Help a Catholic understand Protestantism better please

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
Incorrect doctrine? Oh, and here comes another straw man argument. I have forgiven, but I will not apologize for defending the truth and exposing the false teachings of Roman Catholicism.
Strawman? Wow. You know all the terms.

YOU HATE THE CATHOLIC CHURCH.

Why not just admit it.

Stop posting incorrect doctrine and saying things that are NOT TRUE.

Maybe I should start saying some things that are not true about Protestants and see how YOU like it.

JESUS meant for all HIS people to be as one.

Catholics do NOT hate Protestants
But Protestants DO HATE Catholics.

Once again we find those doing GOOD being called EVIL
And those doing EVIL feeling they are GOOD.

If it weren't so sad it would be funny.
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
This is hilarious. You come here pretending you want to better understand what we believe except you find it so offensive to be presented with the many errors and perversions of Catholicism plus your own bad attitude, you resort to further pretending we do not understand Catholicism but you do LOLOLOL. Like the other Lying Catholic defender, telling us that Catholics are not told to pray to Mary, when the whole month of May is devoted to corporate prayers to Mary. If you want to engage in dialogue you must stop being so dishonest.
Once again Magenta, You've been very nice and ladylike to a newcomer.
It's a darn good thing not everyone here is like you.

Why don't you calm down and try to be like the Christian you claim to be.

Too difficult, huh?

WimpyPete has been very nice.
More so than you deserve.

I DO HOPE HE STOPS TALKING TO YOU AND NOTUPTOME.

Nothing gained from speaking to either of you --- a waste of time.
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
This is hilarious. You come here pretending you want to better understand what we believe except you find it so offensive to be presented with the many errors and perversions of Catholicism plus your own bad attitude, you resort to further pretending we do not understand Catholicism but you do LOLOLOL. Like the other Lying Catholic defender, telling us that Catholics are not told to pray to Mary, when the whole month of May is devoted to corporate prayers to Mary. If you want to engage in dialogue you must stop being so dishonest.
PLEASE PRAY TO SOMEBODY!!!!

ANYBODY!!!!!
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
Amen! Jesus is the Bread of Life. Just as bread nourishes our physical bodies, Jesus gives and sustains eternal life to all believers. "I am the bread of life. He who comes to Me shall never hunger, and he who believes in Me shall never thirst." (John 6:35) Jesus used figurative language to emphasize these great spiritual truths. Jesus explains the sense of the entire passage when He says, "It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh profits nothing. The words that I speak to you are spirit, and they are life." (John 6:63)

The literal interpretation is absurd, leading to cannibalism and the drinking of blood contrary to the commandment of God. No eating of any flesh can give spiritual life. By faith we partake of Christ, and the benefits of His bodily sacrifice on the cross and the merits of His shed blood, receiving and enjoying eternal life. Eating and drinking is not with the mouth and the digestive organs of our bodies, but the reception of God’s grace by believing in Christ, as He makes abundantly clear by repeating the same truths both in metaphoric and plain language. Compare for example the following two verses:

"Most assuredly, I say to you, he who believes in Me has everlasting life" (John 6:47).

"He who eats this bread will live forever" (John 6:58).

"He who believes" in Christ is equivalent to "he who eats this bread" and as we can see, the result is the same, eternal life. Also notice the parallel in verses 40 and 54:

"Everyone who sees the Son and believes in Him may have everlasting life; and I will raise him up at the last day" (John 6:40).

"Whoever eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day (John 6:54).

John 6 does not afford any support to the false Roman Catholic doctrine of transubstantiation. On the contrary, it is an emphatic statement on the primacy of faith as the means by which we receive the grace of God. Jesus is the Bread of Life; we eat of Him and are satisfied when we believe in Him.

Bread represents the "staff of life." Sustenance. That which is essential to sustain life. Just as bread or sustenance is necessary to maintain physical life, Jesus is all the sustenance necessary for spiritual life.

The source of physical life is blood -- "life is in the blood." As with the bread, just as blood is the empowering or source of life physically, Jesus is all the source of spiritual life necessary.
LOL


You seem to like Greek.

