T
TruthDefender
Guest
I don't see the word "never" in that text. You eyesight might be better than mine. Could you please highlight the word "never", so I can see it too?
“They were NOT of us…..” It’s most emphatic, yes?
I don't see the word "never" in that text. You eyesight might be better than mine. Could you please highlight the word "never", so I can see it too?
Tell that to those who are falling away right now.It may even entail a loss of eternal rewards and position. But it will NOT result in lost Salvation.
If somebody backslid & never came back, you could still say at the time," they were not of us."“They were NOT of us…..” It’s most emphatic, yes?
If somebody backslid & never came back, you could still say at the time," they were not of us."
I could fall off a house, or I could fall down in the yard. Either way, I've fallen.Why are you reading into things that aren’t there? Just take the verse for what it says.
Why do you have to interject things? What does it matter??
If the person doesn’t believe God came in the flesh, they most certainly are not of us. Yes?
Maybe move on!?![]()
Let me rephrase... Those who are falling away are going into the tribulation to reap God's wrath. Tell THEM they're still saved.Tell what?
I could fall off a house, or I could fall down in the yard. Either way, I've fallen.
WHEN they came out, it says NOWHERE they were never of us, only they were not of us when they left.
“They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would have continued with us…”
IF they had been of us….. so this means they were weren’t of them.
You change the meaning when you add “when they left”, because it adds another dynamic which otherwise I’m not reading!
What really convinced me “they were not of us” is when John says they have the spirit of antichrist…
truly, anyone with the spirit of antichrist is not saved and will fall away and leave.
It would seem they never had the Spirit of God, hence they are not of us.
They could have had it, yet wandered off after other spirits.
Any christian who apostatises is not of us.
Was Israel saved out of Egypt? Yes. Did God destroy those whom he saved, but afterwards disbelieved? Yes.
Can a person with weak faith be saved by confessing Christ and being baptized into his name? Yes. Will God destroy those who give him lip service, but don't do his will or deny him? Yes
I wouldn’t say God saved Israel out of Egypt… but, I would say God delivered Israel out of Egypt making a way of escape from the bondage… Israel was no longer controlled by Egypt.
Yet, there is still a wilderness journey before they entered the Promised Land and only those that believed and did not doubt could enter…
Again, scenarios are being added.