That's a good observation, and I think it strengthens your argument that this isn't just a "modern translation" issue.It is an ongoing action that is contingent if we are holding fast. The present state does not negate the ongoing action.
There are only 14 occurrences in the NT with verbs parsed the same way that I can see.
I do not have time presently to go through them thoroughly. But scratching the surface I do not see where we can ignore the process of the present action happening. Here are the verses:
Matthew 23:28
2 Corinthians 6:12
Ephesians 2:22
Philippians 2:15
Colossians 2:20
1 Corinthians 6:7
1 Corinthians 15:2
Galatians 5:4
Galatians 5:18
1 Peter 2:5
1 Peter 4:14
Mark 5:39
Mark 12:24
Mark 12:27
There are older ones also, YLT for one.
1Cor 15:2 through which also ye are being saved, in what words I proclaimed good news to you, if ye hold fast, except ye did believe in vain,
Thanks for the thoughtful reply. As I said I am pressed for time. However I intend to give your post the attention it deserves when I am a bit more freed up.
May the Lord our God continue to bless us in all His Way, Jesus Christ.
Even Young's Literal Translation renders it: "through which also ye are being saved ... if ye hold fast..."
So let me ask the question this way: If Paul wanted to emphasize a completed, unconditional event here, why use a present-passive form and then immediately attach an "if you hold fast" condition?
That doesn't sound like Paul is merely looking back to a past profession of faith.
It sounds like he's describing an ongoing reality connected to perseverance in the gospel