Predestination is misunderstood...

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Johann

Active member
Apr 12, 2022
928
212
43
Well I believe it's this way



John 3:36

New International Version



36 Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life, but whoever rejects the Son will not see life, for God’s wrath remains on them.

Then it

Well I believe it's this way



John 3:36

New International Version

In order to repent you must believe in the son first.

36 Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life, but whoever rejects the Son will not see life, for God’s wrath remains on them.

Then its this.
Mark 16:16 NIV
Whoever believes and is baptized will be saved, but whoever does not believe will be condemned.
Then its this


This would be why this is said
Repent, and believe in the gospel" (Mark 1:15).

Because in order to repent you must believe first.


When you believe in the the son, the Holy Spirit should come upon you. Then you repent.

Because of this

John 16:8

New International Version



8 When he comes, he will prove the world to be in the wrong about sin and righteousness and judgment:


Well if you don't have the Holy spirit come upon you you will not repent.

Then this will not happen.

Act 2.38 be baptised in the name of Jesus Christ everyone of you to receive the Gift of the holy spirit.


No Holy Spirit come upon you means no repentance.

You can change your mind all you like.

But without the Holy Spirit to baptize you in water, there is no remission of sin and no repentance, and no being risen in the resurrected christ, no washing of your blood, no atonement for your blood or your sin, no completely being saved, and you will have to wait until your dead to see if you will receive salvation 😊

So you can continue to preach a false Gospel all you like, as I've got use to your heresies now.
I think the time to put you on ignore is nigh.
J.
 
Dec 18, 2023
6,402
406
83
Ever considered that you may be a heretic? A play actor?
I find it astounding how you reply to at least 50 percent of my posts within 1 minute.

It's almost you've become a thorn in my side 😁
 

Johann

Active member
Apr 12, 2022
928
212
43
Telling people water baptism has no part in saving you, is telling people to follow you.
No-water does not 'save" you and I'm not here for likes-hearts-agree-give me more disagreements and ONE or TWO genuine believers.
 
Dec 18, 2023
6,402
406
83
No-water does not 'save" you and I'm not here for likes-hearts-agree-give me more disagreements and ONE or TWO genuine believers.
Living water saves you and you speak about fresh water coming out of your mouth.

Do you know about speaking fresh water also. Or where in the scripture is speaking fresh water is ?

1 Peter 3:21

and this water symbolizes baptism that now saves you also—not the removal of dirt from the body but the pledge of a clear conscience toward God. It saves you by the resurrection of Jesus Christ,

Angus Buchan 10 hours ago 😊


 

Johann

Active member
Apr 12, 2022
928
212
43
Living water saves you and you speak about fresh water coming out of your mouth.

Do you know about speaking fresh water also. Or where in the scripture is speaking fresh water is ?

1 Peter 3:21

and this water symbolizes baptism that now saves you also—not the removal of dirt from the body but the pledge of a clear conscience toward God. It saves you by the resurrection of Jesus Christ,

Angus Buchan 10 hours ago 😊


1 Peter 3:21 states, "Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ."

This verse indicates that baptism is not a means of physical cleansing but rather a symbol of spiritual regeneration and purification. Baptism signifies a commitment to follow Christ and a promise of a clean conscience before God. However, it does not save in the sense that water itself has saving power. Water baptism is a symbolic action that represents the forgiveness of sins and the new life received through faith in Jesus Christ. Salvation comes through faith in Jesus Christ and His resurrection, not through water baptism itself.

like. Rom_5:14, 1Co_4:6, *Heb_9:24 g. *Heb_11:19.
figure. or, antitype. R. L. Keeler asks, "What saves us? Peter says ’the antitype baptism now saves us.’ What is this antitype baptism, and how does it save us? By examining the type or figure we will better understand the antitype. Water and the ark together saved Noah’s family in the type. In the antitype it is the blood of Christ (of which water is the type), and Christ himself (of which the ark is the type), by which we are saved—saved from sin and everlasting death" (Christian Baptism, p. 285). Rom_5:14, 1Co_10:6, Heb_8:5; Heb_9:9; *Heb_9:24 g.

baptism. Gr. baptisma (S# G908, Mat_3:7). FS101, +Deu_32:42, This is a reference to real, not ritual baptism, for ritual baptism does not save us, it being only a humanly administered ordinance, and Peter’s parenthetical words seem expressly given to guard against such a misapplication of his words to the ritual ordinance.

