Replacement/Supersessionism Theology,Why it Matters

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
692
113
Hello HeRose,

The apostles are not considered Israel, because once any Israelite receives Christ as Lord, then and now, they then belong to the body of Christ. Therefore, the apostles are considered as belonging to the church even though they are from the lineage of Israel.

Those Israelites who did not and currently do not receive Christ, are the nation Israel proper. As for the body of Christ, there is now neither Jew nor Gentile for all are in Christ. Those of Israel who have died in Christ, along with the Gentile believers, will be resurrected as the body of Christ. Immediately after that, those who are of Israel who are in Christ and are still alive along with the Gentile believers, will be changed in a moment and will be caught up together. At the resurrection and catching away, those who are of Israel who have not received Christ, they are the one's who will remain here and will be the one's who will partake in the time of Jacob's trouble and upon whom the prophesies regarding Israel will be fulfilled.
Replacement theology at its finest. I've respected everything you've written until this point.
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
692
113
It had a great, high wall, with twelve gates, and at the gates twelve angels, and on the gates the names of the twelve tribes of the sons of Israel were inscribed—on the east three gates, on the north three gates, on the south three gates, and on the west three gates. And the wall of the city had twelve foundations, and on them were the twelve names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb.
(Rev 21:12-14)

Perhaps the assumption is yours?
The distinction is already there, I am not trying to make it.. How do you explain it (away)?
I don't know what it means exactly. Just at first glance, the apostles are the leaders and the foundation, and the tribes aren't. It has nothing to do with church/Israel distinctions.
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
692
113
nowhere in the bible is the new testement church called the house of Israel
People have to be extraordinarily clueless (or brainwashed) to not see that Jesus was the mediator of the new covenant with the house of Israel, and that that covenant was made at the last supper, which can only mean that the 11 disciples are the house of Israel because no one else was present.

I'm astonished at what I'm hearing. This is worse than all of the carnal twisting and contorting that Hebrew Roots and law keeper folks employ.

Sorry for having to call you folks clueless, but you really are.
 
Jul 27, 2011
1,622
89
0
Clueless? When it comes to understanding you, yes i'm clueless. You are not God Almighty, but you speak like you are His final authority. i always see you say (i have proof). Well you may have proof, that you have proved to your self, but you won't prove to me that disobeying is better than being obedient. So quit speaking like you know all the mysteries, and any one that doesn't agree with you are clueless sheep. Remember Jesus said what you have done to the least of these you have done to Him. Come down of that high horse, its better than being knocked off it.
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
692
113
Clueless? When it comes to understanding you, yes i'm clueless. You are not God Almighty, but you speak like you are His final authority. i always see you say (i have proof). Well you may have proof, that you have proved to your self, but you won't prove to me that disobeying is better than being obedient. So quit speaking like you know all the mysteries, and any one that doesn't agree with you are clueless sheep. Remember Jesus said what you have done to the least of these you have done to Him. Come down of that high horse, its better than being knocked off it.
You don't understand the most basic thing about salvation. If the new covenant had not been made with Israel, then you are still dead in your sins, because there is no salvation apart from the new covenant. That covenant wasn't made with the world, but with Israel.
 
Jul 27, 2011
1,622
89
0
i don't see what you see, but does that make me blind? Maybe i'm blind to what you see, but i do see what i see. Does that make me better than you? No! Does you seeing something i don't see better than me? i don't think so! So instead of telling people how clueless they are, pray for them that they might see what you see.
 

prove-all

Senior Member
May 16, 2014
5,977
400
83
64
People have to be extraordinarily clueless (or brainwashed) to not see that Jesus was the mediator of the new covenant with the house of Israel, and that that covenant was made at the last supper, which can only mean that the 11 disciples are the house of Israel because no one else was present.

I'm astonished at what I'm hearing. This is worse than all of the carnal twisting and contorting that Hebrew Roots and law keeper folks employ.

