do them. and it is all by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ only!
The scriptural warning is that faith without works is a dead faith! It seems that people don't like to be obedient to anyone, because that sounds like works!! and others seem to think their obedience saves them, work righteousness.
NONE good NO NOT ONE, There is NOT a just man on the earth that does GOOD and sins not....
If the works of the law will not help one be saved.....you can bet that the works of the flesh which are not GOOD will not help one be saved......
WORKS are WORKS are WORKS.....they will not facilitate, help or add to one's salvation that they ALREADY possess by FAITH.......YOU or I cannot EMBELLISH our salvation and or HELP in our SALVATION....that is entirely the WORK of JESUS!