I am so horrified by the thought of this that I was barely able to engage the "laughing emoji" on your post!!
I'm fortunate to have only had suspicion/proof a mouse's presence once. I agonized over which type of traps to buy. I didn't really want to have to face a tiny little body smashed into a wooden plank by its neck.

But I was also too traumatized by catching it live and letting it go, only so it could continue to cause its rodent ruckus.
I dutifully settled on plain old-fashioned traps, baited them with peanut butter (not because I consider cheese to be the equivalent of solid gold like
@Tazzo 
, but because I reasoned that peanut butter took effort, coaxing the victim to stay in place rather than pulling a snatch'n'go.)
I even tied the traps to the cupboard doors with string, having read too many horror stories of mice running off with traps, hiding in some place not meant for humans to find, then causing a stench that could never be fully removed after passing on to that great mouse maze in the sky.
I even recruited a friend to come over and dispose of the trap whenever the furry little perp was caught.
But wouldn't you know it!
I totally underestimated that mouse, as I found the trap COMPLETELY LICKED CLEAN of peanut butter -- but with NOT SO MUCH as even a slight snap of the trap. It was otherwise totally intact. ARGH!!!
Since this was under the sink and there was some space around the pipe and the floorboard, I promptly sealed up any such spaces with duct tape, in both the kitchen and the bathroom.
I never saw evidence of a mouse again, but seeing as the one I was battling wits with was so darn clever, I'm kind of glad I never actually met it face to face.