Revolution in Iran

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Very legitimate question from the information given on this thread.

Israel is no more, to the church replaced Israel, to Israel now has a future?!?!

No distinction to distinction.

What a mess.

How is "did Israel replace the church?" a sensical question, much less a legitimate one? How can what came before replace what came after?

And how can the assembly of God (natural Israel) replace the assembly of God (Israel born in the spirit)? Israel means a people, not a land, or a kingdom, or a geopolitical entity.
 
How is "did Israel replace the church?" a sensical question, much less a legitimate one? How can what came before replace what came after?

And how can the assembly of God (natural Israel) replace the assembly of God (Israel born in the spirit)? Israel means a people, not a land, or a kingdom, or a geopolitical entity.
What you have there is Augustinian pseudo-philosophical bafflegab nuttery.

It isn't supposed to make sense. That's part of the grift. Just blow up a lot of smoke with fancy spiritually sounding mystical buzzwords and keep the suckers dazzled and guessing.

Which is how all of these options remain open for endless debate:

"So did the Church replace Israel?
Or did Israel replace the Church?
Are all gentile believers now Israelites (spiritually or otherwise)?
Or is it that saved Israelites and saved gentiles are categorically discrete?"

Keep moving the shell and pea, the suckers keep guessing and dizzy. That's the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LTTexan and Kroogz
None of that makes any sense to me

Well that's obvious.

Some don't know that the Jews are beloved of the Lord (Romans 11:28) which is their excuse to be racist towards the Jews not having any mercy to desire that the descendants of Abraham be saved.

It's funny that these racists want mercy for themselves but none for the Jews.

Genesis 12:3
I will bless those who bless you,
But I will curse those who curse you.
And through you I will bless all the nations

Numbers 24:9
Whoever blesses Israel will be blessed,
And whoever curses Israel will be cursed

Romans 11:28
they are beloved for the Father's sakes

Those that are racist and hateful towards God's chosen people... are cursed.
For he shall have judgment without mercy, that hath shewed no mercy - James 2:13

You should know that just like the prodigal son, the Father longs for them to return to Him.


The problem with your view is that "all these nations are not coming together to destroy national Israel".

They all hate the Jews so you should be right at home with these people.

Here's another news flash for you - the vast majority of what passes for "christianity" in the end times are actually the tares Jesus warned of who are actually the children of the devil just playing religious games claiming they are Christians.

Matthew 7:13,14
Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat:
Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.

According to Jesus, most people end up going to hell.
 
All of it deals with whether or not God gives us timelines in His prophecies which your minister said He doesn't. So now you are saying "Yes, God gave timelines for how long Israel would be in captivity before their exodus, how long before a man named Moses, a type of the Messiah, would come and deliver them", and yes God gave timelines for how long Israel would be scattered in Babylon before God would bring them back, and yes, God told us how long it would be before Jesus Christ the Messiah would come and be crucified, and yes, both Jesus and John the Baptist told us the day and the manner with which Jesus Christ, the Messiah would be crucified. But God does not give us a timeline for the Day of the Lord, the end of the age, despite the Day of the Lord and the second coming of Jesus being the single biggest prophetic topic in the Bible. 150 chapters in the Bible deal with the end times. The second coming of the Lord is mentioned more than 2,000 times in the Bible (counting both Old Testament and New Testament references). The New Testament mentions the Second Coming of Jesus Christ over 300 times (approximately once every 25 verses), and Jesus gives us specific commands to "watch," "be ready," or "wait" for His return (Matthew 24-25, Mark 13, Luke 12, 21). We are told specifically what the signs will be, what the generation will be, and yet your "minister" tells you not to watch. Don't pay attention to these signs. I got it, you have told me more than enough about "your minister" and how foolish you are to let him dissuade you from heeding the Lord's command to watch. You don't deny that all the references I gave you were timelines given by God in His word, you only deny that Ezekiel and Daniel and the books of Moses gave us a timeline for the second coming and your reasoning was "God doesn't give timelines" hence they can't be timelines. Wake up. The only one you are kidding is yourself.
I'm not sure why you ignored what I said, earlier - "Nobody is disputing the fact that the old testament did indicate timelines for the fulfilment of some prophecies".

My Minister never said anything about the old testament prophecies which were given to Israel, they don't concern us, they weren't given for us or to us. But your attempt to figure out the day or year for the return of the Lord Jesus is foolish, because He said nobody knows, but you reject what He said by claiming you know. So you minister/teacher has deceived you.

The Lord Jesus told His audience to "watch and be ready" 2000 years ago, and people like you ran around telling everyone that His return is immanent 2000 years ago, Can you see how silly they looked 2000 years ago and how silly it is to be making the same silly mistake in 2026.
 
Well that's obvious.

Some don't know that the Jews are beloved of the Lord (Romans 11:28) which is their excuse to be racist towards the Jews not having any mercy to desire that the descendants of Abraham be saved.

It's funny that these racists want mercy for themselves but none for the Jews.

