It seems there's so many in these threads that are straddling the doctrinal fence. They talk one way and teach the other.
I see what you're saying. But I can't help but think there's something bigger going on. For example, I hear some make some very good statements, then talk about false doctrine like it's all they've ever known. Sure, there's hypocrisy in this discussion forum, and some "them vs us" arguments, but there seems to be a unity between those that believe various false doctrines. That doesn't make sense.The contradictions and duplicity of people is amazing here. There seems to be only one discussion on the BDF:
How were you saved. Nothing else is ever discussed, because "if we cannot get this right!!!!, we cannot discuss anything else.
Possible Translation? All I know is saving grace so other true discussion is out.
I see what you're saying. But I can't help but think there's something bigger going on. For example, I hear some make some very good statements, then talk about false doctrine like it's all they've ever known. Sure, there's hypocrisy in this discussion forum, and some "them vs us" arguments, but there seems to be a unity between those that believe various false doctrines. That doesn't make sense.
John writes..."All unrighteousness is sin." (1 John 5:17)Let us get to the core of this: Do you believe you never actually commit sin, or are you taking the gnostic position that your "spirit never sins" but the flesh may do so?
Furthermore, if your interpretation of 1 john 3:9 is correct, why did the same epistle contain 1 John 2:1?
Eternal security? OSAS? Or hypergrace?
The verse you quoted is key too.
"For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus hath made me free from THE LAW OF SIN and death.
We as believers are no longer guilty or subject to the law of sin and death. But we can in our ignorance subject ourselves to it when we have already been freed from it. And many Christians are doing this. I did it for years as a way of walking my Christian life. But now am learning to walk by the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus.
We have many gifts given to us in our salvation that have to be "worked out" We work out what Jesus worked in us. He is the one who does the work and we do the believing. We join Him as Gal.2:20 says. But as we are learning., we are still walking and following Jesus.
Please remember that we are "working things out" as children of God now, and not children of the devil.[SUP]20 [/SUP]I have been crucified with Christ [in Him I have shared His crucifixion]; it is no longer I who live, but Christ (the Messiah) lives in me; and the life I now live in the body I live by faith in (by adherence to and reliance on and complete trust in) the Son of God, Who loved me and gave Himself up for me.
Are they not intertwined?It's not relying on our works of how well we follow Him., It's about living by the faith... reliance and complete trust in what Jesus has done. Not our works and how well we can follow.
How can you possibly "forget" you are in Christ?Hi PJW., Did you know that Romans 8:1 is correctly translated in only a few Bibles. I've discovered the NAS is the translation that is most accurate so I use it mostly but also use the KJV and Amplified too. There is no condition except having being IN Christ in Romans 8:1
8 There is therefore now no condemnation to them that are in Christ Jesus. (Period)
The condition is ONLY those who are IN Christ Jesus.
It frustrates me that some of the translators added to the Bible in certain verses. But there are things we have to be aware of by comparing Scriptures with Scriptures. How can there be condemnation when Jesus took all our condemnation and made us 100% righteous in His sight? That is one of the reasons the OP (Ben) started this thread. We can't confess our way back into God's good graces. We already have His good graces IN Christ.
I've found my biggest problems arise when I forget who I am IN Christ. That is when the enemy gains a foot hold in our lives. he did it with Adam and Eve and he keeps using the same trick with Christians today and he's used it all through the centuries. God no longer deals with us according to our sins. He no longer counts our sins against us.
But if we live our lives like God does condemn us and doesn't see us IN Christ.... we will miss out on millions of promises that are ours IN Christ. We won't boldly walk as the sons of God because we will walk as if we only get what we deserve. We get what Jesus deserves. We deserve nothing on our own. And some Christians live that way sadly.
You will need to provide a scripture that mentions taking away any future sins.Our sins, present, past, and future are forgiven. Our confession is not to secure forgiveness but rather to acknowledge that we should not be comfortable with sin even though it is forgiven. It is also a preamble to asking help in avoiding repetition of our sin.
