A question for christians #1

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
stabbo said:
Could you tell me how changing your mind doesnt have any effect on who you are as a person.
Click to expand...
We weren't talking about it not having any effect. We were discussing the fact that it doesn't make them a different person.

BTW, this was addressed in that Google site I posted. But, you knew that, because you are concerned enough to have read it.
 
stabbo said:
So God doesnt learn anything new when he changes his mind.
Click to expand...

God isn't on the time line we are He knows the end from the beginning so how would He learn something different from what He already knows?
 
stabbo said:
What do say about people who see in the bible that some verses appear to suggest that God sometimes changes his mind about things.
Click to expand...

I think that's a honest reading of the scriptures that as God is involved in the affairs of man he has used His judgment and in relation to man decided to change a situation. But He Himself does not change .
 
Willie-T said:
We weren't talking about it not having any effect. We were discussing the fact that it doesn't make them a different person.

BTW, this was addressed in that Google site I posted. But, you knew that, because you are concerned enough to have read it.
Click to expand...
What would you say if I told you that changing my mind about things has made me a very diffrent person.
 
stabbo said:
What would you say if I told you that changing my mind about things has made me a very diffrent person.
Click to expand...
I would ask you, "How?" I've changed my mind about a lot of things, but that hasn't changed the basic person I am. It may have tempered the way I react and respond, but for instance, I still think Obama is out to destroy as much of the American image as he can, but I don't cuss him as I once would have, nor would I vote for him, although I DO pray for him... "occasionally." But being a Christian has not made me get any warm fuzzies for him.
 
Willie-T said:
I would ask you, "How?" I've changed my mind about a lot of things, but that hasn't changed the basic person I am. It may have tempered the way I react and respond, but for instance, I still think Obama is out to destroy as much of the American image as he can, but I don't cuss him as I once would have, nor would I vote for him, although I DO pray for him... "occasionally." But being a Christian has not made me get any warm fuzzies for him.
Click to expand...
How? well what we think effects how we behave.
 
Elin said:
Well, I'm pretty sure I know why, but it would be interesting to hear your take on it.
Click to expand...
Well I'll only state the case for me.

The reason I believe my apostasy is justified is because it can be justified not because it can't be justified. A good scientist will say "A good theory is a falsifiable one" this just means that what ever theories you have should be attempted to be disproven first before claiming them as fact. This is the very good thing about science and why it can self correct. Now when I started questioning the claims of Christianity I just applied the same principle to the bibles theories. All I was trying to do was prove to myself that they weren't disprovable so I could believe it.

And that's how I justify my apostasy.
 
stabbo said:
Well I'll only state the case for me.

The reason I believe my apostasy is justified is because it can be justified not because it can't be justified. A good scientist will say "A good theory is a falsifiable one" this just means that what ever theories you have should be attempted to be disproven first before claiming them as fact. This is the very good thing about science and why it can self correct. Now when I started questioning the claims of Christianity I just applied the same principle to the bibles theories. All I was trying to do was prove to myself that they weren't disprovable so I could believe it.

And that's how I justify my apostasy.
Click to expand...
Yea stabbo it takes faith in things not seen...that's why its called "faith" :) At some point a part of a man has to go beyond what can be seen in the natural realm and admit there is more than just this world....Many great scientist have understood this and true science is not opposed to faith.
 
stabbo said:
Well I'll only state the case for me.

The reason I believe my apostasy is justified is because it can be justified not because it can't be justified. A good scientist will say
"A good theory is a falsifiable one" this just means that what ever theories you have should be attempted to be disproven first before claiming them as fact. This is the very good thing about science and why it can self correct. Now when I started questioning the claims of Christianity I just applied the same principle to the bibles theories. All I was trying to do was prove to myself that they weren't disprovable so I could believe it.

And that's how I justify my apostasy.
Click to expand...
Got it. . .so that means you have decided God's revelation is only theory unless it can be proven by science?

That means, for you, science governs the Author of science?

So the real issue here is belief. . .you do not believe the Scriptures, which reveal the God of the universe.

Well here's the thing. . .the truth of Scripture cannot be "proven" by any human means.

Our acceptance of them as truth is a matter of faith, and faith is a matter of the Holy Spirit.

Do you want this faith?
 
stabbo said:
... Now when I started questioning the claims of Christianity I just applied the same principle to the bibles theories...
Click to expand...

Applying the scientific method to non testable 'theories.' Yeah, that makes sense.
Your beloved Popper just turned in his grave.
 
stabbo said:
Well I'll only state the case for me.

The reason I believe my apostasy is justified is because it can be justified not because it can't be justified. A good scientist will say "A good theory is a falsifiable one" this just means that what ever theories you have should be attempted to be disproven first before claiming them as fact. This is the very good thing about science and why it can self correct. Now when I started questioning the claims of Christianity I just applied the same principle to the bibles theories. All I was trying to do was prove to myself that they weren't disprovable so I could believe it.

And that's how I justify my apostasy.
Click to expand...
You're not happy with your findings though are you - or you wouldn't be here?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back