The Trolley Problem, kill 1 to save 5?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Nov 23, 2016
510
37
0
#22
There is a runaway trolley barrelling down the railway tracks. Ahead, on the tracks, there are five people tied up and unable to move. The trolley is headed straight for them. You are standing some distance off in the train yard, next to a lever. If you pull this lever, the trolley will switch to a different set of tracks. However, you notice that there is one person tied up on the side track. You have two options:

  1. Do nothing, and the trolley kills the five people on the main track.
  2. Pull the lever, diverting the trolley onto the side track where it will kill one person

Here is something to note, you can kill that one person to save 1 but your're deliberately pulling the lever. You can do nothing and maybe your conscious would be clean since there was nothing you can do.
Are the 5 people liberal democrats ? :cool:
 

EarnestQ

Senior Member
Apr 28, 2016
2,577
293
83
#23
I understand this to be a true story. (I think it was in the 30's.) A railroad drawbridge operator brought his young child to work with him one day. He told the child to stay away from the big gears. After a while, a train came along and he had to lower the bridge. He noticed that his child had gotten into the gears and that if he lowered the bridge the child would be killed. But if he didn't lower the bridge everyone on the train would be killed.

What would you do? He lowered the bridge.

None of those people on the train knew what had happened to save their lives.

I pray I never have to make a decision like that.
 

JonahLynx

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2014
1,017
27
48
#24
To answer your question Socreta, I would not pull the lever because I'm closer to Kantian than utilitarian. This probably isn't the forum for a philosophy debate though lol.
 

oldethennew

Senior Member
Feb 28, 2016
7,751
574
113
#26
this is such a 'nutter' post, ask yourself why someone would make a thread about
such a thing as this??? - and WHY you would respond to it???
 

Lynx

Senior Member
Aug 13, 2014
13,031
695
113
#28
EarnestQ: The drawbridge keeper is actually a retelling of an older story from the 1800's. At least that is as far back as anybody has been able to trace it. Nobody knows if it is true, but I have heard many versions of it and even seen a video (drama, with a religious motif about Jesus dying for us.)
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
23,550
2,031
113
63
Florida
#29
People still take trolleys?

Maybe somebody needs to take an introductory ethics class from a school with newer books.
Only one I know who uses a trolley is Mr. Roger's. If he is talking about pulling the lever to save 5 and kill Mr. Rodger's then I'm not moving that lever, not in my neighborhood.
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
23,550
2,031
113
63
Florida
#30
Are the 5 people liberal democrats ? :cool:
Yeah, and the single guy is a Republican. This dilemma is a no brainer. Perhaps the guy at the lever is an Independent? I'm voting that he doesn't throw the lever.
 

preacher4truth

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2016
6,038
292
83
#31
I pulled that dumb lever only half way because I got tired of hearing about it. Everybody was saved.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#32
Only one I know who uses a trolley is Mr. Roger's. If he is talking about pulling the lever to save 5 and kill Mr. Rodger's then I'm not moving that lever, not in my neighborhood.
We still have them.

Hard to tell the difference between them and our buses, but trolleys need the electricity of the wire above it to move.


 
J

joefizz

Guest
#33
this is such a 'nutter' post, ask yourself why someone would make a thread about
such a thing as this??? - and WHY you would respond to it???
but "You" just did! lol.
 
J

joefizz

Guest
#34
Only one I know who uses a trolley is Mr. Roger's. If he is talking about pulling the lever to save 5 and kill Mr. Rodger's then I'm not moving that lever, not in my neighborhood.
Have you forgotten?
Mr.Roger's Trolley "moves on it's own" it would "stop itself" before any harm would befall anyone,think about it!
 

NewStuff17

Senior Member
Dec 30, 2017
137
5
0
#36
I actually LOVE questions like this. I had a few of my own; Some made up some retold but I would like it to be better received than this scenario so I am trepidatious about sharing them.

I would leave the lever alone. It isn't legal for me to mess with it. And I would think it may be a trick from some evil mastermind to pull it anyway. Maybe the one person is real and the other 5 are fake. The villain just wanted me to kill someone. Better safe than sorry.