Sorry for having to call you folks clueless, but you really are.
26A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you: and I will
take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh.

27And I will put my spirit within you, and [cause you to walk] in [my statutes],
and ye[ shall] keep [my judgments], and do them.

28And ye shall dwell in the land that [I gave to your fathers]; and ye shall be my people,
and I will be your God. 29I will also save you from all your uncleannesses:
and I will call for the corn, and will increase it, and lay no famine upon you.


so this is a current covenent, are you living in [the land] he gave to the fathers?
no famine or heathen nations around, will be no more

are you doing Gods statues and judgements he gave are forfathers?

I do not think so. this is a future covent with the house of Israel



42Then will I remember my covenant with Jacob, and also my covenant with Isaac,
and also my covenant with Abraham will I remember; and I will remember the land.


43
The land also shall be left of them, and shall enjoy her sabbaths, while she lieth desolate without them: and they shall accept of the punishment of their iniquity: because, even because they despised my judgments, and because their soul abhorred my statutes.


44
And yet for all that, when they be in the land of their enemies, I will not cast them away, neither will I abhor them, to destroy them utterly, and to break my covenant with them: for I am the Lord their God.


45
But I will for their sakes remember the covenant of their ancestors, whom I brought forth out of the land of Egypt in the sight of the heathen, that I might be their God: I am the Lord.


46
These are the statutes and judgments and laws, which the Lord made between him and the children of Israel in mount Sinai by the hand of Moses.



Nevertheless I will remember my covenant with thee in the days of thy youth,
and I will establish unto thee an everlasting covenant.

My mercy will I keep for him for evermore, and my covenant shall stand fast with him.
My covenant will I not break, nor alter the thing that is gone out of my lips.


The secret of the Lord is with them that fear him; and he will shew them his covenant.
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
126
63
nowhere in the bible is the new testement church called the house of Israel
In James 1.1 it is called the twelve tribes of Israel.

Had James only been writing to Jews in such an ethical letter he would have had to explain how they were to deal with Gentile converts, but there is not even a hint of it. He is clearly writing to the whole church.
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
692
113
.
Your grade for Bible 101: F-
.

26A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you: and I will
take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh.

27And I will put my spirit within you, and [cause you to walk] in [my statutes],
and ye[ shall] keep [my judgments], and do them.

28And ye shall dwell in the land that [I gave to your fathers]; and ye shall be my people,
and I will be your God. 29I will also save you from all your uncleannesses:
and I will call for the corn, and will increase it, and lay no famine upon you.


so this is a current covenent, are you living in [the land] he gave to the fathers?
no famine or heathen nations around, will be no more

are you doing Gods statues and judgements he gave are forfathers?

I do not think so. this is a future covent with the house of Israel



42Then will I remember my covenant with Jacob, and also my covenant with Isaac,
and also my covenant with Abraham will I remember; and I will remember the land.


43
The land also shall be left of them, and shall enjoy her sabbaths, while she lieth desolate without them: and they shall accept of the punishment of their iniquity: because, even because they despised my judgments, and because their soul abhorred my statutes.


44
And yet for all that, when they be in the land of their enemies, I will not cast them away, neither will I abhor them, to destroy them utterly, and to break my covenant with them: for I am the Lord their God.


45
But I will for their sakes remember the covenant of their ancestors, whom I brought forth out of the land of Egypt in the sight of the heathen, that I might be their God: I am the Lord.


46
These are the statutes and judgments and laws, which the Lord made between him and the children of Israel in mount Sinai by the hand of Moses.



Nevertheless I will remember my covenant with thee in the days of thy youth,
and I will establish unto thee an everlasting covenant.

My mercy will I keep for him for evermore, and my covenant shall stand fast with him.
My covenant will I not break, nor alter the thing that is gone out of my lips.