Genesis 12:3
I will bless those who bless you,
But I will curse those who curse you.
And through you I will bless all the nations

Numbers 24:9
Whoever blesses Israel will be blessed,
And whoever curses Israel will be cursed

Romans 11:28
they are beloved for the Father's sakes

Those that are racist and hateful towards God's chosen people... are cursed.
For he shall have judgment without mercy, that hath shewed no mercy - James 2:13

You should know that just like the prodigal son, the Father longs for them to return to Him.




They all hate the Jews so you should be right at home with these people.

Here's another news flash for you - the vast majority of what passes for "christianity" in the end times are actually the tares Jesus warned of who are actually the children of the devil just playing religious games claiming they are Christians.

Matthew 7:13,14
Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat:
Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.

According to Jesus, most people end up going to hell.
" are actually the children of the devil just playing religious games claiming they are Christians."

And it runs the spectrum from peddling false doctrine to willful ignorance to denial of what is clearly true. And so much more.
 
I'm not sure why you ignored what I said, earlier - "Nobody is disputing the fact that the old testament did indicate timelines for the fulfilment of some prophecies".

My Minister never said anything about the old testament prophecies which were given to Israel, they don't concern us, they weren't given for us or to us. But your attempt to figure out the day or year for the return of the Lord Jesus is foolish, because He said nobody knows, but you reject what He said by claiming you know. So you minister/teacher has deceived you.

The Lord Jesus told His audience to "watch and be ready" 2000 years ago, and people like you ran around telling everyone that His return is immanent 2000 years ago, Can you see how silly they looked 2000 years ago and how silly it is to be making the same silly mistake in 2026.
"My Minister never said anything about the old testament prophecies which were given to Israel"

You would do better to put your nose to the grindstone and find out the truth for yourself.

I had no choice but to dismiss and walk away from many many faux bogus "Churches" and hopelessly addled clueless "pastors" around here. They struck out so badly it was truly appalling to behold.

Nope. It's pre-trib rapture of the Church, an accurate understanding of prophecy aka futurism, premillennialism and restoration of Israel.....or nothing.

Because that is what Jesus, Paul and the Apostles preached and what the earliest Church believed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LTTexan and Kroogz
Does God give us a timeline for the end of the age?


Here is a Pdf summarizing what I have shared. If cv5 has suggestions for additions let me know. Anyone can download it, 13 pages long, it is easier to read than to go through the back and forth on this. However, I do include the verses that @Journey_man gave to support his "minister's" interpretation.
I didn't bother wasting time reading the link, because the title itself is an oxymoron. It's self defeating by asking an invalid question, because the Lord said that nobody knows except for the Father.
But you can't accept what Jesus said, so you go and look for ear ticklers to tell you what you what to hear.


Tell your pastor that he first of all needs to become a high level expert in koine and classical Greek. Oh.....and Sanskrit too.
Oh wait. Hebrew also. And near east thought processes.

Then and only then will he realize that his super-deterministic pretension are......total rubbish.

Most pastors today are unqualified in these matters of scholarly knowledge and finesse and therefore disqualified.
And I know (surely know) that all hyper-Cal pastors are definitely unqualified. As are all hard core Reformed pastors.

*******************************************************

Predestined = "to (yet future ) obtain/fulfil ***a thing"***.

[Eph 1:11 KJV]
11 In whom also we have obtained an inheritance, being predestinated G4309 (to obtain it) according to the purpose of him who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will:

11 In whom also we have obtained an inheritance, being predestinated (the FUTURE REALIZATION yet to be revealed!) according to the purpose of him (this INHERITANCE a part of the plan of God from eternity past!) who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will:

These "THINGS" are predestined (PREPARED ***DESTINATION***) for us":

***************************************************************************

God has chosen ***THESE THINGS, namely*** blamelessness, conformation to His image, justification, adoption, obtaining an inheritance and glory ***FOR those*** who WILL believe, those who WILL CHOOSE to enter the covenant.

That's the gist of προορίζω proorizó, SG4309 .

And this term NEVER, EVER pertains to anything about God choosing any individual FOR SALVATION whatsoever and certainly nothing about "pre-birth Calvinistic selection" either.

Rom 8:29
For whom he did foreknow, he G4309 also did predestinate G4309 to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brethren.

Rom 8:30
Moreover whom he did predestinate, G4309 them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified.

Eph 1:5
Having predestinated G4309 us unto the adoption of children by Jesus Christ to himself, according to the good pleasure of his will,


Eph 1:11
In whom also we have obtained an inheritance, being predestinated G4309 according to the purpose of him who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will:

******************************************************************************************************

Act 4:28
For to do whatsoever thy hand and thy counsel determined before G4309 to be done.
(The cross, planned from before time, but by then had already arrived at the "destination/realization").

1Co 2:7
But we speak the wisdom of God in a mystery, even the hidden wisdom, which God ordained G4309 before the world unto our glory:
1Co 2:8
Which none of the princes of this world knew: for had they known it, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory.
(The cross, planned from before time, but by then had already arrived at the "destination/realization").
My Pastor doesn't need to speak Greek or Yiddish to understand the English translation of the Bible. Let me remind you that we are in the 21st century and not the 1st.