Real baptism accomplished by the Holy Spirit saves us, placing us in the body of Christ, and applying the cleansing blood of Christ to our hearts (+*Act_1:5 note. +*Act_22:16, 1Co_12:13, Tit_3:5, Heb_10:22, Rev_1:5) upon our calling upon Christ (Rom_10:13) and placing faith in his resurrection (Rom_10:9). Mat_3:6; Mat_3:11; Mat_3:16; +*Mat_28:19, Mar_10:38-39; **Mar_16:16, *Luk_12:50, **Act_2:38; Act_8:12; Act_16:33; +*Act_22:16, **Rom_6:3-6, +*1Co_6:11; **1Co_12:13, **Gal_3:27, Eph_4:5; *Eph_5:26, **Col_2:12, **Tit_3:5-7, +*Heb_6:2; +*Heb_10:22, Jas_4:8, 2Pe_1:9, 1Jn_5:6; 1Jn_5:8.
save us. Dr. Francis Nigel Lee in a work titled From Circumcision to Baptism, page 3, states "But fallen man constantly sins, even from his very birth onward. So God renewed His transgressed Covenant – with Noah and his family (Gen_6:18). Then, Noah and all his covenanted household were baptized by rainwater from above. However, the wicked outside the ark were non-baptismally drowned to death by total submersion from beneath. Gen_6:18; Gen_7:1-23 cf. 1Pe_3:20 f." 1Sa_4:3, +*Tit_3:5.

J.
 

Johann

Active member
Apr 12, 2022
928
212
43
1 Peter 3:21 states, "Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ."

This verse indicates that baptism is not a means of physical cleansing but rather a symbol of spiritual regeneration and purification. Baptism signifies a commitment to follow Christ and a promise of a clean conscience before God. However, it does not save in the sense that water itself has saving power. Water baptism is a symbolic action that represents the forgiveness of sins and the new life received through faith in Jesus Christ. Salvation comes through faith in Jesus Christ and His resurrection, not through water baptism itself.

like. Rom_5:14, 1Co_4:6, *Heb_9:24 g. *Heb_11:19.
figure. or, antitype. R. L. Keeler asks, "What saves us? Peter says ’the antitype baptism now saves us.’ What is this antitype baptism, and how does it save us? By examining the type or figure we will better understand the antitype. Water and the ark together saved Noah’s family in the type. In the antitype it is the blood of Christ (of which water is the type), and Christ himself (of which the ark is the type), by which we are saved—saved from sin and everlasting death" (Christian Baptism, p. 285). Rom_5:14, 1Co_10:6, Heb_8:5; Heb_9:9; *Heb_9:24 g.

baptism. Gr. baptisma (S# G908, Mat_3:7). FS101, +Deu_32:42, This is a reference to real, not ritual baptism, for ritual baptism does not save us, it being only a humanly administered ordinance, and Peter’s parenthetical words seem expressly given to guard against such a misapplication of his words to the ritual ordinance.

Real baptism accomplished by the Holy Spirit saves us, placing us in the body of Christ, and applying the cleansing blood of Christ to our hearts (+*Act_1:5 note. +*Act_22:16, 1Co_12:13, Tit_3:5, Heb_10:22, Rev_1:5) upon our calling upon Christ (Rom_10:13) and placing faith in his resurrection (Rom_10:9). Mat_3:6; Mat_3:11; Mat_3:16; +*Mat_28:19, Mar_10:38-39; **Mar_16:16, *Luk_12:50, **Act_2:38; Act_8:12; Act_16:33; +*Act_22:16, **Rom_6:3-6, +*1Co_6:11; **1Co_12:13, **Gal_3:27, Eph_4:5; *Eph_5:26, **Col_2:12, **Tit_3:5-7, +*Heb_6:2; +*Heb_10:22, Jas_4:8, 2Pe_1:9, 1Jn_5:6; 1Jn_5:8.
save us. Dr. Francis Nigel Lee in a work titled From Circumcision to Baptism, page 3, states "But fallen man constantly sins, even from his very birth onward. So God renewed His transgressed Covenant – with Noah and his family (Gen_6:18). Then, Noah and all his covenanted household were baptized by rainwater from above. However, the wicked outside the ark were non-baptismally drowned to death by total submersion from beneath. Gen_6:18; Gen_7:1-23 cf. 1Pe_3:20 f." 1Sa_4:3, +*Tit_3:5.