You will need to provide a scripture that mentions taking away any future sins.Our sins, present, past, and future are forgiven. Our confession is not to secure forgiveness but rather to acknowledge that we should not be comfortable with sin even though it is forgiven. It is also a preamble to asking help in avoiding repetition of our sin.
Both Eternal Security and OSAS.
I believe Scripture teaches both; but I recognize your right to disagree.
After I explain why I believe what I believe; it is not my role to persuade you or yours to persuade me.
If we are both saved, the Lord will correct one or both of us in His time.
It is not my role to speculate about your Salvation or yours to question mine.
Salvation won't be assured till after the final judgement.
AMEN!! Can I get another AMEN!!!
How can you possibly "forget" you are in Christ?
Why do I have to confess my sins for forgiveness when Jesus as my High Priest was the last and once and for all sacrifice for sin? Not only this, scripture says that He isn't like the priests of old having to often sacrifice for his sins and the people's sins, otherwise He would've suffered since the foundation of the world (since He, Himself, is that very sacrifice; Hebrews 9:25-28).
First...I don't like your version of the bible...with all the interrupting insertions.Didn't say I forgot I am in Christ. I said we can forget WHO we are IN Christ.
I heard a message with the verse 2 Peter 1:9 about those who lack the qualities of diligence to your faith., moral excellence, knowledge., self control., perseverance, godliness, brotherly kindness and love. It is they who have forgotten they were purged and are sons of God. Soooo important we hold on to the truth of who we are IN Christ.
Here is the cure for that...For as long as we remain in our bodies of corruption we will sin at times. We all do.
I would like to also see a verse that says future sins are already forgiven. I aint seen one yet. Romans 3:25 mentions past, 1 john 1:9 mentions present. What about the future?
Would you mind telling me whose doctrine this is?
"Forgiven" .. for sins that cause an interruption of our walking in fellowship with God in the filling of the Spirit.
In contrast to: What was "PAID FOR" on the Cross, so God would not forsake all mankind all together. Without the provision of the Cross all of us would have been forsaken and not even offered forgiveness.
The penalty for sin was bore by Jesus on the Cross.
He was forsaken so that all mankind would not have to be forsaken forever. Forsaken by a Holy God that can have nothing to do with man's depravity.
"My God! My God! Why have you forsaken me!?"
Jesus was forsaken by the Father. Forsaken for the sins of the all mankind while they were being poured on his body as he was nailed on the Cross!
Jesus paid the penalty for us being born a sinner by nature .. And, even for those who would refuse to believe in Him!
Jesus paid the penalty for being born a sinner by nature for both believer and unbeliever!
"He is the atoning sacrifice for our sins, and not only for ours
but also for the sins of the whole world." 1 John 2:2
All unbelievers will not be going to the Lake of Fire for their sins. The penalty was paid for on the Cross!
And I saw the dead, small and great, standing before God, and books
were opened. And another book was opened, which is the Book of Life.
And the dead were judged according to their works,(not sins) by
the things which were written in the books."
No unbeliever's sins will be mentioned in the final judgement. Only their works will be evaluated.
One work will be searched for and not found! That one work? They never believed in Jesus Christ! (John 6:28-29)
Then they asked him, “What must we do to do the works God requires?”
Jesus answered, “The work of God is this: to believe in the one he
has sent.”
The unbeliever's rejection of Jesus Christ will condemn them Not their sins which were paid for on the Cross! God has given everyone a fair and equal chance for salvation.
At the final judgment of the unbeliever only their works will be evaluated (no sins will be mentioned). And, everyone who rejected Christ will come up short of the required righteousness by God for His acceptance of them into His Kingdom. Their works will not save them. They will be seen as filthy rags in His sight.
With the penalty for being born sinners having been paid for on the Cross? ... We yet remain on this earth in a body that can sin. So, the lhe lingering effect of sin was resolved by the blood of Christ. For we can now regain lost filling of the Spirit when we may sin by the blood of Christ provision, by simply naming our sins.
Acknowledge when you sin before God? Do not deny it? And, back into walking in the Light with God. The provision of the forgiveness of sins can only be offered to those who believe. For that power for forgiveness restores us to walking in the Spirit after we may have stumbled into a sin.