Please tell us all what the word EAT means in John 6:54

THANK YOU.
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
Hmmmm.

I doubt you'll be able to.
Just like you cannot seem to be able to explain what BELIEVE means.

Wonder Why?
Guess it doesn't suit you.
 

Zen

Senior Member
Sep 11, 2015
752
16
18
Strawman? Wow. You know all the terms.

YOU HATE THE CATHOLIC CHURCH.

Why not just admit it.

Stop posting incorrect doctrine and saying things that are NOT TRUE.

Maybe I should start saying some things that are not true about Protestants and see how YOU like it.

JESUS meant for all HIS people to be as one.

Catholics do NOT hate Protestants
But Protestants DO HATE Catholics.

Once again we find those doing GOOD being called EVIL
And those doing EVIL feeling they are GOOD.

If it weren't so sad it would be funny.
It's true that Lord Jesus' teachings are for Catholics too. But what are we supposed to do when they insist on worshiping "Queen of the Universe"? Their religion is not from God, it's backwards. And they get offended when we point it out.

They talk about men as authors and quote them, when it has nothing to do with God.

It's like Muslims and their idol worship, what are we supposed to do about it? How do you convert someone that their parents raised in that religion who has no interest in the truth?

How are we supposed to tell Catholics that we have a relationship with God when they do not have this frame of reference? They look at the words but they don't understand. They want to know why we don't revere the pope or follow their strange pagan religion.

Notice his initial posts in this thread, he said he can't understand why we don't agree with him. Well I can't understand why people worship idols and put the words and traditions of men above God. *shrug*

Amos 3:3
Can two walk together, except they be agreed?
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,001
26,138
113
God several times throughout Scripture says He will not share
His glory,while Catholics glorify, venerate, and adore Mary.

Jesus did not once in Scripture address Mary as His mother,
but Catholics call her the mother of humanity, and as if that
were not enough, the queen of heaven and the second Eve.

Jesus said that anyone who did the will of God was His mother,
His brother, His sister. Jesus never elevated Mary above others,
but Catholics feel a need to not just elevate Mary above others,
but they put her on a par with Jesus in terms of His sinlessness.

They are forced by so-called infallible papal decree to accept the
Marian dogmas of her bodily assumption and immaculate conception,
neither of which have any basis whatsoever in Scripture.

Jesus told us to pray to our Father in heaven, yet they pray to Mary,
because their popes tell them to despite what Jesus explicitly instructed.

Scripture clearly states that there is one intercessor between God and man,
yet their popes, bishops, priests, parishioners etc, will tell you to pray to Mary,
and other dead people, for intercession. They fault those who do as Jesus
suggested/directed, while they disobey Him to follow someone else instead.

We see nothing in Scripture to endorse her bodily assumption, her perpetual
virginity (Jesus had siblings after all, two of whom have books in the Bible!),
her immaculate conception. We see no need to pray to her, or any ability on
her part, as dead as she is believed to be, to intercede on our behalf against
the explicit words of Jesus in Scripture.

Within Catholicism, there is a drive to define a new Marian dogma in which
Catholics, as a matter of faith, would be obliged to accept: 1) Mary participates
in redemption with Jesus Christ; 2) grace is granted by Jesus only through
the intercession of Mary; and 3) all prayers from the faithful must flow
through Mary, who brings them to the attention of her Son.

Scripture also tells us not to call anyone Father but God, while they call many
men "father" and blindly follow them. They believe that a fallible man is the
Rock that Jesus is building His Church on, not a confession of faith divinely
inspired by the Holy Spirit of God, despite a plethora of Scriptures that attest
to the fact that God is the sole Rock of our salvation.

They teach purgatory, and many other things neither the apostles nor Jesus
ever taught. For instance, they claim priests must be celibate, when they were
not in the early church. They burned people at the stake for daring to read the
Bible, which is what Scripture tells us to do. Despite all this, and many more
abuses, the RCC considered herself the only valid expression of the community of God.

These are FACTS, not misunderstandings :)
 
W

WimpyPete

Guest
Hi WP

You're new here.

Regarding what I highlighted above.