Your theology is incoherent, it's all messed up. You got it back to front in Eph 1:11 which says (we have obtained an inheritance), present tense, but you twist to make it say (we will obtain an inheritance) meaning a future inheritance.

My Pastor teaches us that we are "already saved" and we are "being saved" and we "will be saved". You may not have the capacity to get your mind around that concept but that's OK, not many have the gift of discernment which God gave to my pastor.

You believe that a spiritually dead person (that's all of humanity), has the ability to resurrect themselves to life and then manufacture saving faith out of a dead spirit, and then put to death their old sin nature (which hates God and loves sin) and then fabricate a new nature and then fabricate faith by their own magical power and then cash in that faith to receive the reward of eternal life in paradise and gain all the riches of the universe.

But the problem with your philosophy is, God said no. No you can't do anything, because you are dead in your sin and you are enslaved by your sin and Satan. So the only way for a dead man to be made alive and set free from bondage is by God Himself. It's not something you can do for yourself.
I know Arminianism teaches you the man centred version of the gospel, but that version can't save anyone because it's fake.
 
Well that's obvious.

Some don't know that the Jews are beloved of the Lord (Romans 11:28) which is their excuse to be racist towards the Jews not having any mercy to desire that the descendants of Abraham be saved.

It's funny that these racists want mercy for themselves but none for the Jews.

Genesis 12:3
I will bless those who bless you,
But I will curse those who curse you.
And through you I will bless all the nations

Numbers 24:9
Whoever blesses Israel will be blessed,
And whoever curses Israel will be cursed

Romans 11:28
they are beloved for the Father's sakes

Those that are racist and hateful towards God's chosen people... are cursed.
For he shall have judgment without mercy, that hath shewed no mercy - James 2:13

You should know that just like the prodigal son, the Father longs for them to return to Him.




They all hate the Jews so you should be right at home with these people.

Here's another news flash for you - the vast majority of what passes for "christianity" in the end times are actually the tares Jesus warned of who are actually the children of the devil just playing religious games claiming they are Christians.

Matthew 7:13,14
Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat:
Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it.

According to Jesus, most people end up going to hell.
Gods elect are not Jews or Israelis, Gods elect are the Church (The Body of Christ). Israel/Jews were chosen for a purpouse, to proclaim Gods Word to the world. The elect (the Church) was chosen for salvation. God wrote each of our names in His Book of Life, before He created the world.

The elect has always been made up of Gentiles like Abraham and Job, from the beginning. This idea that Gentiles were added to Gods elect, under the new covenant is false. God chose a specific number of people (the elect) for salvation, before He made the world.

The Jews are all born dead in sin, just like everyone else. They don't get any special privileges, if anything they suffer worse punishment for their sin because the law was given to them so they are without excuse.

There are no Jews or Gentiles in Christ.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: LTTexan
I'm not sure why you ignored what I said, earlier - "Nobody is disputing the fact that the old testament did indicate timelines for the fulfilment of some prophecies".

My Minister never said anything about the old testament prophecies which were given to Israel, they don't concern us, they weren't given for us or to us. But your attempt to figure out the day or year for the return of the Lord Jesus is foolish, because He said nobody knows, but you reject what He said by claiming you know. So you minister/teacher has deceived you.

The Lord Jesus told His audience to "watch and be ready" 2000 years ago, and people like you ran around telling everyone that His return is immanent 2000 years ago, Can you see how silly they looked 2000 years ago and how silly it is to be making the same silly mistake in 2026.
Just a quick heads-up:

If as you say your pastor is super-determinist and staunchly Reformed, then axiomatically he also holds to the diametrically opposite view of the true and grammatically intended meaning of the terms "predestined" and "predestination".

In other words, he would be "dead wrong". Dead wrong about some of the most doctrinally important and crucial passages in all the Bible.

Have a nice night!
 
  • Like
Reactions: LTTexan and Kroogz
I'm not sure why you ignored what I said, earlier - "Nobody is disputing the fact that the old testament did indicate timelines for the fulfilment of some prophecies".

My Minister never said anything about the old testament prophecies which were given to Israel, they don't concern us, they weren't given for us or to us. But your attempt to figure out the day or year for the return of the Lord Jesus is foolish, because He said nobody knows, but you reject what He said by claiming you know. So you minister/teacher has deceived you.

The Lord Jesus told His audience to "watch and be ready" 2000 years ago, and people like you ran around telling everyone that His return is immanent 2000 years ago, Can you see how silly they looked 2000 years ago and how silly it is to be making the same silly mistake in 2026.
You said that your minister said that "God does not give timelines" hence Ezekiel is not giving us a timeline. Now you say that your minister knows that God gave timelines about everything, everything except for the day of the Lord which is the single biggest topic in Biblical prophecy and because God doesn't do it that is why the timeline that is given in Ezekiel doesn't mean what it says.

At this point it is a complete waste of time talking with you about this anymore.

Not only so you accuse me of doing things I am not doing. I am not trying to figure out the day. What I am trying to do is understand the word of God and I refuse to limited by some "minister" making absurd claims that are patently false.