The secret of the Lord is with them that fear him; and he will shew them his covenant.
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
126
63
nowhere in the bible is the new testement church called the house of Israel
The church is called 'the Israel of God' in Gal 6.16. The previous verse has made clear that divisions have been broken down and that there is neither circumcision nor uncircumcision but ONE new creation. Thus the Israel of God must be that new creation.

Furthermore in Christ there is neither Jew nor Greek. How then can there be an Israel of God which does not include both?

Unless Paul is totally contradicting himself 'the Israel of God' MUST be the whole church.
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
126
63
26A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you: and I will
take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh.

27And I will put my spirit within you, and [cause you to walk] in [my statutes],
and ye[ shall] keep [my judgments], and do them.

28And ye shall dwell in the land that [I gave to your fathers]; and ye shall be my people,
and I will be your God. 29I will also save you from all your uncleannesses:
and I will call for the corn, and will increase it, and lay no famine upon you.


so this is a current covenent, are you living in [the land] he gave to the fathers?
no famine or heathen nations around, will be no more

are you doing Gods statues and judgements he gave are forfathers?

I do not think so. this is a future covenant with the house of Israel
This was fulfilled after the Return from exile.



Then will I remember my covenant with Jacob, and also my covenant with Isaac,
and also my covenant with Abraham will I remember; and I will remember the land.

43
The land also shall be left of them, and shall enjoy her sabbaths, while she lieth desolate without them: and they shall accept of the punishment of their iniquity: because, even because they despised my judgments, and because their soul abhorred my statutes.


44
And yet for all that, when they be in the land of their enemies, I will not cast them away, neither will I abhor them, to destroy them utterly, and to break my covenant with them: for I am the Lord their God.


45
But I will for their sakes remember the covenant of their ancestors, whom I brought forth out of the land of Egypt in the sight of the heathen, that I might be their God: I am the Lord.


46
These are the statutes and judgments and laws, which the Lord made between him and the children of Israel in mount Sinai by the hand of Moses.



Nevertheless I will remember my covenant with thee in the days of thy youth,
and I will establish unto thee an everlasting covenant.

My mercy will I keep for him for evermore, and my covenant shall stand fast with him.
My covenant will I not break, nor alter the thing that is gone out of my lips.


The secret of the Lord is with them that fear him; and he will shew them his covenant.
Again this was fulfilled after the return from Exile.

Neither are referring to the new covenant made by Jesus Christ which took the covenant to a new level.
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
692
113
This was fulfilled after the Return from exile.



Again this was fulfilled after the return from Exile.

Neither are referring to the new covenant made by Jesus Christ which took the covenant to a new level.


How can you say this?
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
692
113
.
The new covenant with the house of Israel prophesied

Behold, the days come, saith the LORD, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah: Jeremiah 31:31

Jesus makes the new covenant ...


For this is my blood of the new covenant, which is shed for many for the remission of sins. Matthew 26:28

... with the house of Israel

Now when the evening was come, he sat down with the twelve. Matthew 26:20
 
B

BradC

Guest
It was never about the nation or physical Jew. God needed a nation in which the Seed would come. This view of Israel today being some kind of favored people goes against every thing in scripture. Read Gal 3:27-29 and Eph 2:13-18. It puts this modern theory in the wastebasket. It is a theory that denies Christ and His accomplishment for man.
After the regathering of the Jews, who were scattered into many nations, back to their homeland and becoming a nation in 1948, is not that an incredible turn of events that favored the Jews as a people after much suffering and being dispersed? Do you know of another people and nation that this has happened to? May I remind you this state of Israel occured approximately 1915 years after Pentecost and the beginning of the Christian church which has continued to the present. The church and body of Christ has also been active during this time alongside the favor that has been showed to the people of Israel. There are two distinct bodies that have been showed favor from God, one being Israel which is still in unbelief and two being the church (called out ones) who have believed on the Son of God. One has not replaced the other and both are intact presently, being imperfect as they are.