Do yourself a favor and don't dialog with either one,
or with anyone who is not only NOT willing to LISTEN,
but is so prejudiced they cannot even HEAR.

Blessings
Heh, thanks Fran. I apprecaite your willingness to understand us on our own terms
 

mailmandan

Senior Member
Apr 7, 2014
25,047
13,056
113
58
Strawman? Wow. You know all the terms.

YOU HATE THE CATHOLIC CHURCH.

Why not just admit it.

Stop posting incorrect doctrine and saying things that are NOT TRUE.

Maybe I should start saying some things that are not true about Protestants and see how YOU like it.

JESUS meant for all HIS people to be as one.

Catholics do NOT hate Protestants
But Protestants DO HATE Catholics.

Once again we find those doing GOOD being called EVIL
And those doing EVIL feeling they are GOOD.

If it weren't so sad it would be funny.
You only see and believe what you want to see and believe and your straw man arguments are ridiculous. Again, I will not apologize for defending the truth and exposing the false teachings of Roman Catholicism.
 

mailmandan

Senior Member
Apr 7, 2014
25,047
13,056
113
58
Hmmmm.

I doubt you'll be able to.
Just like you cannot seem to be able to explain what BELIEVE means.

Wonder Why?
Guess it doesn't suit you.
I could explain the truth to you until I'm blue in the face but you just won't get it, as you have already demonstrated on numerous occasions. BYY I already explained to you what BELIEVE means, but you rejected the truth and preferred the Roman Catholic definition of "believe" which is infused with works.
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
It's true that Lord Jesus' teachings are for Catholics too. But what are we supposed to do when they insist on worshiping "Queen of the Universe"? Their religion is not from God, it's backwards. And they get offended when we point it out.

They talk about men as authors and quote them, when it has nothing to do with God.

It's like Muslims and their idol worship, what are we supposed to do about it? How do you convert someone that their parents raised in that religion who has no interest in the truth?

How are we supposed to tell Catholics that we have a relationship with God when they do not have this frame of reference? They look at the words but they don't understand. They want to know why we don't revere the pope or follow their strange pagan religion.

Notice his initial posts in this thread, he said he can't understand why we don't agree with him. Well I can't understand why people worship idols and put the words and traditions of men above God. *shrug*
You certainly cannot do it the way some here try to.
it turns the person totally to the off position.

And you call Catholicism pagan. That's terrible! We may not agree with their doctrine, that does not make that Church pagan.

Let's see if I can go through your question since you seem serious.

If Jesus was God, and the first Church was called The Way (Acts) and then called Catholic (in Antioch) meaning Universal since it was the only Church and was being spread thought the known "universe" (world) could we not safely assume that this universal or Catholic Church believed in GOD? Was Jesus God or not??

We really should learn about apostolic succession. We may not agree with it, but it's A HISTORICAL fact. It cannot be denied.
It makes us look DUMB to deny it.

Mary came on the scene later and was not really a part of the beginnings of the Church. By this I Always mean PRIOR to Constantine declarin it the State Religion. This is when all the trouble began. It was very pure before that.

So they wanted to Honor Mary. They still Honor her much more than we do and maybe tooo much. So? It's the mother of our Lord. He loved her as His mother. They go over board, I agree, so are we to say they're not Christian?

Christian means one believes in CHRIST. Cathlics believe in Christ.
I was at a bible study of theirs just a few weeks ago and Galatians 2:16 was brought up by the Deacon to explain to some older folk that it's not our WORKS that save us but our belief in God. The older folk are having a bit of a problem understanding this because it was never taught before. However, salvation was still theirs if they loved Jesus because it's Jesus that saves, not some doctrine.

Priests KNOW that it's not enough to be "good". They know we have to have a relationship with Jesus. They know God is love.
There is not enough teaching in the Catholic Church. This is a problem.

If you want to witness to someone Catholic, just tell them about Jesus and the plan of salvation. No need to put down the Church they were raised in. And if they STAY in the Church? There's a prominant Protestant, can't think of his name right now,
that became Orthodox about two months ago. Should we ssend him to hell too? We're all brothers in Christ, and we should treat each other as such.