J.
And-I don't listen to "faith like potatoes"
 

Johann

Active member
Apr 12, 2022
928
212
43
1 Peter 3:21 states, "Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ."

This verse indicates that baptism is not a means of physical cleansing but rather a symbol of spiritual regeneration and purification. Baptism signifies a commitment to follow Christ and a promise of a clean conscience before God. However, it does not save in the sense that water itself has saving power. Water baptism is a symbolic action that represents the forgiveness of sins and the new life received through faith in Jesus Christ. Salvation comes through faith in Jesus Christ and His resurrection, not through water baptism itself.

like. Rom_5:14, 1Co_4:6, *Heb_9:24 g. *Heb_11:19.
figure. or, antitype. R. L. Keeler asks, "What saves us? Peter says ’the antitype baptism now saves us.’ What is this antitype baptism, and how does it save us? By examining the type or figure we will better understand the antitype. Water and the ark together saved Noah’s family in the type. In the antitype it is the blood of Christ (of which water is the type), and Christ himself (of which the ark is the type), by which we are saved—saved from sin and everlasting death" (Christian Baptism, p. 285). Rom_5:14, 1Co_10:6, Heb_8:5; Heb_9:9; *Heb_9:24 g.

baptism. Gr. baptisma (S# G908, Mat_3:7). FS101, +Deu_32:42, This is a reference to real, not ritual baptism, for ritual baptism does not save us, it being only a humanly administered ordinance, and Peter’s parenthetical words seem expressly given to guard against such a misapplication of his words to the ritual ordinance.

Real baptism accomplished by the Holy Spirit saves us, placing us in the body of Christ, and applying the cleansing blood of Christ to our hearts (+*Act_1:5 note. +*Act_22:16, 1Co_12:13, Tit_3:5, Heb_10:22, Rev_1:5) upon our calling upon Christ (Rom_10:13) and placing faith in his resurrection (Rom_10:9). Mat_3:6; Mat_3:11; Mat_3:16; +*Mat_28:19, Mar_10:38-39; **Mar_16:16, *Luk_12:50, **Act_2:38; Act_8:12; Act_16:33; +*Act_22:16, **Rom_6:3-6, +*1Co_6:11; **1Co_12:13, **Gal_3:27, Eph_4:5; *Eph_5:26, **Col_2:12, **Tit_3:5-7, +*Heb_6:2; +*Heb_10:22, Jas_4:8, 2Pe_1:9, 1Jn_5:6; 1Jn_5:8.
save us. Dr. Francis Nigel Lee in a work titled From Circumcision to Baptism, page 3, states "But fallen man constantly sins, even from his very birth onward. So God renewed His transgressed Covenant – with Noah and his family (Gen_6:18). Then, Noah and all his covenanted household were baptized by rainwater from above. However, the wicked outside the ark were non-baptismally drowned to death by total submersion from beneath. Gen_6:18; Gen_7:1-23 cf. 1Pe_3:20 f." 1Sa_4:3, +*Tit_3:5.

J.
The term "living waters" appears in various books throughout the Bible and can be understood in different ways. In John 4:10, Jesus tells the woman at the well that if she knew who He was, she would have asked Him for living water. Jesus means eternal life, and through communion with Him in the Holy Spirit, we receive the living water of everlasting life. In John 7:38, Jesus declares that whoever believes in Him, as Scripture has said, rivers of living water will flow from within them. Here, Jesus refers to the Holy Spirit as the living water, which dwells in believers and seals them for salvation. The living water is a metaphor used in the Bible to depict the spiritual sustenance and salvation that Jesus Christ offers. It symbolizes the spiritual refreshment that comes from accepting Jesus Christ and His teachings. Water baptism is a symbolic action that represents the forgiveness of sins and the new life received through faith in Jesus Christ. However, it does not save in the sense that water itself has saving power.
 
Dec 18, 2023
6,402
406
83
1 Peter 3:21 states, "Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ."