Paul prayed to God in (Romans 10) that Israel might be saved for they were a disobedient and gainsaying people (v.21) because he knew that God had not cast away his people which he foreknew (Rom 11:2) who had been blinded in part (v.25). Paul was a member of the church and to this very day his prayer is still active within the pillar and ground of the church.

Rom 11:25-36

25 For I would not, brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits; that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles be come in.
26 And so all Israel shall be saved: as it is written, There shall come out of Sion the Deliverer, and shall turn away ungodliness from Jacob:
27 For this is my covenant unto them, when I shall take away their sins.
28 As concerning the gospel, they are enemies for your sakes: but as touching the election, they are beloved for the father's sakes.
29 For the gifts and calling of God are without repentance.
30 For as ye in times past have not believed God, yet have now obtained mercy through their unbelief:
31 Even so have these also now not believed, that through your mercy they also may obtain mercy.
32 For God hath concluded them all in unbelief, that he might have mercy upon all.
33 O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! how unsearchable are his judgments, and his ways past finding out!
34 For who hath known the mind of the Lord? or who hath been his counsellor?
35 Or who hath first given to him, and it shall be recompensed unto him again?
36 For of him, and through him, and to him, are all things: to whom be glory for ever. Amen.
 
E

ember

Guest
The law was never given to man to lead us to salvation but to reveal the characteristics of God.

It would be impossible to be saved through the law...did you read my post wrong? As it is though, the actual purpose of the law was to reveal sin.


Wherefore then serveth the law? It was added because of transgressions, till the seed should come to whom the promise was made; and it was ordained by angels in the hand of a mediator. Galatians 3:19
 
E

ember

Guest
This could not be further from the truth. I believe that God never changed. What did change is that I don't have to bring the sin sacrifice because my Saviour did that for me and showed us the perfect grace. This is not difficult to understand but people want to see Israel the nation and a piece of land but they can't see the spiritual Israel.

I can read both OT & NT because they are both relevant to me as a Bible believing child of God. People struggle with the OT because they believe it was written for the Jews and we have no part in it, but we know that God will always be the same and therefor we can read the whole Bible.

Like I said before there were never ever ever salvation in keeping the law. The law was to show us the characteristics of God and if He never changed I doubt it that His characteristics changed :)
I think I need to say it again.

the law does not reveal the characteristics of God. it reveals sin.

What is the main characteristic of God? 'thou shalt not?' I don't think so

there is confusion here

God IS Spirit...he is holy, omniscient, omnipresent, omnipotent, immutable, righteous and others...that is not revealed in the law...oh, you might think so if you already know something about God...but how does a person see these things if they do not know God? All they see is their tendency to break the commandments! Which, is exactly the reason for the law
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
126
63
Because IT WAS. Some of you people seem to think that God has never worked in the past, but after the return there were a number of great 'revivals' and the land prospered more and more. All that was promised in those promises was fulfilled.

And then the promises came to final fulfilment in the Coming of Jesus Christ which so many of you seem to try to bypass or see as some minor event. Jesus Christ finally established the new everlasting covenant, the covenant in the blood of God. There can be no greater..
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
Would someone please ask herose to stop hijacking and arguing in this thread? He blocked me before and now is taking over the thread. He's had his say. Since I cant ask him to stop I would ask someone reading this to do so for me. Thank you.
 
E

ember

Guest
I know I'm a carnal being, it's the way you stated it.
You're stating it as if you are some higher person than who you are talking to.
Last I checked we are all equal.
We're all sinner's here, no one is greater than the next person, nor higher than the next person.
logic?

we are not sinners...we are made righteous in Christ...that is how God sees us...we do sin, but we have an advocate (lawyer or someone to plea our case if you will) with the Father and He is righteous and just and forgives our sin when we admit it and bring it to the light

I am starting to cringe when I read Christians calling themselves sinners

please don't take this the wrong way...it is for good