As far as the Pope goes, this could use its own thread. In a way, it's not wrong. He keeps the religion together. Look at us...
33,000 churches, incl the non-denominationals. It's becoming rediculous.

Catholics do not worship IDOLS. Please let's stop saying this.

There are some here who have had bad experiences in that Church and cannot forget them.

Jesus said to forgive each other and our enemies.
We should be doing this.

No Church is perfect...
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
I could explain the truth to you until I'm blue in the face but you just won't get it, as you have already demonstrated on numerous occasions. BYY I already explained to you what BELIEVE means, but you rejected the truth and preferred the Roman Catholic definition of "believe" which is infused with works.
MMD

THERE IS ONLY ONE definition for believe.
Is there more than one Koinè Greek Language?

You've NEVER explained believe because to do so would go against all you say about how works are not NECESSARY.
When, in fact, they are.

And YOU don't have to explain the truth to me MMD.

I believe I know the truth.
And it's not what YOU teach.
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
You only see and believe what you want to see and believe and your straw man arguments are ridiculous. Again, I will not apologize for defending the truth and exposing the false teachings of Roman Catholicism.
Isn't this, LIKE, what YOU do???

What truth are you defending? You don't know the truth.

You don't even know what's going on in the Catholic Church.


Try going to some bible studies of theirs so you could speak as one who knows
what he's talking about....
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
God several times throughout Scripture says He will not share
His glory,while Catholics glorify, venerate, and adore Mary.

Jesus did not once in Scripture address Mary as His mother,
but Catholics call her the mother of humanity, and as if that
were not enough, the queen of heaven and the second Eve.

Jesus said that anyone who did the will of God was His mother,
His brother, His sister. Jesus never elevated Mary above others,
but Catholics feel a need to not just elevate Mary above others,
but they put her on a par with Jesus in terms of His sinlessness.

They are forced by so-called infallible papal decree to accept the
Marian dogmas of her bodily assumption and immaculate conception,
neither of which have any basis whatsoever in Scripture.

Jesus told us to pray to our Father in heaven, yet they pray to Mary,
because their popes tell them to despite what Jesus explicitly instructed.

Scripture clearly states that there is one intercessor between God and man,
yet their popes, bishops, priests, parishioners etc, will tell you to pray to Mary,
and other dead people, for intercession. They fault those who do as Jesus
suggested/directed, while they disobey Him to follow someone else instead.

We see nothing in Scripture to endorse her bodily assumption, her perpetual
virginity (Jesus had siblings after all, two of whom have books in the Bible!),
her immaculate conception. We see no need to pray to her, or any ability on
her part, as dead as she is believed to be, to intercede on our behalf against
the explicit words of Jesus in Scripture.

Within Catholicism, there is a drive to define a new Marian dogma in which
Catholics, as a matter of faith, would be obliged to accept: 1) Mary participates
in redemption with Jesus Christ; 2) grace is granted by Jesus only through
the intercession of Mary; and 3) all prayers from the faithful must flow
through Mary, who brings them to the attention of her Son.

Scripture also tells us not to call anyone Father but God, while they call many
men "father" and blindly follow them. They believe that a fallible man is the
Rock that Jesus is building His Church on, not a confession of faith divinely
inspired by the Holy Spirit of God, despite a plethora of Scriptures that attest
to the fact that God is the sole Rock of our salvation.

They teach purgatory, and many other things neither the apostles nor Jesus
ever taught. For instance, they claim priests must be celibate, when they were
not in the early church. They burned people at the stake for daring to read the
Bible, which is what Scripture tells us to do. Despite all this, and many more
abuses, the RCC considered herself the only valid expression of the community of God.

These are FACTS, not misunderstandings :)
How do you force a person to believe something?

Are you jealous of Mary? Why Always bring her up?

Are all YOUR doctrines correct?
Yeah. I'll bet they are.

Why don't you just stop being so unchristianly-like.
So hateful....
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
As a former Catholic, raised in a predominately Catholic neighborhood, while I agree it has diminished over the years, there are still Catholics who hate Protestants and some are priests.

I hate most of the theology but not the people.



Strawman? Wow. You know all the terms.

YOU HATE THE CATHOLIC CHURCH.