This verse indicates that baptism is not a means of physical cleansing but rather a symbol of spiritual regeneration and purification. Baptism signifies a commitment to follow Christ and a promise of a clean conscience before God. However, it does not save in the sense that water itself has saving power. Water baptism is a symbolic action that represents the forgiveness of sins and the new life received through faith in Jesus Christ. Salvation comes through faith in Jesus Christ and His resurrection, not through water baptism itself.

like. Rom_5:14, 1Co_4:6, *Heb_9:24 g. *Heb_11:19.
figure. or, antitype. R. L. Keeler asks, "What saves us? Peter says ’the antitype baptism now saves us.’ What is this antitype baptism, and how does it save us? By examining the type or figure we will better understand the antitype. Water and the ark together saved Noah’s family in the type. In the antitype it is the blood of Christ (of which water is the type), and Christ himself (of which the ark is the type), by which we are saved—saved from sin and everlasting death" (Christian Baptism, p. 285). Rom_5:14, 1Co_10:6, Heb_8:5; Heb_9:9; *Heb_9:24 g.

baptism. Gr. baptisma (S# G908, Mat_3:7). FS101, +Deu_32:42, This is a reference to real, not ritual baptism, for ritual baptism does not save us, it being only a humanly administered ordinance, and Peter’s parenthetical words seem expressly given to guard against such a misapplication of his words to the ritual ordinance.

Real baptism accomplished by the Holy Spirit saves us, placing us in the body of Christ, and applying the cleansing blood of Christ to our hearts (+*Act_1:5 note. +*Act_22:16, 1Co_12:13, Tit_3:5, Heb_10:22, Rev_1:5) upon our calling upon Christ (Rom_10:13) and placing faith in his resurrection (Rom_10:9). Mat_3:6; Mat_3:11; Mat_3:16; +*Mat_28:19, Mar_10:38-39; **Mar_16:16, *Luk_12:50, **Act_2:38; Act_8:12; Act_16:33; +*Act_22:16, **Rom_6:3-6, +*1Co_6:11; **1Co_12:13, **Gal_3:27, Eph_4:5; *Eph_5:26, **Col_2:12, **Tit_3:5-7, +*Heb_6:2; +*Heb_10:22, Jas_4:8, 2Pe_1:9, 1Jn_5:6; 1Jn_5:8.
save us. Dr. Francis Nigel Lee in a work titled From Circumcision to Baptism, page 3, states "But fallen man constantly sins, even from his very birth onward. So God renewed His transgressed Covenant – with Noah and his family (Gen_6:18). Then, Noah and all his covenanted household were baptized by rainwater from above. However, the wicked outside the ark were non-baptismally drowned to death by total submersion from beneath. Gen_6:18; Gen_7:1-23 cf. 1Pe_3:20 f." 1Sa_4:3, +*Tit_3:5.

J.
Nope, it's what takes place during water baptism that saves you.
 

Johann

Active member
Apr 12, 2022
928
212
43
Nope, it's what takes place during water baptism that saves you.
A unregenerate can be water baptized and STILL be unregenerate-but a unregenerate baptized with and into the Holy Spirit CANNOT be or remain in a STATE of being unregenerate.
J.
 
Dec 18, 2023
6,402
406
83
A unregenerate can be water baptized and STILL be unregenerate-but a unregenerate baptized with and into the Holy Spirit CANNOT be or remain in a STATE of being unregenerate.
J.
You have to be baptised in to Water with the Holy Spirit to receive salvation before you die.

Don't and you may receive it after you die, you may not.
 

Mem

Senior Member
Sep 23, 2014
7,161
2,175
113
I must be missing something. Can you state it again for me please?
The premise of your position is that we have no choice unless it is given to us. And my position doesn't reject that reality. We've confounded our own desire to not die by doing that which brought death which on the surface (your view imo) is sin but at the root is unbelief (imho) and that leaves us no choice other than death. So, if Jesus only enables some to make the choice to live, then He did not die for the sins of the world but only for the those who believe, namely, the elect (your reality). However, if Jesus restored the capability of choice by eliminating sin as the hindrance to the ability to choose, then there is only unbelief that stands between life and death. And this, in my view, is how He chose us while we were yet sinners. He chose to die for the sins of the world so that those that take advantage (which doesn't take any work) of the way (i.e., choosing it, that is, taken by faith) might have eternal life.
 

Cameron143

Well-known member
Mar 1, 2022
19,318
6,645
113
62
You most probably don't realise it, but by saying the heart is the source of the problem, then you are saying God creates the soul evil.
No I'm not. Everything God created was good and very good. Sin is what made the heart as it is. And God is the one who restores the heart.