Why not just admit it.

Stop posting incorrect doctrine and saying things that are NOT TRUE.

Maybe I should start saying some things that are not true about Protestants and see how YOU like it.

JESUS meant for all HIS people to be as one.

Catholics do NOT hate Protestants
But Protestants DO HATE Catholics.

Once again we find those doing GOOD being called EVIL
And those doing EVIL feeling they are GOOD.

If it weren't so sad it would be funny.
 

Zen

Senior Member
Sep 11, 2015
752
16
18
You certainly cannot do it the way some here try to.
it turns the person totally to the off position.

And you call Catholicism pagan. That's terrible! We may not agree with their doctrine, that does not make that Church pagan.

Let's see if I can go through your question since you seem serious.

If Jesus was God, and the first Church was called The Way (Acts) and then called Catholic (in Antioch) meaning Universal since it was the only Church and was being spread thought the known "universe" (world) could we not safely assume that this universal or Catholic Church believed in GOD? Was Jesus God or not??

We really should learn about apostolic succession. We may not agree with it, but it's A HISTORICAL fact. It cannot be denied.
It makes us look DUMB to deny it.

Mary came on the scene later and was not really a part of the beginnings of the Church. By this I Always mean PRIOR to Constantine declarin it the State Religion. This is when all the trouble began. It was very pure before that.

So they wanted to Honor Mary. They still Honor her much more than we do and maybe tooo much. So? It's the mother of our Lord. He loved her as His mother. They go over board, I agree, so are we to say they're not Christian?

Christian means one believes in CHRIST. Cathlics believe in Christ.
I was at a bible study of theirs just a few weeks ago and Galatians 2:16 was brought up by the Deacon to explain to some older folk that it's not our WORKS that save us but our belief in God. The older folk are having a bit of a problem understanding this because it was never taught before. However, salvation was still theirs if they loved Jesus because it's Jesus that saves, not some doctrine.

Priests KNOW that it's not enough to be "good". They know we have to have a relationship with Jesus. They know God is love.
There is not enough teaching in the Catholic Church. This is a problem.

If you want to witness to someone Catholic, just tell them about Jesus and the plan of salvation. No need to put down the Church they were raised in. And if they STAY in the Church? There's a prominant Protestant, can't think of his name right now,
that became Orthodox about two months ago. Should we ssend him to hell too? We're all brothers in Christ, and we should treat each other as such.

As far as the Pope goes, this could use its own thread. In a way, it's not wrong. He keeps the religion together. Look at us...
33,000 churches, incl the non-denominationals. It's becoming rediculous.

Catholics do not worship IDOLS. Please let's stop saying this.

There are some here who have had bad experiences in that Church and cannot forget them.

Jesus said to forgive each other and our enemies.
We should be doing this.

No Church is perfect...
I agree with a lot of your points.

I don't hate Catholics, I just think the religion is based off stupid man-made things and the more I look at it, the more I'm seeing the anti-Christ religion / seat of the beast.

As for apostolic succession, I've seen arguments about this before. It's like saying someone who lived 200 years after Lord Jesus had the authority to introduce man-made things in to the church and that's what we see happen today. If they were saying things like "follow this scripture which is in the bible, it's true and always will be, my teachers were the followers of the apostles" then I'd agree with them, but the fact that they keep changing scripture and introducing stupid things just puts me off. The people who lived generations after the apostles are not infallible, only God is.

God never said Peter would go to Rome and set up the religion of man. You'd agree we are all stones being built together as part of God's church, it has nothing to do with walled city of idols, gold and strange priests who are known for molesting children.
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
As a former Catholic, raised in a predominately Catholic neighborhood, while I agree it has diminished over the years, there are still Catholics who hate Protestants and some are priests.

I hate most of the theology but not the people.
What does it mean to be a former Catholic?
Did you study the theology?
Why do they baptize babies?

Priests don't hate Protestants.
They feel Luther made a big mistake and in a way he did.
Can't get into that now.

I mean, the CC needed to be cleaned out, there was so much corruption.
But look what we got...
A mess.

Here we are arguing about the dumbest things when we should be loving each other.